Sea of Thieves' Mysterious Stranger and the much-touted status of Pirate Legend are closely linked, with the stranger forming the gateway to the game's interesting-sounding late game.

Here on this page we'll let you know just who the Mysterious Stranger is, as well as the Pirate Legend riddle solution, what you can expect from when you become Pirate Legend, how to become Pirate Legend and what we know about Pirate Legend rewards, of course, too.

A word of warning though: there will of course be spoilers for just about everything to do with Pirate Legend, below.

Sea of Thieves' Mysterious Stranger explained - riddle solution and how to become Pirate Legend

The Mysterious Stranger is the person lurking in the corner of the Outpost island taverns. Talk to them at various levels and they'll give you a little bit of dialogue, always to the effect of "great, now come back when you're a higher level".


How to become Pirate Legend

Level 50 - in all three factions: the Gold Hoarders, Order of Souls and Merchant Alliance - is what you will eventually need to reach. It's an almighty grind, but get there and the Mysterious Stranger will have something else to say to you at last.

Talk to them when you've reached max level in all three factions and they'll grant you a new title, outfit, and most importantly a new shanty - a song you can play with your instruments.

Along with that you'll get a riddle:

Through many voyages upon the sea, you searched to find the legends key. Now one last step to pass the tests, to find where Athena's Fortune rests. Take this tune and make a sound, the secret lies near in the ground.

The riddle solution, if you hadn't guessed already, is to play the new shanty with your instrument whilst inside that same tavern with the Mysterious Stranger.

Do it right and you'll hear the ground open up nearby - a staircase will form out of the floorboards and, following it, you'll be lead into a tunnel until you reach a waterfall.

Head through the waterfall and, on the other side, you'll find your Legendary Hideout, including a new tavern, several NPCs, a shipwright vendor and a new vendor of Legendary Voyages.

Here's controvertial 'first' Pirate Legend streamer Prod1gyX finally unlocking the Legendary Hideout's entrance.

Treasure hunting for more guides like this? Best to start with our main Sea of Thieves guide, including voyages, quests, progression and what to do first, or if you're right at the end of the game, take a look at our guide to Pirate Legend rewards and the Mysterious Stranger explained. We also have step-by-step instructions on how to download and install Sea of Thieves; there's also a guide on the Sea of Thieves map and how to find every island location, shape and name, along with our guide to Sea of Thieves' chicken, pig and snake locations for Merchant Alliance Voyages, a guide to loot values and how to earn Sea of Thieves gold fast, info on the full set of Sea of Thieves controls for Xbox and PC, a long list of various Sea of Thieves tips and tricks, an in-depth explainer on the dastardly Skeleton Forts, Skull clouds and Stronghold Keys, a massive collection of advice on Sea of Thieves sailing, ship combat and how to sail into the wind, plus how to find and kill Sea of Thieves' Kraken, and finally some advice for those encountering Sea of Thieves LavenderBeard, CyanBeard and CinnamonBeard error messages, too.

Pirate Legend explained - what is Pirate Legend and what are the Pirate Legend rewards?


The initial rewards for Pirate Legend are what we've already noted above: namely a new title, outfit and shanty to play with your instruments.

The broader reward is your access to the Legendary Hideout. From there, you'll be able to undertake special, longer versions of voyages - although they operate in largely the same manner - and receive special Ancient Chests as rewards, which we understand to contain new items that allow further customisation of your character and ship.

We'll update this page when we know some more precise details, but the main takeaway is this: becoming Pirate Legend is mostly a case of doing it for the pride.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Jump to comments (1)

About the author

Chris Tapsell

Chris Tapsell

Staff Writer

Chris Tapsell is Eurogamer's Staff Writer, its newest Chris, and a keen explorer of the dark arts of gaming, from League of Legends to the murky world of competitive Pokémon.