Long read: Who is qualified to make a world?

In search of the magic of maps.

If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Weakest Link

Review - another quiz show comes to the PC, this time with Anne Robinson at the helm

This is the Weakest Link...

The task of turning The Weakest Link into a computer game probably seems like a relatively simple task at first. After all, it worked for Who Wants To Be A Millionaire. But then you start to realise that there is a lot more to it than that. There is the competition between players, the scheming and rivalry, the rapidly increasing tension as the number of players dwindles. Oh, and let's not forget the ever-present game show host of doom, Anne Robinson. What surprises you when you first play Weakest Link is the amount of effort that has been put into recreating the show as accurately as possible. Instead of simply sticking the voice of the host into the game and be done with it, the developers have created a 3D interpretation of the entire Weakest Link studio, complete with inanimate cardboard cut-out audience, swooping camera angles, beaming lights and nervously fidgeting contestants. While it's certainly more impressive to have a fully 3D set as opposed to a 2D graphical display interspersed with FMV, the overall graphical quality is fairly mediocre. From the low-resolution textures to the extremely low-poly studio set and characters, it all appears very dated by today's aesthetic standards. The blockhead human models are almost comical in fact, and their animations do little to impress either. The same could be said about the voice acting, with poorly impersonated regional accents and phrases that become increasingly irritating the more they are repeated.


You start off by choosing from a set of 24 pre-defined contestants, whose character portraits couldn't be more stereotypical if they tried. For example, "29 year old Tim is a nerdy, boring computer programmer with an interest in trains and bird watching". Playing on your own, you are pitched against six computer-controlled contestants of varying intelligence, until you get voted out as the weakest link or win the game. In multiplayer the game plays exactly the same, except with up to seven human players. I can't quite imagine having that many people crowded around my PC for a game, but multiplayer is certainly more fun, as you really feel like you're stabbing somebody in the back as you vote them out of the game, whereas you couldn't care less about the computer. The tension of the TV show is also recreated well, especially towards the end of the game when you are up against one other player in a sudden death scenario. Sadly though the main draw of the game, the "icy" Anne Robinson, barely plays a role in creating any of the tension when pitching in with her "humiliating" put-downs during the FMV sequences that pop up throughout the game. In fact, it almost seems as if Robinson is there simply because she has to be, as opposed to playing a major part in making the game what it is.


The feeling of being part of a game show and competing is achieved to great effect in The Weakest Link though, despite the slightly shoddy presentation. And with 100,000 questions up its sleeve, it is definitely going to last a lot longer than Who Wants To Be A Millionaire, despite the inability to expand the game for free. It will be interesting to see which of these two games wins out this Christmas. Neither is particularly remarkable, but if I had to choose between them, I would probably choose The Weakest Link.


Who Wants To Be A Millionaire : 2nd Edition review

6 / 10