GamesIndustry.biz: BBFC talks sense

Read this week's GI.biz editorial on Dead Rising.

Published as part of our sister-site GamesIndustry.biz' widely-read weekly newsletter, the GamesIndustry.biz Editorial is a weekly dissection of one of the issues weighing on the minds of the people at the top of the games business. It appears on Eurogamer a day after it goes out to GI.biz newsletter subscribers.

If you walk into a store in the United Kingdom to pick up a copy of Capcom's eagerly awaited Xbox 360 title Dead Rising next month, you'll find that the methods of dispatching zombies available to you in the game are somewhat, well, unadulterated. Smashing undead skulls into the floor and lopping heads off with well placed scythe slashes are only two of the many, many carnage related options which will be open to players of the game, which borrows many of its cues from classic zombie movies such as Dawn of the Dead.

The interesting thing about this level of violence and gore isn't that it's present in the first place - after all, zombie films and other horror and action movies have been blowing apart the undead in showers of claret for decades, and "decency" campaigners seem to have given up on moaning about escapist fantasy movies quite some time ago. No, what's interesting is that despite the game having a rocky time with censorship and ratings boards elsewhere in the world, in Britain it will be released entirely uncensored, with not a single change to the content.

That's a situation which movie aficionados have gradually become used to in this country; the British Board of Film Classification, empowered by the excellent if sometimes weakly enforced age rating system which is applied to media in the UK, has been passing more and more films without cuts. Instead, films are rated 18, and the board takes the view that if content is not clearly going to be harmful to adults, then adults should be permitted to view or experience it.

Now the BBFC is applying the same logic to videogames - and the straightforward, reasonable point of view expressed by the board brings a breath of fresh air to the debate over videogame violence and censorship, which has become increasingly bogged down in rhetoric and embarrassing public spats between key proponents on both sides in the last year or so.

You can read the board's full comments on why they're passing Dead Rising as an 18-rated game, uncut, in this news story - but suffice it to say that the guardians at the gates of Britain's sensitive minds not only regard claims that videogames turn people into killers with a sceptical eye, but they also, crucially, get the joke. Their statement to us not only acknowledges that the game is aimed at an adult audience (a fact commonly missed in discussions about violent videogames), but also that the violence has a fantasy element and crucially, that the game has "a sense of humour, albeit a macabre one."

Herein, perhaps, lies the clearest sign we've seen in quite some time that the tide is turning in favour of interactive media. The key problem faced by games for years has been that they are widely seen as being a form of entertainment which was aimed at children and which was both straightforward and unsubtle. When a newspaper talks about a film featuring a violent or sexual scene, readers automatically assume that this falls into the context of the film; when we talk about games featuring similar scenes, many people automatically assume that this game is an outright "violence simulator" or "sex simulator", because they cannot conceive of a game having complex narrative, satire, humour or subtlety.

In acknowledging the humour which drives Dead Rising, the BBFC acknowledges the maturity of the videogaming medium. In granting it an 18 rating - described by a spokesperson as "a fairly straightforward 18" - it acknowledges it as entertainment for adults. In making these viewpoints public, as much as in granting the rating in the first place, it shows us how far the perception of videogames in the British political establishment has come.

We welcome, of course, the opportunity to enjoy Dead Rising as its creators intended - an experience no more harmful, and possibly even more fun, than spending an evening with friends watching cult classic George A Romero films. More than that, however, we welcome the implicit confirmation of the BBFC's view that games deserve equal treatment to their counterparts in film. The censorship debate will roll on regardless, of course - especially in the USA where much of it focuses on the ability to ban the sale of violent games to minors, something which the UK has already done for years - but the end of this long dark tunnel is more clearly in sight than ever before.

For more views on the industry and to keep up to date with news relevant to the games business, read GamesIndustry.biz. You can sign up to the newsletter and receive the GamesIndustry.biz Editorial directly each Thursday afternoon.

Comments (10) Latest comment 6 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • penhalion #1 6 years ago

  • Troutio #2 6 years ago

    It is a mark of how good we have it over here (compared to our Yankee chums) that this is such a non-story. Hooray for sensible people at the BBFC!
  • mal #3 6 years ago

    "they cannot conceive of a game having complex narrative, satire, humour or subtlety."

    Wait... I've been playing games for (shit) over 20 years now, and I still can't conceive of a game having a complex narrative or the rest of the above ;)

    "In acknowledging the humour which drives Dead Rising, the BBFC acknowledges the maturity of the videogaming medium. In granting it an 18 rating - described by a spokesperson as "a fairly straightforward 18" - it acknowledges it as entertainment for adults."

    The BBFC has been issuing 18 ratings for games for years. This latest decision tells us nothing, except that perhaps that the BBFC misguidedly believe parents give two hoots about them saying 'adult only' on the rating.
  • Kami #4 6 years ago

    @ mal;

    "The BBFC has been issuing 18 ratings for games for years. This latest decision tells us nothing, except that perhaps that the BBFC misguidedly believe parents give two hoots about them saying 'adult only' on the rating."

    There is a little more to it than that. It's the fact that the BBFC have openly come out and said they don't need to intervene so strictly on 18-rated games because at 18, you're an adult and they shouldn't be dictating what you can and can't play. This is not only very different from it's opinions some years ago, but it's a breath of fresh air when a dozen other countries have been censoring the bejeezhua out of the game.

    In effect, we may end up one of very few countries that allow this game through totally uncensored. This is almost unheard of to us Brits and I hope it's a precedent that continues to other titles as well...
  • darkbhudda #5 6 years ago

    ALERT:The "in this news story -" hyperlink points back to the same article.

    Now we wait to see what other countries like Australia are going to do to the game.

  • NegativeZero #6 6 years ago

    Australia will refuse to classify it. Guaranteed.

    Then again, a lot of the time it feels like the OFLC grab ratings out of a hat, so you never know...
  • Sammy Capcom #7 6 years ago

    Australia officially rated Dead Rising MA15+, OFLC slightly changed the ratings advice to: "Strong Horror Violence, Blood and Gore".

    Hope that sets your mind at rest!
  • Skeletor #8 6 years ago

    Australia rated it 15+? Nice one! It seems that the overprotective and bullshit talking German rating board are the only ones who refused to give the game a rating in Europe. Serves them right!
    How about other European countries - like Spain or France? Do they have their own rating boards too?
    Edited by 1 at 16/08/06 @ 19:15
  • Bitkari #9 6 years ago

    It is a mark of how good we have it over here (compared to our Yankee chums) that this is such a non-story. Hooray for sensible people at the BBFC!

    One of the reasons that these sorts of stories make big news over the pond is that a game rated for adults is essentially relegated to RETAIL DEATH, with many chain stores refusing to even carry the title.

    Of course most of those "adult" ratings are given for sexual content, but we need not discuss the well-known morality chasm that exists between us crazy liberal euros and thems folks over thar...

  • jamesbee #10 6 years ago

    It's banned in Germany, as far as I have been told.