Last night, during Sony's Gamescom press conference, Sony Computer Entertainment boss Andrew House took to the stage to criticise Microsoft for backtracking on a number of its Xbox One policies since the E3 trade show in June.

Towards the end of Sony's press conference, Sony Computer Entertainment boss Andrew House said: "While others have shifted their message and changed their story, we were consistent in maintaining a message that is fair and in tune with consumer desires."

It was a thinly-veiled bash at Microsoft's decision to ditch the always online aspect of Xbox One, allow games to be traded freely, and to let customers use the console without Kinect plugged in - essentially, all disc-based games will work on Xbox One as they work on Xbox 360.

Microsoft's dramatic reversal has meant some Xbox One functionality has been delayed, including family sharing. A patch will be required when the Xbox One is first connected to the internet in order to enable offline mode and update the system software. Xbox One exclusive Forza 5, which uses the Xbox Live cloud to power Drivatars, also needs to be tweaked.

In an interview with Eurogamer Microsoft Studios boss Phil Spencer accused “certain people” of trying to turn these policy changes into “a bad thing”, insisting the company's ability to react to feedback was “a strength”.

"While others have shifted their message and changed their story, we were consistent in maintaining a message that is fair and in tune with consumer desires."

Sony Computer Entertainment boss Andrew House

“The thing I love about the space we're in is you're always going to get feedback, whether it's on your Twitter feed, whether it's in NeoGAF, whether it's in Eurogamer,” Spencer said.

“People are going to tell you in comment threads how they feel about decisions.

“The two-way conversation we have with our customers is a strength. Certain people have tried to turn that into something that's a bad thing about what we're trying to do, and I just disagree."

Spencer explained his position: "We built a platform for gamers. Gamers invest their time and their money in the things they want to play, and they're going to invest their time in telling us what they love about the platform, and they're giving us feedback on areas where they have more critical feedback.

Microsoft Studios boss Phil Spencer.

“That two-way conversation with gamers has to be core to who we are as a platform. And if we don't have the capability of listening and reacting to what people are saying about our platform, then we're being too disconnected from customers who make investments in our platform and the games we build.”

Responding directly to Andrew House's comment, Spencer mentioned the community-focused event Microsoft held at Gamescom last night, during which the executive walked the floor and listened to what people were saying about the likes of Killer Instinct, Ryse and Kinect Sports Rivals - good and bad.

“The two-way conversation that we have with gamers is critical,” he said. "If we weren't able to listen then I don't think we're really creating the ecosystem that means people want to come into the platform.

"Other people will do and say what they're going to say. Fine. We're running our program. That's a strength of who we are."

"Other people will do and say what they're going to say. Fine. We're running our program. That's a strength of who we are."

Microsoft Studios boss Phil Spencer

Despite the criticism Microsoft has received for its Xbox One policies, Spencer said the firm remains steadfast in its commitment to a digital future. And while for the launch of Xbox One many of its digital-focused features have been scaled back, Spencer said the concept of a digital ecosystem “remains a core philosophy” for the console as it evolves over time.

“Now, we have a vision, and we've stayed on that vision around the digital ecosystem we want to put on Xbox Live,” he said. “It remains a core philosophy. We heard people valued some of the existing generation's disc-based DRM, so we said we're going to add that to the digital ecosystem we're building.

“It meant some delays in some of the stuff around digital so we could fit in the time to get physical done at launch, but our vision remains the same. I look at that as just us having that two-way conversation with gamers. That has to be a strength.”

Spencer described the Xbox One as "more of a service than a fixed piece of hardware", and said changing its offering was a natural part of the process.

"When you think about the platform and all of the times we've updated the dash on 360, Live and the live ecosystem that's there, it's really important that we run the program as a service," he said, "and community and social engagement with the gamers who are playing on the system is critical."

Xbox One launches in the UK this November.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Jump to comments (308)

About the author

Wesley Yin-Poole

Wesley Yin-Poole

Deputy Editor

Wesley is Eurogamer's deputy editor. He likes news, interviews, and more news. He also likes Street Fighter more than anyone can get him to shut up about it.

More articles by Wesley Yin-Poole

Comments (308)

Comments for this article are now closed, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

Hide low-scoring comments


Oxenfree and Forza 5 will be free in September for Xbox Live Gold subscribers

Along with Battlefield 3 and and Hydro Thunder Hurricane.

What's the deal with steering wheels for PS4 and Xbox One?

Most last-gen wheels don't work with current-gen consoles. Why? We investigate.

Forza Horizon 2 gets September release date

Plus, Nurburgring comes to Forza 5 at last - today!