PC gaming portal Games For Windows was flawed from the get-go, custodian Microsoft has admitted.
Speaking in an interview with CVG, senior producer Kevin Unangst explained that though its intentions were good, the platform got off on entirely the wrong footing by attempting to replicate a console model.
"The service started with the right intent, which was to bring Achievements, friends, multiplayer gaming and matchmaking in a really great way to PC," he said.
"I think because it was designed originally as a partner to the console service more than the PC service, we had a rocky start.
"We also didn't back it up with the most important thing, which is doing fantastic games to take advantage of the service. A network by itself isn't valuable - there needs to be great games to take advantage."
He went on to insist that Microsoft has been incorporating feedback from developers and the future was looking much more positive.
"I look at it as like what Halo did for Xbox Live, where you had Bungie and Microsoft going back and saying 'to make a great multiplayer game here's some things I need in the service, here's my audience'.
"The Age of Empire team has got a lot of great input and the same can be said for Lionhead, who said 'we're going to build Fable 3 on the PC' and know what they want out of the service.
"I think the underpinnings are great, I think it's going to continue to get better," he continued. "We launched a new Marketplace which was great, we're selling Live and non-Live enabled games.
"We're also seeing developers get back to development. Epic did a great job of promoting Live with Bulletstorm. They're pleased with the platform and the service is going to continue to get better over time."
Become a Eurogamer subscriber and get your first month for £1
Get your first month for £1 (normally £3.99) when you buy a Standard Eurogamer subscription. Enjoy ad-free browsing, merch discounts, our monthly letter from the editor, and show your support with a supporter-exclusive comment flair!