German court sides with Nintendo over claim its eShop pre-order practices are illegal

But an appeal is in the works.

An attempt by German and Norwegian consumer authorities to declare Nintendo's eShop pre-order practices illegal under European law (Nintendo prevents consumers from cancelling a pre-order once made) has been dismissed, with a German court ruling in Nintendo's favour.

The Norwegian Consumer Council initially raised concerns over Nintendo's digital sales practices back in February 2018, claiming the company was in breach of European law.

Ordinarily, European consumers have the right to cancel a pre-order at any time before a game's release, but Nintendo insists eShop users waive that right prior to any purchases by ticking a box stating, "I consent that Nintendo begins with the performance of its obligations before the cancellation period ends. I acknowledge that I thereby lose my right to cancel."

"According to the right of withdrawal laid down in the Consumer Rights Directive," the NCC argued, "such terms are illegal. Until the game can be downloaded and launched, the seller cannot prohibit the consumer from cancelling their pre-order."

1
All eShop users must waive their right to withdrawal at the time of a pre-order purchase.

Since then, the Norwegian Consumer Council has joined forces with the German VZBV (Federation of German Consumer Organisations) to bring the case before the Regional Court of Frankfurt. However, just before Christmas, as reported by Norwegian gaming website Press Fire, the court announced its ruling in Nintendo's favour.

As Press Fire notes, Nintendo's defense cited a European law stating a consumer's right of withdrawal automatically disappears if "the performance has begun with the consumers prior express consent and his acknowledgment that he thereby loses his right of withdrawal". It further argued that its contract with a user was fulfilled at the time of purchase, as pre-orders immediately receive a pre-load version of a game (even though that version might not be playable for months) - an interpretation the court ultimately agreed with.

Both the German VZBV and Norwegian Consumer Council have appealed the decision, suggesting that because the pre-load is useless before it unlocks on launch day, delivery cannot be said to have begun. However, it could take up to a year and a half before the appeal passes through court and a ruling is made.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Jump to comments (57)

About the author

Matt Wales

Matt Wales

Reporter

Matt Wales is a freelance writer and gambolling summer child who won't even pretend to live a busily impressive life of dynamic go-getting for the purposes of this bio. He is the sole and founding member of the Birdo for President of Everything Society.

Related

Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Remaster launches tomorrow

UPDATE: Activision finally confirms - and announces PS4 timed exclusivity.

Long-running Official Xbox Magazine shuts down

Future bosses say they've taken pay cuts to reduce lay-offs.

FeatureAs Riot bids to take on Blizzard and Valve, the studio faces challenges of its own making

"There are no limits" co-founder Marc Merrill tells us, as a new world order emerges.

Someone's built the entire Earth in Minecraft - to scale

And he wants your help to add buildings.

You may also enjoy...

Comments (57)

Comments for this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

Hide low-scoring comments
Order
Threading