Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

SEGA Rally First Impressions

Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 First Impressions by Tom Bramwell

21 June, 2007

Page 1 of 2. Page 2 ->

As with all such things, the key to making a good rally game is wedged in the door marked 'pub'. "You sit late in bars with drivers and co-drivers talking about how these things work," says SEGA Racing Studio boss Guy Wilday. Then you go home and do some programming. So what do rally drivers say? "It's all about tyres, and it's all about surfaces. That really is a key topic of conversation. The cars themselves are obviously very technically innovative, but the thing they focus on is the tyres and the surfaces - what tyres they need for a particular surface, how a car is going to behave on a particular surface, and how that surface is going to change."

It's ironic, in a way, because it was likely Wilday's success working on Codemasters' Colin McRae Rally series that led to his founding the Solihull-based SEGA Racing Studio in the first place, and yet he's just told us that the key to rally driving is changes to conditions that nothing he worked on there - prior to PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 and modern PC hardware - could hope to emulate. The technology simply wasn't around. Well, as they say, it is now. SEGA Rally demonstrates the difference that six rally cars can make tearing across a tightly wound circuit. In fact, surface deformation has such a pronounced effect on gameplay that the game's online, leaderboard-based Time Attack mode will require you to complete three laps and submit an averaged time. "The difference between laps one and three can just be huge."

All this talk of consultation, loose-surface racing, deformation technology and Colin McRae could well send a chill up the spines of SEGA Rally's old guard. As will Wilday's comment that "the remit behind this studio was always to develop content for the Western market". It's not hard to take the things he's saying, add them together and end up with a sort of SEGA Off-Road Gran Turismo. GT's turned into a sort of ASDA trolley dash for motorsport, and sales suggest it's what we want. But surely Racing Studio isn't just going to try and emulate GT's volume factor? "I think there's pressure to do that," he says. "I absolutely agree that Gran Turismo has become a content-based game. It's a fantastic visual showroom of content." But, (phew), "we've been concentrating on creating something very playable that people can latch onto, and not get caught up in the whole content battle."

'SEGA Rally' Screenshot 1

The game has a range of view modes - bonnet, cockpit, third-person. This wouldn't be a practical one.

Surface deformation might sound spoddy, then, but it's sailed in under the aegis of fun. "The original arcade game was groundbreaking; for me it was a milestone in off-road racing. It was really the first game where you really felt in control of a car off-road," Wilday explains. "What we wanted to do here was something else that was new and original that again was going to be another milestone; that was going to be the first game where you actually feel the surface changing and evolving underneath you, and across a number of laps the race is different." At this point it dawns on us that while SEGA Rally 12 years ago couldn't have dreamed of it, in a sense the essence of what surface deformation offers the 2007 vintage is the strongest link between the two games we could've hoped for: the desire to innovate rather than rehash.

Interpretation will only get you so far though (paragraph five, on this evidence). Strapping into a Force Feedback chair with a GT Force steering wheel hooked up to the PlayStation 3 version, and later settling in for a few hours learning each of the four demo circuits in more detail with an identical Xbox 360 build, now we get the chance to put our theories to the test.

'SEGA Rally' Screenshot 2

The Alpine track's peak sections feature a dangerous snake of opposing bends that you can cut a line straight through. With practice.

Starting with the chair was a mistake, we realise a few hairpin catastrophes later, but SEGA's made few mistakes in the way it's harnessed the technology - something it will also do on the Xbox side with Microsoft's handsome steering wheel. The wheel response, the palpability of the surface changes, and the precarious feel of a rally race are all present and correct. But it's the more concerted exposure we get on the control pad that endears us. Racing against five other humans, or against a mixture of AI racers, we get to tour the three environments (Alpine, Canyon and Tropical - the latter having two tracks on display) and see how the experience develops.

To begin with you're all over the place. It's still fun, but as you clamber up mountain roads, transition into wading through slush and then skating across snow, or glide round sandy turns down by the beach, you throw the back end of the car out too far, you overcorrect on the steering and snag the sides of the track, and you regularly plough straight into the wall at the peak of a hairpin. As you get a better grasp of the relationship between braking, the accelerator, and powerslides, you're able to concentrate on keeping a good line and showing sharp turns a sensible amount of respect, rather than baring your arse to the spectators in blind fear and losing a couple of seconds in the process.

'SEGA Rally' Screenshot 3

We've mostly seen Tropical in past demos because it accentuates the deformation. Look at those ruts - all dynamic.

What's interesting though is that the most frustrating thing - smacking walls - starts to disappear from your laps quite quickly. You make mistakes, and they cost you, but the tracks seem to bulge in the places where you make them. It's subtle, and once you've graduated beyond learner lines and started rutting the optimal approach, you won't even notice the run-offs. We put it to Wilday that perhaps they've deliberately designed the tracks to catch newbies when they fall. He laughs. "Motivation from the start was that SEGA Rally's about throwing the car sideways and powersliding round corners, so having the ability to do that is enormously important, so it's quite forgiving. If you make a mistake and go wide on a corner, the penalty is that you've taken a longer line - you're not necessarily penalised by hitting a wall."

To Page 2 ->

Advertisement

Are you excited about SEGA Rally on PlayStation 3/Xbox 360/PC?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 51 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
drunkymonkey
21/06/07 @ 13:32
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
SEGA Rally returns eh? SEGA getting back on track? Hopefully.

They've been making some pretty wise decisions lately, what with taking hold of the Total War series, and while the latest Sonic offerings have been like dipping your head in a pot of acid while listening Girls Aloud on rewind, I also heard good things about SEGA Rally. If anything, it'll give Colin McRae a run (or should that be drive?) for his money.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 21/06/07 @ 14:34
Beano
21/06/07 @ 13:33
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hopefully better than DIRT....
SeesThroughAll
21/06/07 @ 13:33
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hopefully it will be the great arcade fun from the 90's we all know and love.

SEGA, release your own console. Come back....... :'(
Edited 1 times, most recently on 21/06/07 @ 14:33
Beano
21/06/07 @ 13:37
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"SEGA, release your own console. Come back....... :'( "

No please don't... not another piece of hardware we need to buy. Three current consoles are enough for me ;)
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 13:41
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I bought a wheel for Forza, this, and DiRT. Turns out it is apparently only good with Forza! Thats £80 well spent then!
Arcadiian
21/06/07 @ 13:47
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i have such high hopes for this game. o_O
jonestm
21/06/07 @ 13:51
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It sounds as if it may become easy rather too quickly.
Darren
21/06/07 @ 13:58
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nice to hear that both the PS3 and Xbox 360 versions look graphically identical (I presume that includes the framerate?) but for me the deciding factor in which to go for comes down to rumble as rally games really benefit from feedback I feel. Also I'd expect the 360 version to have better anti-aliasing than the PS3 version... as an owner of both machines, I've noticed that the AA in 360 games tends to look better in games like Virtua Tennis 3 and Oblivion. That would be another reason for me to opt for the 360 version.
gizmo
21/06/07 @ 13:59
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
No damage modelling?

90's, no sale.
SeesThroughAll
21/06/07 @ 14:02
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So, is there split-screen two player?
SimonM7
21/06/07 @ 14:04
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I want to be excited and jump around based on this article, but considering what a warm reception the ultra wonky DiRT got on here I dunno if it's entirely trustworthy. :(
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 14:19
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Dirt got a warm reception everywhere
jimbob101
21/06/07 @ 14:20
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm disappointed there are 30 cars, I would prefer a lot less so we can really tell the difference between each one.

I want fewer tracks, fewer cars. MORE polish.


It sounds as if it may become easy rather too quickly.

If it's anything like the brillant original it's about beating your times.
PapaSmurf630
21/06/07 @ 14:29
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Dirts a great game. Accept that maybe your opinion might not be the popular one.

This game certainly gets my hopes up for some Arcadey action and the track deformation is something I feel is sorely missing from CMR:D! Looking forward to it!
SBfistfun
21/06/07 @ 14:38
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
360 and ps 3 versions the same?I don't believe it, what about teh power of the cell??!?!
TheEnd
21/06/07 @ 14:43
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Powerslides eh?

Already sounds more realistic than DiRT.
septimus
21/06/07 @ 14:46
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"360 and ps 3 versions the same?I don't believe it, what about teh power of the cell??!?!"

It's going to be a blatant port, what do you expect?

--

"Powerslides eh?

Already sounds more realistic than DiRT."

Agreed.
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 14:48
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
sorry thats the 2nd time i have double posted. I bet you lot wish i was your postman on your birthday!
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 14:58
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Racing fans. 2 q's please.
1
How do i keep a RWD vehicle on the road in Forza 2? lol,

2
Does anyone play DiRT with the official wheel, and is it poor, as i have read elsewhere? ......... I'd hate to think i'd forked out 80 nicker for one game usage


ryohazuki1983
21/06/07 @ 14:58
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
lol
BadBoyBonner
21/06/07 @ 15:03
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
JackyB

As for the MS wheel - go to advance options and get rid of all the dead Zones/spots i.e. put everything to 100%.

Improved it for me no end.
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 15:08
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Thanks badboy, I dont have DiRT yet, but i feel it will be a safer purchase now. ta
BadBoyBonner
21/06/07 @ 15:08
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Racing fans. 2 q's please.
1
How do i keep a RWD vehicle on the road in Forza 2? lol,

2
Does anyone play DiRT with the official wheel, and is it poor, as i have read elsewhere? ......... I'd hate to think i'd forked out 80 nicker for one game usage

1) upgrade the tires to slicks, buy the best diff, lower the car, soften tire pressure, buy a rear spoiler an set down force to maximum. Forza 2 slides all over the place - I own the MX5 featured in the game. If it really handled like that I would be involved in a massive RTA every time I came to a round-a-bout. Think it exaggerates it so you can feel the difference.

2) Played the DiRT demo with the wheel - it plays terrible without the alteration and not that much better with it - due in no small part to the car turning on a central pivot - resulting in wild over steer. DiRT is really an arcade racer - with the handling somewhere between Forza & Ridge Racer and IMO is closer to Forza than Ridge - but not by a huge margin.
Edited 2 times, most recently on 21/06/07 @ 16:11
JackyB
21/06/07 @ 15:12
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
cheers bad boy. you da best. Yeah i am all over the place with the MX5 in Forza!
BadBoyBonner
21/06/07 @ 15:13
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Thing that put me off dirt is that you can not race against other poeple - only their time.

Which for me - is rubbish!

http://forums.xbox.com/12782845/ShowPost...

have a read of that for some further info - but to me it seems crazy to not include the ability to race against other people.
Ceatlan
21/06/07 @ 15:36
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
JackyB,

With RWD cars you really have to learn to put the power on progressively, as once the wheels start to spin and the tail starts to slide your only hope is to get off the power, and that results in slowing you down a lot and losing a lot of time. Putting the power on slowly and waiting until you are pointing in a straight line and no longer steering is the best way to drive RWD cars. (Actually the general rule for all racing is break in a straight line and apply power in a straight line, never whilst cornering)

And in real life an MX-5 can perform exactly like that when you take it around a track, there is a big difference between driving a car normally, where revs very rarely hit the limit and you are not trying to corner on the edge of adhesion, and driving a car around a track where you are taking everything to the limit.

(When will I learn to spell or punctuate ?)
Edited 4 times, most recently on 21/06/07 @ 16:39
qwerty123
21/06/07 @ 15:57
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It would be nice if they include the originals 4 tracks and 3 cars.
Sega Rally > Sega Rally 2

I hope they include a classic arcade mode for pick up and playability.
I enjoyed the old Arcade style with the field of racers spread out and you only gained 1st place on the 3rd track.

andromeda
21/06/07 @ 16:02
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Whats with all the DiRT bashing? Are u all bonkers?
As long as you avoid the terrible chase cam its the most solid rally game ever>>
Sega rally has always been terribly overrated. Its just slip and slide arcade cheap thrill. Perhaps this new track deformity or whatever might actually give you the sense that your touching the ground for once!
Caimbeul
21/06/07 @ 16:03
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
so have these screen shots been photoshopped?
Tomo
21/06/07 @ 16:06
#30
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Dynamic ruts! The current generation's cell shading!
LeSpank
21/06/07 @ 16:08
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Sega rally has always been terribly overrated."

You are very wrong.
BadBoyBonner
21/06/07 @ 16:12
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ceatlan

Having owned several MX-5’s over the years, all modified to different degree's, and having the pleasure of several track days, and possessing the driving skill to slide round many a corner (track or round-a-bout). I feel more than qualified to state the level of adhesion offered from the car in real life, and in the game. They are not the same – anyone accustom to driving rear wheel drive cars can attest to the fact that forza's are more than a little too twitchy. This does make for awesome technical feat of controlling the cars in game and probably increases the pleasure in some instance (although being clipped by the “blind computer” sending you into a spin is a bit cack).

For an example with a front wheel drive car: - select the first time trial with the Ford Focus RS. Anyone who has driven one (me for instance) can assure anyone who is worried about going around a corner in it at anything above 40 MPH, is indeed possible without it seeming like you are on black ice (when in fact it is meant to be racing track grade surface in rich sunshine).

Before anyone starts creating, let it be known that Forza 2 has not been out of my 360’s drive since the day I bought it, and I love racing with friends on it. Best game on 360 for me thus far.

Anyone doubting my credentials on Forza 2 – with realistically powered rear wheel drive cars on Forza 2 - should check out Semi-Pro under 200Hp Invitational. Where on Suzuka Circuit East I have the 2nd fastest time in the world. Download it an watch the replay.
Vertical Stand
21/06/07 @ 16:28
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Interesting, though I think they;d have been better off going for all out arcadey action, rather than worrying about realism, will of course have to play to find out (hurrah for a pre-release demo!).

One thing about this article bothers me though, single world market for games? Bollocks to that, I want crazy Japanese games, crazy American games and God damn it I want crazy British games. Stuff that stands out, rather than trying to be everything to everyone...
citizenHUNTER
21/06/07 @ 16:29
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This sounds good to me! I hope it's as addictive and polished as the original seemed years ago. DiRT was cack from the demo, no way in hell I'd pay £40 for that game (well I don't want the game full stop). Forza on the other hand, awesome demo, made me want to buy it while the original Xbox game left me cold, if only I had £35 spare :(

I love games like PGR3 for it's arcade fun handling but yet with a very concrete feel to it, it is consistent and you can really challenge yourself, games like Need For Speed or even Dirt, it's mostly about pressing left and right and braking occcasionally (in the demo of dirt you could break about 5 meters before the corner on 'dirt' and still slow down in time, just silly).

This game sounds gooood.
andromeda
21/06/07 @ 16:34
#35
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Sega rally has always been terribly overrated."

"You are very wrong."

i admire your innocence.



mcmonkeyplc
21/06/07 @ 17:08
#36
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
September?! Foooooooools!
Scimarad
21/06/07 @ 17:34
#37
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Really looking forward to this though I've never played a Sega Rally game before.

"Also I'd expect the 360 version to have better anti-aliasing than the PS3 version"

Odd, so far I'd say the PS3 has been better in that particular area...

Edited 1 times, most recently on 21/06/07 @ 18:36
Negotiator
21/06/07 @ 18:40
#38
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Also I'd expect the 360 version to have better anti-aliasing than the PS3 version"

Odd, so far I'd say the PS3 has been better in that particular area...

Then you would be wrong sir, or blind I don't know which but if you own dark glasses and a dog I apologize in advance.
smurphs
21/06/07 @ 18:52
#39
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@BadboyBonner

that central pivot feel drives me mad, I'm sure the earlier colin mcraes didn't have it, but I can't play the newer ones any more because of it.

Hoping this and flatout don't feel that way, as I'd like to recapture the excitement of rally driving first fostered by Screamer 2 (classic) and Network Q RAC Rally Championship.
onyxbox
21/06/07 @ 19:02
#40
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Also I'd expect the 360 version to have better anti-aliasing than the PS3 version"

I have both and I'd have to agree, the AA on Xbox is stronger although to be honest at 200mph I don't think anyones going to notice :-D
Ryze
21/06/07 @ 19:40
#41
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'll 'ave you'z all on this come September!

360 & PSP versions.

I slap all of you with my Gauntlet (or whatever).

/remembers Homer's "Glove Slap" episode from The Simpsons

/prepares edible words, hat
BadBoyBonner
21/06/07 @ 21:50
#42
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Smurphs

That central pivot feel drives me mad, I'm sure the earlier colin mcraes didn't have it, but I can't play the newer ones any more because of it.

Have Codemasters robbed us of our fav rally game?

I think it’s mainly that it was always seen as one of the most realistic rally games of its generation on the consoles. Clearly the talent is there at Codemasters to go in that direction, but they have seemingly chosen, what they hope is a better strategy to expand their market share in the USA. I hope it works out for them, and feel Richard Burns Rally (god bless him) showed that realism may even (negativley) impact sales, if the realism is not pushed hard enough as the key feature.

For me, I find the deformable track an intriguing idea and hope it is more than a novelty. Sega rally on the Saturn, was easily one of the best games on the system. Although I did love the “cheat” you could do on the 3DO version of Need for Speed that turned the grippy tarmac into a gravel like surface.
Daikon
22/06/07 @ 02:30
#43
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
... apart from that and the lack of rumble in the PS3 pad, "you'd be hard-pushed to tell them apart".

You insensitive clod. The fact that there is no rumble in the PS3 pads is not a "lack" of anything. It's a feature.

^_^
DrunKao
22/06/07 @ 07:29
#44
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sound better than Dirt to me, and that's saying A LOT.
bloodflowers
22/06/07 @ 07:44
#45
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I played DIRT /just/ long enough to notice two things before turning it off:

1) WTF IS THAT BLOOM EFFECT!? If I wanted to feel like I'd been on drugs the night before, I'd take them.
2) Judderjudderjuddertearjudderjuddertearjudder. Not good enough. Not good enough at all.
Snooz
22/06/07 @ 10:26
#46
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"hollywood realism" --- are any of the new games even close to Richard Burns Rally on the hardest settings?

Actually played RBR last week, damn that game still is the best rally sim I've ever played. Felt even better than I could remember and I spent 2+ straight hours playing until my shoulders hurt from the slightly too high table mounting of my wheel.

*thinking about writing a reader review on RBR*
smurphs
22/06/07 @ 11:05
#47
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@bloodflowers

I thought that about the bloom. I had to keep squinting thinking my eyes were watering or something! It's nice in oblivion, but when you're driving you want everything to be as sharp as it can be. No-one else has mentioned it that i've seen though, so maybe it is our eyes!
afray
22/06/07 @ 11:34
#48
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Bloom is of the Devil's making. It must be destroyed.
AOFanboi
22/06/07 @ 19:29
#49
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Bloom is the new lens flare.
Monkey-Wizard-Ken
25/06/07 @ 16:24
#50
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@septimus
hat about teh power of the cell??!?!"

Lol, there isn't any - its all marketing non-sense.
It’s like the PS2 emotion engine, Being an early adopter - my emotion was mostly disappointment.

Comments: 1-50 of 51 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery