The 3rd Birthday Review

Three and uneasy.

Version tested: PSP

For the survival horror hardcore, a new Parasite Eve game has been a long time coming – 11 years, if you haven't been keeping up. Well, you can keep waiting, because The 3rd Birthday bears very little relation to the series that provides the game's sighing, whimpering lead character, Aya Brea. No wonder Square Enix has positioned it as a spin-off.

On the plus side, you can dive into The 3rd Birthday's intertwining narrative without feeling like you've missed anything: you really haven't. For Aya Brea's part, she couldn't fill you in on what happened anyway. She wakes up in a blood-soaked wedding dress in 2010 without a single memory of what came before, or why she can transfer her soul from body to body. Maybe someone played Especially For You as the first dance music by mistake.

With this 'Overdrive' ability, Brea subsequently becomes an essential part of the Counter Twisted Investigation's fight against the towering 'Babel' roots that inexplicably burst out from underneath Manhattan a couple of years later. As a seemingly unending army of Twisted organisms starts spawning, aiming to take down snivelling humanity, she finds herself embroiled in a nightmarish, body-surfing, time-travelling shootout to prevent the whole sorry chain of events from ever occurring.

Its hilariously convoluted premise aside, The 3rd Birthday is a brain-optional affair. Once the basic mechanics are nailed down, it quickly boils down to a relentless and ultimately repetitive series of stiff encounters against the Twisted masses. In its favour, the ability to instantly dive into the body of any of the human allies that populate the environment is a pleasant distraction from many of the game's more irritating tendencies – of which, more in due course.

1

Beguiling.

If any of your AI helpers happens to be in your immediate proximity, a quick stab of the triangle button sends you directly into his or her body, and serves as a handy means of topping up your health and ammo. After a period of the game shouting at you to take advantage of flanking positions, it settles into a pleasantly restless groove where you're constantly sizing up whose body to occupy next.

This positional strategy becomes especially apparent on some of the game's more testing encounters in which you essentially play tag-team bash-the-weak-spot. With numerous soldiers to switch between, you might need one of them, for example, to stray from the pack and leg it up to a vantage point before you can start to do any real damage. Once the boss turns its attention on him, it's usually a good idea to swiftly switch back to someone on the opposite side to continue chipping away at its distressingly multi-layered health bar while the opportunity presents itself.

You're occasionally allowed to, essentially, psyche out enemies when prompted by the gigantic triangle icon that appears. If you activate it quick enough, you'll Overdrive into them and carve off a significant chunk of their health in the process. Another neat – albeit risky – tactic involves invoking a coordinated Crossfire attack by locking onto the enemy for a brief moment without shooting. Once the bar fills up, everyone blasts furiously on the target at once.

While we don't mind a fair challenge now and then, The 3rd Birthday delights in cranking the difficulty up to levels that appear specifically designed to give you a deeper understanding of Wayne Rooney's inner turmoil. Like Wayne, part of the problem comes down to the age-old issue of not having adequate control over the camera.

To give Square Enix its dues, it has done a reasonable job of shoehorning a third-person shooter onto a one-stick handheld. Most of the time, the game's lock-on serviceably snaps the reticule to the nearest enemy, but it all starts to unravel as soon as you need to manually adjust your aim or target specific body parts of an όber-boss. Even a split-second's hesitation while you fumble with the d-pad to cycle through the available targets is enough to get you into trouble when coupled with Brea's slovenly running pace.

In a game featuring such aggressive enemies, her casual jog seems completely at odds with the gravity of the situation, leaving you cursing. It wouldn't be so bad if the scantily clad saucetress could stand up to the Twisted masses just a tiny bit. But in a game where up to half of your health bar can be whittled away by a single hit, mistakes can be punishing – especially once you factor in the ineffectual recharging health system.

In sections where you're fighting alone, with no chance to Overdrive, it's particularly aggravating to persistently fall foul of the game's anachronistic harshness. 11 long years might have elapsed since Ava last saved the world, but evidently the game's designers are still firmly rooted in the conventions of the late 1990s. Anyone who pines for the days when you used to have to battle vicious enemies with minimal health and without the safety net of sensible checkpointing will be in their element. The rest of us might struggle to resist the urge to hurl the PSP at the nearest wall.

2

The endless corridors of death.

If you can calm your inner psycho long enough to reach a chapter's conclusion, there's masochistic satisfaction to be had. You can bask in temporary calm, take in the game's bewildering DNA upgrade system, and spend some of your hard-earned cash on the usual assortment of weapon upgrades. Eventually, you might even find yourself powerful enough to make light work of some of the game's early encounters, but the incentive to overcome your boiling frustration and make that happen is limited to say the least.

If you're really invested in the completely cracked storyline, you can also immerse yourself in the unending character bios and logs about things that presumably will make at least one person in the world feel a more complete human being. The respite is all too fleeting, though, and soon you're sent off on another against-the-odds round of predictable combat encounters.

Eventually it becomes clear how Aya developed her Overdrive ability, and who she was getting married to, and what the Twisted are all about. The problem is, it's hard to ever truly engage with it when so many of the The 3rd Birthday's key encounters are fundamentally spiteful. If you're really determined to eke some enjoyment from the rubble of frustration, there are a few moments that might make you feel like it's worth it. Sadly those occasions don't come along nearly enough to justify all the joyless attrition en route.

6 / 10

Read the Eurogamer.net scoring policy

Comments (26) Latest comment 1 year ago

Comments for this article are now closed, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • tomkuryakin #1 1 year ago

    "She wakes up in a blood-soaked wedding dress in 2010 without a single memory of what came before..."

    I hate it when that happens.
  • Mercatoria #2 1 year ago

  • Vlad27145 #3 1 year ago

    Bit of a harsh review there, Krista, although it is, as any review, an opinion, so I won't judge it. There is just one thing that bothers me a little, but in this case too, I can't blame it on you, as it's quite common. It seems that one of the main issues you had with this game was the fact that it is heavily focused on combat, which you consider to be broken. But the reasons behind this conclusion have much more to do with the PSP rather than the game itself. It's been 6 years since the PSP's been out. We know it's limitations, but some of us learned to live with them, and I think this game manges to go around these limitations quite well for that matter.
  • Diogo_Ribeiro #4 1 year ago

    "She wakes up in a blood-soaked wedding dress in 2010 without a single memory of what came before..."

    So, is The 3rd Birthday Kill Bill for people who desperately wanted to see Thurman's clothes being torn apart?
  • MattEdWithCheese #5 1 year ago

    lol! well I'm enjoying it a lot anyway, most of your issues with the game seem to be related to lack of skill but the whole point, given that this is an RPG, is that if it gets too difficult, you can ascend and grind on the earlier episodes.

    also guys, when will you be publishing your duodecim review it's been nearly 2 weeks!
  • FireMonkey #6 1 year ago

    @Vlad27145 - "But the reasons behind this conclusion have much more to do with the PSP rather than the game itself."

    I don't think that is a valid excuse.
    If an element of a game can not be done correctly on a specific platform then either that element should be dropped from that platform, the game should not be developed for that platform or the developers should figure out a good way around the problem.

    This game was developed for PSP. The developers knew the limitations (as you say " It's been 6 years since the PSP's been out. We know it's limitations...";) they should be able to work around them at development time and not expect the player to put up with the issues.
    Edited by FireMonkey at 06/04/11 @ 14:25
  • Goffee #7 1 year ago

    Time for a quick PS3 or NGP upgrade then - and not so many bloody corridors - isn't Persona plagued by them too?
  • Vistrix #8 1 year ago

    Seriously, what the hell has happened to Square Enix over the past few years? What's with all these bland games they keep releasing?

    They need to completely reorganise if they're going to survive.
  • MattEdWithCheese #9 1 year ago

    @FireMonkey Vlad's point was that for PSP gamers, these are non- issues because we have learned to live with the way the PSP is
    ie tapping the dpad with the index finger aka "Monster Hunter Claw"

    generally such things are small consessions to make and make much more sense than saying "port this to a home console" to a developer from handheld-centric Japan
  • Strokuss #10 1 year ago

    @vistrix

    That's what they bought Eidos for. Eidos Montreal, Io, and Crystal Dynamics will provide the good stuff while their Japanese studios keep doing what they do. So long as they have Tomb Raider, Deus Ex, Thief, and Hitman to counter the Mindjacks and Third Birthdays they'll be alright.
  • toy_brain #11 1 year ago

    I'm on chapter 4 and enjoying it quite a bit. A 6/10 might be a bit harsh, but I wouldn't try to convince anyone its worth a 9/10.
    Mostly its the difficulty spikes that get me. The game can dump some really nasty encounters on you that result in a lot of restarts and trail-and-error, only to follow them up with several areas of fairly simple run-and-gun action.
    Part of the challenge is re-wiring the fps part of your brain to how 3rd Birthday works. Yes its a shooter, but without aiming to worry about, there had to be something else to keep you occupied, which is why some of the enemies are designed the way they are, and you have a bunch of stat-based systems on top, and the gameplay mechanics can take some getting used to.

    I'm easily finding this to be as enjoyable as Resistance: Retribution, or both the Syphon Filter's; though in all games it's a case of delivering a 'compromised' shooter, and how well you manage that compromise. It seems there is no truly right way to do it.
  • darleysam #12 1 year ago

    This is the one that has a shower scene because the fans demanded it?
    I think I'll pass.
  • SlackMaster #13 1 year ago

    And it still gets a 6 out of 10???
  • andywilkie35 #14 1 year ago

    It's quite odd, all the gameplay videos look absolutely terrible yet I have been drawn to it the whole time, hoping that it was in fact good, but the reviews make it sound a bit "meh" so will give it a miss and go play Parasite Eve II again
  • Ryze #15 1 year ago

    Ooops - still no right-analogue stick.

    /sigh
  • GamesConnoisseur #16 1 year ago

    Played 1st and 2nd iteration, and coming into 3rd Birthday...was very disappointed with how this iteration seems to ignore the previous two games and thus my difficulty in identifying with Aya of this game as being the same person from PS1 era.

    Doesnt also feels like a reboot or a stand alone game in its own right, ie Lara Croft. But a messy confusion of what the game tries to be, maybe not intended but its how its seemed.
  • Pwnsweet #17 1 year ago

    there are a few moments that might make you feel like it's worth it. Sadly those occasions don't come along nearly enough to justify all the joyless attrition en route.

    You obviously haven't come across the shower scene yet. That'll make all the pain worthwhile.
  • miiiguel #18 1 year ago

    oooh the shower scene, incoming flashback.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_MLgWpiXEU
    Edited by miiiguel at 06/04/11 @ 16:04
  • HiddenAway #19 1 year ago

    @FireMonkey

    Just to further clarify, this game was initially a mobile phone game before it became a PSP game.

    I was taken by the trailers of the game as I didn't actually rate the gameplay myself. Not started on it yet myself.

    That begs the question though, where's the Dissidia duodecim review?! That came out before this did :p
  • spekkeh #20 1 year ago

    Another day, another Squeenix game with crappy pacing and yesterday's game design.
  • Vortextk #21 1 year ago

    Just started the first parasite eve, ever, cause this one looked fun. From what I'm seeing and reading I think I personally will rate it more than a 6/10, so I look forward to eventually playing it. It's too bad another game comes and goes from SE kind of riding the "yeah, it's ok" wave as so many of there games have lately. Then again, some others recently have been worse.

    As I play the first PE and think of their snes and ps1 library of games I am truly amazed at the massive amount of quality games. You forget sometimes, being as it's over half my life ago that I was gaming on a snes as my main console, but this brand was like the blizzard or valve of console games(without the half decades between game iterations), just pure awesomeness.
  • orangpelupa #22 1 year ago

    seems the difficulty spikes is the problem.

    i wonder if playing with a cheat will make this game more fun.
    game devs should give cheat options on every game.... (like GTA, warcraft, the sims, and so on)
  • NewbieZilla #23 1 year ago

    @Vistrix

    I'd place it around the time they became Square Enix (no longer Squaresoft).
  • Vlad27145 #24 1 year ago

    @MattEdWithCheese

    Thank you! I guess I'm having more and more of a hard time in trying to convey my point with clarity. Thankfully it's clear enough that at least a person or two gets it and clarifies for me :)

    @FireMonkey

    I take your point, but I also mentioned in my previous comment that IMHO they found a pretty good way to go around the problem with a good auto-aim system. In my experience with the game, I haven't had particular issues with the controls. Now, I'm not saying that I'm right and the reviewer is wrong, or that he's a noob and if he can't handle the controls he should just suck it up. The game should be penalized in the review because some players might find the controls unwieldy. I just think it's been penalized a bit too harshly, because not ALL players will have issues.
  • karaokequeen3 #25 1 year ago

    miguel: Midnight Club 2!

    Oh, and it's Yvonne Strahovski in this game, right?
  • des #26 1 year ago

    meh,game is horrible and boring
    meh