Rock Band

It's a hard rock life.

I don't listen to a lot of rock music any more, my audio diet consists of 95 per cent hip-hop and a little bit of Girls Aloud. They only time I hear guitars is when MOP has sampled them and are bawling out really offensive lyrics over the top. But you know, if DJ Shadow can sample Metallica, I can sample a little bit of metal.

So there I am, drumming along to Weezer's Say It Ain't So. I mean, I liked Beverley Hills when DJ Muggs mashed it up with the Big Tymers but it's not like I'm sitting here wearing a cardigan, horned-rimmed glasses and one leg shorter than the other. But I am actually 'rocking out', as the youngsters would have it. I'll be worshipping Satan instead of strippers next.

Rock Band is, of course, exactly what you've been waiting for since Guitar Hero turned out to be - as every reviewer has stated since they got their hands on the plastic Gibson - AWESOME. It's also exactly what you were expecting. There's no surprises here, but who needs them when you've got Fender guitars, a microphone that doubles as a tambourine and a neat '80s-style electro drumkit? I don't even know the American chap who's singing to the right of me, or the the other fella's on guitar, but through the shared musical language of rock, we are like brothers in arms. I can't actually see the attraction of playing this online when we're all crowded into a sweaty rehearsal room to play together. It's like we've been jamming for hours, passing the jingo and cracking open another groupie. Games like this have made it acceptable for men to sing to each other, and that's something worth applauding.

For those about to rock

'Rock Band' Screenshot 1

At this early hands-on stage we're using prototype peripherals. I imagine holding a prototype machine gun would be quite exciting, but a prototype guitar isn't very thrilling, especially when one of the buttons falls off. But even on a unfinished Fender, the ease of use and beauty of the game is clear. As well as five fret buttons, there're another five at the base of the board for noodling guitar solos, which makes instant sense as soon as you see it. The guitar can also be tilted to activate Star Power - used to bring someone back into play if they fudge their instrument and get booted from the track.

The microphone might be the least glamorous instrument on offer, but if you're the frontman you'll probably be more concerned about your stage presence than anything else. The mic promises to pick up individual vowels and consonants because it's that sensitive, but with a bunch of pudgy games journalists pounding, hooting and pawing at the game, it's difficult to determine whether this really is the case.

'Rock Band' Screenshot 2

The drum kit is a personal favourite, being as it's the shit. Four coloured pads, one kick drum pedal, wooden sticks and instant thrills. I know it's a beautiful illusion of actually playing the drums because I'm tone death, I have the kind of timing where I walk on my wife with another man and I'm left handed. Yet I still felt like John Bonham. Confident players can stick it on the higher settings and know they're actually, really, honestly drumming along to the songs, but I'm happy with the illusion that I'm playing.

While my guitar gently bleeps

There's no doubt that Harmonix is treating every instrument in the game with the same care and attention. In the hands of a lesser developer Rock Band could stink of cash-in, but with the team behind the original Guitar Hero, Amplitude and FreQuency, we get the impression these guys would rather be making music than making games. "The thing that we're looking forward to is just turning people into musicians," says Daniel Sussman, Harmonix employee and member of punk band The Acro Brats.

"We've seen it to some extent with Guitar Hero where we heard stories of people trading in a toy guitar for a real one and that makes us happy. Hopefully we're going to see a lot more of that - groups of people who get the high from Rock Band that go on to form their own band."

For Harmonix, the branding of the in-game peripherals is important, not just to give users the real deal in their hands, but as a way of giving something back to the music industry.

'Rock Band' Screenshot 3

"If you look at the music industry there's a lot of resentment about the fact that videogames are taking kids away from music," says Sussman. "For me, I'm a musician and I've been playing guitar for as along as I can remember. So I'm thrilled to be taking people along for the ride. Working with people like Fender, Boss, Roland - it's a way for us to ground what we're doing in reality. The fact that Fender is supporting what we're doing, that's good karma."

U-G-L-Y, you ain't got no alibi

The actual on-screen action in Rock Band is plain ugly, but perfectly functional. Three instruments divide the bottom of the screen while lyrics run across the top. The fret boards are transparent enabling a view of your character rocking out. It's a mess to be honest, but thankfully this is one game where what's on screen visually isn't nearly as important as the tool in your hands and the sound blasting your ears. You can build and customise your own avatars from a selection of various gurning rockstar parodies, but again it's not important. I love System of a Down but I don't to stare at them, know what I mean?

The fact that I wouldn't listen to a good portion of the licensed music but am happy to play along with it perhaps indicates that the tracklisting isn't as important as it might first seem. And even though we've heard the tracks a thousand times (some of them in other games), the likes of Black Sabbath, The Who, David Bowie, Nirvana and Blue Oyster Cult are perfect for jamming. Certainly, Don't Fear the Reaper is better placed in Rock Band than it was in Midway's Roadkill. What matters is the feeling you get from playing these tracks.

'Rock Band' Screenshot 4

Although there's no doubt that Rock Band is going to cost more than the average videogame, it's promising to offer value for money. Players are getting four games in one and it's claimed that the guitar portion alone is bigger than Guitar Hero. Add your vocal game, drumming sessions, bass parts and the four-player co-operative play that ties it all together, and there's no denying this should be the complete rock n' roll experience. And, similar to Guitar Hero, it also comes complete with a World Tour mode where bands start out playing spit n' saw dust venues before climbing the the stairway to rock heaven. You'll just have to supply your own booze, drugs and, erm, shark.

The deciding factor of whether you pick up Rock Band isn't likely to be the fact that it's all about rock music. That's not important. It's the price that will seal the deal for many. And if it doesn't break your bank, then you're going to get countless laughs out of standing around with your mates - Jack Sabbath, Brain Maiden and Tracy DC - and getting down like crazed hard-rock nutters.

Comments (21) Latest comment 5 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • ProtoformX #1 5 years ago

    Must obtain this game...

    Joining a real band FTL :-P
  • ToAks #2 5 years ago

    man, love the idea of this, hopefully it will rock!
  • Stu #3 5 years ago

  • Toothball #4 5 years ago

    I showed my mother a video of this, and she told me to buy one for her whatever the cost. It was a shame to have to tell her that it wasn't out yet.
  • Universal_Hamster #5 5 years ago

    Buy her REAL INSTRUMENTS FFS!!!!!!!!!!
    Edited by 1 at 11/07/07 @ 10:04
  • Jeepers #6 5 years ago

    "Whilst my guitar gently bleeps".

    The author deserves a pay-rise for that.
  • lost_soul #7 5 years ago

    You walk on your wife with another man? At the same time? Does this hurt her, or are you and your co-walker very light?

    edit: maybe walk is a misspelling and it should have been wank. That'd make more sense.
    Edited by 1 at 11/07/07 @ 10:59
  • Zastai #8 5 years ago

    @lost_soul: you're obviously joking, but the intent probably was to say "the kind of timing where I walk IN on my wife with another man".
  • Zastai #9 5 years ago

    He also probably meant "... but I don't NEED/WANT to stare at them", and "Brian Maiden" works better as a pun name than "Brain Maiden" (unless he pronounces "Iron" in a very peculiar way).


    One thing that I haven't seen mentioned so far is whether or not the multiplayer component supports a number of players other than 4 (i.e. if I get two mates round, do we need to find a 4th online somewhere or can we just rock out offline?). This article suggests 4 are indeed required, which would make the multiplayer much less appealing to me.
  • lost_soul #10 5 years ago

    Just kidding, Zastai :-)

    But yeah, Rock Band: is it current gen. only? There has to be a PS2 version, right?
  • moggsy #11 5 years ago

    But yeah, Rock Band: is it current gen. only? There has to be a PS2 version, right?

    I think disc's first post answers this question...
  • Incolas #12 5 years ago

    Hey I just saw that the Rock Band dev team will attend a live chat on Xfire next week: http://ww w.xfire.com/cms/xf_music_week_h... It could be cool to get a direct hold of developers for once.
  • wellsie #13 5 years ago

    I know Guitar Hero made me take up the guitar for real, but I still enjoy Guitar Hero because playing the 10 chords I know :p is not the same feeling yet as nailing a song on hard. Plus if you can really play the drumms along to a song that is brilliant!
  • Toothball #14 5 years ago

    @Universal Hamster

    Buy her REAL INSTRUMENTS FFS!!!!!!!!!!

    You see, she likes to have this sort of crazy new thing to show off at parties. In the past, this has included flamenco dancers, a chocolate fountain (before they were popular, DDR, Singstar and most recently Guitar Hero. It usually takes a while to get the older party-goers to sing or dance or whatever, but they get there in the end.

    Now, while I'm sure a set of real instruments would be far better musically, what can a bunch of middle-aged, drunken office workers do with those? There would be noise, sure. Some of them might know how to play an instrument. But the non musicians wouldn't have all that much to do. With Rock Band however, they all join in. They're pretty bad at it, but the music is still coming out of the TV, which makes them feel like they're playing something. Which is what makes the difference really.
  • adman123 #15 5 years ago

    Looks amazing, cannot wait to play it...drums for sure are going to be amazing!!
  • nickthegun #16 5 years ago

    Misspelled 'Brian'. Brain Maiden sounds like a Japanese dating sim.
  • onyx_elite #17 5 years ago

    Reviewer needs english lessons. I still don't quite get

    'I have the kind of timing where I walk on my wife with another man and I'm left handed.'

    and 'Brain Maiden' is just lazy.
  • Monkey #18 5 years ago

  • zozart #19 5 years ago

    All I want to know is:

    1) Is the tambourine function of the mic optional; i.e. can one person play guitar/drums and sing. If the tambourine is manditory and you get penalised for not doing it, that's a bit rubbish.

    2) For the online, can you turn off vocals... I'm obviously going to give the online a go but I don't want to have to listen to some bloody 14 year old screeching. I can't see the vocals being that popular online if you can't. Also, it'd be nice if you could turn of sending your own vocals to everyone else, too. I can imagine a lot of people would be reluctant to sing in front of strangers (whole different kettle if you're playing with friends of course).

    Apart from that, this game looks amazing and I will be buying it no matter the cost.
  • figaro7 #20 5 years ago

    I dont know if i want to know how much this is going to cost us in our AU dollar, Guitar hero 2 was $150 AU, i cant see this being less than $200 AU though...
  • Dafridge #21 5 years ago

    Are all the instrument peripherals packaged together or do you have to buy them separately?