Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

God of War Collection Review

PlayStation 3 Retro ntsc-us Import Review by Kristan Reed

29 November, 2009

Page 1 of 2. Page 2 ->

"I don't care about innovation - I care about fun." So said God of War lead designer David Jaffe in a typically brash interview in the run up to the game's release in March 2005.

But, to address the dangling implication, Sony's PlayStation 2 exclusive was the best kind of blatant rip-off. It might well have been an attempt to do Onimusha with Greek mythology, but the way it wove ICO's enigmatic ambience alongside multi-layered puzzles ensured that its appeal went much deeper than hand-mangling combo mastery.

Perhaps it was Sony Santa Monica's cocksure belief that it could "execute this better than anybody" that drove it from a stylishly knockabout homage to Ray Harryhausen movies, into becoming one of the most complete action-adventure games of all-time. But whatever the explanation, the results were astonishing.

Still, evidently not everyone agrees. The other night while I was playing through the God of War Collection, my girlfriend spluttered incredulously: "Why do people get so bloody worked up about God of War anyway? It looks really irritating." Coming from someone who has slogged through hundreds of hours of Monster Hunter Freedom Unite, I found this simultaneously irritating and hilarious, but anyway.

"Because of everything!" was roughly my response. Playing through both games all over again had merely underlined why the series got me so excited in the first place - and few games have ever felt so enjoyable second time around.

'God of War Collection' Screenshot 1

Horse business.

It was all about the execution. Every single element of the game was brilliantly realised from front to back, and hit the sweet spot every time. Whichever part of the game you looked at, whether the combat system, the puzzles, the boss encounters, the narrative, the technology behind the game, or even the audio, it was absolutely outstanding.

And Jaffe was right to care about the fun above anything else. Fundamentally, God of War is accessible in everything it does. Playing it through again, it still feels irresistible; it still compels you to finish it. Something that's often overlooked in games is pacing, but Sony Santa Monica evidently understands that ebb and flow and variety is as important as anything else.

Its many contrasts all work within the general framework and transition seamlessly - to the point where the game starts to feel like an epic journey rather than a series of level and tasks. It never lingers on one element for very long; as soon as you've fought a few battles you're off exploring, leaping athletically around the environment or figuring out the next puzzle.

The pay-off is the inevitable epic boss fights, of course, but even these are handled with a degree of finesse that's hard to resist. Not so much screen-filling as area-filling, these multi-stage battles see Sony Santa Monica throwing everything into the pot, tasking players with using all the things they've learned in combat, lateral thought and platform dexterity to kill a vast enemy in stunning fashion.

'God of War Collection' Screenshot 2

God of War Collection is only out in the US at the moment, but hey, PS3 games are region-free. It's the future! Of the past!

And like the best videogames, something new and exciting threatens to appear at any moment. You don't just do the same old thing in slightly different-looking environments; the game evolves quite dramatically, offering you new weapons and abilities as well as a large procession of radically contrasting enemies.

But none of this would mean anything if the game didn't feel right, and it's something that strikes you from the word go. It's tempting to dismiss the combat as a typical button-masher, but that would be to underestimate the game's combat depth entirely.

While the games do initially allow you to stab triangle or square to swish your blades in a swashbuckling blizzard of fury, the longer they last the more enemies appear that take advantage of such a ham-fisted and lazy approach. Switching between blocking, evading, comboing, magic attacks, grab attacks and specific weapons gives you a pleasing amount of flexibility at all times - and without overwhelming players with needlessly complex commands.

Employing an automatic camera system was also a smart decision for numerous reasons - not least because it allowed the developers to enhance the cinematic impact of the game in ways that you lose if you're busy with the camera. Even better, by ignoring direct camera control the game frees the right analogue stick for rolling out of the way of enemy attacks. It's one of many potentially divisive decisions that you understand, and rarely if ever resent.

Advertisement

Are you excited about God of War Collection on PlayStation 3?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 74 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Dizzy
29/11/09 @ 08:49
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
And this is why you don't need backwards compatibility!

/recycle
djronz
29/11/09 @ 08:52
#2
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
got a 60gb bc ps3, got ps2 gow1 , but never played gow2 though, hmmm
EarlBassett
29/11/09 @ 09:05
#3
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've never played the first game, but really liked the second.
Not sure I can be bothered to get this with number 3 round the corner, as they all essentially seem to be the same game.

Maybe get it for xmas for the special lady though, as she loves it
Kostabi
29/11/09 @ 09:08
#4
+15
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I really want to like these games ( GoW, Devil May Cry, Bayonetta, etc) as they always look so entertaining when other people are playing them. As soon as I take over I end up mashing buttons like I'm playing in mittens.
Geordiemp
29/11/09 @ 09:27
#5
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Funny how good adventure / fighting type games are in a drought and then all come along at once.

Looks like will get this on import as I missed the Ps2 era, and Bayonnetta on 360.

Where is the best place to get GOW collection on import in UK ?
FooAtari
29/11/09 @ 09:28
#6
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Kostabi, button mashing is fairly effective in GoW
dominalien
29/11/09 @ 09:32
#7
+23
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
And why do we have to wait again?

Because you speak some language the americans can't understand.
Phily50
29/11/09 @ 09:34
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Where's the best place to import this from?
CaoSlayer
29/11/09 @ 09:34
#9
+7
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Button mash is impossible in hard or god modes.

In those modes is all about spamming a safe cancelable combo, roll when attacked and repeat all day long.

I don't like GoW as much as DMC or Ninja Gaide because how dull the combat becomes in harder settings.
leafmulch
29/11/09 @ 09:40
#10
-8
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I played through GoW 1 to the end and I thought it accomplished, yet soulless. It's like DMC without the pizazz. It's like giving people everything they thought they want... Having watched a playthrough of GoW3 on giantbomb, I had absolutely no compulsion to use the download code and try it for myself. Besides Bayonetta is around the corner, so who the heck needs this?
GamesConnoisseur
29/11/09 @ 09:42
#11
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Played PS2 versions recently on PS3 (still no ylod), and yes still great game which are pure fun but with sprinkling of odd frustrations. For me it was the platform jumping about in later stage where it is so easy to die, again and again due to the sheer cruelty of Santa Monica folks but the joy of beating the more challenging bits are worth it and PSP version is a very great addition that feels the same and can't wait for GOW3.
Lemming81
29/11/09 @ 09:50
#12
+7
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This is my first foray into GoW and while it is an excepetional set of games (GoW2 more so), it's not without it's problems.

Killing minotaurs that increase with hits per colour is not fun, it's just a time sink. That goes of any monster actually. How many times can you go 'ok here is an ogre....oh you killed him? OK, here is two!" before it gets samey?



That said I found the puzzles refreshing by today's standards. The lateral thinking involved without everything being signposted is brilliant.
Gillespionage
29/11/09 @ 09:51
#13
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I got the US version from Movietyme..
They sell mostly import blu-rays, but if you have a mosey around you can find GoW collection for £30 or so :)

It's worth it, as I could only ever find the ps2 versions in shops for around £15 each anyway.. So I may as well get it in lovely HD instea
Kenshin001
29/11/09 @ 09:54
#14
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Besides Bayonetta is around the corner, so who the heck needs this?"

Me, since I didn't like the Bayonetta demo. It's good to have the choice though. Actually my copy of the GoW Collection should arrive in a couple of days so this review pleases me.
NotSoSlim
29/11/09 @ 10:04
#15
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Collection is awesome!! Nostalgia is great...GOW3 demo is mint too :o)
stevethemeat
29/11/09 @ 10:32
#16
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Picked the US version up a few days ago, i missed these first time around so i had to try them before GOW 3 comes out, really enjoying the first one so far, and i am looking forward to the second seeing as it is better than the first,

I normally wouldnt go for this type of game, but i was fan of films like Clash of the Titans growing up and being a fan of greek mythology in general helps.

Is the GOW3 demo available on the playstation store?
Edited 3 times, most recently on 29/11/09 @ 11:35
jamhead
29/11/09 @ 10:59
#17
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Disappointing that they didn't bother to update the cut scenes to HD, especially given all the spiel and bollocks Sony gave about PS3 = TRUE HD etc. It's just laziness.

For all those of you who played one of the GoW's and not the other - they're both very much worth playing IMO. Really annoyed that I may fall into Sony's trap and buy this even though I own both on the PS2 already. Damn you and your borked/lack of PS2 BC in Europe!

/shakes fist
redneon
29/11/09 @ 10:59
#18
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I imported it from videogamesplus.ca. Though dvdboxoffice.com would be just as good. Then there's play-asia too.

What a superb set of games. Nearly finished the first one again and couldn't agree with this review more.
EarlBassett
29/11/09 @ 11:00
#19
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I got the US version from Movietyme.."

I used to use them, but their delivery times are staggering. Average of nearly 2 weeks for me on blu-rays
cyacomini
29/11/09 @ 11:14
#20
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I actually bought a PS2 just to play the GoW games when I realised BC had been removed from the PS3's..

Looking forward to Dantes Inferno more than GoW3 to be honest - think I've just sickened myself with Kratos.
kentmonkey
29/11/09 @ 11:51
#21
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've got to admit, I really wanted to love GOW, but I just didn't. I preferred Ninja Gaiden. I'm not sure what it was, but it just felt a little formulaic to me, which is a surprise considering the universal love it gets.

One of those games that just didn't click, I guess. Even so, still weirdly tempted to give it another go to see, although I'm fairly sure it won't change my opinion.
Freek
29/11/09 @ 11:58
#22
+9
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
They can't roll out the "europe has different languages" exuse anymore. Many games have world wide releases, even with multipell soundtracks all in the game.

And this is a re-release, all the translation work has already been done!

So what's the real reason here? SCEE just being rubbish as usual?
hyperkineticninja
29/11/09 @ 12:13
#23
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Good place to import:

http://videogamesplus.ca/

Canadian website, I live in Spain GOW collection cost me 37 Euros incl. P and P.

They take about a week to deliver, and give you updates all along the way.
NorUraeus
29/11/09 @ 12:31
#24
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Freek: Most game developers tend to point out these days that translations is not the biggest issue with doing European releases. Things like certification processes, sorting out rights issues and complying to various other pieces of local law is what tend to take time. Also for re-releasing older games you might have old publisher agreements which needs re-negotiating, unlike for instance the US and Japan where most major game studios published their own stuff.
ParanoidZombie
29/11/09 @ 12:33
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
GOW1 was really a shock for me back in 2005. I expected a violent button-masher, but the story and atmosphere really caught me by surprise. GOW2 was a bitter disappointment, because the plot was vastly inferiror (IMO) and Kratos didn't feel "right" in this sequel, the character became some sort of caricature of his previous self. GOW3 really needs to tell an interesting story, otherwise the final product will be nothing but an average game with stellar production values, a bit like killzone 2.
trebell
29/11/09 @ 12:36
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
God of war was a funny one for me, i loved the setting and the style and enjoyed the puzzle elements but didn't enjoy the combat much and never finished it.

I've thought about getting 2 but would just get the ps2 one as i have a b/c PS3 and can get it for under a tenner.

Currently playing God of PSP and I am enjoying that , so maybe my tastes are changing and i can still enjoy the third one.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 29/11/09 @ 12:37
makeamazing
29/11/09 @ 12:43
#27
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Coming from someone who has slogged through hundreds of hours of Monster Hunter Freedom Unite, I found this simultaneously irritating and hilarious, but anyway.

Haha great comment. This is so true of gamers, its amazing how one person will slate one game, only to be doing exactly the same on another type of game.

Not sure if I will pick this up, not really my type of game, but considering it took 15 weeks of dev, they have sold about 120k so far, that is very impressive.
actionfitz
29/11/09 @ 12:58
#28
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Best of all, PS3 games are region-free, so there's no excuse for not importing this immediately. Simply divine."

I approve of this message.
- My copy arrived on friday hehe
woop woop!
EarlBassett
29/11/09 @ 13:30
#29
+9
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"my girlfriend spluttered incredulously"

Even reviewers feel the need to remind us they have girlfriends any chance they get, not just the commenters
freakzilla
29/11/09 @ 13:58
#30
-6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sony seriously needs to get their shit together if they want to keep competing with the likes of Microsoft, being unable to release their own first party titles simultaneously across the US and EU is not a good sign.

Oh just F**** off!!! Sony has no bloody excuse, GoW collection was the only christmas game I wanted and it won't even be here till next year. And whats their excuse this time? All the F***ing localising has already been done.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 29/11/09 @ 19:56
hilts
29/11/09 @ 13:58
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think it is unlikely this will even get released in Europe ..if III is due out in March? Think will import ... Are there any issues with trophies etc if you buy the import?
Edited 1 times, most recently on 02/12/09 @ 10:17
Beano
29/11/09 @ 14:11
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
no
Beano
29/11/09 @ 14:12
#33
+7
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I think it is unlikely this will even get released in Europe "

I belive it has allready been confirmed for Europe...
Skire
29/11/09 @ 14:30
#34
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
nope, everything works as it should.
fjharps
29/11/09 @ 15:09
#35
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm quite lucky that my local game store imports games from the US as soon as they are released this year I've enjoyed Blazblue, Demon's Soul and now lucky for me God of War collection and all of them priced as normal european releases. I have been playing the GoW collection for the past week and I couldn't agree more with the review i'm having much more fun playing this second time round than i did the first time it's one of those games that really hasn't aged at all and i think they were impressive for ps2 standards in the first place especially GoW2. What I do agree is with the blu-ray, Vhs comparisons the reviewer did when it came to the cut scenes they do look bad compared to the crisp look of the game.
davisorle
29/11/09 @ 16:46
#36
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This collection is great for those that dont have any of the titles included already and havent played either. I do need to ask though the reviewer:
With what criteria do you give an upscaled ( more or less ) PS2's title a 9/10 on the PS3? Dont gwet me wrong, great value, good game and all... But its a PS2, with not everything in higher resolution, game. I dont know if my question is clear on what and how im asking it.

P.S. Dont import it. Wait for it. You never know what else might be included by then in the BR.
leafmulch
29/11/09 @ 16:53
#37
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Kenshin001 as you didn't like the Bayonetta demo out of interest did you try the ps3 or xbox demo?

I just realised that after the technical DF mauling people may well be looking to GoW3 to shine for the PS3. Looks like from the comments it's pretty much a 50/50 split of ppl who love the franchise and others who thought it lacked that special something. Regarding my previous post, I was obviously talking about the GoW3 demo download/playthrough... Maybe it's my mistake, but I do see this as in the same genre as DMC/Bayonetta/NG et al. And therefore the reason for my comment.
notmyrealname
29/11/09 @ 17:10
#38
-4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
''while God of War III faces off against a lot of big names in 2010, the greatest threats to its dominance lie in its own past''

And we are all scared shitless it won't live up to it. PLEASE LET IT BE AS GREAT AS GOW II!! PLEEEAAASE!

and you haven't played the game properly until you have completed it on the hardest difficulty. Then come back with the 'timesinks' argument.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 29/11/09 @ 17:13
hilts
29/11/09 @ 17:11
#39
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I know it has been confirmed but the fact that there isn't a specific date and that 3 is due out here and in the US in March does not bode well in my opinion, maybe all 3 will come on one special package but I am not too hopeful :(
BigAl-1992
29/11/09 @ 17:17
#40
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Can I just ask if it only got 9/10 because of the imperfect porting for the cutscenes, or for something else.
rogueJT
29/11/09 @ 18:43
#41
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'd go with Axel Music for this. Works out as 32 euro delivered, and as It's sent from within the EU you won't be hit with any customs charges(I know it's unlikely you'll be caugth anyway, but still)

http://www.axelmusic.com/productDetails/...
Pablo2k5
29/11/09 @ 19:16
#42
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ BigAl-1992 "Can I just ask if it only got 9/10 because of the imperfect porting for the cutscenes, or for something else."

...erm, because it's not perfect. 10 would suggest the game had no significant faults... *confused*
Voyeurism
29/11/09 @ 19:23
#43
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
And why do we have to wait again?

Because you speak some language the americans can't understand.


Yes. That language is English.
Santino
29/11/09 @ 19:24
#44
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"With what criteria do you give an upscaled ( more or less ) PS2's title a 9/10 on the PS3? Dont gwet me wrong, great value, good game and all... But its a PS2, with not everything in higher resolution, game. I dont know if my question is clear on what and how im asking it."

i think it might be because these 2 games are still better than almost everything that has been released on the ps3 so far.

I bought my copy from an ebay seller as it was a UK seller, but mine didn't come with a demo code, i take it only some copies do? where is the logic in that?
IMD1_Pk
29/11/09 @ 19:48
#45
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
As far as I am concerned I don't think there are many other games that deserve to be ported to the PS3. Like the review said God of War used textures and an art style that was near impossible to get done on such low resolution and that is why it benefited from the increase in resolution so much. It's a special case because most good game developers aim to make the game look as good as it can under the constraints of the console and what's the best type of art style they can achieve.

A great case would be Shadow of the Colossus which looks really messy when unscaled to higher resolutions. They used extremely low resolution textures and their art style is what helped create the illusion of an eerily realistic land.

There are some other good candidates for conversion though. Off the top of my head FF12, zone of enders2, resident evil 4, silent hill 3, and MGS3(2 would be a bad candidate though) and Black(it looked fantastic played on a 360 with AA and 720 upscaling so I assume with a resolution boost it would look even better on the PS3).

Now the wait for GoW III begins....
Sparkplug
29/11/09 @ 20:06
#46
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Had this for a week, and even though I own GOW 1&2 on PS2 I thought it was worth buying as they are both epic games! Looks good in HD as well. There are very few HD remakes I would buy, but this for me is worth the money, I just hope Konami take note and do the same for MGS 3.

Also it's a fucking joke that this was released in the US before the UK. It also sets the scene nicely for GOW 3!
wile_coyote
29/11/09 @ 20:50
#47
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
There's something about Greek mythology that fails to interest me. That said, I do own a Playstation 2 and a copy of GoW. I got as far as the snake thing on the boat near the start, and thats as far as I got. The game did little for me. Maybe I should give it another go.
Gregolution
29/11/09 @ 21:25
#48
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I missed GOW 1 and 2 so pleased they re released this. I'm thoroughly enjoying the first one, I think I'm close to the end. Being someone thats well into the latest graphics I'm surprised I can enjoy it, but it still looks very decent. Story is good, puzzles are fun, combat is more deep than I thought it would be and I absolutely love greek mythology - it's so epic!
Frosty840
29/11/09 @ 22:06
#49
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Got sadly stuck on GoW1 on the first real level, where it asks you to "do a combo" to break an enemy's shield. I had no idea how to do that, and no guide on the internet ever explained what I was meant to do at that point. So I had to give up, because the game became largely impossible.

Might go back to it now, though. I'll have to see if anyone's made an idiot-friendly walkthrough for the entire game...
Widge
29/11/09 @ 22:13
#50
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ah, thats the attack where you start off with some Square hits and the finish with Triangle hits. That causes Kratos to SMASH down at the end of his combo, busting the shields.

Comments: 1-50 of 74 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Get Games.  Download Great PC Games!

X View gallery