Cheshire: PSP is a "bollocking useless waste of space"
Codemasters bigwig not a fan.
Gavin Cheshire, Codemasters Studios vice president, isn't a great believer in the PSP.
"Well, speaking as a person who bought a PSP, the problem was that I always thought - because it was a better screen than iPod's - that I'd be doing more with it. But it was such a bollocking useless waste of space; just getting stuff on it was ridiculous," he told Edge magazine, issue 213.
"That was its downfall. Relatively speaking, [Codemasters] didn't do too badly on F1 PSP. But regarding the future, I think they've got - well... no.
"PSPgo's a lovely device," he added, "really smart - but our senior VP bought one the day it came out and has a great story, because he ended up on some customer support line just trying to do basic stuff. He had to re-download his software, do an immediate firmware update, and that's your user experience.
"Sony just hasn't got it right. Stuff like that will make people leave it alone."
Conversely, Cheshire thinks Apple's new iPad is "brilliant" and believes there's potential despite the App Store being swamped with content.
"The ecosystem's right," he said, "the straight-to-console nature of it."
Some people believe the PSP and iPhone are on a collision course. PopCap's John Vechey told Eurogamer earlier this year that as Apple revised iPhone hardware, graphics would eventually improve and match Sony's machine. What happens then, we'll leave you to speculate.
You may also like...
-
Why Devs Owe You Nothing
-
Digital Foundry: PS3 Skyrim Lag Fixed?
-
Face-Off: The Darkness 2
-
App of the Day: Sir Benfro's Brilliant Balloon
-
Sony admits "dropping the ball" with Demon's Souls
-
Who Killed Rare?
-
EA evaluating FIFA Street features for FIFA 13
-
Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3 Vita Review
-
CD Projekt: Witcher 2 intro cinematic "the most expensive asset we ever created"
-
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning Review
-
Gotham City Impostors Review
-
One Piece: Unlimited Cruise SP Review
-
Grand Slam Tennis 2 Review
-
The Darkness 2 Review
-
Skyrim patch 1.4 performance tip: make a new manual save
-
Skyrim patch 1.4 now live for Xbox 360
-
Mass Effect 3 FemShep trailer debuts
-
Epic's Sweeney on graphics tech: "the limit really is in sight"
-
Valve admits hackers accessed Steam transaction log
-
Double Fine Adventure passes Day of the Tentacle budget
-
King Arthur 2 Review
-
Metal Gear Solid: The "Lost" HD Remasters
-
Next Xbox has tablet-like touch-screen controller - rumour
-
Sony: The Last Guardian is making "slow progress"
-
App of the Day: Superman









Comments (93) Latest comment 2 years ago
Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
The DS on the other hand I've had loads of fun with.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I'll keep the PSP until PeaceWalker comes out, and then I think I'll trade it in.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I hate using my iTouch for games because it's buttonless, there's no tactile feedback and screen-based "virtual" analog sticks are an abomination straight from Satan's arse.
Great for music, mouse-style apps and the web, but if you want games get a proper games machine. Get a PSP or DSi.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Granted for puzzle games and more casual stuff the iPhone is brilliant, but it doesn't come close when you want hardcore game.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
"SHARXTREME: iPad is 500$-900$ and it doesnt even support flash or running 2 apps at the same time"
+1 for truth
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Oh... hang on... I'll get me coat.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
But what hurts PSP most IMHO is that it is too much like your proper home console. It offers too few game experiences that can't be played elsewhere. DSi is better positioned in that regard.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Saying that I can't be bothered to buy a PSP either.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
@ Johnhost - if you want to get some of the App Store action for yourself , try an iPod touch which does exactly the same things except make calls and take low-res photos. Vastly cheaper too. Personally I love my iPhone but games that try to crowbar a traditional control scheme onto the touch screen really really suffer. GTA for example: awesome conversion, practically seamlessly the exact same game as DS and PSP, but those controls, man they were annoying. Deleted within an hour. Plants vs Zombies on the other hand, wicked.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Some things are too good to miss. Well done Edge for such a priceless quote.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
What scares me is that none of those requests are complicated or expensive, or new - yet Sony seems incapable of getting off its butt.
One major point in its favour, I let my kid play with the PSP - but he's not allowed on the phone
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
http://ww w.edge-online.com/news/codemast...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I love my iPhone and I use it a fair bit, but my PSP is where I go if I am playing portable variants of "peoper console games". There are some awesome games on the iPhone Fflightcontrol is an addictive steal at 59p), but they are for 5 minute hits at a time.
That said, the iPad will end up brining more software to the iPhone too, which can't be a bad thing.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Lest we forget that the PSPgo:
- Is much more expensive than a PSPfat/slim.
- It's not backwards compatible with the games you already bought on UMD.
- It's download only - no UMD - nothing tangible to hold in your hand, to say you 'own' that game.
- The storage device is not backwards compatible - say goodbye to all those Memory Sticks you bought.
- Memory Stick M2 still cost a small fortune.
- After buying a few games by download, MemSticks will run out of memory (especially if you also download demos, music, photos etc.) More MemSticks = more cost!
- You now have to consider buying a game and buying a MemStick to fit it on.
- It's screen is smaller than the previous models...hello!!!
- No Homebrew. Sony have no intention of 'opening it up' to the open source community or simplifying its SDK.
- Indented buttons suck.
- Need I go on...?
He should really put the two units next to each other and look very hard at what he's missing, if he goes for a PSPgo.
As for how they stack up against the iPhone? Well, all I can say is that any mobile phone trying to act as a games console will immediately depreciated the virtues of having a dedicated portable games device.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Me: Does the PSP?
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Why not begin with a really good controller, e.g. an XBox360 controller or a PS3 Dual Shock or whatever, and hang a little screen, processor, RAM, etc off the back of that? It'd fit in a backpack, or by your bedside, or whatever, and you could play games that looked decent, and *felt* right. That would be a step in the right direction IMO.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
He's right though, it's a lovely device but the overall experience of owning one has been quite arduous. Nearly six months down the line and most of the PSP range still isn't available for download. I don't particularly like what Apple do with hardware and software, but they really know how to run a service.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
@zedzee you can't site Homebrew as a negative against the PSPgo, its not like it is a standard feature of the standard PSPs either. Also, coming from someone who has to resort to lugging a PSP around for music purposes at the moment, a smaller size is actually a positive, not a negative.
I'm sure the 16GB of onboard memory kind of negates the entire memory stick thing too.
Not being able to put a UMD on the machine is a great shame though, and that puts me off the change. Its a hard thing to manage though, as you'd imagine people would just hire and rip off games. You'd need some sort of ripping program that requires validation from the game disc each week or something.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
1) I'm an atheist but if iPad helps to rid the net of Flash, it'd be a godsend
2) 3rd party multitasking on the iPad is one of the big unknowns at this time. But when it comes to games, multitasking is hardly the biggest worry. E.g. PSP and DSi aren't exactly known for their multitasking prowess...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
The biggest twat i ever worked for.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
"I always thought - because it was a better screen than iPod's - that I'd be doing more with it. But it was such a bollocking useless waste of space".
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Good for people who loves their PSP and swears by it, but the reality is that the wider world doesn't agree as evident by the poor sales and supports from devs. Still believe Sony made huge mistake in not commiting to PSP2 instead of stopgap PSPGo. The product wouldn't help Sony's reputation any.
IPhone for me is an unmissable device for all the right reason, does pushes in a lot of new directions in games as well. Sword and Sworcery and few mores show there are still potentials. Yet yes the console experience are better fit on PSP or DS to an extent. Still there are great fun on iPhone as Sword n Poker etc. These doesn't exists on DS or PSP.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Some of your points are good ones, but...
"- It's download only - no UMD - nothing tangible to hold in your hand, to say you 'own' that game."
I think the app store shows very few people (as in, effectively none) really give a shit about that. And besides no forward thinking person in charge of new tech products should have "tangible disc to hold in your hand" anywhere NEAR a list of core requirements.
And you seem to be making the memory stick point 4 times in slightly different ways.
Otherwise, you make some fair points.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
You have misunderstood the quote, or perhaps just selectively c'n'pasted it.
The full section was...
"Well, speaking as a person who bought a PSP, the problem was that I always thought - because it was a better screen than iPod's - that I'd be doing more with it. But it was such a bollocking useless waste of space; just getting stuff on it was ridiculous"
Translation. I thought I would get more done with the PSP, as it has a better screen than the iPod, but it turned out to be useless. He ain't talking about the screen being useless. The screen was the benefit in his eyes.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I think it's nice to acknowledge those moments when a viewpoint gets the perfect spokesman.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I completely agree that the iPhone lacks tactile feedback and for that reason some types of game just don't work, but the PSPs dreadful loading times combined with poor quality console conversions meant I played it less and less.
In the end LocoRoco was the only really outstanding PSP title for me and that game seems like a perfect fit for iPhone motion controls.
Edit: Typo
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Wow, uncanny - that's exactly what went through my mind whilst playing Dragon Rising.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Nice to see a developer who isn't afraid to say what needed to be said.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Want to look like a bourgeois douchebag, get the iPad/iPhone/iWhatever.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
theres a world of difference between buying games on the app store for a couple of quid and being forced to pay full price for PSPGO games on download when you can buy them in a shop for half price. That's the problem, not the fact that they are downloaded
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Dissidia is the only PSP exclusive I own, but it's great, also have Street Fighter Alpha 3 Max, imo, the best portable Street Fighter experience out there, Breath Of Fire 3, very dated, horrible load times, but decent, and some absolute classic old PSOne gems, RE 2 portable for 5 Euro? FF VII portable for 10 Euro?
and my most wanted games this year are all PSP exclusives, Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep, Valkyria Chronicles 2 and MGS Peace Walker.
All that and a great portable MP3 and video player makes it 180 Euro well spent
I have a DS too, which is great, but I love playing console quality games on the bus or train, and tbh, stylus based games can be very hard to play on a bumpy bus journey, console style games usually work better
PSP and DS both get much love from me
Comment below viewing threshold Show
It's a piece of piss.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Well someone has to i s'pose.
:-D
Comment below viewing threshold Show
PSPgo has it. But it's PSPgo...
I think iPods do games the way PSP does movies. It looks good, but somehow I don't want it.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
that is why there are PSP Minis with prices from about a £1 to £4; they are the ones you should be comparing to as opposed to the full price titles.
I like my PSP - I don't play it much. I generally take it with me on hols where it gets used a fair bit.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
iPad/iPhone gaming is the future: cheap, accessible and letting the bedroom coders get a look-in once again.
*waits for negs*
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Please go away and come back when you're slightly less of a retard.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Wow. If you're going to judge a console on one bad experience, then every console is bad. And so is the Ipod touch/ Iphone.
If anything, the Ipohne is competing with the DS, and given that the cheapest Iphone is still at least twice the price of the most evpensive DS, and more expensive than a PSP go, it's not much of a collision course.
Also, the PSP isn't marketed in the same way as the Iphone. The Iphone is shown as a jack-of-all-trade machine, on t.v. you get those adverts showing it's utility, and the vast catalogue of different apps. Whereas the PSP is a games machine, and everything else it can do is merely miscellaneous and not the main focus. And the PSP does have better games, so in that respect this is quite an unfair comparison to make.
In the same way that people don't criticise iphone games on the same level as PSP games, because a games machine is not it's main purpose. Also forgetting the price factor - overall, most would say that apple products are overpriced - hence why most people have PCs, and Iphones/ipods are as much a fashion item as they are music players. There are better and cheaper music players/phones than the Iphone, whereas the PSP is more powerful, and arguably better than the DS.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Me a happy twerp
Comment below viewing threshold Show
If the Go had better battery life and a better browser then it'd be a worthy contender for the iPod touch, as it effectively has all of the same features as the iPod Touch - albeit with a greater focus on more serious gameplay.
Here's an idea Sony, sell a 37" Bravia 1080p TV with a PS3 and say 4 games (LBP, ModNation Racers, Uncharted 2 and Ratchet and Clank) a few blu-rays and a PSP with £50 PSN voucher, extra Dual Shock 3 and PlayTV for around a grand, aiming it at the all-in-one family device and you're onto a winner...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Not much happening on it at the moment, that's true, but I'd pick up Loco Roco 3 in a heartbeat. (hope they're making one right now!)
Comment below viewing threshold Show
"theres a world of difference between buying games on the app store for a couple of quid and being forced to pay full price for PSPGO games on download when you can buy them in a shop for half price"
I agree whole heartedly. But the issue I was talking about isn't the same thing.
My point is that "having a disc you can hold" doesn't really matter to anyone anymore. If however, software on the app store could be bought on disc for half as much, people would indeed care about that.
What they care about is the price difference, not the existence of the disc. To turn things around, if PSP games on the PSN Store cost half as much as the discs in the shops, people would care even LESS about holding a disc
@Windypops
I don't agree with your paper weight comment, but you are right about bedroom coders getting a look in on the iPhone (maybe if you had posted these points seperately, the second one wouldn't have got negs
@Rev. Stuart Campbell
I've never seen you write a post that is becoming of your actual age. Its pretty tragic.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
As I understand it, the mainstream software does ok (as its audience simply don't pirate software), but the more hardcore titles get pirated at an astonishing rate. Given that the PSP catalogue is comprised of far more hardcore titles than that of the DS, is it really comparing apples with apples for the article to put the effects of piracy on the two platforms alongside?
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
When someone says "its not all the fault of piracy", they are alerady skewing the discussion. I'm not saying piracy is solely responsible for anything, I'm not even saying piracy is responsible in part for anything.
I'm simply saying that "The DS suffers piracy, and the DS has high software sales, therefore piracy does not account for low software sales on the PSP" is an oversimplified and unsafe statement.
Association, not causation. A crucial difference.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
A great story? That explains the 'plot' in Dragon Rising :-D
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
He was clearly talking about the iPad (which isn't 4-5 times more expensive than a PSP at the entry point, but its getting there).
And the post you quoted referenced the "iPhone/iPad". So its a little cheeky to choose the iPod Touch as a comparison for your own ends.
Why are you always so angry? Always. All the time.
Edit: deleted post? Interesting.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Only 4-5 times more expensive then PSP or DS."
Wow, you're a special kind of stupid.
An iPod Touch costs less to buy than a DS or PSP - the 8GB Touch, which has room for hundreds of games, currently sells for about £120.
New (legal) games start at free and mostly cost 59p and £1.19, compared to £20-25 on DS and PSP. There are literally dozens of games made available for free on limited-time promotions every day.
GTA Chinatown Wars costs £25 on DS or PSP, and £5.99 on iPod/iPhone for the same game.
So do explain to us where in the non-fuckwit world you get "4-5 times more expensive" from, you complete fucking penis.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I'd love to own a PSP GO from an aesthetic point of view... but i know Sony will just wallet rape me for the cost of the beast, then force me to buy their artificially expensive software too.
bah.
/mourns what could have been.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Do something Sony!!!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
But it seems if you say something "pro psp" you get positives here, pro iphone will net you a negative... Same as posting an anti piracy post on a thread about piracy... etc etc
.. Something tells me the "positive/negative" thing which (IMHO) is SUPPOSED to be used to hide trolls is being abused.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
This is just bollocks. You can't have it both ways. That's the trouble with gamers: they want the world but never want to pay for it. With consoles, part of the software price is to offset the losses or low margins on the hardware. A disruptor like the iPhone / iPod Touch is now shaking up the market: Apple already makes a profit on the hardware and sees the software as a means to make its hardware attractive. And through digital distribution it found a way to deliver the software very cheap to the users of its hardware.
DS, PSP and the home consoles still make use of the 'old' model. PSPgo is in an especially odd position because it embraces the new model while still being tied to the old as Sony didn't cut the ties completely with the PSP, thus creating competition between DLC and physical games which in turn resulted in retailers putting the pressure on Sony to price its DLC higher or dropping the PSPgo altogether. A very stupid move by Sony.
Solution to this is either increase PSPgo price so retailers make a healthy margin on the hardware alone or cut out the middle man for selling the hardware by opening Sony stores and using direct web sales.
It will be interesting to see which business model in the end gets the upper hand: 1) cheap hardware vs expensive software or 2) expensive hardware vs cheap software.
My bet is still on the old model because of human psychology: People just can't properly value future cost and therefore will pretty much always go for a 300 euro system with 60 euro games instead of a 600 euro system with 30 euro games although simple math will tell you that you 'only' need to buy over 10 games for the second option to be the better value (not taking into account time value of money and other uses the console might provide).
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Now on the other hand, i have an ipod touch - and have bought EASILY 80 or 90 one dollar games for it. It's perfect for the plane/train, as they're simple quick games to enjoy without too much concentration (for example swords and poker). They're certainly not games i'd pay $20+ for the umd of, but when i can buy 5 games for the price of one beer, that's good value imho.
Im also more likely to be more experimental with my purchases at that price too. Subsequently my ipod gets used lots, and my psp (to quote the fanboys in a wii thread) is "gathering dust".
Comment below viewing threshold Show
E.g. in pretty much all cases I can get AAA PS3/PSP titles for considerably less than in the stores with a little searching on the internet while the difference between online and brick&mortar prices for Wii/DS games is negligible. Or am I looking in the wrong places?
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Well, actually the price range is $500 (499 if you want to be precise) to $ 830 (829 if you want to be precise again)...
The 'cheap' model is actually relatively inexpensive (looking purely at cost price, not from a value to the consumer PoV as that's rather subjective), being subsidised by the more expensive versions. Like the low margin on the 8GB iPod Touch is offset by higher margins on the more expensive models / iPhone.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
No, you were replying to one about, and I quote, "iPad/iPhone gaming". Currently there are no iPad-specific games, so iPod, iPad and iPhone games are all the same thing, which can be accessed on a cheap iPod Touch.
In any event, games costing 59p rather than £25 would make up any hardware price difference in no time. App Store gaming is by miles the cheapest overall of any current format.
My penis is fully functional, but thanks for your concern. If only we could say the same about that soggy dishrag between your ears, eh?
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Delighted to, as soon as you explain to us how it's more 4-5 times more expensive to play App Store games than DS or PSP ones, or acknowledge that you're a fucking idiot who badly needs to shut up before he makes an even bigger dick of himself.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I go through handheld phases every now and then but without major commutes the appeal eventually fades. Yes threre's gaming lying back on the sofa or in bed but hell I have my 40" tv by my bed and use the bed as a sofa.
Its a shame really because I know Im missing out on some great PSP and DS games. But as it is I'm buying 2 full price console/pc games, at least, a month so I can't really justify buying handheld games as well.