Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

Battlefield 1943 Review

Xbox 360 PC PlayStation 3 Review by Dan Whitehead

10 July, 2009

Page 2 of 2. <- Page 1

So, two identical factions, three classes, three main maps and one game mode. For a download title it's an adequate start, but it does leave you in little doubt that the future of Battlefield 1943 lies in micropayments and DLC. Again, those reared on the mod community of the original game will no doubt bristle at having to pay for map packs and the like, and it's true that the prospect of paying to keep the game interesting rather negates the current bargain price.

As an initial investment, the game certainly impresses. It's an incredibly immersive dip into familiar waters, with the Bad Company's Frostbite engine offering up a satisfying destructible world, where buildings can crumble and walls collapse under the treads of a rampaging tank. Character models are a little basic, and the maps show their limitations when you take a plane high into the sky, but there's not much to complain about where production values are concerned. If anything dampens things on that front, it's the lag, which is most notable if you're trying to shoot down planes which teleport across the sky in distracting lurches. Hopefully the server fix will eradicate this problem.

Despite being pitched at console gamers, there are few concessions to the n00bs here. Anyone used to the subtle auto-aiming that makes most console shooters playable online will be flummoxed by the unforgiving accuracy demanded here, while the pace of the gameplay leaves little room for those trying to find their feet. There's a tutorial, but with no live foes it doesn't do much to prepare you for the mayhem ahead.

It comes with the territory, but it's no surprise to see the leaderboards for each match dominated by a handful of elite players who walk away from the round with over 500 points, while newcomers struggle to double figures. There's thankfully no friendly fire, but many of the other frustrations from Battlefields of old are still here, especially the prevalence of camping snipers. The sniper rifle in BF1943 is a ludicrously overpowered beast, capable of killing players in one shot from the other side of the map, so all it takes is for one team to have a proficient long-distance shooter and the precious balance so beautifully created by the weaponry and vehicles starts to fall apart.

'Battlefield 1943' Screenshot 3

Tanks are great for clearing fortified areas, but are easy prey for the Infantry bazookas.

Movement on foot is sometimes snagged by rogue scenery or a wayward incline, and vehicle control isn't all it could be. The planes are slippery customers, but mastering their peculiarities is one of the few ways to guarantee massive scores. You can also be sure to find queues of annoying players loitering around the plane respawn points, practically begging to be sniped. The land vehicles aren't quite as successful - with no reverse gear they're easy to jam into impossible spaces, and tanks are often more trouble than they're worth.

The slimline features also means that there's not much benefit in ranking up. Although there are awards for specific feats, these are just collectable stamps. There are no perks, no bonuses, no loftier purpose behind climbing the ranks than old-fashioned bragging rights. Nor are the lobby options much to get excited about. The front-end is functional but inflexible, clearly favouring those who just want to dive into the first available match. You can join up with friends as a squad, and carry your own private chat channel from one round to the next, but in terms of setting up custom games you're limited to basic options.

These minor irritations come and go as you battle through lengthy sessions, and while the gameplay benefits from the no-frills approach, rendering the action accessible to all in concept if not always in practice, there is a lingering danger that the game's undeniable appeal will dim pretty quickly with so few variables to play with. In the first flushes of infatuation it's an easy game to love, and one that will easily provide hours of ferocious enjoyment. In a few months' time the spell may well have worn off, but for this price that's really not something to worry about right now.

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Battlefield 1943 on PC/PlayStation 3/Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 139 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
mowgli
10/07/09 @ 10:33
#2
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Game is fucking awesome. It's just bloody hard to get a game!
r4z0rbl4d3
10/07/09 @ 10:34
#3
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Gl3n - No one cares

Great review, I've had a blast with the game, when I get to play it... EA are doing some maintenance right now and no one can play, hopefully the get things running more smoothly soon!
Edited 1 times, most recently on 10/07/09 @ 11:34
mikeck
10/07/09 @ 10:34
#4
+18
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I love the fact that instead of playing a multiplayer shooter in dark, grim environments, I get to shoot people in the head under lovely blue skies, on gorgeous pacific islands, with a big ass bright sun shining away - awesome stuff ;)
butler`
10/07/09 @ 10:35
#5
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
hmmmm ps3 or 360

i suppose 360 for the pad
AphoticCosmos
10/07/09 @ 10:36
#6
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's a really, really fun game, and the planes are extremely well done! I can't wait for Coral Sea to be unlocked.

And whilst doing a bit of browsing I found out that EA has confirmed BF3 somewhat under the radar in a cryptic statement! Why did nobody tell me, because it's about time that BF2 got a proper sequel!
CableNut
10/07/09 @ 10:36
#7
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Great review, great game........... :P
jack_klugman
10/07/09 @ 10:37
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The default controls aren't immediately intuitive for sure. Odd spread of weapon-swap controls on the infantry and confusing transitions between infantry and vehicles, with vehicles making next to no use of the left analogue stick. Why does nobody learn from Halo that third person vehicle control and consistent use of left stick movement and right stick aiming is the way to go? Bah!
DFawkes
10/07/09 @ 10:37
#9
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Could do with another map I felt, though I'll get my wish in a few million kills time so now I just have to play the waiting (and killing) game...

Great game though, love the simplified classes.
Paulanator
10/07/09 @ 10:38
#10
+15
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"The land vehicles aren't quite as successful - with no reverse gear they're easy to jam into impossible spaces"

I'm 99% sure that there is a reverse gear, you just have to hold LB (on the 360), the same button used for braking.
DDevil
10/07/09 @ 10:38
#11
+11
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"The land vehicles aren't quite as successful - with no reverse gear they're easy to jam into impossible spaces, and tanks are often more trouble than they're worth."

Err... All the land vehicles I've been bombing around in have had reverse gears! Good job too especially when I slide tanks down hills and through trees!
CableNut
10/07/09 @ 10:39
#12
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
paulanator ..... left trigger forward...... left button is reverse :P
El-Dev
10/07/09 @ 10:41
#13
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hold L2 for reverse.

8 is a fair score, but when you consider it's only £10 for the amount of hours that will get spent playing this it's well worth it.

A few European City maps, such as Berlin and Operation Market Garden from BF1942 and a few more weapon classes would well be worth a few quid in DLC.
agparrot
10/07/09 @ 10:41
#14
+11
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"The land vehicles aren't quite as successful - with no reverse gear they're easy to jam into impossible spaces,"

+1 to all the people who have played the game and noticed that there is a reverse gear!
Dizzy
10/07/09 @ 10:44
#15
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think it is great except for the uber deadly snipers :(

/tries to find reverse for plane
Edited 1 times, most recently on 10/07/09 @ 11:45
Agent_Orange
10/07/09 @ 10:44
#16
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Good review based on the game, fair enough the controls are maybe slightly niggly, and the destruction may cause some issues, but I think it deserves an extra 1 point for the price! Definately the best XBLA game i've played.
jack_klugman
10/07/09 @ 10:44
#17
+13
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
-1 to whoever thought holding the LB Button to reverse was a satisfactory button allocation. :P
rhinoxious
10/07/09 @ 10:45
#18
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Played it last night, briefly, it does seem to favour super serious players (with the powerful planes and snipers). I thought a more forgiving and accessible appoach would be better suited to a cheaply available, and inevitably popular, console shooter.
b00n
10/07/09 @ 10:48
#19
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Any BF42 veterans who have played the game? Wonder if it's worth it because it seems a lot of the depth, and sheer fun, has disappeared. Probably going to wait for BF3 instead of supporting this DLC fueled dumbing down of one of the most deep, engaging mp games ever.
Mike P
10/07/09 @ 10:50
#20
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I swapped the land vehicles onto stick drive, feels much more natural than splitting throttle control for forward / brake(and reverse, Dan) across two buttons.

I think the plane controls are daft though. To pull off a tight turn you should be able to roll it so the wings are vertical and pull back on the stick (like you would with a real plane or a scale model). Instead, nearly all the directional control comes via the rudder. That is, unless I'm missing something...
Mkwone
10/07/09 @ 10:51
#21
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Great game for starters, but hopefully we'll see free DLC. A couple more classes and maps would be grand.
jonarob
10/07/09 @ 10:52
#22
-3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Er, left bumper button does reverse, left trigger accelerates.
JammyPez
10/07/09 @ 10:56
#23
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"If anything dampens things on that front, it's the lag, which is most notable if you're trying to shoot down planes which teleport across the sky in distracting lurches. Hopefully the server fix will eradicate this problem."
That's all that has been said on the crippling problems that have beset the 360 launch, meaning many people can't play the game they've paid for?
Fab4
10/07/09 @ 10:57
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You wonder with the preponderance of sniper wannabes in FPSers nowadays, that no developer ever came out with a successful sniper game...you'd think they'd be tripping over themselves to play such a game....the sneaky little runts.
Eraser
10/07/09 @ 10:57
#25
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
How many MS points is it?
AphoticCosmos
10/07/09 @ 10:58
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
1200

Well worth it IMHO
Waffleaber
10/07/09 @ 10:59
#27
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Exactly how overpowered are the sniper rifles? We in AWP territory here?
Hog-lumps
10/07/09 @ 10:59
#28
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
To pull off a tight turn you should be able to roll it so the wings are vertical and pull back on the stick (like you would with a real plane or a scale model).

You can do this - although I find it's much easier if you flip the sticks over (southpaw) and invert the axis.

Edit, I still think they should have seperated the rotation and tail flaps to opposite sticks (like most arcade flights sims handle control) with the rudder assigned to the triggers - It feels wrong to rotate and pull back all on one single stick to me.....
Edited 2 times, most recently on 10/07/09 @ 12:08
MikeN
10/07/09 @ 11:01
#29
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think the server problems have definitely got to be taken into consideration as a strike against the game. No matter how great the game is and it is tons of fun once you eventually get into a match, that matters little if you cannot even play the game.
jonarob
10/07/09 @ 11:01
#30
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Also, the sniper rifles really aren't overpowered. If anything, most people have been complaining about them being underpowered on forums I go on/Twitter. They're actually neither - they're really good and powerful if you master them, but incredibly difficult to use effectively if you don't know what you're doing. Certainly not AWP territory. I think Dan may have been sniped a few times by some experienced players, which made him think they were overpowered.
PearOfAnguish
10/07/09 @ 11:04
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Any BF42 veterans who have played the game?

I'd like to know this too. How does it compare? BF1942 is still the best in the series.
jonarob
10/07/09 @ 11:05
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'd like to know this too. How does it compare? BF1942 is still the best in the series.

It's good! I'm enjoying it a lot. 8/10 is probably about spot on. If they bring some more maps out from the other campaigns, it'd be absolutely awesome. Obviously I'm missing the extra vehicles/classes, etc., but this works really well with a control pad and I'd recommend it.
George Roper
10/07/09 @ 11:08
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Very good game for a tenner. Hugely entertaining.
DUFFKING
10/07/09 @ 11:09
#34
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I don't think 3 maps will be too much of an issue with this either, half the people who played BF2 were happy to only ever play Karkand, Sharqui Peninsula and Mashtuur City all day every day :P Twas even worse on BF2MC where you only ever had 2 maps come up :D

Snipers are spot on btw. Bodyshots won't kill, headshots do. Simple.
Von_Adder
10/07/09 @ 11:11
#35
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Here we go again with the "Snipers are too powerful and deadly" bullshit...the sniper in real life as ingame is designed to be a stealth killer so get over it...as for the rifles being overpowered hmm not come across that yet in my two solid days of playing(when i can get on) all body shots drop the targets health by about half and unless you follow up instantly with another hit the guy is gonna live...alas the chances of following up instantly are slim to say the least as it takes a second to reload and any player with an ounce of sense has realised he's been hit by a sniper and will scarper into cover sharpish...headshots will kill in one no surprises there as they will with all the other weapons...this game for a tenner is unfucking believable and should be a 10 yes a few teething problems at launch but its called patience people (come on EG you show me the equivalant in price and gameplay and community), sorry for the mini rant but i'm fed up with us poor sad grotesquely overpowered super snipers getting a bad rep...and yes you can drive the vehicles backwards i would have hated bieng your driving instructor :P
Bloodhunter
10/07/09 @ 11:11
#37
-3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I enjoyed the 30 mins I was able to play in the demo, now I need to decide whether to buy it...
XdarXideX
10/07/09 @ 11:13
#38
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Been playing Battlefield from the start here... 1943 is obviously similar to 1942 but I prefered the aircraft in BF1942. I loved Bad Company though so overall I'm enjoying 1943 more. I just wish they would do a Battlefield Vietnam remake!

@j-bo
Have you been avoiding console FPS games or something? I got used to the stick controls years ago and I find it no harder than using a mouse and keyboard. It takes some getting used to just like anything and if you feel it doesn't work then that's just your inability, not the concept's fault. Millions of people are just fine with a controller in FPS games... your argument is old.

However, BF2 was brilliant. Not sure about BF2142.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 10/07/09 @ 12:18
Ryuken
10/07/09 @ 11:15
#39
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
As long as the planes aren't overpowered, that totally ruined BF2 most of the time.
ThemisB
10/07/09 @ 11:15
#40
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Played this for hours last night on my PS3 and I love it. Surprisingly didn't have any lag issues whatsoever, and no trouble joining games. Got disconnected a couple of times, had some trouble with comms, and the "join match with friends" feature doesn't seem to work properly. Apart from that, very little bad to say about it.

Oh, and the vehicles do have a reverse gear.
Apollo
10/07/09 @ 11:17
#41
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Marvelous value for a tenner\twelve euros, balance perfect, weapons and vehicles spot on. Maps gorgeous. No complaints here...
Fab4
10/07/09 @ 11:18
#42
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I don't care whether they are overpowered or not, I merely stated that they are a very popular class in almost all FPSers nowadays. In the forces they are an elite...in games (yes, yes, I get that they arent real) you cant move for tripping over them. I just wondered how much fun they'd be if everyone decided to be a sniper.
Dizzy
10/07/09 @ 11:23
#43
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
>I just wondered how much fun they'd be if everyone decided to be a sniper.

This could easily be fixed by adding pop caps for certain classes and maybe a queue if you really want to be something specific.
AphoticCosmos
10/07/09 @ 11:23
#44
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Guessing this doesn't stand up much to BF2 or BF2142 for any of us PC & Console gamers? "

BF2 and 2142 are getting a proper sequel anyway - BF3 - but even as someone who has well over 2000 hours combined between the two, 1943 is absolutely great!
Fidjit
10/07/09 @ 11:23
#45
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Fab4

Snipers < Tanks
Hog-lumps
10/07/09 @ 11:23
#46
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If everyone was a sniper, wouldn't you simply jump in the nearest plane and drop bombs on their heads?:/

I think that's whats great about this game, you have lot's of different tactics at you disposal if one thing isn't working.......
tinners
10/07/09 @ 11:24
#47
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Can't reverse with Land Vehicles? erm you can???
tinners
10/07/09 @ 11:28
#48
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Makes me wonder how long EG played this for based on that no reverse gear statement, the most obvious thing in the game tbh lol.......obviously if they were on the same servers as us they would get about 1 game per hour, damn you EA! :(
Eighthours
10/07/09 @ 11:30
#49
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I wonder if Dan's going to amend that line in that review...? :)
XdarXideX
10/07/09 @ 11:31
#50
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Mappman - Clearly they didn't anticipate such a large number of players

Comments: 1-50 of 139 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Get Games.  Download Great PC Games!

X View gallery