Jump to navigation
Advertisement

GUN: Showdown Review

PSP Review by Dave McCarthy

21 November, 2006

Yep, we're home on the range again, back in the big country, checking out all the pretty horses, and hellbent on restoring law and order to Dodge City in old California (sort of), thanks to Activision's decision to enlist the help of a hired hand to convert last year's western, GUN, for Sony's little big man, the PSP. British developer, Rebellion (not a bad company) has shown true grit in porting the title, with some technically impressive results, but unfortunately while the game's got a fair bit of good, it's also got it's share of the bad and the ugly too. How's this concept intro working out for you by the way? I'll level with you: it's not going as well as I intended. Am I (un)forgiven?

Maybe I'd be better off cribbing (again) from the original Eurogamer review of the home console versions. As more or less a direct port of those games, GUN Showdown is still "set in the harsh, unforgiving, lawless American West in 1890, a place where you trust no-one. A place where the preacher's a murderer, the lawmen are more corrupt than the criminals and even the women have the capacity to grow really unnerving facial hair on demand. Against that rather unsavoury backdrop, you play Colton White, on a mission for truth and revenge; that is, the truth of who your 'father' really is, and vengeance for his untimely death."

'GUN: Showdown' Screenshot 1

Except in order to shoehorn a quart designed for home consoles into the PSP's pint pot, the control scheme has suffered, making horse-riding too twitchy.

And as more or less a direct port of previous versions of the game, it's also still a third-person shooter that benefits from a compelling storyline enlivened by reasonably deep characterisation and decent voice acting. In fact, Rebellion's achievement in getting the game to look pretty much as polished on the PSP as it was on the PlayStation and Xbox is a fairly impressive one. First impressions are that in terms of draw distance, texture quality, cut-scene polish, and all that sort of stuff, the PSP version of the game absolutely holds its own against its big brothers.

There's one crucial flaw that becomes apparent very early on, though: The PSP only has one analog stick. Rebellion's solution is to map the first/third-person-standard dual-stick control scheme to the PSP by using its face buttons in place of the right analog stick. Thus the analog stick controls movement, and the face buttons control aiming, or vice versa. It's not a satisfactory solution. It's not a total disaster, in the single-player mode, because the slo-mo Quickdraw mode is, as in the console versions of the game, reasonably forgiving. But it does make the simple act of navigating the game world much more complicated than it needs to be, which is compounded by the way the PSP's twitchy nipple also complicates the simple act of riding a horse (which ramps up the difficulty of the Pony Express side missions).

Equally irritating is that as the game goes on an increasing number of minor technical glitches begin to emerge. Enemies slide around without animations, or you'll occasionally be stopped in your tracks by invisible obstacles, for example, and towns are almost comically sparsely populated. That said, it's probably not such a big deal that some of the console content has been cut (such as an interactive cannon sequence during the steamboat massacre at the start of the game, which is slightly annoying; or the removal of scalping, which isn't annoying at all).

'GUN: Showdown' Screenshot 2

It's possible to play Poker. Not for real money though, obviously.

It's more of a big deal that the developer has done little to remedy the chief criticism of its console counterparts - it's still very brief. Rebellion has gone to the effort of adding various bits of new content, but none of it really stands up. The most obvious new addition is a series of 'Quickplay games' - five-minute mini-games that all consist of shooting waves of targets to achieve a high score. There are also a few new missions and weapons that appear in the main game, and a version of Texas Hold 'Em that can be played from the main menu. And finally it's possible to play multiplayer modes either wirelessly against other players, or against AI-controlled bots if you've got no PSP-owning mates.

But playing multiplayer games against bots is no fun because there's no recourse to quickdraw to remedy the inadequacy of the control scheme. Indeed, all of the extra content is undermined by the limitations of the platform, and in any case it's not really sufficient to keep you entertained for more than a few minutes. Indeed, because of the limitations it's hard to imagine that a PSP port of GUN could have been any better, even if Activision had forked out for a few dollars more (sorry, I'll stop now). What that means is: it's GUN on a handheld platform, but it doesn't work quite as well as it does on consoles.

5/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about GUN Showdown on PSP?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-22 of 22 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
pagedown
21/11/06 @ 08:26
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Another crap game for the psp?
lambtron
21/11/06 @ 08:34
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
What the hell is going on with his gun in the screenshot! It's only half a gun! Hmm kind of like this game...
Dezm0nd
21/11/06 @ 08:58
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
haha I just noticed that too. If you can spot a bug in the review screenshot then there's alot more wrong with this game than not.

I wonder how long before people realise the PSP is boring for the most part?
Talha
21/11/06 @ 09:07
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Increasingly, flaws in games for PSP are becoming flaws with the PSP itself. I have a feeling that not long after PSP will become a white elephant for Sony. Best leave the handhelds to Nintendo, who do them best.
MrFlintBlackman
21/11/06 @ 09:10
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The last good western game was Sunset Riders for the SNES and Megadrive, since then all the rest are poor.

Yes even Red Dead Revolourthingy
Talha
21/11/06 @ 09:18
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@herod: You might be right, but one starts thinking if increasingly the reviews mention the hardware as a sticking point. After all, you will find very few, if any, frustrated comments on DS reviews. I know the two machines are not directly comparable, but still.
lambtron
21/11/06 @ 09:21
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I actually enjoyed Gun on teh cube for a cheap 30 euros. It was a good laugh, a bit behind the times in terms of gameplay mechanics and physics etc but still fun which is the main thing for me when it comes to games. I would never dream of playing it on my psp though what with a broken control scheme and load times (which aren't so much of an issue at home but on the move they're a deal breaker for me).
Dezm0nd
21/11/06 @ 09:27
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The PSP is as good as its games, which isn't anything more than alright. IMO
Edited 1 times, most recently on 21/11/06 @ 09:28
Darren
21/11/06 @ 09:36
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I thought GUN was OK on the 360 when I picked it up at launch and I enjoyed playing it even if it was a little bland and empty. It's definitely not a great game though and now I wouldn't give it more than 5/10 as it could have been so much better, especially on the 360.
MadMirko
21/11/06 @ 09:46
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I wonder why every developer thinks that porting a Playstation game to the PSP is a good idea. Yes, the system is called a "PlayStation PORTable". :)

But still, there are genres that work better on a handheld, why not specifically develop for the PSP? Have the devs already lost faith, or what?
Cuke
21/11/06 @ 12:08
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
ummm... I actualy enjoyed this... Using the buttons instead of the second analogue isn't as hard as the review makes it sounds and I only encountered one scenery glitch in the whole game.

It's not great, but then the original wasn't, but I'd have given it a 7 as it's good fun while it lasts...
MadMirko
21/11/06 @ 12:15
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hold your horses, herod, I'm not the enemy. :)

Was just wondering, being a PSP owner myself BTW.
SeesThroughAll
21/11/06 @ 12:25
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Predictably bad.
bunglebonce
21/11/06 @ 12:26
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The PSP is as good as its games, which isn't anything more than alright. IMO

As good as nine EG 9s?
DUFFMAN5
21/11/06 @ 12:36
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm one of the few who like (liked) Gun, I had it on xbox and played all the way through. I sold my psp last week, I had owned for eight months, enjoyed S.F Dark mirror,Everybody golf and Football manger hand held (mighty Gunners) but I had a choice to sell Ds or PSP, no contest, I want Zelda and I'm still playing Mario 64. I'm not a "fan boy" of any make/company just games. I do think Sony need to get their act together with the psp so much promise yet to be seen. If you haven't played Gun give it a go, who didn't want to be a cowboy ? or maybe the horse fetish is just mine!
Slatters
DUFFMAN5
21/11/06 @ 12:49
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Re: Mario indeed I am. Never played it before, it's great. Playing Scarface on xbox 55% into that and enjoying. Waiting for Zelda GC to come out, only reason I still have the Gamecube.
Trying to get through all my old games before I get a 360 after xmas.
Talha
21/11/06 @ 12:56
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
By this time, it should be possible for Sony to shrink PS2 down to PSP size and add that gorgeous screen. As for controls, you'll just have to recreate Dual Shock one on both sides. Problem solved! Millions of games available! Play GT4 on the go! :)
DUFFMAN5
21/11/06 @ 12:59
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Talha.................I'd buy that for a dollar, maybe even more. Nice one.
Feanor
21/11/06 @ 13:47
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
PSP really needs a top class RPG.
Steroyd
21/11/06 @ 14:25
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If Jeanne D'arc from Level 5 or FFVII Crisis Core from Square Enix, doesn't eject some RPG lovin' into the PSP i think i'll cry. ;_;

So far there's been some old PSone ports like BoF 3, Tales of Eternia, and Valkryie Lenneth... heck even Disgaea is going to get ported to the PSP.

I don't want ports goddamnit i want new RPG's.
kiroquai
21/11/06 @ 15:05
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Was sent this the other day and been giving it a go. To be honest, I agree with the sentiment that Rebellion couldn't really have done much more with it. The game looks pretty decent and it seems to have kept most (if not all) the original features and such. Unfortunately the limits of the PSP kind of hamper it a bit, although to be honest I actually got used to the control scheme fairly quickly and got on with it.

5/10? Bit harsh possibly. I'd given it a 6 because the developers have squeezed the most out of it and done a pretty good job on a game which was never suited to the hardware. Like the reviewer said, it's hard to imagine where it could have improved. Sadly, GUN really needs dual stick controls which the PSP obviously doesn't have.
Hughes.
21/11/06 @ 21:23
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wow, a game that was shit on every other machine is still shit on this one, but as usual a bunch of tossers show up to blame the PSP and demonstrate their total ignorance of the massive depth and variety of titles available on the system.

Perhaps I should hop on over to yesterdays 3/10 score for Crash Boom Bang on the DS and talk about how that must mean the DS is a gimmicky piece of shit?

Oh wait, I forgot, I'm not an ignorant troll.
Edited 2 times, most recently on 31/12/06 @ 09:43

Comments: 1-22 of 22 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery