Great response. So you haven't read the review yet (of course you haven't, and I nor anyone else would believe you if you said you had), but felt compelled to slag of its objectivity anyway. Face it, Halo 3 is one of the best games to be released this year. The sales, the scores, it's unanimous. I suggest you come to an acceptance 'mate'. And so ends our dialogue. You can't possibly have anything of worth left to say that's worth my time or a response!
"As for Edge - That is not surprising. Most magazines will for some reason? Thats what the prob is. Sure - give it a great score, for the right reasons without ignoring the bad. In which case Edge didnt give a review - they gave a praise - which kind of defeats the object and misleads the public"
Em, have you even READ their review yet to know that?! Take that lemon out of your mouth, puh-lease. Halo 3 for GOTY! \o/ Reply0
A psychologist could learn a lot from this thread. The sheer, unadulterated outpouring of venomous hate from certain 'contributors', whilst being lol-worthy to the max, is surely indicative of deep-seated and worrying psychological issues. It is with a mixture of shock, horror and bemusement that I ask myself just why it is that some people are so angry that Eurogamer decided to award Halo 3 a 10.
Here's what Shinji (the reviewer) just said in the forums:
"Halo 3 is not a perfect game, but it is the pinnacle of a fantastic series and by far the best game within its own genre - which is balls-out, blockbuster-style FPS action. That, to my mind as a reviewer, is enough to justify a 10/10 - because the game simply doesn't have enough flaws or problems to justify dropping a full mark from its score.
There are two kinds of tens which I've awarded as a reviewer; tens for games which are genuinely groundbreaking and innovative (Shadow of the Colossus, Half-Life 2) and tens for games which simply take existing game mechanics and build a stunningly polished experience out of them, which genuinely stands head and shoulders over other things in the genre. Halo 3 is in the latter camp."
Take it or leave it, but that's the bottom line folks. Reply0
Easy to say biker_bob. But now that you've said it, people aren't going to forget, so for your sake you'd better be 100% in everything that you've just said, otherwise you've just destroyed all credibility you ever had with that last post. Reply0
Not that I give too much credence to what that Kato guys says normally, but aren't you the same poster that suffered through multiple 'old' 360 failures? And now, surprise, surprise, you're on your THIRD Elite in TWO weeks?
You'll forgive me if I choose to call bullshit on your claims. Maybe Kato was right after all. Maybe you are an anti-MS troll, under the guise of a supposedly disgruntled Xbox 360 'owner'. Maybe you're on some pointless and misguided FUD-spread quest?
Maybe not. But at this stage, it's really becoming difficult to seperate fact from fiction with regards your claim. I know MS' hardware is shonky and all, but your occurences just seem a bit out there.... Reply0
I wonder will there ever be a Halo-related comments thread that doesn't reach 100 posts and descend into trolling and flamebait? Probably not, while there are a copious amount of bitter and twisted h@70rz out there, determined to try and rain on somebody's parade, for their own entirely unfathomable reasons. Ah well. I'd much rather be sat here in my chair, excited in the manner of a child weeks before Christmas Day, anxiously awaiting the release of a game that I'm sure to get hours upon hours of enjoyment out of, than a sad git sat on internet messageboards, trying to convince everybody that such and such a game is crap, and that people are somehow wrong to like/love it for their own personal reasons... Reply0
(Potentially) quality Xbox 360 console exclusives out in the next few months:
Halo 3
PGR4
Mass Effect
Lost Odyssey
Blue Dragon (Yeah, yeah, yeah, demo schemo. Metacritic score 89 bitches! ;))
BioShock
Have I missed anything....?
Just for the bitter Sony fanboys who are trying to pick holes at all the multiplat games in EG's list. Of course there'll be a few. That's the reality of the industry today. The point is that you don't need a PS3 because the Xbox 360 has got the lion's share of its worthwhile (multiplat) games anyway, as well as a smattering of potentially awesome exclusives to complement the third party riches being bestowed upon MS' box this season.
You know what's scary about this list (in a good way)? There's SO much they've left out, as evidenced by all the "why no mention of game X" comments already.
Truly, it is a good time to be a (Xbox 360) gamer. Reply0
Out of interest, is there any video footage of the superior hands-on demo that all the sites are saying Microsoft/Bungie should have shown the world? Reply0
Am I the only that I thinks that only retards like Halo only because it's the only game out there that is crap yet is only hyped because it's a shooter, which are only liked because it helps people live out their aggressive tendencies, which are only there because society........
Anyway, I though Top Spin 2 was better than Virtua Tennis 3. It was more realistic, more tactical, and just a better all round simulation, to VT's arcadey sensibilities. It was flawed though (TS) and it's about time they took out those gimmicky EA-style 'risk shots'. Other than that, looking forward to this. COME ON TIM! :D Reply0
Halo 3
:D Reply 0
Em, have you even READ their review yet to know that?! Take that lemon out of your mouth, puh-lease. Halo 3 for GOTY! \o/ Reply 0
Edge magazine awarded Halo 3 a rather outstanding 10/10.
Yours sincerely,
joeking :) Reply 0
:O Reply 0
"Halo 3 is not a perfect game, but it is the pinnacle of a fantastic series and by far the best game within its own genre - which is balls-out, blockbuster-style FPS action. That, to my mind as a reviewer, is enough to justify a 10/10 - because the game simply doesn't have enough flaws or problems to justify dropping a full mark from its score.
There are two kinds of tens which I've awarded as a reviewer; tens for games which are genuinely groundbreaking and innovative (Shadow of the Colossus, Half-Life 2) and tens for games which simply take existing game mechanics and build a stunningly polished experience out of them, which genuinely stands head and shoulders over other things in the genre. Halo 3 is in the latter camp."
Take it or leave it, but that's the bottom line folks. Reply 0
BELIEVE!
:D Reply 0
Crysis demo delayed
/Halo 3 review comments thread reference Reply 0
UK 360 surges, PSP falls
Not that I give too much credence to what that Kato guys says normally, but aren't you the same poster that suffered through multiple 'old' 360 failures? And now, surprise, surprise, you're on your THIRD Elite in TWO weeks?
You'll forgive me if I choose to call bullshit on your claims. Maybe Kato was right after all. Maybe you are an anti-MS troll, under the guise of a supposedly disgruntled Xbox 360 'owner'. Maybe you're on some pointless and misguided FUD-spread quest?
Maybe not. But at this stage, it's really becoming difficult to seperate fact from fiction with regards your claim. I know MS' hardware is shonky and all, but your occurences just seem a bit out there.... Reply 0
Scene It? Lights, Camera, Action
Surely you meant that buttons comment in jest? Surely? Because if you were being genuine, for fuck's sake.... Reply 0
US Halo 3 breaks 1m pre-orders
Wii: 2007's Most Wanted
EA axes old game support
GTA IV delayed
Probably need the extra time to bring the PS3 version up to scratch! ;)
/runs Reply 0
360: 2007's Most Wanted
Halo 3
PGR4
Mass Effect
Lost Odyssey
Blue Dragon (Yeah, yeah, yeah, demo schemo. Metacritic score 89 bitches! ;))
BioShock
Have I missed anything....?
Just for the bitter Sony fanboys who are trying to pick holes at all the multiplat games in EG's list. Of course there'll be a few. That's the reality of the industry today. The point is that you don't need a PS3 because the Xbox 360 has got the lion's share of its worthwhile (multiplat) games anyway, as well as a smattering of potentially awesome exclusives to complement the third party riches being bestowed upon MS' box this season.
So there! :D Reply 0
Truly, it is a good time to be a (Xbox 360) gamer. Reply 0
E3: Halo 3
GLOL! :) Reply 0
/badum tish! Reply 0
Yes, because you are not after enlightenment. You are after disagreement. Big difference, and you're as transparet as Hell. Reply 0
/kills self Reply 0
E3: Too Human - Trailer
E3: Top Spin 3 announced
Anyway, I though Top Spin 2 was better than Virtua Tennis 3. It was more realistic, more tactical, and just a better all round simulation, to VT's arcadey sensibilities. It was flawed though (TS) and it's about time they took out those gimmicky EA-style 'risk shots'. Other than that, looking forward to this. COME ON TIM! :D Reply 0