With Dead Space 3 hitting shop shelves this past Friday, I was wondering how many of you invest in the franchises which utilise cross-media.|
"Dead Space" is covered in multiple games, across multiple platforms, with a story that is further expanded upon through animated films, novels and comics.
The same can be said of Halo, Mass Effect, Assassin's Creed, to name a few. Some complain that they shouldn't have to heavily invest in order to get the whole story. Some argue that the core games themselves should be able to cover everything.
I'm not so sure. I think the worlds/universes these developers are now capable of making are often big enough and interesting enough to warrant vast exploration.
Is it something you embrace?
I prefer my lore to be in-game, but then I normally play games that last more than a weekend.
mal 29,081 posts
Seen 6 hours ago
Registered 16 years ago
Never read a tie in book or comic. Not seen a tie-in movie since Super Mario Bros to the best of my knowledge. Don't see the point of it to be honest - I like my games to be interactive, and my books and films to have decent stories.
bad09 8,159 posts
Seen 17 minutes ago
Registered 11 years ago
I see it as waste of time and tend to ignore most of it. I did see the Dead Space animations and they were OK but pretty forgettable, especially the 2nd one, and added absolutely nothing to the game.
Still some people like that sort of thing so let them spend on it, as long as I get a complete story in the game not missing bits or confusing because I didn't read some comic or watch some crap straight to DVD thing I'm not bothered by it either way.
Edited by bad09 at 21:07:53 10-02-2013
DFawkes Friendliest Forumite, 2016 31,756 posts
Seen 2 hours ago
Registered 12 years ago
I was hoping this was a Defiance thread. I loves me some Defiance
For what it's worth, I'm a big fan of cross media stuff. Some of the Halo books are really good, though some are terrible so it can be hard to do properly. The main for me is that the extended universe introduced in the other thing (be it books, web based minigames, animated film or whatever else) shouldn't be necessary to understand the games - the game should be self-contained.
I'm not entirely sure that's the case for the likes of Halo 4 and the Halo books about the Forerunners. Heck, they even made the use of Halo Waypoint mandatory to watch all the videos you unlock in the game! In most cases though, other media is just a bonus.
Which brings me to Defiance, which is something intended to be cross media from day one. The game and the TV show both take place in different places, but it's a shared universe so characters come and go between them. Some of the main characters start off in the game, then go off to the show. The alien races are all humanoid for obvious budgetary reasons, but also because they realised at the conceptual stage it'd create balance issues to have a major variation - imagine an MMO with a race of oddjob's from Goldeneye
Should be interesting to see how it goes, even if it fails.
Edited by DFawkes at 21:29:46 10-02-2013
Kostabi 5,912 posts
Seen 15 hours ago
Registered 13 years ago
I quite like the extra fluff some games can generate and I'm a fan of using books, comics or even other platforms to expand the universe. What I'm not a fan of is when it gets shoehorned in ME3 style where you almost feel forced to play another game just to progress in the one you're currently invested in.
So long as each item can standalone I'm in favour of it.
GuiltySpark 6,756 posts
Seen 8 hours ago
Registered 13 years ago
It depends whether or not it is worth it. I'd rather it not move into comics territory, where an event forces you to purchase comics you wouldn't otherwise buy.
But really, Dead Space's story is fairly throwaway anyway. I'm not saying there isn't lots of story, there possibly is, I'm saying that it's not very good - something that can be said for many, many games.
Gearskin wrote:No. I believe you can fit everything you need into the game. I figure all the other stuff is marketing people who just don't know where to stop. A tidal wave of crap (or even stuff that isn't crap) doesn't add anything to a game for me - it just takes away.
Is it something you embrace?
Multimedia shit is just annoying, and little more than a way to sell more merchandise. It's also far from unique to videogames. Even boardgames are getting "lore" novels nowadays that explain why X is like Y without having to bother with any internal cohesion.
Edited by meme at 22:19:40 10-02-2013
I would sight "Dead Space: Martyr" as a perfect example of something too big, in of itself, to be relegated to an in-game text/video log.
For one, the story it tells is unknown within the core timeline in which the games are set. For two, it paints a different light on something ultimately very important within the Dead Space universe.
It was different when games were simple, but nowadays they can be as complex as any other form of entertainment.
Oh-Bollox 6,514 posts
Seen 5 days ago
Registered 10 years ago
I'd be in favour of it, if any of it was any good. It rarely is.
To take Dead Space as an example: the films aren't very good. I remember the animation in the second one ranging from the good to the shit, and the mix of styles was jarring. Even in the first one, the average standard was far higher, but sometimes it looked shockingly cheap, and then go back to looking quite nice.
Dead Space Ignition was shite, the dev claimed it wasn't a game when it reviewed poorly (IIRC).
Tie-in novels as a whole tend to be crap, because you get the same circle of journeyman novelists doing work for hire and knocking it out at speed, often working from a universe primer, not having played the games themselves. It's not a writer being inspired by the game, it'sa writer to a story outline from a mong. The writer doesn't give two hoots if it's shite, they're not seeing any of the profits.
The challenge is, how do you go about creating a cohesive whole from so many different projects in different mediums, made by creative people who can't always stay on the side of the line you want them on, if you want them to do their best work.
The games I've played (DS, DS2, Extraction), I've really enjoyed. The rest of the media that has been produced has been lacking.
Edited by Oh-Bollox at 00:06:22 11-02-2013
Sometimes posts may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.