1. Ico
2. Okami
3. Prince of Persia: SoT
There's so many to choose from though.
2. Okami
3. Prince of Persia: SoT
There's so many to choose from though.
Best PS2 game EVER! • Page 2
-
Page
of 7 First / Last -
ManicDrunkMonk 443 posts
Seen 2 hours ago
Registered 7 years ago -
@Murbal and ManicDrunkMonk, thanks for voting! I am still taking votes till tomorrow but if it's still a tie between the top 2, I will go to "penalty shootout". So far MGS3 and FFXII both have one a piece from each site.
@ Snakehips, so is that an MGS3 vote...?
@Blerk, is that a vote then?
@ Thanks Cappy!
@ rodpad, I do these list for myself, if other people enjoy them then fair enough. But to comment on this thread 3 times seems to me, to make you the sad one looking for attention.
If you don't like it, stop coming in here.
-
chrisno21 870 posts
Seen 6 hours ago
Registered 5 years ago -
slickloose wrote:
Nope I've not played it, I was just voicing my surprise that FFXII was held in such esteem
@ Snakehips, so is that an MGS3 vote...? -
@chrisno, thanks!
@ snakehips, fair enough! you should be happy though, your demand for more disgaea has had an effect! It has torn up the table! -
slickloose wrote:
Yes, that's a vote. It's a gut-reaction vote without thinking about it too carefully, though. :-D
@Blerk, is that a vote then? -
Blerk wrote:
Gut reaction or not, it seems after putting in your vote, the tables fate is sealed.
Yes, that's a vote. It's a gut-reaction vote without thinking about it too carefully, though. :-D -
King_Edward 9,370 posts
Seen 1 day ago
Registered 3 years agoI'm glad to see FFXII isn't half as hated as I thought it was. Fookin' excellent game. -
slickloose wrote:
\o/
@ snakehips, fair enough! you should be happy though, your demand for more disgaea has had an effect! It has torn up the table! -
stalinsmash 25 posts
Seen 2 years ago
Registered 3 years agoKing_Edward wrote:
I would like it if it wasn't called Final Fantasy.
I'm glad to see FFXII isn't half as hated as I thought it was. Fookin' excellent game. -
OK, so here are the results. It was close for a while but then a last surge from Eurogamers changed everything! I won't lie I was a little disappointed with CVG's response.
Anyway, here are the results!
CVG
1. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater/Subsistence (8)
2. Final Fantasy X (8)
3. Grand Theft Auto 3 (6)
4. Burnout 3: Takedown (4)
=Final Fantasy XII (4)
6. Star Wars: Battlefront II (3)
7. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King (2)
=God of War (2)
=Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 (2)
=Star Wars: Battlefront (2)
=Resident Evil 4 (2)
=Tekken 4 (2)
=Rogue Galaxy (2)
=Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2)
=Silent Hill 2 (2)
+
Eurogamers
1. Ico (15)
2. Shadow of the Colossus (13)
3. Disgaea: Hour of Darkness (10)
=Okami (10)
5. Final Fantasy XII (7)
6. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 (6)
7. Shadow Hearts: Covenant (6)
8. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty (5)
=Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (5)
10. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King (5)
=
Total
1. Ico (15)
2. Shadow of the Colossus (13)
3. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater/Subsistence (11) (5 individual votes)
4. Final Fantasy XII (11) (3 individual votes)
5. Disgaea: Hour of Darkness (10)
=Okami (10)
7. Final Fantasy X (9)
=Grand Theft Auto 3 (9)
9. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King (7)
10.Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty (6)
=Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (6)
=Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 (6)
=Shadow Hearts: Covenant (6)
So the top 2 games were ALL Eurogamer votes, this happened in reverse on the DS, with the overall winner not being voted for at all by anyone on Eurogamers. So a worthy winner? Is Ico really the best PS2 game!?
GTA: San Andreas, the highest selling game on the PS2 came joint 17th!
While the highest rating game on the PS2, Resident Evil 4, came joint 11th with Devil May Cry!
Just goes to show how different peoples opinions can be! -
So I think that's a second Eurogamer "win".
-
oh and lol at Disgaea being in joint 5th, maybe due to Snakehips...
-
lucky_jim 4,896 posts
Seen 7 minutes ago
Registered 11 years agoThat EG chart is so much better than the CVG one. -
CVG forums are like a chimp colony, so I think its pretty impressive that they have evolved to a point where they can cobble together a list.
-
I vote rodpads post 8/10, lets all vote on it, then I will go over and get all the cvg votes, then we can see what average score he gets and compare it to the score from each website, and I will draw a graph and then quickly organise all my shopping into alphabetical order, then I will label all my socks in my sock room, then we can see what the results are.
-
I miss the PS2 GTA's wish they would make them more like that.
-
Youthist 8,816 posts
Seen 6 hours ago
Registered 7 years agoDQVIII for me. -
TheHammerite 1,311 posts
Seen 2 hours ago
Registered 4 years agoSan Andreas -
stalinsmash 25 posts
Seen 2 years ago
Registered 3 years agoEveryone knows that Final Fantasy X-2 is the best game ever made and therefore the best game on the PS2. This list is bunk. -
Tekken 4? Star Wars: Battlefront? I think those CVG lot were having you on.
-
rickalish 1,689 posts
Seen 5 hours ago
Registered 9 years agoWhy on earth is FFXII at the No. 2 spot? Worse combat system I've ever seen!
MGS3
DQVIII
GTA:SA
Done! -
rickalish 1,689 posts
Seen 5 hours ago
Registered 9 years agostalinsmash wrote:
If the combat wasn't so crap and the story focused more around Vaan, I'd be happier with it. It just wasn't emo enough for me.King_Edward wrote:
I would like it if it wasn't called Final Fantasy.
I'm glad to see FFXII isn't half as hated as I thought it was. Fookin' excellent game..gif)
-
stalinsmash 25 posts
Seen 2 years ago
Registered 3 years agorickalish wrote:
No, fuck Vaan. He's a completely uncharismatic faggot. The main character should have been Balthier and the game should have centered around him being a sky pirate. Vaan and Penelo should have been axed. Then the game would be good. And if the battle system was an ATB/realtime hybrid with enemies present on the overworld map and all four characters in the party at all times, it would have been an awesome game.stalinsmash wrote:
If the combat wasn't so crap and the story focused more around Vaan, I'd be happier with it. It just wasn't emo enough for me.King_Edward wrote:
I would like it if it wasn't called Final Fantasy.
I'm glad to see FFXII isn't half as hated as I thought it was. Fookin' excellent game. -
rickalish 1,689 posts
Seen 5 hours ago
Registered 9 years agoBalthier is a cool character, but I think he works best as a supporting character without the responsibility of being the leader. I think he's too laid back for all that shouting!
Vaan's character wasn't explored enough. He could've/should've been equal to Tidus from FFIX imo. -
slickloose wrote:
hey, don't lay that at my door, I was just commenting that the CVG readers evidently missed mentioning a host of decent games, Disgaea HoD being one of my favourites of the absentees.
oh and lol at Disgaea being in joint 5th, maybe due to Snakehips...
That said, I'm glad to see it fared so well in your chart
Also, it doesn't bode well that no one from CVG ranked Ico in their top 3. Are all the posters there 8yo? That would excuse them tbh -
rickalish wrote:
Finally, someone with sense!
Why on earth is FFXII at the No. 2 spot? Worse combat system I've ever seen! -
TearYouAsunder 2,997 posts
Seen 30 minutes ago
Registered 4 years ago/o\ DMC relegated to joint 11th place, it is a sad day
I collect spores, molds and fungus
-
To be fair DMC was a bit dull though - I'd rank it ahead of Shadow Hearts though personally (and probably MGS2 - the orange years)
-
Page
of 7 First / Last
