FIFA 10: Ultimate Team Review

You can't win anything with cards.

Version tested:

FIFA 09's Ultimate Team downloadable expansion was something of a surprise hit last year. According to EA, downloads numbered in six figures and there were reportedly around 35 million in-game card packs purchased, either with real money or in-game coins earned by playing the mode. This means that not only did those hundreds of thousands of players invest £7.99 in Ultimate Team, but a large portion of them either sunk a ton of playing time into it or opened their wallets and spent.

Once these figures came in, it was a pretty safe bet that FIFA 10 would include an Ultimate Team mode - and, now that it's finally here, it's likely to be an ever bigger success than last year's DLC. Why? Firstly, it offers a far faster, deeper and altogether better package than the FIFA 09 equivalent. Secondly, it's being sold at the cheaper price of £3.99 (or 400 Microsoft Points).

If you're new to the concept of the Ultimate Team mode, then imagine the FIFA manager mode played as a hybrid of FIFA, speed chess and top trumps. Players start the game with a randomly selected set of playing cards which include players, a stadium and handy items such as player contracts, training cards and staff cards. They then select a squad and a formation and can begin to build their teams.

'FIFA 10: Ultimate Team' Screenshot 1

The Magic: The Gathering it's OK to like.

The objective is to build up the best side possible by swapping cards and buying booster decks. Players can buy these cards using either real-world cash or in-game coins that they earn through playing games against online opponents or the local AI. Anyone who played this mode last year gets a couple of perks going in: the new DLC imports the name of their club (although you can feel free to rename it) and tags it with last year's date, to advertise the fact that they've already put in a season. More importantly, they get two free gold booster packs.

The number of players available for use this year has been widened to include around 7500 from 29 leagues. Cards can be acquired from other players in the trade section of the game, if you're prepared to do a bit of haggling. Player cards can also be bought at auction; a new aspect of the mode allows players to monitor ongoing auctions and swoop in with a bid at the last minute. The in-game Coins are the only type of currency that can be used at auctions, so players will need to have logged a decent amount of playing time to have any chance of outbidding the opposition.

Those who can't be bothered with this sort of horse-trading have the option to buy player cards in booster packs which are available from the store. The booster decks come in three tiers: Bronze, Silver and Gold. However, those have now been broken into a further two categories, standard and premium packs, which guarantee players a higher return on their investment. They're priced accordingly; the decks start at 500 Coins for a Bronze pack. At Silver level players can start spending real-world money; the cost of the decks starts at 45p for a Silver and ends at 7500 Coins (or around £1.19) for a Premium Gold pack. This of course, means that players with deeper pockets have something of an advantage to begin with.

Perhaps in an effort to level the playing field a little more, the developers have spent a lot of time tinkering with the mode's main tactical off-pitch element, the chemistry system. Players need to take into account their team members' nationalities, leagues and which club they play for. They'll also want to keep an eye on their players' preferred positions and formations. Players obviously perform better if they're playing where they want and with who they want.

However, this time the players are linked with each other, so deciding what formations to use and where to place the players lends a little more weight to the overall chemistry of the team. You'll also need to be aware of how well your squad members will interact with the the team-mates who are placed in close proximity to them. This makes a few positions more crucial in deciding the overall chemistry score; for example, there's not much compatibility required between a striker and a goalkeeper, but a central midfielder needs to be able to 'connect' with up to four other players.

The team's chemistry is also affected by the off-pitch staff. You have the opportunity to sign managers, fitness coaches and physios and it's worth making sure that you keep decent staff cards at your club, because these can tip the balance. Once again, cards have a finite number of games for which they can be used. They can be reactivated with a contract card, and unlike last year's mode, players won't have to discard superstars once they've played their requisite number of games. It's also worth keeping an eye on the menu screen's news banner because if a certain player has a decent week in the real world, their Ultimate Team player card will receive bonuses as a result.

'FIFA 10: Ultimate Team' Screenshot 2

Virtual foil makes all the difference when deciding to part with non-virtual cash.

Once you've assembled a squad, you can compete in one-on-one matches or local tournaments against the game's AI, or head online and play in tournaments against human opponents. This year, some of the tournaments have entry criteria, such as a team's star-rating, minimum and maximum amounts of players allowed from the same country, and club affiliation. You are now allowed to create more than one club in this new mode, so you can select from a number of teams to meet each criteria. Also, there is a time limit on some of the tournaments; players have a limited time to enter, and once the deadline's been and gone, some trophies are off-limits for good. In the offline arena, at least in the early stages, Ultimate Team is rather easy, but as you progress to the higher levels of competition you'll find a decent team chemistry becomes more a crucial element.

Alongside the new features and added depth of team management, EA has also decided to strip away a couple of features from last year's model. Game modifiers have been taken out, which lends the whole mode a less arcade-style feel. The sticker book has also been removed, so virtual card collector hounds are out of luck. Strangely enough, EA has placed a cap on player training - it's no longer possible to train a lesser player up to a 99-rated superstar.

It's possible that these changes may irk some of the faithful. But at £3.99, Ultimate Mode is far more reasonably priced than last year's offering. The new chemistry depth offers tons of combinations which can be tried out, and the influx of new content that will become available - such as new packs and new tournaments - is guaranteed to attract anyone who bought this mode last year. EA's decision to profit from micro-transactions may seem a little off-putting, but at least the off-pitch gameplay has been tweaked sufficiently to ensure that a big real-world bank balance isn't the deciding factor for success. In Ultimate Team mode at least, rising to the top of the heap requires more than a blank cheque.

7 / 10

Read the Eurogamer.net scoring policy

Comments (23) Latest comment 2 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • Ka-blamo #1 2 years ago

  • Zomoniac #2 2 years ago

    No 99 players is a good thing. My problem is why is there nowhere listing kits and badges? If I want to change my kit I have to go to the collection and go through EVERY FUCKING TEAM in EVERY FUCKING COUNTRY to find out what kits I have. Why isn't there just a section for kits and a section for badges?!?! On the whole it seems great but with all the new features it's much harder to find your way round. It's in danger of doing a Football Manager, just throwing in a million new things to make navigating it a nightmare.
  • Eraysor #3 2 years ago

    It's strange that I'm considering buying FIFA 10 because of this. I really enjoyed the 09 version.
  • feistycheese #4 2 years ago

    I wouldn't bother getting this as yet, the game is massively bugged, with the most serious issue bieng the 'reverse chemistry' problem.

    This essentially means that you can spend loads of time and coins building up a great squad that work well together, get it near to a hundred chemistry, then when you take them for an online match, they play like a team of doped up snails, with the crappy team your playing with low chemistry playing like 10 Lionel Messi's on speed.

    Im not joking, I took my 5 star, 100 chemistry squad online over the weekend and got beaten by a 3 star team of 11 Goalkeepers with no chemistry

    Its completely ruined the experience for me.

    If I were you guys I would consider waiting for the relevant patches.

    PS. the above mentioned issue is apparent on both 360 and PS3 versions.
  • enfilade #5 2 years ago

    Unfortunately I don't think EA Sports has a particularly great record releasing patches for their games. As in, they don't have a record at all. Like, say, the constant game freezes (even on a disc install), the achievement awards that glitch, the fact it's possible to have £2.6 billion of debt in manager mode for no reason, the interface that chugs and churns its way through menus at snail's pace... the list goes on (and does so indefinitely on specially made lists and the like.)

    They manage to bypass the issues with glitches with having what is generally still a very good gameplay experience. For all the menu faults and server outs and disconnecting players online (grrr), the game of football in FIFA 10 is probably the best created so for. Ultimate Team is surprisingly fun and brings back memories of collecting Panini stickers and the constant search for a 'rare shiny.' But the chemistry problem are occasional, and I've been told on more than one occasion that I still need to buy the game, and it freezes me out of the content until I sign in again.

    EA Sports are really hard to warm to sometimes, but they're just as hard to say no to :(
    Edited by 1 at 01/03/10 @ 15:27
  • zisssou #6 2 years ago

    I was completely addicted to this last year! At the moment I'm playing pes though, master league pwns.
  • jebus #7 2 years ago

    @enfilade

    Yeah that pretty much sums up FIFA for me as well. I play a lot of Online Club stuff and sometimes it is so horrible and bugged that you think "I'm never going to play again as it's too depressing". But then when you play and it all goes right it's the best thing ever.
    The fact that a whole heap of the bugs and known issues are on the forum yet they still don't fix them is an utter disgrace as far as I am concerned. It's usually one patch per version and then the attitude of "Well we'll leave that till next years game now" which makes me hate them. It's like they deliberatly try to not make the perfect game as people may not buy a new one.
  • MrChuckles #8 2 years ago

    I played this a lot in the Champions League game a few years ago. Picked up Fifa 10 last year in a PS3 bundle but the league mode wasn't as exciting. Think i might pay my 3.99 and give this a go, Ultimate Team ftw!
  • rodpad #9 2 years ago

    Jebus hits the nail on the head.
  • Zomoniac #10 2 years ago

    It's usually one patch per version and then the attitude of "Well we'll leave that till next years game now" which makes me hate them. It's like they deliberatly try to not make the perfect game as people may not buy a new one.

    Or so you'd think, until you realise that actually most of the bugs have been in the last 3 versions (all the online cheating was is 08, Euro 08 and 09, all complained about heavily and all still untouched).
  • stevetuck #11 2 years ago

  • suhawk75 #12 2 years ago

    @ stevetuck

    I guess that the use of the old Real Madrid photo is deliberate since that 2002-04 team was the ultimate experiment in Pokemon football management.
  • Power_n_Glory #13 2 years ago

    EA are incompetent. There were bugs in the last UT mode, bugs in Fifa 10 and I knew they'd release a bugged UT mode again. The gameplay can be great but it doesn't excuse the lazy development. It's an insult and I refuse to pay for another bugged up mode when they don't even have the decency to fix Fifa 10. I'll rent Fifa 11 and check the forums before I buy.

    EA are a disgrace. The developers or MW2 and Mag have already released a number of patches to fix bugs and get the balance of the game right, while EA have released 1 pathetic patch and which hasn't addressed the major bugs but yet still have their greedy grubby hands out asking for customers to fork out more money for another bugged up game mode. Some nerve.

  • curtlikesmeat #14 2 years ago

    Yeah, not even touching it with a 500 ft barge pole, between the lack of patches, removing staff presence from their official forums because of the backlash, Peter Moore deleting all the complaints from his blog.... I can't even be bothered any more.
  • Harmonica #15 2 years ago

    It's not a breath of fresh air but if you enjoyed it last year but found that playing with less-than-gold players was tiresome due to their inept chemistry and dribbling 'skills', then that's fixed for the large part.

    You can pass the time building a squad based around, say, silver rated african players, and then stick them in some tournaments.

    Like FIFA 10 itself, it's basically a revision of last years release, at a bargain price point (plus two included gold packs if you played last year), and as such, won't set the world on fire but will give you hours worth of sticker collecting.
  • Harmonica #16 2 years ago

    ... the only thing that bugs me about it, honestly, is the lack of the sticker book itself, because that rounded the whole collecting aspect off nicely last time out.
  • AaronTurner #17 2 years ago

    There's an infinite gold pack glitch doing the rounds apparently, kind of ruins things really.
  • Stuart78 #18 2 years ago

    Although i love Fifa and this new DLC.. im getting annoyed at the losing to rubbish side's. Like Feistycheese say's you can have a 100 cem side and lose so badly to a 30 side. Your players seem slower and anable to pass 10yrds without it going to the other side.
    And whats with the adjusted gameplay, i can't quite put my finger on whats differnt but i have noticed the keeper comes off it line more offten resulting in countless lobs Which is bloody annoying as thats the main way i now conceed goals.
    Edited by 1 at 02/03/10 @ 12:44
  • AaronTurner #19 2 years ago

    The keeper lobbing thing is a bit of a problem with FIFA 10, you can double tap Y to keep him on the line. Don't understand why they changed that.
  • Raz76 #20 2 years ago

    I agree that it's abhorrent that EA can keep getting away with not fixing all the bugs in the FIFA products.

    If only there was some sort of gaming journalism around that could call them out on it.
  • Stuart78 #21 2 years ago

    @Aaron turner
    is that true about double tapping Y to make him stay on his line? I have played a few games and noticed other gamers staying on their line, just thought it happened to me.
    Do you double tap when you need to or at teh start of the game or something.
  • HarryPalmer #22 2 years ago

    @ Stuart78 - when you need to, it's hit n miss tho, sometimes the keeps will come charging out and you'll double tap and instead of retreating to his line he'll just flap about in no-mans land.
  • joone #23 2 years ago

    is it possible to play against a friend and not just randomly selected players this time?