Jump to navigation
Advertisement

Music 3000 Review

PlayStation 2 Review by Tom Bramwell

2 June, 2003

Depending on whom you talk to, I am a musician. That is, to my mum and dad, I am a musician. To my friends, I am someone who sits on a stage pounding seven shades out of my long-suffering drum kit, or rolling about on the floor tearing at a guitar with my bleeding fists as waves of white noise make the audience's faces melt. I'm sure they love it really. I am, however, not very good at making music with computers - the very sight of Cubase sends me into a cold sweat. So when the opportunity came along to construct something close to listenable with my PS2, I jumped at the chance. Well... okay, Tom pushed me at the chance.

Listen and learn

'Music 3000' Screenshot 1

It's quite obvious from the outset that Music 3000 is an extremely powerful package. Diving straight into point-and-click creation the first time you load the software up is inadvisable. Luckily, Jester has included a large selection of tutorials designed to help you get to grips with the interface and the title's many, many features, so naturally this should be any new user's first stop.

You're first taken through the basics of the package; choosing a "riff" - which can be anything from a drum loop to a piano line - and pasting it into the track editor. Depending on the length of the riff, it will take the form of a number of blocks in the track editor, which is your visual indication of how long each sound is. These blocks can be copied, pasted (both singularly and en masse), and shuffled around and deleted at will.

A wide range of instruments and samples are present from a series of basic genres; garage, hip-hop, indie, metal, pop and trance each contain a wide range of fairly high-quality samples which you can mix and match to your heart's content. Most surprising to us were the rock samples though, with chugging guitars, pounding drums and thundering basslines sounding suitably metallic. Attempting to reconstruct your favourite classical pieces might prove to be a little disappointing though, as the string and piano sounds in particular have a distinctly MIDI feel about them, cheapening your hard work. It's probably best to stick to the thudding garage anthems.

Tricky disco

'Music 3000' Screenshot 2

For many, getting to grips with these basic functions is all they will ever want or need to know to put together a basic song. Music 3000 comes with thousands of samples and instruments to choose from, so building a basic tune is simply a matter of choosing your preferred genre, picking up the loops, breaks, fills, melodies and samples, and arranging them in an ear-pleasing pattern.

However, the above is covered in just the first tutorial, taking about five minutes to get through. There are nineteen tutorials all attempting to give you a whirlwind tour through Music 3000's features and to be honest, once we got finished with the fifth lesson we were bored to tears.

The problem is that beyond the simple track editing, the interface becomes incredibly unintuitive, and you can be forgiven for getting totally lost when venturing beneath the surface. All of a sudden Cubase starts becoming an attractive prospect as you struggle to remember which icon does what when you press a certain button.

Karaoke

'Music 3000' Screenshot 3

Creating your own samples, and being able to sing into a microphone and have your wails converted into melodies via the separately sold USB sampler is obviously a key selling point of Music 3000, but does it work particularly well? Well, we had a mixed amount of success actually getting the sounds we wanted into the software, with it rarely being able to understand what we were warbling into it. That said, we weren't using the exact model Jester will be flogging at retail.

Making samples from outside sources is easier, and the 20MB of storage available offers a fair amount of scope for this feature, especially when you consider that you can sample just about anything - from Game Boys and (god forbid) other games consoles, to MiniDisc and MP3 players - just as long as it has a line-out capability. Again, though, the interface is fiddly and seems like more trouble that it's worth, particularly for the £20 you have to lay down for the sampler on top of the cost of the software.

Something we found slightly irritating was the inability to apply effects to specific parts of the song. You can't, for example, pass the drums through an echo filter and expect them to behave independently of the rest of the instruments. You can either make everything echo, or you can make the individual sample echo, which will make the echo effect repeat every time that sample is used. This was, we thought, a strange oversight.

Superstar DJs

'Music 3000' Screenshot 4

You can even put together videos to run alongside your songs. This works in much the same way as simple song creation does, with the user choosing video riffs from various categories of visuals, and arranging them alongside the music in the track editor. While it's a nice feature to have, and actually markedly less fiddly than the music construction elements, the limitations of having a pre-set amount of content with which to create your videos really begins to show when everything from classical to garage tracks end up looking like an early-90s Prodigy video.

But it doesn't stop there. You can mix tracks live with six virtual "decks" which is, again, fiddly, but does serve as the title's "multiplayer" element, whereby you and a pal can team up and have a bit of a DJ jam. You can also rip samples straight from your CD collection, which a saves fair bit of fannying around with the sampler. You can remix some included tracks by Timo Maas and Paul Oakenfold, and probably even make them a bit better. There are more features than we can even remember at the moment, and you can spend an absolute age finding them all. Whether or not this is a good thing really does depend on what you want from the package.

We won't be scoring Music 3000 because it's really not a game. It is, in fact, a very powerful set of tools. And while we had quite a lot of fun with the basic elements of Music 3000, getting to grips with the plethora of deep and sophisticated options is a daunting task. There really isn't any competition on the PS2 that even comes close to matching the massive capabilities offered here - not even Jester's original and oddly named MTV Music Generator 2 - it just comes down to whether or not you have the patience to learn it all properly. If you do, it's a steal at £29.99.

Advertisement

Are you excited about Music 3 on PlayStation 2?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
moore25
02/06/03 @ 13:07
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Erm! Just thought you should know that you forgot to give this game a rating out of ten.
terminalterror
02/06/03 @ 13:07
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
\o/ second post!

congrats for getting round to reviewing it
Edited 1 times, most recently on 02/06/03 @ 14:08
FWB
02/06/03 @ 13:09
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Make it stop! Please!

Remember that kipper assault on Mugwam? Guess who's next.
Killerbee
02/06/03 @ 13:11
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Erm! Just thought you should know that you forgot to give this game a rating out of ten.

Heh.. who didn't read the article then...? :)
mouse [staff]
02/06/03 @ 13:11
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Beat me to it, KB.
Killerbee
02/06/03 @ 13:16
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Isn't cutting and pasting bits of someone else's samples kind of... well, *cheating* a bit? I know it's all well and good for DJs and the like, but it's not really making music, is it?

Nice idea, but not really one for someone who actually wants to make their own music I feel. Then again, I suppose that is reflected in the price tag. However, I'll be sticking with Cubase VST and my Korg.
mouse [staff]
02/06/03 @ 13:19
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You can make tunes too, Killerbee! It's just really, really hard.
sharpkiddie [staff]
02/06/03 @ 13:21
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I had a play with this while Mouse was writing his review, and whilst there's certainly a lot of fun to be had, the interface and limited effects chain are a bit crippling for me. I'd say that if you have a PC, it's a much better platform for this sort of thing -- there's already a lot of (often free) software available, and you don't have to put up with struggling with a joypad. But it's still fun!
sam_spade
02/06/03 @ 13:26
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
C'mon mouse, pimp your tunes.
Killerbee
02/06/03 @ 13:35
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You can make tunes too, Killerbee! It's just really, really hard.

I can imagine. :/

Having watched someone go through the torturous process of actually clicking an entire tune into Cubase, I don't think having to do that using a game pad and a low-res TV screen would be a step in the right direction.

Surely they could release some kind of USB MIDI interface for the PS2 that'd open things up a bit, perhaps in a future version? I like the idea of a console being used to make music - with the number of problems a PC throws up like getting drivers to work, sound card latency etc etc, it'd be great to have something that just works. It'd be better if you could simply burn your tracks onto CD when you're done - maybe with a PSX they could do that? Otherwise I assume you're left with plugging a Minidisc recorder into the back of the PS2.
Tiger_Walts
02/06/03 @ 15:02
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nice linking there mouse ;)
Aaarrrgh
02/06/03 @ 15:04
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Best linking. Evar!
Khab
02/06/03 @ 15:05
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Oooh, sneaky!
FeZZ
02/06/03 @ 15:28
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
But what happens after you've finished your song?
I mean, you can import 20 mb of samples,but the biggest PS2 memcard is 8mb right ?
Xensor
02/06/03 @ 16:11
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm gonna assume the answer is no, but ask the question anyway - does it support DTS 5.1? That would be fecking cool to build surround sound music!
FWB
02/06/03 @ 16:12
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Surround sound
no


:)
Razz
05/06/03 @ 14:17
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Any news on a PC release?
FWB
05/06/03 @ 14:46
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Razz, don't encourage them, please.

Go here, here or here instead.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 05/06/03 @ 15:46
eviltobz
05/06/03 @ 15:35
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
razz, it sounds a lot like the ejay series on the pc in how stuff is put together, you might want to check some of them out, they are a lot of fun, for a bit at least.
Takashi
05/06/03 @ 22:06
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Killerbee, MIDI interface on a console, eh. Now you're onto something...

It's not like if someone hasn't done it before.
mouse [staff]
07/06/03 @ 11:07
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Heh.
frantyk
10/06/03 @ 03:15
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i know a guy who bought it from game.. and returned it 4 days later with out opening the polythene packaging. and he loved the previous m2000.

must have been the depressing thought of havin to cope with the new ui.. more crap beats and limited (song)replay..(ps2 to cd anyone?)
get this if you want a studio with out having to buy a pc
Dorag_kid
12/06/03 @ 04:41
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
WELL, i wouldnt call it a game myself more like an MP3 player with multiplayer and alot more graphics to look at. This game can probably make anybody who is anybody feel capable of becoming a DJ, which is a zero percent Chance.

(I like the way zero looks,("...zero...")

Hey id give the game a chance if i wanted to,but not right now. It seems like a good fun way to pass up the time on a rainy day,after i lose my other games to an outrageous fire. Mix and Burn up- some popular CDs mak'em better. Who said you couldnt have yur CD go platinum, well now its possible. ("Id like to thank God for giving me this Award, word up fo-sheeze baby").
Its Not like it'll happen seriously just give up u low-life disc-jockey.

Id rate this game a 3out of 5

"!!!Well be right back after a quick shout out from our sponsors!!!"

Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery