Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

PlanetSide Re-review

MMO PC Re-review by Daniel Etherington

1 August, 2008

Page 1 of 2. Page 2 ->

Giant, bipedal war machines stalk through the hills, small groups of tanks roll in determinedly, while around them infantry move up and engineers lay down defences, fix up damaged vehicles. Soldiers select equipment from a mobile re-spawn vehicle, squatting under a shimmering cloaking dome. Overhead, aircraft dogfight, while a dropship, braving anti-aircraft fire, flies over the besieged base and discharges a contingent of soldiers, some nestled inside bulky exo-armour with formidable firepower. Defenders man gun turrets and return fire from the parapet that tops the base's imposing walls. The battle rages. Welcome to PlanetSide.

Released back in May 2003, PlanetSide was yet another bellicose videogame vision of the future. But unlike previous games involving humans fighting a future war, PlanetSide was unique in that those doing the scrapping were exclusively other players. Potentially thousands of other players, working with a remarkably diverse array of hardware to create unprecedented, elaborate gameplay. That elaborate play survives to this day, with much of what PlanetSide offers yet to be bettered by any game, FPS or MMO. Call of Duty 4's multiplayer, for example, may offer diversity in its weapons, but you're still on small-scale maps on servers that only support small numbers of players. PlanetSide is massive. An entire world at war.

Although the massively multiplayer FPS had been born a few years earlier with World War II Online, PlanetSide improved considerably on the formula. It promised to transform the FPS genre. It didn't. But for those of us who got hooked on PlanetSide, it was a landmark in gaming.

'PlanetSide' Screenshot 1

Since a peak in late 2003, PlanetSide starting losing popularity, many online gamers forsaking its twitch-based but frequently laggy play for more traditional RPG pleasures. Today, the PlanetSide community is a pale shadow of its former self, purportedly less than a third of the 75,000 subscriptions the game peaked at in late 2003. Playing these days, however, it's hard to even believe there are 20,000 subscribers frequenting the two remaining servers. (The five-year anniversary of the game in May 2008 was marked by an effort to reinvigorate the action by the combining the two North American servers to form the new Gemini. Meanwhile, the European server, Werner, can be deathly quiet.)

And yet, the things that made PlanetSide so remarkable back in the day are still worth writing home about. For those who've never had the pleasure, PlanetSide was built around a simple premise - humanity went through a wormhole, established colonies on the newly discovered planet Auraxis, the wormhole collapsed, the colonies came to blows. These colonies formed the game's three empires: the New Conglomerate, sporting blue and yellow armour and nominally driven by an ideology of fighting tyranny; the Terran Republic, the remnants of the old earth order, clad in suitably fascistic red and black; and the Vanu Sovereignty, who found ancient alien tech (lots of hot plasma, basically) and wear slinky purple outfits. The backstory is hardly relevant though. PlanetSide is about persistent, perpetual combat, not narrative. And about comradeship.

'PlanetSide' Screenshot 2

I've never experienced such a sense of gaming comradeship as in the heyday of PlanetSide, when the massed members of your Outfit (the equivalent to a guild) set out with a mission to conquer a particular swathe of Auraxis. The planet was initially made up of ten continents, but after 2003's Core Combat expansion pack it also included caverns, ostensibly designed to offer a semblance of urban combat. The game's setting was altered further in August 2004's The Bending, which saw the continents become planetoids, though that didn't affect the game's dynamics notably. Something that did affect the dynamics, however, was October 2004's Aftershock, which introduced the aforementioned bipedal mecha: BFRs (the acronym stands for Battle Frame Robotics, honest). For many, this hardware thoroughly shafted the game's balance, and in tandem with the release of World of Warcraft caused some serious migrations.

To Page 2 ->

Advertisement

Are you excited about Planetside: Core Combat on PC?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-47 of 47 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
DFawkes
01/08/08 @ 13:26
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Never even heard of it until sound, sounds awesome. Might give it a try sometime.
Lovemoose
01/08/08 @ 13:34
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I loved this game. There came a point though that I couldn't justify the sub for the amount of time I'd spend on it in a month.

The announcement of a Planetside 2, while unlikely, would bring joy to my heart.
Turambar
01/08/08 @ 13:38
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I played it a long time ago. Unfortunately a lot of things were hideously broken (missile lock-on being the one that stands out in my mind since i wanted to play an anti-vehicle class) and I tended to get rocket spammed to death by reavers on an infuriatingly regular basis. So i stopped. I keep meaning to try it again though.
Xeaon
01/08/08 @ 13:39
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Shame this game's all but dead now, with only a few of the hardcore left playing. I also loved this game and can't understand why they don't make a more upto date sequel as everyone who's ever played it loved it. The only reason i've heard was that it's 'really expensive to run a fps-mmo'.
bogrot
01/08/08 @ 13:41
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This was the only MMO to really get me hooked. Used to love the huge battles and sneaking in to the enemy base to cause havoc. Happy days!! If only there were other MMOFPS' out there. Maybe huxley will fill the void...if it ever arrives
Turambar
01/08/08 @ 13:42
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Huh, seems i wont be trying it again as SOE don't sell it anymore.
Clive Dunn
01/08/08 @ 13:44
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ahhh, the bridge battles from beta are still a fond memory. Great fun.

The great problem with the game was the balancing, they always seemed to get it just a little bit wrong and it ended up being infuriating. Those stupid mag-riders that ran over anyone who came within 20 foot of them, overpowered lasher spam etc.

NC shotty was fine though. Stop moaning noobs.
SBfistfun
01/08/08 @ 13:54
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I thought this sounded great at the time. Went out bought it, and spent my 30 days free trial thinking "if this didnt lag like shit, it could be good" that was if for me. Shame really :(
stoopidgreg
01/08/08 @ 14:05
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i want a tribes MMO :(
BigJonno
01/08/08 @ 14:11
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If it wasn't for that damn monthly fee, I'd probably still be playing it. Great game, loved it to bits, but not worth the monthly sub.
squarejawhero
01/08/08 @ 14:17
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
One of the finest games ever made, and one excellent online shooter. Some of my only cherished gaming memories come from working alongside the rest of Clan on Werner. Good times.
Gurrah
01/08/08 @ 14:59
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Uhhh, happy days! The biggest problems back in '03 were indeed the lag but that didn't stop me from playing it for quite some time. Hunting vehicles has never been so much fun, neither has storming a base and defending it while your hacker tried to crack that control console.
Quine
01/08/08 @ 15:23
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This game provided most of my best gaming experiences ever. If you haven't seen several hundred people all scrapping for the same base then you've sadly missed out. If ever a game needed a proper update with a modern engine then this is it.

Just playing a support role could entirely change a front line, and you could spend half a day assaulting a tower and still feel like you've achieved something significant when it finally fell. Once you'd learned the way the weapons worked you could do some amazing stuff.

Haven't played it for a couple of years but I still miss my Thumper grenade launcher and Phoenix guided missiles...
alpha-0ne
01/08/08 @ 15:39
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I played the game for about a year at its heigh it was great 300 palyer battles to capture a base very cool
SwedBear
01/08/08 @ 16:11
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yeah, this was an excellent game. my clan (Windhund) from WWII Online migrated to Planetside and we had some excellent months of gaming. There was so many brilliant moments with huge battles that ebbed and flowed back and forth for several hours.

I kind of miss that kind of games today. That was also what I liked with WWII Online and what I loved about Allegiance. in the end none of them could keep up and keep people interested ....

Bergeron
01/08/08 @ 16:32
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Thank you mr. Etherington, old wounds from true love never heal when you reopen them with a dagger.
This brought back memories from the glory days of the NCWA, truly a great game at it's peak, but sadly it had some flaws and the dev team didn't know what they where doing.

A PlanetSide 2 would be nice, but seriously that will never happen.
Nithron
01/08/08 @ 16:42
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I tried this fairly recently on a free trial, unfortunately it was more or less dead and dominated by high level players who essentially instant-killed anyone just joining - looks like I just came to late to the game.


But seriously, I hate all these identikit "Click on an enemy and wait for your character to kill it" WoW clones. An update to this would actually make me play an MMO.
Chufty
01/08/08 @ 17:16
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Planetside is one of the greatest ever multiplayer experiences, many people who played it in it's hayday will concur.

A sequel would absolutely blow my mind. I can't believe a game of this type hasn't been done since.
bauhaus
01/08/08 @ 17:18
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Best gaming memories ever
Xeaon
01/08/08 @ 18:21
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nothing has beaten the sight of many galaxies all dropping loads of players at once over a battle that had been going on for ages :(
Fusey
01/08/08 @ 19:49
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It was a fantastic game.

Sony, don't you think you could make some money out of selling a client that comes with a standalone server?

It would sell by the bucket loads.. :-)
anomagnus
01/08/08 @ 20:01
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
the glory days of this game are as yet unmatched in any mmo i have ever played

i was introduced to it during the open beta, and i remember battles waging for entire days over a single bridge. I remember sever populations fit to bursting.

i remember capping a base, and hundreds of soilders saddling up, in tanks, buggies and air transport convoys. I remember looking down on 300 hundred soliders moving on a single objective, and never did i feel so emersed in a game.

sadly, as predicted, they could never get the subscribers on the fee they were looking, and the game died. But god, while it lasted, there was nothing like it. There was nothing like being part of an orchastrated strike of hundreds of people.

Quite literally, the greatest 'could have been' i have ever played.
Clive Dunn
01/08/08 @ 20:03
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Nothing has beaten the sight of many galaxies all dropping loads of players at once over a battle that had been going on for ages :("

Very true, although Galaxy death spams by flying really low over bridges could beat that.

Sad to think that in 2003 we had MMOFPS games, and today we are forced to play a bunch of EQ1 clones ( albeit much more polished ).

I'm bored of sad old turn based combat, time for an ambitious developer to give us more.
Chufty
01/08/08 @ 20:38
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's funny, all the comments on this article are about how awesome an experience Planetside was, yet still no sign of a sequel or remake...

Surely the market is there?
AtomicBanana
01/08/08 @ 22:00
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I reached the highest command rank for the TR in this game, was one of the first bunch to do it too. I remember getting my copy a day early and being 1 of about 10 people on werner when it went live. I actually teamed up with and spoke to the lead developer on more than on occasion. I loved this game, I was so into it, it was unreal. Knew everything about it, played it constantly.

No game before or since has ever given me some of the moments I've had in this game. Sure, sometimes the newer generation of straight FPS games like battlefield have been close, but they've never topped it. I'd never, ever return though, I'd just be too depressed.
berelain
01/08/08 @ 22:30
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I only played it briefly, but thoroughly enjoyed it- though my dial-up connection wasn't too happy with it. I always meant to pick it up again when I got broadband and never did. Pity, the likes of tabula Rasa are nothing compared to the outright warfare of Planesiode. Interesting setting and style too.
TheRealBadabing
01/08/08 @ 23:13
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sad that even the article reflects the feelings of those that have played it. A death knoll is never nice to hear, especially for a game like this.

People talk about the mass battles but I remember the silly small stuff like finally getting a Vanguard and charging to the frontlines, only to be foiled by a nasty dip in the road and spending a good half hour trying to get free. Mr Dunn swearing his head off on teamspeak just sweetened the whole experience.

The bridge battles were all sorts of awesome though.
urban
02/08/08 @ 00:32
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
how many times do you have to re-review this?
thegamesthething
02/08/08 @ 07:30
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Until they make another one. So a long time.

+1 for greatest online evah, albeit with a few flaws. The updates Core-Combat and beyond spring to mind, plus a relative lack of longevity compared to WOW type games.

Being a Galaxy pilot was a quite astonishing amount of fun - dropping the squad on a tower, then hearing the firefight over teampspeak whilst I parked up and repaired ready to hit the base. Also, when a big raid worked, and you got in before the cap, and infront of you were dozens of tanks, infantry and fliers pouring towards the enemy, well ... top.

Werner NC ftw.
MrWonderstuff
02/08/08 @ 11:40
#30
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I lovely time in my gaming career was playing this. Wonderful wonderful. Hot dropping onto a tower with your buddies cannot be bettered.

Not sure why people are saying they won't announce a planetside 2 - why? I'd be up for a new and improved version.
silke
02/08/08 @ 12:18
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yes, I agree, Planetside was definitely something. Sure, it had a quite prevailing tendecy of repetition, but it was also one of those few games which really could inspire awe.
TheJuriel
02/08/08 @ 13:53
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Planetside is a great MMO, especially its leveling scheme - you gain more in breadth of ability, rather than in direct power.

Or, well, was, as I haven't looked at it in a few years...
cnlfailure
02/08/08 @ 18:32
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It was a great game and handled the numbers of players really well. No other game has come close in terms of gamer war stories about defending a base or hot dropping into the action as part of a 200 man push.

Its biggest problem was that you just stopped caring. You could spend all evening fighting to control a continent, go to bed at 2am then check the map first thing at work only to discover that it'd be retaken by half a dozen lads during off peak play. The changes to base hacking didn't help either, as it became horribly complicated to do.

It really needed a political meta-game with more factions so intra-faction alliances could be had and lost, and RTS element built up so that CR3s+ could contribute to a push in more way than just nuking crap from orbit. It also needed lengthening so that it would take a week of solid push to take a continent but you'd then be in a position to hold it or advance knowing some late night Germans weren't just going to swipe it back.

It was big enough in terms of players in the war, but too small in terms of scope.

The best time ever was the squad of 10 I was in disobeying orders to pull out of a continent to join the counterattack and digging in at a small outpost, holding off a full 200+ man assault from the Barneys for almost 2 hours, and in so doing allowing we happy Smurfs to take another continent while the lasher n00bs were occupied :)

Planetside 2 please. Or maybe that's what MAG will be?
TheBlueShmoo
03/08/08 @ 09:50
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Bergeron wrote:
This brought back memories from the glory days of the NCWA

Hehe, i played PS for 3.5 years, leading one of the NC Outfits in the NCWA, i LOVED those events that we used to run. I think in the haydays, we had what 120+ people all on that TS server, using chancom to liaise and strategise with the other outfit leaders. Nothing was as awesome as doing a 16 galaxy drop on a base, or rolling into an enemy hotspot with 25+ Vanguards with air support. We kicked arse! I always imagined the look on the VS or TR's faces when they realised that the NCWA were about to assault them.... priceless.

No other game, EVER, in nearly 27 years of gaming has given me such a sense of teamwork or achievement as did Planetside. Its a shame it died to death when everyone went to WoW. WoW never gave me the same sense of size as PS did.

/lights a candle in memory of Werner and all the great people i met and became friends with.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 03/08/08 @ 10:51
spanky50
03/08/08 @ 12:17
#35
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
My first ever MMO experience, played support in NC outfit Brutal Deluxe on Werner. Great times and never had the same experience in an MMO since.
As cnlfailure said probably needed some sort of higher level to the gameplay to give it more legs. Would love to see something similar again tho', with all these fantasy mmos a decent sci-fi themed one would be great to see, Tabula Rasa just seemed to miss the mark for me.
Mox
03/08/08 @ 15:46
#36
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ideally you'd arrange it so the higher levels would migrate out of the grunt-work and into command-oriented behind-the-lines tasks. They'd still be on the field, but they'd need to be in command positions at the base control console, or the tower basement, or with a super-AMS type vehicle, instead of defending the base entrances, making it less likely that the front-line soldier will encounter one.

Regardless, the real thing Planetside needs is a critical mass of numbers; when it's one-on-one, you need to rely on scissors-paper-stone style match ups to get an advantage on your target, and veterans know what their gear can't handle, and therefore where not to be. But when it's a hundred-strong Terran zerg hot-dropping on Ghanon, even the BR25 CR5 veteran is going to flee or get chain-gunned.
Trikk
03/08/08 @ 15:58
#37
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Definitely one of the best MMOs ever. The lack of a sequel is proof enough for me that there is no God. At least not one that loves humanity.
Kalu
04/08/08 @ 02:19
#38
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
One of the best gaming experiences of my life and ive been gaming for at least 15 years!

THIS GAME WAS AMAZING -

I still resub from time to time year after year! Yes it had its ups and downs like every MMO.

But since this is to this day the only TRUE MMOFPS ever! I still give it 10/10

Viva la Planetside! If i could rewind time and play it all over again - this would be the game i would do it for.
zozart
04/08/08 @ 09:18
#39
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Couldn't agree more. Best online experiences I ever had were in PlanetSide. I log on once a year or so to check it out but it's just not the same. Come on, SOE! Go ahead and do PlanetSide 2.
Dether
04/08/08 @ 09:47
#40
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sounds like a lot of us old hands are in agreement about PS.

Nothing has ever compared.

Why didn't it get all the acclaim and attention it deserved back when it was in its prime? Sure it was laggy and had balance issues, but those battles were awesome. Yeah, those bridge battles were expecially cool.

I suspect PS2 is a dream that'll never come true, and Huxley won't compare.

SOE are probably ever so slightly busy with the small matter of DCUO now methinks. :-(
Edited 2 times, most recently on 06/08/08 @ 15:49
Schiraman
04/08/08 @ 10:40
#41
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I have so many great memories of playing Planetside, every role in the game had its own logic to it, its own set of skills - it was like having a dozen games in one. Also: a genuinely tactical and intelligent FPS. Something I have never seen before or since.

As an example, for those who've never played: when you got to really know the game, you could recognise every one of the dozens of different weapons in the game by its distinctive firing sound. Doesn't really sound that useful, does it? But believe me, being able to tell there's a cloaked enemy nearby because you recognise the sound his pistol makes - even over the constant yammering of friendly rifles and heavy weapons - is a skill that's worth its weight in not-being-ganked.

Not to mention that ACEs (the item that combat engineers use to deploy mines, auto-turrets and remote-trigger bombs) make a tiny little noise when you get them out. It's pretty quiet, so mostly you won't notice it - but once or twice hearing that noise gave me just the warning I needed to spin round and shoot the guy who had crept up behind me and was just about to plant a big-arse bomb right between my legs. Which naturally got me accused of hacking ;)

It's a crying shame that Planetside was so overlooked, I can't think of a game more deserving of a remake or sequel - or just greater recognition in general. In game-design terms, Planetside was absolute genius - it's full of genuinely clever ideas that made it so much deeper and more satisfying to play than the likes of Battlefield. But because it wasn't a big commercial success, all those ideas have been overlooked and instead we get a constant stream of MMORPGs that are just the old text-based MUDs with a graphical skin. So much for innovation, eh?
RedSparrows
04/08/08 @ 11:17
#42
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I played it for a few months about two years ago. I managed one kill in the whole time, but it was fun!

I think I got one kill, I just sucked so bad. I tended to fly around and get shot down lots ;(
Quak
04/08/08 @ 12:09
#43
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Swap the screenshots for Tribes 2 screens and you have another review, equally relevant.
Mox
04/08/08 @ 12:15
#44
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I remember showing a friend at work this "Planetside" game I was playing. I was showing him a few different weapons while guarding a tower; most of the rest of the Terran Republic were attacking the nearby base. I had the Rocklet Rifle in my hands when, as I was strafing across a landing, I hit an obstruction. An invisible obstruction. Up until that point, I'd been giving him a running commentary about the controls and the alternate fire modes and things, but when I hit that immobile blank space, I paused for a fraction of a second and fell silent, then jumped back and spammed the area with rocklets. Sure enough, a New Conglomerate cloaker dropped dead out of thin air.

That game had the best stealth mechanic I've seen in a long time.

Generally, I played a tank driver. The Prowler was quite unrewarding for the driver, but it had its moments. I liked to park my tank on an approach overlook and shell enemies, using it like an artillery piece. When I repaired it, I'd run over to the dual-15mm slot (upgraded from 12mm!) so that if I was attacked, I could get in the guns and mow people down. Often, my gunners would be in reinforced exo-armour, while I was just wearing agile, so if we debussed for some reason (usually, chasing troops into heavy cover that the tank can't work with) I'd be firing my Cycler over the nose of the Prowler while my buddies would be charging forth with their Chain guns churning up the terrain. Sometimes, my driver's outfit would only carry the trusty Repeater for anti-personnel self defense. I did manage to kill someone with it, when they tried to carjack me.
NoseBagUK
04/08/08 @ 13:00
#45
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Like other posters I have some of my best gaming moments from planetside. The BFR's ruined it a bit for me.


Looking forward to Huxley as that seems like out best chance of a good FPS mmorpg.

Mox
04/08/08 @ 13:16
#46
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yeah, BFRs did kind of upend the game. I think they should have been made multi-crew vehicles, which had to be dropped from orbit after being constructed at the sanctuary. This would mean that if you wanted to summon one, you'd need to have a crew and some clear terrain to order a drop, and if you lost the ground in the meantime the BFR could be hacked and stolen before you'd even got in it.

Remember when you didn't automatically get into a vehicle you'd requisitioned, and would have to run over to the freshly-spawned tank to get in before someone robs your ride?
Bergeron
07/08/08 @ 09:19
#47
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It feels like we're talking about something that happened a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away.
But then again, five years is a long time in the videogame industry.
I thought about installing it lately, but I fear a visit to Auraxis now would be like stumbling drunk through a cornfield on a sunday morning, it's lonesome and there's only a small chance you'll be run over by a tresher.

Turbojugend "..too fast for love."

Warriors of Fire
Brutal Deluxe
Armored Fist

Thanks for playing on Werner when it was fun.


Comments: 1-47 of 47 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery