Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

Firemint Real Racing Review

iPhone Review by Simon Parkin

2 September, 2009

Page 1 of 2. Page 2 ->

When was the last time Eurogamer praised a game for its lens flare? The visual flourish so beloved of the late 1990s became a cheap trick; once a sign of contemporary graphical frisson, it was fast turned into a cliché through incessant use. But as you clutch your iPhone like a miniature steering wheel, tipping your body left and right to negotiate high-speed chicanes, the flash of Real Racing's lens flare is almost an epiphany.

Like the very first time you set eyes on the PlayStation's Gran Turismo, it's a vision of the impossible: evidence that videogames may surpass even the wildest imaginings of our youth, squeezing worlds into pockets. From Nokia's primordial Snake, the mobile phone game's evolutionary trajectory has soared like no other. In Real Racing's skies it breaks the stratosphere, and the dazzle is blinding.

So, Firemint's car game presents a towering technical achievement. A fully 3D racing game with the superstructure of a full-price console release, it packs time trials, global leaderboards, online championships and custom soundtracks into a £5.99 suckerpunch. In-game, racing against the plucky, challenging AI of five other vehicles, it comfortably represents the pinnacle of technological accomplishment on the iPhone and iPod Touch, the driving model much more robust than its immediate competitors.

'Firemint Real Racing' Screenshot 1

Braking is achieved by simply touching anywhere on the screen, something you'll want to do in conjunction with the AI-controlled auto-brake initially.

And yet, for these very same reasons, this is a game that sits somewhat awkwardly on Apple's machine. It takes an orthodox, blockbuster console game approach, pushing the boundaries of what's possible on the platform, aping the greats of the racing genre in form and function, demanding that serious gamers take it seriously. But, in the context of a platform that prides and defines itself on low-priced, throwaway entertainment, it seems like too much - a showboating embarrassment of riches that, in its vainglory, almost misses the point.

The democratic publishing system of the App Store encourages the sort of low-budget, high-impact productions that defined the bedroom coding days of the 1980s. And these are the games that directly appeal to iPhone's gamers, those in their late twenties and thirties for whom bombastic visuals and technological accomplishments play second fiddle to brevity, efficiency and, dare we say, reheated nostalgia. As such the economic style of Space Invaders: Infinity Gene is far more likely to produce a groundswell of support from iPhone owners than, say, a miniaturised big-hitter such as Resident Evil 4: Mobile Edition. In this universe, the traditional roles are reversed: the 59p arcade-style punts are the headline hits, while the polished blockbusters are the risk-takers.

For that reason, Real Racing's ambitious approach shifts the boundaries somewhat. Whereas the average iPhone game can be stacked up favourably against any number of throwaway webgames, Real Racing's rivals are handheld heavyweights such as Ridge Racers and the forthcoming Gran Turismo PSP. Compared to a webgame, Real Racing is the future inpixellate, an experience of such awesome depth and breadth as to render the competition redundant. But set against Sony and Namco's greatest, is it really anything more than a polished but uninspired racer, high on showboating graphical pizzazz, short on innovation and second-tier features?

To Page 2 ->

Advertisement

Are you excited about Firemint Real Racing on iPhone?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-28 of 28 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
t8yman
03/09/09 @ 06:46
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
sounds good, reckon I'll be picking this one up if only to impress myself with my new phone's capabilities!
UncleLou
03/09/09 @ 06:50
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Great review (not just because I agree with it).

Braking is achieved by simply touching anywhere on the screen, something you'll want to do in conjunction with the AI-controlled auto-brake initially.

I've got to admit, I don' quite get how the auto-braking works and turned it off almost immediately as I found it confusing. I either forgot to brake because I thought the game is taking care of it, or braked too much.
secombe
03/09/09 @ 06:54
#3
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've had this for a while now, and while undoubtedly it's a technical masterpiece (in terms of the control/handling model, as well as the graphics) and an absolute hoot to play...I find that I don't actually play it very often.

Same goes for F.A.S.T, great game, great graphics...but like Real Racing, it's almost a bit too 'console gaming' for my needs. It's confirmed why I've always been a DS owner rather than a PSP owner, portable gaming - in my opinion - shouldn't just be about console-gaming-on-the-go.

I could praise Real Racing all day, but you're far more likely to find me (still) playing DrawRace, FlightControl, Peggle, iShoot etc, basically simpler games which are more suited to playing on the go. The one game that sits fairly well between the two is Alive4Ever, it looks gorgeous and plays more like a 'traditional' console game, yet it simple enough to have a quick blast on when you get a spare 5 minutes.
lucky_jim
03/09/09 @ 07:15
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Agreed secombe. I tend to mostly load Real Racing up to show the phone off: when I'm playing games on it, it'll be stuff like Wurdle, Spider, Uniwar or Peggle.
Hamflank
03/09/09 @ 07:35
#5
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
A tad off-topic, but I have been using an iPhone since January this year and I must say that I find the majority of games utterly disappointing. Of course, you have to take into account the low cost for the games, but you really can't compare these games with DS offerings. Especially the controls are weak in most games, I just need those damn buttons. Which is a shame, because in terms of graphics, the hardware can take on the DS with ease.
UncleLou
03/09/09 @ 07:49
#6
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Of course, you have to take into account the low cost for the games, but you really can't compare these games with DS offerings

I disgaree. I've bought lots of DS games before, but now haven't bought one for 18 months. Games like Spider, GeoDefense, Return to the Mysterious Island or Space Invaders: IG are easily on par with what the DS has to offer, and often more than that.

The trick is not to buy the Sonics and whatnots, but the games that play to the device's strengths.
flaming.carrot
03/09/09 @ 07:59
#7
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I find myself playing DoodleJump the most on my iPhone, much more than Real Racing. It's 59p, simple idea but utterly compelling.
ademkermad
03/09/09 @ 08:17
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Review Modern Combat: Sandstorm please.
Hamflank
03/09/09 @ 08:31
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The trick is not to buy the Sonics and whatnots, but the games that play to the device's strengths.

Indeed, so like I said, you can't really compare it to the DS, because the devices have different strengths ;-]
Greebo
03/09/09 @ 08:51
#10
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"you can't really compare it to the DS, because the devices have different strengths"

That's how I justified buying the ipod Touch when I already have far too many portable gaming devices! (and mp3 players for that matter) :-)
septimus
03/09/09 @ 08:56
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wow, late review. The multiplayer in this is very good, works well and doesn't cause lag.

Well worth the price.

Love to see EG's thoughts on Alive4Ever (brilliant fun, especially multiplayer), and Samurai (look on TouchArcade).
influenceuk
03/09/09 @ 09:14
#12
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think it was firemint who made FlightControl for the iPhone too, which is bloody addictive! It's good to see they know what they are doing when making some iPhone games. Considering there is so much crap out there, their games are jewels in the rough!
Spooke
03/09/09 @ 09:55
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I agree with many people on this thread in saying it's a great tech demo but not a really satisfying game. I find the other drivers too aggressive and feel cheated when I'm knocked off the track. The steering it very wobbly and all in all it's just not a playable as it looks like it will be.
samaran
03/09/09 @ 09:58
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i like this game infinitely more than any racer on DS (and probably PSP if you don't count wipeout), put it that way. i'll be buying gran turismo PSP, but i'll be wondering if i'm really getting something worth 5 times as much.
secombe
03/09/09 @ 12:12
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Of course, you have to take into account the low cost for the games, but you really can't compare these games with DS offerings

If Real Racing was on the DS, would I have paid £20+ for it? The answer would be yes, I happily spent £25 on Race Driver DS and to be honest this is no better or worse.

The dilemma comes when you consider that most iPhone games are 1/10 the cost of this. For £6 you could buy 6-10 great games that arguably would give you more more playtime than this. £6 bought me Alive4Ever, DrawRace, FlightControl, Ragdoll Blaster, MX Mayhem, iShoot and Peggle...based on that, Real Racing isn't good value.

So, compared to a DS game it's a steal (and in my opinion, it's directly comparable to any DS 'real' racing game), but compared to what is on offer on iTunes it isn't.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 03/09/09 @ 13:14
UncleLou
03/09/09 @ 13:56
#16
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So, compared to a DS game it's a steal (and in my opinion, it's directly comparable to any DS 'real' racing game), but compared to what is on offer on iTunes it isn't.

I see where you're coming from, but I find that argument a little dangerous for the platform. Yes, you can buy ten 59c games that will give you more playtime, but RR is clearly a more ambitious title, and I find it only just that more ambitious games cost more. I seriously hope there is a market for such "premium" (still a joke compared to games on real handhelds) games on the platform, or the lesson devs will learn will not be to sell their games cheaper, but only to aim for the 59c market from the beginning (as enjoyable as many of these games are).
Super_Zee
03/09/09 @ 14:04
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You can drift around corners if you use a control scheme that has manual accelerate and brake. I'm also not sure that the iPhone being the home of throwaway 99c flash games should count as a negative against something that tries to be more ambitious.

I was on the fence about this until I played it. With control scheme E (thumb controlled steering wheel, manual accelerate and brake), in-car view and brake assist off, it's the most enjoyable, exciting racer I've played in a long time on any platform. Sure, your car is a little over-powered, but this makes for amazing races as the AI is so fantastically aggresive.

Good work, Firemint. Superb game.
Fleeby
03/09/09 @ 18:40
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Bought it eons ago and sadly barely touched it. It just doesn't click with me. Shame.
Rev. Stuart Campbell
04/09/09 @ 07:30
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Indeed, so like I said, you can't really compare it to the DS, because the devices have different strengths ;-] "

So do the DS and PSP, but that doesn't stop people comparing them...
Rev. Stuart Campbell
04/09/09 @ 07:55
#20
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I see where you're coming from, but I find that argument a little dangerous for the platform. Yes, you can buy ten 59c games that will give you more playtime, but RR is clearly a more ambitious title, and I find it only just that more ambitious games cost more."

It's a weird argument, this one. Who cares about "ambitious"? The ONLY thing that should matter when you're buying a game is whether it's a fun game you'll enjoy playing and get value for money from. Whether the developers are being "ambitious" or not is neither here nor there. They've either made a good game or they haven't, and if Real Racing is less fun than ten 59p games then it doesn't deserve to sell, because it's bad value in its market. It's not that £5.99 is a lot in itself, it's that it's SO much more than most of its competition, and there's so MUCH of that competition, that you have to prioritise what's most deserving of your cash.

I haven't bought it because I'm still not very clear on whether it's Gran Turismo-style racing - in which case I wouldn't give you 20p for it - or arcadey Ridge Racer-style, in which case I'm interested. (The review nudges me more towards being interested.) But either way, it's going to have to be DAMN good to beat what else you can get for £6 before I invest the cash and the time. For example:

Flight Control
Parachute Panic
Kill All Bugs
Mr Driller
Mr AahH
Run
Football U
Racer
Cluck It
Dropsum
Minigore

or

Ferrari GT Evolution
GeoDefense
Arcade Bowling
Pajatzo
Dropship
Let's Golf
Paper Toss World Tour
Shift
Super Marble Roll

or

Kill All Bugs
Pinball Dreams
Must Eat Birds
Pool Rebel
Death Ball
Poker Superstars 3
Giant Metal Robot
Harbor Master

or

3D Vector Ball
Wolfenstein RPG
Droplitz
Sentinel: Mars Defence
Siberian Strike
Papi Jump+
Lux Touch
Cartoon Wars

etc etc. Any of those collections will give you many tens of hours of highly varied fun for the same cost as Real Racing. So unless you think you're going to get more than that out of it, the price (or "ambition") shouldn't be commended, because all it's ultimately doing is giving you less gaming for your money.
superdelphinus
04/09/09 @ 08:29
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
all i want is ace attorney
UncleLou
04/09/09 @ 08:30
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's a weird argument, this one. Who cares about "ambitious"? The ONLY thing that should matter when you're buying a game is whether it's a fun game you'll enjoy playing and get value for money from. Whether the developers are being "ambitious" or not is neither here nor there.

Maybe "ambitious" wasn't the right word. It's a game that, in terms of scope, content, presentation etc. is in a different league to most other games on the devices. I've had as much "fun" playing Plants vs. Zombies as I had playing Okami or Bioshock, but that doesn't make the latter two bad value for money in comparison in my book.

To answer your question: It's definitely more Gran Turismo than Ridge Racer.
Rev. Stuart Campbell
04/09/09 @ 08:44
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
A few more £6-packs, just for teh funz:

Car Jack Streets
The Deep Pinball
Futoshiki
Kryzer
BaDaBoo
Paper Ball
Ynth
Traffic Trouble
Zooloretto

Inkvaders
Taxi Drive
Wild Wild Train
Mini Golf Wacky Worlds
Railroad Puzzle
Candy
Star Trigon
Tapword
World Cup Ping Pong
Backyard Soccer
DrawRace

Defender Chronicles
Backyard Soccer
MicroPool
Star Shower
Dice King
iFighter
Papi Jump Land
Driftz
Hotdog Panic
Big Top 10
Banjax
04/09/09 @ 08:57
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Temporary price drop for this one this weekend according to Touch Arcade so hold your horses if you're interested!
Banjax
04/09/09 @ 08:58
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Just where IS the Plants vs Zombies review?!
Rev. Stuart Campbell
04/09/09 @ 09:42
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Um, it's here:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/plants...

If you mean a review of the iPod version, that's not out yet.
Banjax
04/09/09 @ 16:23
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Well blow me down. Thanks Rev!
Penguins20
25/09/09 @ 17:16
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Time Trails? That doesn't sound right...

Comments: 1-28 of 28 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Get Games.  Download Great PC Games!

X View gallery