Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

FIFA 09: Ultimate Team Review

Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Review by Martin Korda

31 March, 2009

Page 1 of 2. Page 2 ->

The deluge of downloadable content for Xbox 360 and PS3 continues unabated, and EA Canada is the latest to throw its hat into the arena with this add-on for FIFA 09. Ultimate Team is actually a rehash of the hit-and-miss Ultimate Team feature that debuted in UEFA Champions League 2006/2007, and is ostensibly a concoction of vanilla FIFA and a trading card game with a hint of Pro Evolution Soccer's Master League thrown in for good measure.

To begin with you're allocated a set of random playing cards. These range from players (each with their own unique stats) to home and away kits, your stadium, training ground and a collection of in-game Gameplay Modifiers that you can cash in during matches. Your ultimate goal is to collect and trade your way to the best possible team and bonuses by swapping cards and spending Coins earned through the successful completion of games against online and AI opponents.

Any card can be directly traded for another. Alternatively, you can spend the Coins you've earned to acquire better cards by hopping online and haggling with other players. If you ever played a Panini trading card game in your primary school days then you'll have a vague idea of what this involves. However, for the impatient player there's the opportunity to buy new cards online in exchange for Microsoft Points or funds from a PS3 wallet: a disappointing design choice that will clearly give some players an unfair advantage.

Both cards and players come in three categories: Bronze, Silver and Gold. By training up lesser players you can advance them to the next rank or alternatively, you can simply try to to buy your way to success. There's also an option to create and customise your own player who, with enough care, attention and outlay, can also be trained up to become world-class.

'FIFA 09: Ultimate Team' Screenshot 2

Put players in their favoured positions and with their preferred tactics to improve your team's chemistry.

In a clear attempt to add an extra strategic vein, Ultimate Team employs a rather lackadaisical chemistry mechanic that factors in each player's nationality, favoured position and preferred formation. You're also given a Manager playing card, with each gaffer preferring certain formations. Use this formation and your team's chemistry receives a boost. The more members of your team that play where they want, how they want and with players from the same country, the higher your team's chemistry rating becomes. In theory, this means better performances on the pitch, although actually gauging the effect it has during a game is difficult unless you play everyone out of position. It's also a strangely restrictive system that often dictates line-ups and formations to you rather than allowing for the more tactical and considered approach of standard FIFA 09.

Player and manager contracts must also be monitored closely, because each squad member will only play a set number of matches before their contract expires. In these circumstances you need to invest in contract cards to extend a player's stay, while crocked squad members can have their recovery sped up with healing bonus cards, which is a decent touch that adds a modicum of depth.

To Page 2 ->

Advertisement

Are you excited about FIFA 09: Ultimate Team on PlayStation 3/Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
ryohazuki1983
31/03/09 @ 10:35
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Downloaded this a few days after launch, was very buggy, I watched the intro trailer then once I was allocated a pack I tried to add the players but kept getting kicked out to the main menu. After winning a few games I bought a new pack of players and tried to add the new players to my team but got kicked back to the main menu, once I reloaded my game the "new" players were no longer within the team.

I've heard about peoples custom players going missing etc, it's just way to buggy to pay for, even if it didn't cost anything I still wouldn't play it. Charging for something so broken is a joke.

After pissing about with this for an hour or so I can't be bothered going back to it, even if they do fix the problems.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 31/03/09 @ 11:36
Zomoniac
31/03/09 @ 10:36
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ultimate Team Mode on a good day: 9
Ultimate Team Mode most of the time: 0

On the rare occasion it works it's brilliant. But I've now run into a completely gamebreaking glitch meaning I can't play it anymore, and I have paid for nothing. Until they fix it properly and it has been running a few weeks without completely crippling fuck-ups, everyone stay well clear. I can see it eating up another 100 hours of my time. Or at least I could if it worked.
dazrichards
31/03/09 @ 10:52
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I really enjoy it but it is buggy. Thankfully not as bad as some people. Sometimes my tournament progress is not saved and I have to replay the same round again (but the players use their contract allowance which can screw-up your management). It has frozen a few times on me too. Plus, can someone explain how the trading works? In the View Trade Status screen I can see all my expired and unsold auctions but can't do anything with them; relist, discard or add to collection
Eighthours
31/03/09 @ 10:58
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
6/10? Sacrilege. When it works, this is absolutely brilliant.
gaselite
31/03/09 @ 10:59
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"It's fun in bursts, but you're likely to find that Ultimate Team is more a short-lived novelty than an addition that will significantly heighten your enjoyment of what is already the best football sim on the market."

I completely disagree with this conclusion. For me, someone who already loved FIFA 09, it's given the game a new lease of life and, at least at the moment, a game mode that is far more more-ish than the others that the game has on offer.

It is weighed against those who can invest real money in cards -or maybe I'm just not playing it very smartly - but not game-breakingly so. It can be frustrating when you end up paired with a 5 star team in the early online tournaments though. Other than that I found the card trading/collecting concept very compelling.

Re: the trading, so many of the gameplay cards in particular just seem useless and more flexibility with the minimum trade amounts would have been nice, as well as a better way other than trading to earn more coinage (bonus for actually winning a tournament for example).

As for the gameplay indicators, I'm not sure what you're talking about because there's a pretty clear icon saying whether a card affects 1 or more players and how long it lasts for. What's more irritating to figure out is the potency of each of these cards and whether they're really worth the effort. It's hard to say in some cases.

I can't speak for the bugginess. The only experience I've had is with being ejected out of a single player tournament for no particular reason mid-tournament. Apart from that it's been fine.

It's been great value for me and I've put a lot of time into it, far more effort I imagined I'd be putting into FIFA 09 again, and a fine example of DLC rejuvenating and already excellent game, an especially good idea coming midway through the release cycle (though you'd hope it'll come with FIFA 2010). Probably an 8 from me.
mjbr
31/03/09 @ 11:06
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
anyone knows what is happening with ea servers for fifa 09 in recent weeks? I don't plat everyday (let's say 2-3 times a week), and I remember of 2 days in the past 2 weeks that I could not access the servers... f... annoying when you pay for something and do not get value for your money.
BulletTheory05
31/03/09 @ 11:10
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's got, got, NEED, got.
Not swap, swap, got, swap!
lord
31/03/09 @ 11:24
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
ah, casual gaming.
mingster
31/03/09 @ 11:26
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Lol i was thinking the exact same thing BulletTheory
Edited 1 times, most recently on 31/03/09 @ 12:26
Gazza_UK
31/03/09 @ 11:34
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Gotta catch em' all, gotta catch em' all ...
viper_h
31/03/09 @ 11:42
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Me too BulletTheory... Never heard anyone say "swap" before.

Anyone remember shineys? I remember someone sold a Manchester United shiney sticker at school for £25 once, then got another one the next day.... ahh good times.
andromeda
31/03/09 @ 11:54
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
lol at the hairdo on the landing page
Joco84
31/03/09 @ 13:03
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Severely unreliable servers means this game should be rated about a 4 currently. When the servers are stable, players don't disappear from your team and everything runs smoothly, this game rocks. Until that happens, stay well clear.
Trigga_Tybalt
31/03/09 @ 13:07
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
this mode seems pointless. i'll stick to the vast amount of modes i've already bought thanks!
Cheeky
31/03/09 @ 13:50
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Guess I won't be buying this then.

I still get outstanding levels of enjoyment from the current online modes anyway, so this isn't an essential purchase for me.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 31/03/09 @ 23:46
rotmm
31/03/09 @ 15:52
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Why is this more expensive on PSN? £7.99 vs about £6.80 on Live seems a little like fleecing.
absinthe
31/03/09 @ 16:18
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Strange comment about the chemistry system.
I watched the video & figured if they are mentioning it that much it must be important.
So I bought wisely and ended up with a bunch of no name players but 95 chemistry.
They play like a bunch of mental just released from a cage tigers.
Brilliant fun to play this 2* team and see them tear apart these muppets with the 5* no chemistry teams.
Also seeing a lot of people having fire sales as they realise they can't keep their all gold team afloat; Chelsea beware!

So as far as an online manager mode that touches on the need to really plan, make clever decisions and cut your cloth to your ability this is pure genius and by far the best thing about FIFA this year.
LawrenceArms
31/03/09 @ 17:20
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This is the most addicted I have been to a game since the first day I played Phantasy Star Online on the Dreamcast. I absolutely love it.

Sadly the servers are terrible and need sorting urgently. If they do.. easy 9/10 from me, and I can see myself playing for months and months to come.
Tetsuo_Shima
31/03/09 @ 19:01
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Is that supposed to be Fellaini?
zisssou
31/03/09 @ 22:03
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
yeah this game is extremely addictive! it feels like being a kid again swapping stickers but you actually get to play with them. big problem i find is that you work your way to getting a gold pack and you get aload of silver cards and afew golds...or you get gold players from like wolves or something :/
Edited 1 times, most recently on 31/03/09 @ 23:03
LawrenceArms
01/04/09 @ 06:42
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
..Or if you are Huntcjna you get Kaka and Ambrosini :''(
JammyPez
01/04/09 @ 11:43
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Conceptually and for the addictive factor this is a 9 out of 10. The review doesn't seem to "get" it, which is a real pity.

The problems with the servers and the poor customer service EA are showing actually means it is not worth more than a 6. This seems to be have been glossed over in the revew which seems to indicate the game wasn't actually played that much at all. Not a great way to review things, then.
JammyPez
01/04/09 @ 12:10
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ gaselite
"It's fun in bursts, but you're likely to find that Ultimate Team is more a short-lived novelty than an addition that will significantly heighten your enjoyment of what is already the best football sim on the market."

I completely disagree with this conclusion. For me, someone who already loved FIFA 09, it's given the game a new lease of life and, at least at the moment, a game mode that is far more more-ish than the others that the game has on offer.
------------
Quite. FIFA has been played more online in recent times than when the game was released.

I'm not sure how the review missed this, or didn't quite get the addictive nature and concept. It does seem like it's really not been given a proper playthrough.

As far as Chemistry being "Throwaway" as noted here, using a lower ability team vs a higher one with lots of "stars" works very well. How can that be so throwaway?

Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery