Digital Foundry
Supporter Program
Get access to   exclusive content unlimited 4K videos Discord Server Retro Corner Support us on Patreon Join now

Face-Off: Mass Effect 2 • Page 2

Hi, I'm Commander Shepard and this is my favourite platform on the Citadel.

The most noticeable difference between the two games comes down to lighting. In our original Mass Effect 2 demo comparison story we posted at the tail end of last year, we speculated that the new ME3 tech may have necessitated the changes. Subsequent to that, there has been the suggestion that the firm simply wanted to make the PS3 game "clearer and more vibrant".

As we said in the demo analysis, at the end of the day the changes will be important or not based on personal preference - for example, some of the lighting is to our taste, and some of it isn't. The PS3 game doesn't feel especially clearer or more vibrant, but there's a definite sense that it's rather more inconsistent than it was before, to the point where the lighting in the occasional scene just doesn't seem logical. In other cases, there are changes but they are subtler - a slight tweak to the ambient lighting level, perhaps.

We're still left rather puzzled by these changes. Was it really a purely design-led decision to make the game brighter and more vibrant? Looking at Mass Effect 2 in its original form, of all the things you might want to improve, was there really anything wrong with the way the game was lit? The impression is that the change here is an answer to a question nobody was asking.

lighting1-360
lighting1-ps3
lighting2-360
lighting2-ps3
The lighting sees the biggest change between the two games and it's still a bit of a mystery as to why BioWare thought this aspect of the game required adjustment.

While Mass Effect 2 may well be based on the Unreal Engine 3 engine (favouring multi-platform development) the firm had the luxury of concentrating resources on getting the best possible 360 game out of the door last year. The 360 has a couple of crucial RAM advantages over the PlayStation 3: developers have access to the whole 512MB RAM to do with as they please, whereas there is a clear split on PS3 with two independent pools of 256MB. Also, while the OS footprint of the PS3 has been falling, it is still generally accepted to be the case that the 360 OS takes up a significantly smaller area of system RAM.

Our fear with a PS3 conversion of Mass Effect 2 was that the artwork would need to be compromised to accommodate these factors. In the demo analysis, we pointed out how Miranda's costume had lost some of its normal mapping but compensated with a higher-resolution texture. With the final game in our possession, we see plenty more of this sort of tweaking, and while it does seem to be the case that specific artwork elements have been pared down, there is still the occasional piece of artwork with more detail than in the Xbox 360 version. The overall impression is that BioWare's work on the art has been outstanding, and in motion there's very little in the way of difference whatsoever.

texture1-360
texture1-ps3
texture2-360
texture2-ps3
Despite the RAM issues, BioWare's work in cramming Mass Effect 2's artwork onto PS3 is exemplary. As seen in these shots, there is the odd hint of normal maps not being so pronounced or of individual textures being a touch more 'smudged', but the overall presentation remains remarkable on both systems.

Otherwise, not much has changed from our conclusions about the respective merits of the two games that we discussed in the Mass Effect 2 demo analysis: precision in some of the shader effects appears to be higher on the Xbox 360, for example, while there are still differences in shadow filtering. The effect definitely appears to be more realistic on the PlayStation 3.

Technical differences are all very well and good, but most likely of far more interest to the average gamer is the thorny issue of cost. There is a definite disparity here, because at the time of writing Mass Effect 2 on Xbox 360 costs just £12.14 bought brand new from one of Amazon's "preferred merchants", while the same e-tailer wants £38.79 for the game on PS3. The chances are that you can lower that a bit with some adept Googling, but on the face of it, PS3 owners are effectively getting a year-old game - albeit an astonishingly good one - but paying three times as much for the privilege.

Charging full-price for an old game might like a bit of a swizz, but off-setting this difference somewhat is the inclusion of all the existing Mass Effect 2 DLC and then some. All the paid-for downloads from Xbox Live are included on the disc, so that's the Overlord, Kasumi's Stolen Memory and Lair of the Shadow Broker packs, which have a combined value of 1920 Microsoft points (around £16.50). The rest of the downloads, including the Mass Effect interactive comic, are Cerberus Network DLC which requires the use of a download token included in the pack.

By and large the DLC is worthwhile and adds a decent amount of new stuff to the game, but there's still the nagging feeling that punters would rather pay the £12.14 and purchase the DLC separately as and when they pleased.

effects-360
effects-ps3
We still see some examples of lower-precision shader effects on the PS3 version of Mass Effect 2, but this is more a technical curiosity than anything that would have any bearing on the purchasing decision.

On the plus side, getting all the DLC integrated right from the get-go does genuinely benefit the gameplay experience: Kasumi's a pretty decent character to have, while Zaeed's quips throughout the game are great - and you'll get the most from these additions by having them available early in the story. Having The Lair of the Shadow Broker built-in is just phenomenal, and once again there are many advantages to completing it fairly early on in the main mission.

The Dark Horse interactive comic does the job of bringing PS3 owners up to date with the Mass Effect storyline, and of course gives you the chance to make the key decisions that have ramifications for the story in both this sequel and the concluding chapter in the saga - check out our Mass Effect comic walkthrough to get a flavour of the comic. It's curious that BioWare went with a traditional comic format when a CG rendering in the style of the game would have been a better fit stylistically, and could have incorporated "your" designer Shepard.

We're in two minds about the whole concept of the comic. BioWare has made the best of a bad situation, but condensing down 30-40 hours of gameplay into 15 minutes has its consequences: you are asked to make decisions without the wealth of background information the original game gave you. Whether we're dealing with Shepard's love life or the genocide of an entire race, you never quite feel comfortable in making such monumental decisions when so much of the back story is not available.

Will you support the Digital Foundry team?

Digital Foundry specialises in technical analysis of gaming hardware and software, using state-of-the-art capture systems and bespoke software to show you how well games and hardware run, visualising precisely what they're capable of. In order to show you what 4K gaming actually looks like we needed to build our own platform to supply high quality 4K video for offline viewing. So we did.

Our videos are multi-gigabyte files and we've chosen a high quality provider to ensure fast downloads. However, that bandwidth isn't free and so we charge a small monthly subscription fee of $5. We think it's a small price to pay for unlimited access to top-tier quality encodes of our content. Thank you.

Support Digital Foundry

Find out more about the benefits of our Patreon

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our policy.

Jump to comments (179)

About the author

Richard Leadbetter

Richard Leadbetter

Technology Editor, Digital Foundry  |  digitalfoundry

Rich has been a games journalist since the days of 16-bit and specialises in technical analysis. He's commonly known around Eurogamer as the Blacksmith of the Future.

Related

You may also enjoy...

Supporters only

Comments (179)

Comments for this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

Hide low-scoring comments
Order
Threading
Eurogamer.net

Buy things with globes on them

And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store!

Eurogamer Merch
Explore our store