PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds developer PUBG Corp has filed a lawsuit against publisher NetEase, accusing the company of copyright infringement, trade dress infringement and unfair business competition in regard to two of its mobile titles - Rules of Survival and Knives Out.

The claims are made in a 155-page court document, obtained by Torrent Freak, which argues that NetEase deliberately copied Battlegrounds' gameplay and aesthetic.

This, says PUBG Corp, was done in order to mislead consumers, making them believe that Rules of Survival and Knives Out are officially affiliated with Battlegrounds, and to profit from the deception by releasing both games into the marketplace "at or below cost for the purpose of gaining market share" before Battlegrounds was launched on mobile.

In its suit, PUBG Corp highlights numerous "substantially similar elements" found in Rules of Survival and Knives Out that it believes infringe on its Battlegrounds' copyright. The list is extensive, but includes Battlegrounds' pre-game lobby and waiting area, its opening air jump system, the shrinking play space, bombardment zones, its "down but not out" mechanic, and, more generally, its "total look and feel" and "overall gameplay".

The lawsuit also lists, with ample pictorial examples, specific aesthetic elements found in NetEase's titles that, it says, are intentionally designed to further confuse consumers into believing that Rules of Survival and Knives Out are official Battlegrounds products.

1
Rules of Survival, left, versus PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds, right.

These include the use of certain environments, buildings, and landscapes seen in Battlegrounds (the suit specifically highlights the shooting range, rural aqueduct, port, and farm, among other locations) as well as vehicles, clothing, and weapons.

In the latter case, the court document draws considerable attention to the inclusion of a frying pan in NetEase's games, making the claim that, prior to Battlegrounds, "shooter games did not include the use of a frying pan". It also makes a similar argument regarding Battlegrounds' "Winner Winner Chicken Dinner" victory phrase which either features directly in NetEase's titles, or is invoked within their marketing material. This phrase, argues PUBG Corp, "has become nearly synonymous with Battlegrounds to gamers".

PUBG Corp states it attempted to address its dispute with NetEase through "other channels besides litigation", and notes that it submitted a complaint to Apple in order to get the publisher's games removed from the App Store.

According to PUBG Corp, however, the "defendants have refused to acknowledge PUBG's intellectual property rights" and "refused to remove or modify the accused games and knowingly persisted in its infringement". As a result, it "determined that legal action would be necessary to enforce its rights".

"PUBG has suffered irreparable harm as a result of Defendants' infringing activities and will continue to suffer irreparable harm in the future unless Defendants are enjoined from their infringing conduct", the lawsuit concludes.

PUBG Corp is requesting the court orders NetEase "to remove each and every version of the games Rules of Survival, Knives Out, and similarly infringing games, from distribution and to cease developing and supporting those games". It is also seeking $150,000 (Ł106k) per infringed work for statutory damages.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Jump to comments (42)

About the author

Matt Wales

Matt Wales

Reporter

Matt Wales is a freelance writer and gambolling summer child who won't even pretend to live a busily impressive life of dynamic go-getting for the purposes of this bio. He is the sole and founding member of the Birdo for President of Everything Society.

More articles by Matt Wales

Comments (42)

Comments for this article are now closed, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

Hide low-scoring comments
Order
Threading

Related

PUBG snow map Vikendi - best start locations and snow map strategies so far

Our early tips and picks for starting spots on the new PUBG snow map, Vikendi.

PUBG Erangel map explained - size, best start locations and Erangel map strategies

Everything you need to know about the original PUBG map.

PUBG desert map Miramar - best start locations and Miramar strategies

A closer look at al the essential info on PUBG's desert map, Miramar.