Saturday Soapbox: Careful What You Choose

Are choice-and-consequence systems making our games less interactive?

Five years ago it was cover systems. Thanks to Gears of War, it got to the point where you couldn't go to the bathroom without being invited to crouch behind something by a whopping red icon. Then for a while it was experience systems in multiplayer. They had been done before, of course, but we can blame Call of Duty 4 for catapulting them to front of mind. Nowadays even 2D platform games on your mobile phone have XP systems.

There are always trends at work in game development, and people are always copying each other (sorry, learning from each other). It's often to our ultimate benefit, too. Third-person action games used to be notoriously crap at gun combat because you couldn't easily judge your level of safety, and thanks to everyone copying Gears of War now we can focus on other things.

The current thing, then, is choice and consequence. It seems like whatever you're playing now, you can expect to have to say something meaningful to somebody, or have someone's life thrust into your hands at a moment's notice.

Rockstar does it all the time - the people in GTA IV, Red Dead Redemption and L.A. Noire all want you to make their minds up for them now and again - and BioWare has built a dynasty out of it. Hell, if Nintendo really wants to appease its shareholders after the 3DS debacle, just stick a gun in Mario's hand and ask him whether he wants to shoot Toad in the face or leave him to his crack habit. And of course our Eurogamer Game of the Week is Deus Ex: Human Revolution, a game which is more or less built on the idea that the world is what you make of it.

Mass Effect is a series built around player choice, but how much impact do your choices really make?

So is this a positive trend too? It certainly seems like it. With a few well-directed exceptions like the Uncharted series and Enslaved, it's nice to be breaking away from games where you have to put down the controls every 20 minutes to watch another unskippable cut-scene where conflicted idiots do stupid things on your behalf.

Then again, previous systemic trends have been more to do with improving your engagement - by making it more fun to do something fundamental to a game, by giving you more reasons to play a game for longer or, going even further back to the advent of third-person cameras in 3D worlds, simply by framing the action better.

And, at the risk of turning this into Saturday Semantics, this latest trend is a bit riskier, because whereas a lot of the other changes at work in game development are injecting more interesting possibilities into our interactions, choice-and-consequence is perhaps beginning to do the opposite.

Take Mass Effect as an example. It's a trilogy of games where your actions are supposed to shape the fate of the universe; where the alien you sleep with in the first game might be a villainous crime lord by the time you meet her in the second; and where your behaviour - even incidental stuff like what you say to a reporter - can alter the way you're perceived and potentially cost the lives of those around you a few years later.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Jump to comments (33)

About the author

Tom Bramwell

Tom Bramwell

Contributor  |  tombramwell

Tom worked at Eurogamer from early 2000 to late 2014, including seven years as Editor-in-Chief.


You may also enjoy...

Square Enix bans almost 6000 players for real-money trading in Final Fantasy 14

"Players should take care to steer clear of any activity that violates the Terms of Service."

Gogeta SS4 is coming to Dragon Ball FighterZ later this week

Plus Dragon Ball Z: Kakarot will receive its final DLC, Trunks: The Warrior of Hope, in "summer 2021".

Take-Two's CEO reckons we're "ready" for $70 video games

"We're here to captivate and engage consumers, and if we do that then monetisation follows.”

Digital FoundryInside Dinosaur Planet - examining Rare's recently recovered 'lost' N64 game

A closer look at the project that would become Star Fox Adventures on GameCube.

Comments (33)

Comments for this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

Hide low-scoring comments

Buy things with globes on them

And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store!

Eurogamer Merch