I was trying to say they have form for marking down Lego games, Batman Lego was only a 6 as well....
This right here is an example of my number one pet hate on gaming forums. One reviewer gave that Lego game a 3/10, and (I assume) another Edge reviewer gave Undercover a different score.
This is edge magazine that gave Lego LOTR a 3/10 so we can safely ignore that review
EDGE review gave it a 5, same as colonial marines!
Different people, different opinions, just happen to be writing for the same publication. Even if they were written by the same person, it's still not always comparable.
So, you appear to believe Edge et al review games as a collective. It doesn't work like that.
Yet they gave aliens a 5/10