Xbox or PS3|
I'm asking for someone else so if you could flag where they lie on the realisism vs crazy fun spectrum too, that would be aces.
What's the best motorbike racing sim?
dogbot 2,902 posts
Seen 3 months ago
Registered 6 years ago
Tbh, none of them are very good.
SBK X isn't dreadful, and there's a fair few difficulty settings that allow you to ride in variety of modes from more arcadey to actual "simulation" but the graphics might as well be a tissue box onscreen as a bike, for all that it feels like riding one.
Edited by dogbot at 13:35:12 06-09-2012
I thought the Moto GP games reviewed quite well from what I remember but not played them. It's not a stellar score but not terrible.
As to if it feels anything like a bike I doubt it. I have never played any game that could get that right. It's far harder to pull of simulating a bike than cars.
SBK X seems to have scored roughly the same. Probably a good idea to check out if there are demo's of either. I do remember playing a demo of Moto GP years ago that was up on Xbox live.
Edited by glaeken at 13:42:44 06-09-2012
Cheers chaps, I'll pass that on and any others who want to weigh in
Murbs 23,434 posts
Seen 3 hours ago
Registered 11 years ago
Bikes in PGR4? Arcadey, but the best arcadey.
I did not really like the bikes in PGR4. For arcadey bike handling I preferred Midnight club LA's bikes.
shamblemonkee 15,550 posts
Seen 2 hours ago
Registered 11 years ago
Not much to add dogbot got it pretty much spot on. There should be demos of both games on xbox live.
You should only consider the very lastest in the moto gp series, that features all the various bikes sizes, has a great sense of speed from the rider cam but the handling is a bit loose - it can be hard to get the bike right where you want it which is a shame as riding faston the bikes is all aobut corner entry position to get the right arc for the exit.
SBK is mostly regarded better than moto gp but again it can all feel a bit flimsy and the AI can vary wildly form too slow to too fast through corners that you can reall ystruggle to replicate their speed through or vice versa.
Really i guess it would come down to how bothered your friend is aobut playing a sim game or just a bike racing game.
not sure that there is anything on the arcade front other than PGR?
I think he's more likely to fall on the side of realism - plays car racing games already, is a petrolhead, etc. But will suggest anything deemed good just in case.
Moto GP 2 on the original Xbox had a simulation mode, for me it was the best, not sure if it's backwards compatible with the 360 though.
Racing in the wet was extremely tricky, great on xbox live also (sadly missed but system link is supported) on the first corner around 60% of players would lose it.
Every other MotoGP or SBK racer since seemed never had the same level of simulation.
robthehermit 5,380 posts
Seen 20 hours ago
Registered 12 years ago
Not a sim, but there's bikes in Burnout Paradise.
What we really need is update of Road Rash.
hypoBla5t 1,978 posts
Seen 1 hour ago
Registered 7 years ago
Or a Manx TT HD remake. That would be sexual.
pinebear 8,564 posts
Seen 4 days ago
Registered 10 years ago
Gosh darn dangit robth, now you've gone and got us all thinking about motorbikes in Most Wanted 2012
Sometimes posts may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.