I think its fantastic.
The SP is great, story isn't bad so far. The gameplay mechanics are also excellent (sync shots are awesome). I'm also finding the tactical challenges and the "ghost" rating almost make it an arcade type experience to get a faultless run on a mission.
All these comments about it being sub-HD really make no difference to the fact the game looks great. NPC models are a bit ropey mind but the explosions etc look fine. Special mention to the sound as well, i was playing the first escort section with Dolby HD 5.1 and almost shit myself. Great sound design.
And then the MP, I havnt tried it yet but everything i have read makes it sound like this could become one of those EG reg games that develops a bit of a community. I also like the fact that there is alot of achievements based on MP, i know they dont matter to everyone, but i like them.
How many EG'rs are around for MP on 360?
Private Floyd is the GT.
Goat is hungry.....