I agree with Repairman on Last Night On Earth. It's too simple for me. The map layout is the problem, since you can't make higgledy-piggledy shapes. I'd also caution against Zombicide, a new game. The scenario difficulty was all out of whack, the characters weren't interesting and there were some silly ideas.
I didn't like Waterdeep at all. It normally takes a few plays for me to warm up to eurogames, but just something about it fell flat. The cubes, the pasted-on theme and so on.
www.hatchetjob.com - more than games. "Seemingly trivial, surprisingly deep"