#7960096, By Dan234 The Official Doctor Who Thread

  • Dan234 13 Sep 2011 23:34:57 2,232 posts
    Seen 3 weeks ago
    Registered 7 years ago
    darkmorgado wrote:
    PARADOX!

    The scene where old amy and real amy speak to each other. Old Amy would therefore know that the doctor would come back because she would have the memories of our Amy talking to herself.

    Isn't this why the whole "you can't cross your own time stream" rule is in place?

    She did say she remembered the conversation and she said no because she's had 36 years to think about who the Doctor really is.

    Paradox 1: Then this time around Old Amy changed her mind.

    Paradox 2: Young Amy was rescued so Old Amy never existed and her timestream disappeared as if it never existed. But for that to have happened in the first place her timestream had to have existed.
Log in or register to reply