disusedgenius wrote:I was referring to TIM there.
And yes, the point is that although as an audience we can prove the Catalyst wrong, the narrative considers him to be unquestionably right, because there is no way in the narrative to say "you are wrong", defy his very premise (that there is a problem requiring a solution), and choose none of his solutions.
If it is trivial for the audience to see the flaws in your reasoning yet the characters never address them, it's because you're a bad writer.
The whole point of Shepard as a blank character whose interactions we choose is to allow this to happen.
And it only "becomes a problem" in concluding the plot if the writer sucks. After all, Planescape: Torment managed it quite ably, having multiple possible conclusions with wide variation reflecting the multiple answers the player could choose to its central question.
#8548756, By GloatingSwine Mass Effect 3 *SPOILERS THREAD*
GloatingSwine 2,785 posts
Seen 3 hours ago
Registered 7 years ago