To be fair he opens his review with an admission that the review and the score do not necessarily tally, and that he expects some harsh feedback in the comments, and in that respect he was not disappointed.
"8/10 - Extremely nice SEGA PR-funded dinner at The Ivy."
4/5 in the Guardian.
He highlighted almost every flaw everyone else has (terrible graphics, terrible models, terrible Alien "hug me! hug me!" animation, terrible AI, terrible maps, terrible end-boss, being able to shoot through NPCs, having Aliens lunge at you through NPCs, etc), then gives it the equivalent of 8/10.
He says he likes it coz he likes Aliens.