Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

Virtua Tennis 2009 Review

Wii Review by Kristan Reed

18 June, 2009

Page 2 of 2. <- Page 1

Not so with the Wii MotionPlus add-on plugged in, however. As with Grand Slam Tennis, WMP in Virtua Tennis 2009 offers a tangible extra layer of precision which returns a great deal of the flowing intuitiveness that any tennis game requires. That said, coaxing the game into letting you play with WMP controls involves an unnecessary amount of nannying. Despite having a global settings option in main menu, the game still forces you to instruct it to utilise WMP controls at the start of every single game, when it also checks whether you're a lefty. Not only that, you're then instructed to point the Wii remote at your player at the start of every single point, presumably so the game can ensure the calibration is correct before the point gets underway. Whatever the reason, you'll soon get heartily tired of having to go through this flow-breaking rigmarole.

Once again, getting used to the controls isn't instant, but again it's something the useful tutorial goes some way to remedying. The most obvious difference between the systems initially is the removal of the shot gauge, which means you have to instantly rely much more on your own judgement rather than focusing on the varying speed of a white line travelling from one side of a horizontal bar to the other. Removing this visual aid generally makes the game feel more immersive, and it's apparent that real-life racquet motions are being replicated on-screen in real-time. Although it's by no-means foolproof, the general direction and velocity of any given shot is replicated convincingly, if not quite as intuitively as in Grand Slam.

But just as with GST, the business of running is still a problematic issue. By default, you can simply leave it up to the AI to position your player for you - an option which obviously strips away a significant amount of the strategy. Worse still, the timing of your wind-up and swing can have an influence on where the AI decides to run to, often resulting in shots where the ball will miraculously reappear, despite having evidently flown beyond your despairing racquet. With the nunchuk plugged in you can take complete control, but at the cost of tethered interference. With practice you'll perhaps get used to a wired controller being plugged in, but it's never the most graceful pairing.

'Virtua Tennis 2009' Screenshot 3

Moments before doing the splits.

In all other senses, the game is almost identical to the PS3 and 360 versions, featuring the exact same World Tour mode, online options, and roster of male and female professionals. Visually the game obviously can't compete with the HD versions, but still manages to boast the flowing animation that has been VT's trademark for almost a decade - at least when the odd juddering slowdown doesn't intervene.

As with the PS3 and 360 versions, the player customisation options are pretty poor, and while the likenesses are great for the real-life pros, the game suffers when you're playing the generic unknowns. Somehow Sumo has managed to make this side of the game proportionally worse than previous VTs, and it's hard to understand how it managed to break something that didn't need fixing. Likewise, the rejigged World Tour mode is a chore to play through, and the new court games fail to engage. Online play also suffers on the Wii thanks to the relative paucity of matches and the ongoing friends code shenanigans, but it would be harsh to put the blame on Sumo for that.

'Virtua Tennis 2009' Screenshot 4

Murray to win Wimbledon? That's where my money's heading.

On the whole, Virtua Tennis 2009 is another clear indication of the potential of the Wii MotionPlus add-on. While the game struggles to provide intuitive accuracy with default motion controls, the addition of Nintendo's little dongle transforms the accuracy of the strokeplay in a manner which will be warmly received by both old-school Virtua Tennis fans, and casual admirers of the sport at large. A few residual issues with the running mechanic aside, VT2009 is a great tennis game, especially in multiplayer. It might lack some of the charm and fluidity of EA’s offering, but Sumo deserves much credit nevertheless. With two strong tennis titles on the market, Wii owners suddenly find themselves spoilt for choice.

7/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Virtua Tennis 2009 on Wii?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-34 of 34 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
carrotcake
19/06/09 @ 05:30
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Thanks for the review, I'm gonna buy this when the shops are open then. Best tennis game on Wii but still not good enough to get an 8? Mmm still a good number though.
Charlie_Miso
19/06/09 @ 05:36
#2
-5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
A seven?

/fake shock
disc
19/06/09 @ 05:37
#3
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I wonder why Nintendo chose to not make the Nunchuck wireless as well. Surely they realized the problem with their own Tennis game.

oerhört
19/06/09 @ 05:48
#4
+10
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Pro_Gamer said: "My little sister likes to plays Wii tennis but i don't think many Eurogamers would be interested in stuff like this."

I'm glad you're not in a position to judge what "Eurogamers" should be treated to, then.
figaro7
19/06/09 @ 06:30
#5
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Review didnt convince me to trade in Grand slam tennis at all.
brof
19/06/09 @ 07:04
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
hm... don't get it why this WMP is better than GST... GST works absolut fine for me 90% of the time..
Edited 1 times, most recently on 19/06/09 @ 08:04
stampz
19/06/09 @ 07:20
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I really think these guys should re-review GST, I don't have any of the problems they mention in the original review. 90% of the time I can hit the ball exactly where I want to, the GST review just felt off to me...
JohnnyWashnGo
19/06/09 @ 07:22
#8
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
/Dull surprise
dr_faulk
19/06/09 @ 08:00
#9
-3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So this is it? This is the Wii's potential realised? What a shame that our imaginations can be so much better than reality.
LazyDan
19/06/09 @ 08:15
#10
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yeah I'm also getting the impression from all the forum chatter I've read on the internet about Grand Slam Tennis that the Eurogamer review isn't really to be trusted.

Listening to the masses vs this review, it seems as though Grand Slam Tennis might actually be the better game - but then with a 100% failure on WM+ reviews prior to this, it's hard to judge whether this one's going to turn out to be largely disagreed with as well.

Hurry up and get this out so the masses can tell me which one's better so I can buy one.
Harmonica
19/06/09 @ 08:34
#11
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
7/10 surely a case of damning with faint praise.

What it boils down to is that until you separate the nunchuk from the wiimote these kind of games are just going to feel really clumsy. Clumsier than playing with a gamepad. I know that the Motion Plus does a good job with the shot types, but what's the point of getting that bit right without the movement part.

Wii Tennis was great back in the day but the improvements made in these new crop of tennis games are not enough to warrant a purchase, in my opinion. We're best off waiting for whenever we get to play tennis games on Natal on the 360.
Santino
19/06/09 @ 08:38
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
have u tried playing either of the games with the nunchuk harmonica? i haven't found it to get in the way yet in GST.
malteaserhead
19/06/09 @ 09:13
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
or without nunchucks or using a wireless one? ;)
Not sure about this in the review
"Unlike Grand Slam Tennis, WMP in Virtua Tennis 2009 offers a tangible extra layer of precision".

I thought the wmp added some more control over normal waggle in GST.
/opens can of worms
Spooke
19/06/09 @ 09:28
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
this is confusing!

I really want a new Tennis game and I now have no idea which to buy.

Is there a straight comparison review anywhere?
JackyB
19/06/09 @ 09:40
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Spooke - got this last night. its good - but hard. great satisfaction when pulling off shots, but frustrating when you dont. Not sure if its me or the controller!
EclipseDj
19/06/09 @ 09:45
#16
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Pro_Gamer, yes well done for pointing out that that we can all play Wii Tennis in Wii Sports, but

Does it offer true singles matches?
Does it offer clay courts?
Does it offer to play as real life tennis players?
Does it offer Motion Plus control?
Does it offer Grand Slam and other world venues?
Does it offer online play including online doubles - with a world ranking and level up system?
Does it let you enter tournements or have a world tour/career mode?

I think you'll find that it does none of the above, and that is why Eurogamers and many other tennis fans around the world are interested in games like this. They offer far greater depth to the sport than a Mii party game can, just as Tiger Woods offers so much more over Wii Sports Golf.
thiswaynow
19/06/09 @ 10:55
#17
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Eurogamer says VT is better than GST, IGN say the other way around... confusing times.
ltbobby
19/06/09 @ 11:01
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Grand slam tennis is no way a 5. its more like a 9. Give it time you wont regret it. its amazing online. Ive owned Top spin, Virtua tennis, all tennis games over the last 5 years, and Grand Slam tennis on the Wii is best and most realistic by far. Take time to learn controls and you will love it
zakrocz
19/06/09 @ 11:54
#20
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You can't trust the 5/10 this reviewer has given Grand Slam Tennis, it's a lot of fun and the controls do work most of the time, and when they don't it's not necessarily the controller as there are many ways to hit a tennis ball and if you hit it wrong then shots are going to go where you didn't intend them to. It took me several hours before I won my first game on Medium, that's game not match!

If you want a demonstration of just how well the M+ works you only need to go online and play some of the masters out there. There was one player who played a great net play game,he was dead subtle, really placing his drop shots and winners, not going for maximum power, like me, hehe. Oh, he whipped my ass 3 - 0.

In real life tennis isn't a precise button game so with M+, GST is easily the best tennis video game to date bar VT 2009 which I haven't played.

EA definately got it right by not attempting to go for photo-realism allowing them to create some gorgeous visuals that make you just want to pick up the wiimote and play! The crowd noises are excellent, the player animations smooth and realistic & you get to be on the other end of the court to witness John McEnroe's unique left handed serve first hand, the courts look gorgeous, bright & colourful, the umpires all sound great and all the sounds are mixed together perfectly. The game is also full of stuff to do on your own, with friends or online.

There is definately a big learning curve, one which the EG reviewer evidentally couldn't get past. The only negative points are having to use a button for lobs and drops and the lack of a 1 to 1 serving mechanic.

I'd give it an 8/10.
Dirtie
19/06/09 @ 12:03
#21
-3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I thought I could trust Eurogamer (been checking out the reviews here for years), but judging by the comments maybe I should rethink my position. Or just remind myself that it's an opinion, and opinions vary wildly from the majority every now and again.
Edited 2 times, most recently on 19/06/09 @ 13:05
jaguarwong
19/06/09 @ 12:05
#22
+15
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Haven' bothered reading the review, just looked at the score."

You sir, are not part of the solution.

db3
19/06/09 @ 12:47
#23
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I recommend GST as the Wii tennis game of choice.
With all the flippin addons we now need to buy I can't afford both ;)
Edited 1 times, most recently on 23/06/09 @ 01:11
superdelphinus
19/06/09 @ 13:19
#24
-2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Thanks to the release of the Wii MotionPlus, tennis games suddenly find themselves the centre of attention "

yeah it's all to do with a remote add on and nothing to do with wimbledon
JackyB
19/06/09 @ 13:22
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
EG are not the only ones to score GST low. In fact the 2 most positive reviews for it are from Official nintendo, and IGN both who had very early reviews. hmm. I wonder if its coincidental that they were afforded first review and the scores were really high?
db3
19/06/09 @ 18:49
#26
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Seriously, if you enjoy tennis and can handle the nunchuck & MP then you should check out GST.
I bought it for my daughter but ended up playing it online more than any new game for my PS3 in the last year.
Forget the reviews listen to what people who have bought it are generally saying.

*edit) Now you can consider the 'revised' reviews.

Edited 1 times, most recently on 23/06/09 @ 01:12
carrotcake
19/06/09 @ 20:14
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
end up not getting VT because my local didn't get any of the VT + WMP bundles in stock. was offered GST but didn't get it because I thought it wasn't supposed to be that good. now I look here and people are saying GST is the better game... hmmm
DarkBytes
22/06/09 @ 09:13
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
so I got both , no wait wait there is a method to my madness , I wanted 2x motion plus do- dah's
so got the GST bundle & VT bundle , gonna play both choose which I like best and trade the other copy

anyhow I started with VT and really liked it , I then went on to GST and I guess because I was in VT mode I found it hard to get to grips with it , although as I played a little more it grew on me , one major difference I noticed was that timing was paramount in GST whilst VT heavily compensated .

anyhow I'm going to give gst more of a play tonight , then make my choice

just the thing though Watch a bit of Wimbledon
then play out your tennis fantasy on the WIi
Edited 1 times, most recently on 22/06/09 @ 10:43
tossetaz
22/06/09 @ 11:41
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
looks like you didn't edit this review? atleast the score isn't available now
krudster [mod]
22/06/09 @ 11:51
#30
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The review has a few nips and tucks where comparisons to GST were made, but is otherwise broadly the same.
UncleLou
22/06/09 @ 12:49
#31
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Was confused by the comments before I realised they're from the 19th, before the re-review of GST, I must admit.
Burkey123
22/06/09 @ 12:59
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
EclipseDj, game, set, match! :)
ltbobby
22/06/09 @ 15:27
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i bought this and Grand Slam tennis. GST is way better. VT 09 is pretty dull in comparison, and i felt that the control you have over the ball was really limited compared to GST
pollehund
09/07/09 @ 22:59
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
is online good portion of virtual tennis 2009

Comments: 1-34 of 34 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery