Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Advertisement

Top Spin 3 Review

Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Review by Kristan Reed

25 June, 2008

Page 2 of 2. <- Page 1

As you might expect, self-improvement follows the fairly standard process of allocating your XP in eight different areas (Forehand, Backhand, Service, Return, Volley, Power, Speed, Stamina). With each set by default at level 30, it's then entirely your choice how you evolve your player. However, with the overall level of your player capped at 560 out of a maximum of 800, you can't max out every stat like you can in other tennis titles. This essentially forces you to prioritise specialist areas of your game; for example, a powerful service, possibly at the expense of stamina, or a nippy net player with sublime volley skills. It's an interesting design choice, and definitely helps shape the way you play the game both offline and online. The only real downside to the Player Evolution is PAM's insistence of playing Jamiroquai's godforsaken "Canned Heat" track every single time you enter the upgrade screen. Still, with The Go! Team and The Stone Roses bouncing and shuffling their way through the other in-game menus, it's not all bad.

Ploughing on beyond the rather straightforward Junior mode brings the reward of Pro status. At this point, the game really starts to come into its own, not just in terms of upping the ante challenge-wise, but having the added allure of letting you play the real-life tennis elite, which in this case means the likes of Roger Federer, Andy Murray, Andy Roddick and Tommy Haas on the male side, and the stupidly well put-together Maria Sharapova for the women's game. From my own thumb-bruising experience, it's brutally challenging to play the hard tournaments in Pro until you've ranked up a fair bit. At this point, you've got a few other useful means of making serious progress: either take the lesser rewards of the easy tournaments, slope off to play the game's standalone tournaments outside of career mode, or try your luck in the online World Tour mode. Whichever you choose, they all help get you the extra XP you need to outperform the better players, and you can eventually return to claim the Pro title and unlock the super-elite Legends mode if you're super-committed.

'Top Spin 3' Screenshot 3

Finally, a tennis game with a vaguely convincing looking crowd!

Inevitably, the further you progress into the game, the lengthier matches become, and the more of an investment of time and energy is required to get through the seasons. In a game where five rounds of a single tournament can easily eat up the best part of an hour, it's not difficult to see what a time-sink Top Spin 3 can be once it gets going. As such, the realisation of the intense demands of career mode makes the online play that much more attractive, and it's possibly here where the game is at its best. Presented with the choice of a quick single three-set, first-to-three game or a more expansive array of tournaments, you're well catered for. World Tour seasons are effectively set over a number of real-time weeks, with the winners based around overall performance during that time. Impressively, the game is very lag-tolerant (unlike VT3, which was a write off most of the time), and although I did experience a few slight glitches here and there, at no stage did it feel like the game was being compromised in any serious way. As far as online tennis goes, Top Spin 3 is top dog, although annoyingly doesn't appear to allow you to set up a custom doubles match.

Another somewhat inexplicable decision PAM has made for this otherwise high-quality sequel is to abandon the more fun training missions you could engage in previously. It's perhaps understandable that the game's creators wanted to streamline the gameplay to be purely about tennis tournaments, but stripping them out inevitably reduces the experience to a one-note succession of matches with no respite or variety along the way. It's not a deal-breaker by any means, but its loss is felt nevertheless. The bizarrely taxing Top Spin school, while necessary, doesn't make up for it at all.

'Top Spin 3' Screenshot 4

Slightly giving the game away that Borg is available later.

Elsewhere, the game is a uniformly impressive technical tour-de-force, and benefits from an array of subtle improvements that add greatly to the sense of immersion. As well as some glorious animation, little touches like the changing lighting conditions, and the developing sweat patches on players' shirts is a fantastic addition. On that note, it's the first tennis title we can recall where player stamina truly has a palpable effect on how your player performs. A little heart monitor gives you an obvious clue as to when players are really worn out, but it's even better to see a player struggling around the court during a lengthy rally. A lot of these smaller touches aren't necessarily noticeable during the first few hours of play, but once you really start getting into manic tie-break scenarios and endless see-sawing break point recoveries, the epic depth of Top Spin 3 becomes truly apparent. As someone who has earned the game's infamous 2K award, I speak from bitter, hand-ruining experience.

But what you really want to know is whether it's worth buying. Unlike last time out, you'll easily be able to pick this game up today for under GBP 30, making it a must-buy for anyone looking for the most advanced tennis title around. Yes, the often exhausting depth might prove to be off-putting for those who prefer the more intuitive Virtua Tennis, but that's precisely part of Top Spin 3's more simulation-minded appeal. With fantastic online play and an obsessive career mode to dive into, it's the thinking man's tennis title.

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Top Spin 3 on Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 57 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Benno
25/06/08 @ 10:26
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
As good as MGS4 then?

Sold.
robg
25/06/08 @ 10:28
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"In truth, all bar the most advanced players will ever master it - I've played them all, and it's a trick that, to this day, eludes me."

If it eludes you, then that means you're a master!

:D
Huddy
25/06/08 @ 10:30
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Tidy.

I love a good game of tennis, and the depth certainly appeals.
mikeck
25/06/08 @ 10:33
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Even against the rookies in career mode, you'll struggle pathetically and wonder what on earth you're doing wrong. Serves will fly limply off target, returns won't go anywhere near where you want them to, and you'll lumber along like a complete chump struggling to win a single point. It's the anti Wii Sports Tennis - a counter-intuitive tennis game that only the committed hardcore player will be able to play."

Are you sure you're good enough to review the game then? ;)
wowami
25/06/08 @ 10:34
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i really enjoyed TS2 so looking forward to getting this.
Best tennis games since Match Point! lol
ryohazuki1983
25/06/08 @ 10:41
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Shame the Wii version isn't online, or I would of bought it straight away! Any chance of a Wii review to see if its worth picking up?
stevetuck
25/06/08 @ 10:51
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think ill stick to my Mario Power Tennis...
Slipstream
25/06/08 @ 10:54
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Mighty generous review. The game has some notable achievements like decent animation and the heart rate system, but other than that I thought it was rather sluggish and unresponsive. Pretty to look at, terrible to play.
Although Virtua Tennis 3 is more arcade rather than sim, it certainly feels alot more satisfying to play due to the faster gameplay.
marronthered
25/06/08 @ 10:56
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
whens the new virtua tennis due out? comparison of the two titles i must...
krudster [mod]
25/06/08 @ 11:03
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think the comment about sluggishness is fair enough to begin with. The more you invest into the game's intricacies, the more satisfying it feels, but getting to that point does take a fair amount of time. It really depends how patient you are. I can totally understand why some people will not take to it and stick with VT.
onezeonx
25/06/08 @ 11:04
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
only 1 week late i see !!

i have it and its great!
CUR715
25/06/08 @ 11:04
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Review is spot on. It's the Anti-Pick-Up-N-Play.

Dedicated players only please.
drumbaby
25/06/08 @ 11:09
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Virtua Tennis 3 ftw...still!
weeno
25/06/08 @ 11:10
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Virtua Tennis 3 worked great online on the 360, for me at least.
I am not sure whether I should pick this up, loved the first TopSpin but I thought the second one was horrible.
BulletTheory05
25/06/08 @ 11:17
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think TS3 is brilliant.

Spot on review imo, and it's defiantley a title with a good learning curve, and a game that you're going to have to put time into to get good at it.

I love the little touches like sweating and stuff, and this might be just me, but I'm pretty sure the players get a bit of a tan too. My career dude used to play in a short sleeve t-shirt, but after a few tournaments I changed to a sleeveless top. Upon closer inspection, my guys forearms look very tanned, while the upper arm is quite pale.
schachmatt
25/06/08 @ 11:20
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
There is no excuse today to leave out the casual gamer!

Hope it bombs, so there will not be more games of this sort.
It rather should have come out for the pc-zombies.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 25/06/08 @ 12:21
mikeck
25/06/08 @ 11:25
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"There is no excuse today to leave out the casual gamer!

Hope it bombs, so there will not be more games of this sort."

Sod off back to the pikey travelling circus to play whack-a-mole then.
jovus
25/06/08 @ 11:28
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Rafa Nadal is PS3 exclusive, and thus ps3 game is more complete(coz u can have number 1 VS number 2 match), and again EG reviews the 360 version... i can only wonder why? :S
Darren
25/06/08 @ 11:31
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ace review (ho ho ho) and absolutely spot on IMO having been playing the 360 version extensively since last Thursday evening. It's so insanely addictive but I have to admit that I did find frustratingly difficult at first to pick up due to having been playing Virtua Tennis 3 to death. Top Spin 3 really does take a bit of adjusting to after that game but it's ultimately a much deeper and more rewarding experience. The only things I don't like about the game are the sloppy menus, the sparse ingame sound and the fact that the Training School is seriously dull and doesn't really explain the lessons thoroughly. Also there's a bug which means if you play a custom sountrack, as I do during the otherwise music-free matches, the ingame music still plays in the menus and stuff which is rather annoying. I'd give it 8/10 too but I still love Virtua Tennis 3 for its pick-and-play appeal.
Darren
25/06/08 @ 11:34
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Slipstream - Top Spin 3 certainly feels sluggish when you start the Career mode with a 30 rated player but at a rating of 68 now my player feels nice and agile. Besides which Top Spin 3 's Career mode is a realistically paced game based around non-pro players unlike the pros-only Virtua Tennis 3. Both games are great but Top Spin 3 definitely feels and plays more like the real sport (well as accurate as you get with a game that plays with a controller anyway! LOL ).
Darren
25/06/08 @ 11:40
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've played the PS3 version as well as the 360 one and the only real difference I noticed apart from strangely longer saving times was the lack of a Mall option (to change outfits, hair, etc.) during the Career mode. The Mall is definitely in the 360 version as I'm forever changing my players appearance (now I have over 300 items to choose from!) and I don't ever remember it not being there. I only played the PS3 version to month 4 of the Junior circuit so maybe I just never noticed that it unlocks later on. You can alter your player's appearance from the Player Arena option in the Main Menu though so there's a way round it, albeit a bit clumsier. Can anyone with the game (EG?) confirm that?
canoot
25/06/08 @ 11:42
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I disagree with the review the control system is pants,they tried to fix something that wasn't broken,i got rid of it the same day i bought it.
ERG1008
25/06/08 @ 11:49
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Loved the 1st one, didn't play the 2nd.
Can anyone tell me if you can save the game during tournaments?
For example, if you win the first round, can you save it before your second round game or do you have to play the whole tournament like in TS1?
koji_m
25/06/08 @ 11:52
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
O look, an 8... what a suprise...
Beats12
25/06/08 @ 11:54
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@jovus

I doubt if the inclusion of Nadal will affect the content of the review. Maybe they reviewed the 360 version because that's the one that was sent to them...
Darren
25/06/08 @ 11:58
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ERG1008 - By default the game auto-saves after each game in the tournament but you can set it to manual and save that way if you want, say, if you wish to have the option of replaying the semi-final or final you just lost again! ;)
Trafford
25/06/08 @ 11:58
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The bird on the box gives me the horn.
But tennis is very alien to be
ERG1008
25/06/08 @ 12:00
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Darren - That's good to know.
I was more concerned about the length it takes to play a tournament non-stop rather than replaying and erm cheating. :o)
Thanks for the answer mate.
Darren
25/06/08 @ 12:00
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Also one thing the review didn't mention was that you can build up your created player's XP (experience) and earn Unlock Points (self-explanatory) outside of the Career mode by using him/her in the Exhibition and Tournament modes. You can also earn Unlock Points using a Pro player too. I think this is excellent as it means you can still build your player up if you get bored of playing a tournament in the Career mode.
ghearoid
25/06/08 @ 12:02
#30
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've had this for a week and, although first impressions are pretty average with unresponsive players and sluggish movement, it does improve once you get used to the controls.

Worth sticking with if you're keen, but definitely not suitable for casual pick up 'n play. I spent my first match watching balls fly by me.
rhubarbandcustard
25/06/08 @ 12:10
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Have no opinion on the game, just wanted to say that tennis is a game that I have loathed since I was a child. It's wimbledon fortnight so the papers and tv will be saturated with the event. Why does anyone care about tennis? I mean, really?!

It is the shitest of all sports.
Huntcjna
25/06/08 @ 12:15
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Awwww damn this wasn't allowed to be good!

/looks at woeful bank balance
/weeps
brockenheimer
25/06/08 @ 12:16
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Darren - "the review didn't mention was that you can build up your created player's XP (experience) and earn Unlock Points (self-explanatory) outside of the Career mode by using him/her in the Exhibition and Tournament modes"

I disagree, that's exactly what I understood from this passage in the review:

"At this point, you've got a few other useful means of making serious progress: either take the lesser rewards of the easy tournaments, slope off to play the game's standalone tournaments outside of career mode, or try your luck in the online World Tour mode. Whichever you choose, they all help get you the extra XP you need to outperform the better players"
Darren
25/06/08 @ 12:18
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ah yes, so it does, sorry I obviously missed that. /oops
TONYgr
25/06/08 @ 12:32
#35
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
the same applies to the ps3 version too?
Darren
25/06/08 @ 13:18
#36
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yes.
ulov3
25/06/08 @ 13:54
#37
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So a great looking simulation who plays nicely gets the same score as a stinky broken rugby game called rugby 08?????

Eurogamer start using a nice principle in your score: compare them......

TONYgr
25/06/08 @ 14:22
#38
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
DARREN


thanks.i m gonna buy it tommorow!
rob230
25/06/08 @ 14:38
#39
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If you haven't already, read everything Darren has said in these comments, they're as helpful as the review itself.
tafkap
25/06/08 @ 15:02
#40
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
My thumbs are hurting from a renewed interest in VT3, so I'll give this a miss until the price comes down and my thumbs revert to their normal size.

Each to their own, but I love tennis - the drama, the spectacle, the skirts going up when ladies serve. Cricket makes me yawn, but then I'm Scottish so it's not in our culture!
Darren
25/06/08 @ 15:16
#41
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Actually playing TS3 with the 360 controller made me realise how uncomfortable its face buttons are to hold as to play the game you have to press and hold them down to hit the ball: the longer you do, the more powerful the shot. I actually had indentations on my fingers from playing the game over the weekend because of this... but I did play it for almost nine hours non-stop (well I did say it was addictive!)! LOL

In that respect the flatter buttons of the PS3's DualShock 3 make for a more comfortable game IMO plus the rumble effects are more effective - you can really feel how powerful the shots are for example whereas the effect is weaker on the 360's controller. That's just a personal preference though and as such it doesn't make one version better than the other provided you don't play it for as long as I do (typically 3-4 hours per night).
mikeck
25/06/08 @ 15:46
#42
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Never mind Andy Murray's mum just loves a good gash eh? "

Wait, she's a lesbian?
praetorian
25/06/08 @ 17:11
#43
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Federer's overall rating is only 75?
Edited 1 times, most recently on 25/06/08 @ 18:11
rob230
25/06/08 @ 17:12
#44
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Could do but then 2k would be bankrupt unless the RRP was £4,000
rob230
25/06/08 @ 17:14
#45
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Fed is only 75 cos he got SPANKED by Nadal, and thus, deserves it.

(or it's because if they made him the tennis robot he is, no-one would EVER pick anyone else.... like Brazil in footie games)
MAX99
25/06/08 @ 20:49
#46
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
disagree with this review. the game is slow and makes individual shots far too tricky. even after you get better this game never feels like real tennis.

i took it back to the shop.
rob230
26/06/08 @ 08:33
#47
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Foooooooooool
infoxicated
26/06/08 @ 09:07
#48
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Saw this in HMV yesterday and thought it looked like shit.

If it had been a launch title for this gen then I'd have given it a pass, but it looked fucking awful - uncanny valley players plopped on top of cartoon-esque environments with shoddy looking shadows and I swear there must have been free entry for facial burns victims, because the stands were packed with 'em. Lots of early Mario style running-in-place in the animation, too.
Liggur
26/06/08 @ 09:31
#49
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
No Mansuor Bahrami, no sale!

How do the controls compare to Top Spin on the olde Xbox?
Socrates
26/06/08 @ 09:47
#50
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Is the onlineplay on PS3 any good ?

Comments: 1-50 of 57 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery