Time reveals top 10 games of 2008 Comments by Robert Purchese
GTA IV best, Braid second, LBP third.
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Poster
|
muscleblade
09/12/08 @ 15:22
0
"two controversial inclusions: Dead Space and Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. Both received 7/10 here on Eurogamer, you may remember."
I loved both of them. More so than Fable 2 for example. |
|
muscleblade
09/12/08 @ 15:23
0
If you didnt find Braid amazing i think you didnt "get it". It is amazing.
|
|
0
Isn't Braid a fairly standard platformer with the clever addition of the time mechanism, but most importantly done beautifully?
That's the impression I've got from the demo, and if MS Points didn't seem like such a marketing exercise to steal as much of my money as possible, I'd have the full thing. |
|
0
I've not had time to devote myself to Braid since it was released. Roll on friday & 3 weeks off work for Christmas holiday :D
GTA4 is another game I haven't had time to devote myself to. Unfortunately, I have no plans to rectify that. For me this has been an amazing year for games. Brawl, Mario Kart, Professor Layton, Braid, Geometry Wars 2, Castle Crashers, Left4Dead, Rock Band 2/GH:WT (and go on then,) Wii Fit... Such a colourful bunch, and no matter who I've got round I've got something to play with them. |
|
0
"Isn't Braid a fairly standard platformer with the clever addition of the time mechanism, but most importantly done beautifully?
That's the impression I've got from the demo.." In the full game, each world has a slightly different twist on the time-manipulation. It's brilliantly inventive, and you've missed out if you haven't played the whole thing. It's still maybe slightly overpriced, compared to the also excellent GW2, but I don't regret buying it for a second. |
|
kinky_mong
09/12/08 @ 16:17
0
Still not as terrible a list as the top ten of 2008 that was in the London Paper last Friday. Dead Space No.1?!
To be honest though any list that doesn't have Left 4 Dead firmly at No. 1 can jog the fuck on. |
|
The_Inquisitor
09/12/08 @ 16:26
0
Not a bad list by any means, it has variety and diversity at least. You could argue that it says more about what games the person who compiled the list enjoyed this year, but that's kind of the point, since it's a small section of the overall publication and probably only has on gamer on the payroll.
|
|
Graham_Bark
09/12/08 @ 16:34
0
The final level of Braid was simply incredibly fantastic and clever, one of the finest moments in gaming as far as I'm concerned. Its easily worthy of 2nd best game of the year, if not first.
GTA IV on the other hand is over rated. Its not bad, its just nothing like the ridiculously high review scores suggested it would be. San Andreas was certainly better. Not played the others on the list, but I do now feel that Fable II is worthy of a place. When I started playing I felt quite underwhelmed by it, but as the game goes on it has gone from strength to strength and is now utterly superb. Like Mass Effect, its a game that inadvertently had me playing until 4am despite lectures the next morning.
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 09/12/08 @ 16:34
|
|
0
GTA IV is a very, very good game, IMO. No doubt it suffered from over-exposure to media, and within the more "hardcore circles" it started to be trendy to bash it.
It has a very good plot, quite deep and ilustrative of post-9/11 America, and it's fun to play too, quite balanced, and technically impresse, scope-wise. It's clever gaming. Well, I love it and I usually miss those trendy waves, though.
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 09/12/08 @ 16:44
|
|
captainrentboy
09/12/08 @ 16:50
0
No Wii 'My Pet Vet Dolphin Zoo Sports Practice 4'? Absolute bullshit.
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 09/12/08 @ 16:51
|
|
0
===========================================================
=OOOOOOOO=========OO==OO===OOOOOO===================OOO==== =OO===============OO==OO==OOO==OOO================OOO=OOO== =OO===============OO==OO==OO====OO==========OO===OOO===OOO= =OO=========OOO===OO==OO==OO====OO==OO=OO==OOOO=======OOO== =OOOOOO====OO=OO==OO==OO==OO====OO==OO=OO===OO======OOOO=== =OO===========OO==OO==OO==OO====OO==OO=OO===OO========OOO== =OO=========OOOO==OO==OO==OO====OO==OO=OO===OO===OOO===OOO= =OO========OO=OO==OO==OO==OOO==OOO==OO=OO===OO====OOO=OOO== =OO=========OOOO==OO==OO===OOOOOO====OOOO===OOO=====OOO==== =========================================================== ==============OOOOOOOO==OOOOOOOO==OO====OO====OO=========== ==============OO===========OO=====OO====OO====OO=========== ==============OO===========OO=====OO====OO====OO=========== ==============OO===========OO=====OO====OO====OO=========== ==============OOOOOO=======OO=====OOO==OOOO==OO============ ==============OO===========OO======OO==OOOO==OO============ ==============OO===========OO======OO==OOOO==OO============ ==============OO===========OO=======OOOO==OOOO============= ==============OO===========OO========OO====OO============== =========================================================== |
|
0
I would also put gta4 at the top, it's a game that has stuck with me long after I finished playing it, not because it is fun to play (because it isn't) but because of the way its portrays Niko as an outsider who really has no interest in being a thug, but does it because it is the only thing he knows.
His life of crime is cleverly counterbalanced with the banality of a 'normal life' that he seems to crave for, and somehow they have managed to place this character conflict at the centre of the gaming experience which makes it a tough game to play. That is the reason its not fun to play, it's not supposed to be - its supposed to be a cold and sombre reflection of the life of a professional killer and as such is genius. just to add that because it isn't 'fun' doesn't mean its not compelling. For a series the has been criticised for glorifying violence it takes a brave step and makes the violence anything but glamourous. It's not fun to kill people in real life, why does it have to be fun in video games?, why can't games invoke different emotions?
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 09/12/08 @ 17:51
|
|
kinky_mong
09/12/08 @ 17:21
0
That is the reason its not fun to play, it's not supposed to be
Brilliant. Just brilliant. |
|
Inquisitor
[mod]
09/12/08 @ 17:52
0
I hardly think Dead Space is a controversial inclusion. The only controversial thing about Dead Space was the Eurogamer score, criminally low...
:P |
|
0
GTA top of the pile - and rightly so.
/ pokes tongue out at the haters Dead Space isn't controversial EG, it's amazing and should be in there I really don't get your review of it TBH. I'm surprised SW:FU is in there though, it's pretty bad, from what I've played so far. Also, Rockband over the likes of MK Wii, MGS4, WIpEout HD, Siren, Fallout 3? REALLY?? I guess gamers are all wannabe rockstars these days :) |
|
spudsbuckley
09/12/08 @ 19:53
0
Saints Row 2 was better than GTA 4 for a start, MGS 4 should have been there, as well as GoW2, Left 4 Dead, Fable 2, WAR and WoTLK to name a few.
This list is aimed and the trendy-Mypace-'The' band listening-too cool for the room-types who are a relatively new section of gaming. Most actual gamers would have a very different list. /is actual gamer-too uncool for the room-type |
|
seamonsterneil
09/12/08 @ 20:36
0
I think LBP is waaaaaaay too high, I just can't seem to get into it despite loving its style, artwork and cuteness. That game has more issues than people like to admit.
GTAIV is the only GTA game I have ever liked and deserves its entry just for the amazing city they crafted... the game however should never be considered the best game of the year. Metal gear is hands down a better game even without the cutscenes. Braid is awesome but seriously people should stop with that "you just dont get it shit" when someone says they didnt find it all that interesting. Dead space is more amazing that I think a lot of people expected it to be. Its full of "WOW" moments and really tight in everything it does from the hudlessness to the satisfying dismemberment. |
|
David_Snakes
09/12/08 @ 21:36
0
That's an interesting viewpoint, paulf. Movies like The Godfather and Taxi Driver aren't necessarily "fun" to watch, why are they so highly acclaimed? Games can do more than entertain; a pity the masses of fucking morons can't see that.
|
|
GiarcYekrub
09/12/08 @ 22:21
0
I'd agree with GTA4 being top if it wasn't for the fooking annoying way multiplayer Races are selected... leaving it to the legions of 12 year old host who wants to play Stars In Your Eyes in supercars constantly is NOT a good idea let me wait for people who want to free race/cannon ball run/one of the other 28 races they don't pick to play
|
|
DjWhizzkidd
09/12/08 @ 22:44
0
Dead Space getting 7 out of 10 is a war crime in my books. Its worst than genocide. Especially considering Fable 2 got 10 out of 10. That's like saying Hitler is nice because he didn't kill as many as Stalin. Or was it the other way round? Oh I don't know. Stop asking me questions.
|
|
WillyWanka
09/12/08 @ 23:02
0
"Isn't Braid a fairly standard platformer with the clever addition of the time mechanism, but most importantly done beautifully? "
Yes that's part of the appeal. But for me the greatest part of the game is it's story: the melancholy atmosphere went down well for me and after the amazing end I felt genuinely moved. This, coupled with the ingenious puzzling, make this my GOTY /edit: to reduce the pretentious fuckwittery as much as possible
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 09/12/08 @ 23:04
|
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Advertisement
