Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 Next

Sponsored by Alienware tracer
Advertisement

The Sims 3 Review

PC Review by Alec Meer

1 June, 2009

Page 2 of 2. <- Page 1

It is an incredibly hard game to become bored by. There's always some new torture to inflict, some new place to visit, someone new to pester or romance. And yet, it is still very much The Sims, only now heaving with extra optional toys. For all the improvements - primarily the relaxation of the pressures upon your sims, so you don't have to plan every day around bathroom breaks anymore - it isn't going to convince anyone with a dislike of the previous games to relax their contempt. Even those that have embraced the series will find a few aspects unsatisfying, like all these places you can send your sims to, yet for the most part their actions there are hidden.

Workplaces, cinemas, sports stadiums, even spooky crypts are visible as buildings in the town, but their interiors aren't shown - the joy of seeing your carefully-designed sim dropped into a new situation is denied in favour of watching a floating bar gradually fill as they perform their invisible tasks. Possibly it's a necessary sacrifice in making a world without loading screens, or possibly these are gaps to be filled in by the inevitable slew of expansion packs - but certainly, it's a shame that so many conceptually fun locations prove so meatless.

It's also perhaps a shame that the roster of content in the game - clothes, items, wallpapers - is relatively thin. EA has elected to push community-built content front and centre, a pre-game launcher app offering a raft of player-made goodies to download. Despite knee-jerk grumbles that there are only three types of hi-fi to choose from, realistically this is a good thing. It'll quickly make the game far more visually diverse than it could be just with hired EA monkeys constantly churning out new curtains and tables. It's borrowed a big old page from Spore's book, leveraging the community to push the game far beyond its out-of-the-box limits.

'The Sims 3' Screenshot 2

This is my life. THIS IS MY LIFE.

Clearly, that stuff isn't available in our review code, however, resulting in a game that perhaps looks a little more austere than (hopefully) it ultimately will. What is in our code is the Style tool, with which you can dramatically alter item colours, then save them as a new object you can yourself upload to the shared servers. It may not sound especially profound, but it's incredibly straightforward.

It's the raft of minor additions like that which mean, despite a few pulled punches, that The Sims 3 is a broad and ridiculously charming game that manages to significantly expand upon its critical formula without ever becoming overwhelming. It's that much closer to what a Sims player has always wanted from The Sims: to create themselves, and their friends, and then set them loose upon the world. It's both more of a role-playing game than it's ever been before, and more of a design game than it's ever been before. It may suffer a few glaring compromises, but it's an essential play for anyone with an interest in what videogames can achieve outside of a targeting reticule.

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about The Sims 3 on PC?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-24 of 24 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Ronan_Crawford
01/06/09 @ 15:05
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm going to get this on Friday then :D
Just hope that they don't bring out 10 expansion packs that include stuff that should of been in the original version.
Waldo
01/06/09 @ 15:05
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"First!"

Your parents must be so proud.
BobasaurasRex
01/06/09 @ 15:08
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hmm, my 'first' seems to have disappeared. Oh well.

@Waldo: Why yes, as a matter of fact they are. :)
SYS64738
01/06/09 @ 15:08
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
From "first" to "none"
iokthemonkey
01/06/09 @ 15:10
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
No offence to the reviewer here, but pretty much every review of The Sims 3 I've read just points out that now it's got an open world and there's more stuff to do.

What about some details though? I want to know about how the custom content stuff works. I want to know if it has SecuROM. I want to know if the Create a Style really is as restrictive as it sounds (i.e. no texture imports) and so on. My big fear is that EA are trying to control custom content to the extent of making the PC versions almost as un-modable as the console versions and then using the EA Store to sell all the "custom" content to us.
Domovoi
01/06/09 @ 15:13
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Man those two women on the front page image have annoying looks on their faces.

Actually so does the guy. If that's a guy.
BobasaurasRex
01/06/09 @ 15:16
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@monkey: As far as I know the SecuROM thing isn't included? Could be wrong!
smernicki
01/06/09 @ 15:16
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i didn't like this review. lacking in focus, seemed to skirt about issues without really going into much depth about them. editor gone to e3?

i give this review a 6/10
rhubarbandcustard
01/06/09 @ 15:17
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Last PC game I bought was Spore which I still dip into occasionally.

That game is all about user created content, so could this be the first Sims game I enjoy?

well, I'm definitely buying it, so I'll soon find out.
Kremlik
01/06/09 @ 15:20
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The biggest consern is the player content if anyone played Sims 2 will know about the ton of 'alturnate'/nishe (using more 'friendly' words there) content out there, just go on any custom site it's hard not to find them. If EA are going to go all 'Spore' with it it's going to be VERY hard to control the content without the playerbase feeling discriminated.

Penis monsters was one thing, now it's a can of worms waiting to happen.
iokthemonkey
01/06/09 @ 15:25
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@monkey: As far as I know the SecuROM thing isn't included? Could be wrong!

-----

I asked EA reps about this and was initially told it WOULD use SecuROM and - when I queried the comments on The Sims 2's site that mentioned NOT using it, they pointed me toward Rod Humble's statements about not using "intrusive DRM." However, as has been pointed out, he didnt' say it wouldn't use SecuROM, so until I hear different, I'm not taking the risk.
iokthemonkey
01/06/09 @ 15:32
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If EA are going to go all 'Spore' with it it's going to be VERY hard to control the content without the playerbase feeling discriminated.

----

I don't think it's even as risque as that. It's simply that you're going to be limited to designing clothing based on existing meshes and having no alpha edit options makes that even more restrictivev. Aside from the obvious "here's a completely see-through t-shirt" options, it means players can't, for example, do mesh patterns, lace effects, neck-line modifications, make finger-less/backless gloves, (or add gloves to "barehand" outfits), add rips to jeans and so on.
Bitkari
01/06/09 @ 15:33
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I made me, as every good little egomaniac does in a Sims game - and he ended up behaving like me, living the life I lead.

So true!

This is the reason I always stop playing the Sims. I sit there thinking "THIS IS JUST LIKE MY REAL LIFE. WHY AM I NOT OUT DOING THIS IN REAL LIFE!?!"

SYS64738
01/06/09 @ 15:36
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ Bitkari

lol so true - that and the fact that I always kept asking myself, why did I spend the whole evening playing this and not really achieving anything of significance? This empty Sims / Sim City feeling....

EDIT: Just pre-ordered anyways - D'OH!
Edited 1 times, most recently on 01/06/09 @ 16:36
Kremlik
01/06/09 @ 15:36
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
iok - if thats the case, EA have killed it's own sales - it's kinda like banning all 'alturnate' content in 2ndlife - The 'alturnate' market I bet made most of the Sims 2 sales in the end
Feanor
01/06/09 @ 15:37
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm waiting and hoping it turns up on Steam. My wife really wants the game, but I don't want the hassle of buying it on DVD and then having to find and install a no-disc crack once and then again when the game is patched.

The Sims 2 take minutes to load using the DVD in the drive, but takes seconds using a no-disc crack.
Raajaa
01/06/09 @ 15:45
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ah yes, however... Steam isn't completely without its disc-checking faults. I bought company of heroes on steam (I was ill in bed and couldn't goto the shops) and installed it on my laptop. Fine with an internet connection. However.. when I tried to launch it on the train it asked me to insert the disc, wth? I'd already authenticated it (I thought) by signing up for a relic account and going through all that.

Steam Fail

(though I like it when i've got a net connection, saves having to reinstall when putting a new OS on there as I found after trying out Windows 7)
asphaltcowboy
01/06/09 @ 15:55
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Feanor. This is EA. Pretty sure it will never end up on Steam. You might find it ridiculously overpriced on EA Downloader/Link though!
Feanor
01/06/09 @ 16:45
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
But I already bought Burnout Paradise and Dead Space on Steam this year. They're both EA games.
byron_hinson
01/06/09 @ 17:12
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Yeah EA games are on Steam in the US - not the UK
the_mtfr
01/06/09 @ 18:05
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So the review itself is worse than Darkfall, then?
ChaK
02/06/09 @ 06:33
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
hmm what about hardware specs? Is it running better than sims 2?


Not that I care, but I think ppl might be interested
levitate
02/06/09 @ 08:13
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Bitkari:

It's safer to be a maniac in a computer game than in RL.
sirtacos
08/06/09 @ 19:10
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Playing The Sims is great fun but inevitably results in bouts of intense introspection: "why am I spending hours micromanaging a virtual me - forcing him to go out, get a job and have a family - at the expense of playing sports, socializing and going to the bathroom myself?". Once I look at my scraggly and bleary-eyed face in the mirror at 3am I really do start to question my existence.

Comments: 1-24 of 24 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery