Jump to navigation
Advertisement

The Orange Box Reader Review

Reader Review by Inquisitor

17 November, 2007

After hurriedly typing out a brief overview of the orange box for the forums I was inspired to embark on a series of brief, time limited reviews.

Remember, I do these things so you don't have to, do not try this at home.

Having completed all 4 of the orange box's single player campaigns I thought I'd offer a brief summary of each.

Lets start with the original, and still best of the 'trilogy' shall we, half life 2.

When I first played this game back in 2004 I was blown away, jaw dropping visuals, believable characters, realistic and satisfying weapons and a breathtakingly authentic physics system.

The game still holds up today, the graphics have aged well but the cracks are beginning to show. It's the feeling of isolation that really steals the show in this game. Even the much maligned boat level creeps me out. Stopping at deserted outposts, the story of the place told not through cut scenes or dialogue but the environment. Magnificent.

On the downside there is some serious pacing issues throughout which become more noticable after repeat playthroughs. I was never a fan of the gravity gun either and stick to conventional weapons where ever possible. Unfortunately only a few of the conventional weapons are fun to use (ironically the shotgun and smg in this game are two of the most satisfying weapons I've ever witnessed in an fps).

Still just about worthy of a 10, even by todays standards.

I was hoping episode 1 would see a continuation of the second games strengths, unforgiveably it seemed to concentrate on everything that was wrong with it. The terrible citadel levels, boring, repetitive zombie battles and confined corridors.

The 3 hours or so it took me to finish it constituted the single worst fps experience I have had this year, a real dissapointment.

6/10

I was hoping Episode 2 could be the episode that would redeem valves policy of 'episodic' content. Luckily for me, and the thousands of half life fans it was an emphatic justification of that policy.

Even though the game starts of with a fairly enjoyable slog through the twisting burrows of an antlions nest I was ecstatic when I finally made it outside. The greater emphasis on wide, open spaces the developers had promised was evident.

Unfortunately, although she is a wonderful character the inclusion of Alyx as a partner throughout almost the entire epsiode robs it of that lonely feeling the second game had.

Vehicles made a welcome reappearance too. Though the controls are difficult to master, having a quicker means of transport than simply walking means the developers are given free reign to expand the environments.

Up until the last battle I couldn't stop smiling. Sadly the final encounter prooved to be one of the most frustrating experiences in the series so far, though the ending had me hungry for more.

9/10

Portal is a strange game. I'm not someone that enjoys the average puzzle game but was looking forward to this after all the hype. Surprised to say it almost lived up to what I'd heard.

I say almost, there were a few occasions when I died through what I felt was no fault of my own and due to it using the source engine the jumping puzzles weren't always easy to judge.

I've got no qualms saying this is the best puzzle game I've ever played though, not least because of it's incredibly well told story. A satisfying, compelling tale and one that resolves the plot whilst still leaving the gate open for a sequal. Oh, and not only will you be humming the theme song for weeks after you'll have to bury your head in the sand if you don't want to keep on hearing the genius 'memes' from the game on 'teh intawebs'.

9/10

Advertisement

Are you excited about The Orange Box on Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-4 of 4 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
ZuluHero
19/11/07 @ 14:07
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
*possible spoilers ahead so bewarned*


Only 6/10 for episode 1? I think that you are being needlessly harsh. Didn't you enjoy the some of the more unique stimulation, storytelling and character interaction that only the presence of Alyx could provide? The bond of that grew between you as you faced all the odds to escape the citadel after HL2? If they didn't set this up in EP1 then how could they provide some of the more emotional and game driving experinces in EP2? I find this especially odd given that you gave ep2 9/10 :S

While I agree that the first 'chapter' of HL2:EP1 marred it somewhat - as did the way the ending of HL2 was suddenly explained away at the start of EP1, but i don't think it pushed to the realms of a 6/10 game even if you hated it.

Still, other than that its a fair-ish review if a little brief for each breakdown of each game IMO, but who am i to say really? I'm not going to write a reveiw after all, but then again you did this so i didn't have to ;)

EDIT - out of interest, what time-limit did you impose on yourself when writing this reveiw?
Edited 1 times, most recently on 19/11/07 @ 14:08
Inquisitor [mod]
19/11/07 @ 16:44
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This review wasn't specifically time limited as I wrote it for the forums, but I'd be surprised if it was over 10 - 15 minutes.

It's quite a challenge to think of things to say about every game in this collection in that time, I can tell you, that's why the review is rather brief. I'm not a professional reviewer either, I don't want people to have to read me waffle for 2 pages when a simple summary should do.

As for episode 1, yes, the way Alyx developed as a character was brilliant, but I do want a bit of fun in there aswell. The only reason it got a 6 pretty much was thanks to Alyx. I just find fighting the zombies incredibly boring, and at times frustrating.
Aaarrrgh
25/11/07 @ 12:37
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nikanoru
26/11/07 @ 11:05
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sadly the final encounter prooved to be one of the most frustrating experiences in the series so far


Really? To me it was one of the very best battle sequences I've played in any traditional FPS, ever. Carrying a bomb with the car, racing back to a supply point after using it, running over the Hunters... it was very hectic, very exciting, difficult yet always feeling in control, just awesome. I died... once, I think. Might have been twice.

Comments: 1-4 of 4 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery