Shadow Hearts: From The New World Review

Brave New Weird.

Version tested: PlayStation 2

Here's the deal. There's this guy - fairly normal chap, goes by the name of Johnny Garland, deeply androgynous in that way which Japanese designers seem to think is hot (as distinct from merely confusing). He's on an adventure of some description; the adventure doesn't matter right now. What does matter is the people he's with.

His sidekick, the female lead of this piece, is a Native American who keeps transforming into powerful native spirits - but she's the least of his worries. The motley band he has assembled also includes Frank, an American ninja who speaks in an appalling mock-Japanese accent and studied in a dojo in the Amazon. There's a chap called Natan who specialises in the long-lost art of "gun-fu", a combination of firearms and chop socky which we suspect has been long lost for a good reason.

Then there's Hilda, a schizophrenic vampire and insatiable gourmand whose personality and combat abilities shift radically according to how many calories she has consumed that day. And then there's Mao, a lazy talking cat who turns out to be Frank's sensei - and has a hand (a paw?) in movie production, not to mention some involvement with the mob...

If any of that made you even remotely think about cracking a grin, then you should probably play Shadow Hearts: From The New World. We think you'll like it.

Hamming up the Depression

'Shadow Hearts: From The New World' Screenshot 1

The judgement ring is back - and so, apparently, are clothes from the eighties. In the 1920s. We don't really get it.

We should also add that if you enjoyed the last entry in the series, Shadow Hearts: Covenant, then there's no question but that you'll like From The New World. Developers XSEED have, at the heart of it, managed to capture most of the things that were really, really good about the last Shadow Hearts outing - from the utterly oddball sense of humour to the unique ability progression system, which focuses on quests and sub-games to unlock abilities, rather than on simple levelling up.

The storyline, unsurprisingly, is every bit as peculiar as previous games in the series have managed. The aforementioned fresh-faced young Johnny is running a detective agency in New York in the 1920s, but a seemingly normal case suddenly puts him in contact with a shadowy netherworld when the man he's following is murdered by a demon right in front of his astonished, androgynous face. From there on, the plot rapidly gathers pace - and the menagerie of characters swells - to encompass everything from the utterly familiar (young orphaned Johnny has a Dark And Mysterious Past to uncover - well, blow me down!) to the completely bloody weird. Like, say, staging a rescue operation to get Al Capone out of Alcatraz. No, really.

The plot hums along at a fair old pace, and as ever, Shadow Hearts provides plenty of distractions to stop you getting bored. There are a solid ten hours of side-quests in the game, alongside about thirty hours of main storyline - with the various quests rewarding your characters with new abilities or powerups which make them well worth exploring.

However, we have to confess that it took a lot longer to warm to Johnny and his crowd - and, indeed, to the American Depression setting through which they move - than it did to fall head over heels for Yuri, Karin and the rest of the band in Shadow Hearts Covenant. In some ways, that might just be that we had previously followed Yuri through the original Shadow Hearts - but by and large, it just feels like Covenant was able to balance its humour with its drama a bit better. The cast of From A New World are so busy trying to be Kerrrraazy!!! that that their dramatic or emotive moments feel a little bit lost; and much as we appreciate the humour, there's nothing here with quite the depth of Yuri's personal quest in Covenant.

Lord of the Ring

'Shadow Hearts: From The New World' Screenshot 2

Here's your lovely assistant. Helpfully, the game gets her to take her clothes off repeatedly in cut-scenes, which is a thoughtful touch.

The combat system in the game once again focuses on the chief innovation of the series, the Judgement Ring. If you have encountered a Shadow Hearts game before, then you'll know exactly how this works; for the uninitiated, it's a ring which appears whenever you fire off an attack in combat (or do anything else that requires an element of chance or skill to be taken into account), with a hand sweeping rapidly around the face. Your job is to hit a button when the hand is in specific highlighted segments of the ring. Missing entirely means that your attack (or other task) fails, while with some attacks it's possible to change the power by hitting the ring in certain places, or to pile on extra blows by hitting multiple segments.

It's a system which is very simple, but works surprisingly well. It gives a solid sense of involvement and interaction in the battle system, and it's rarely too difficult even for those of you who play RPGs largely because your reaction times aren't up to faster games. You know who you are. If all else fails, one of the game's side attractions is a ghost outside Johnny's apartment who is looking for specific items, and will reward you with power-ups which increase the size of the hit segments on your rings, or otherwise decrease the difficulty level.

While each character has their own relatively unique fighting system, as a result of the various abilities they sport, the game does also boast a number of innovations which touch on the battle system as a whole. Chief among these is the "stock" gauge, which effectively allows both players and monsters to store up power as they take or deliver damage. A full stock gauge can be used to unleash multiple-hit attacks, or multi-character combos - with the downside being that monsters, especially bosses, can also be incredibly dangerous with a full stock gauge, so you'll need to be sure to use attacks that decrease their stock to avoid a party wipe-out.

Magic abilities, meanwhile, now come from items called "stellars", which you will pick up as you progress through the game. To use them, they have to be affixed to special grids, which basically mimic the constellations - so, for example, you might have a constellation like Cancer with stellars carrying different magics attached to all of the star positions, thus defining a character's magical abilities. Adding a layer of complexity is the ability to upgrade the magic "nodes" on those grids, which allows you to affix more powerful stellars or enhance the existing ones.

'Shadow Hearts: From The New World' Screenshot 3

And here's a helpful shot of New York, just in case you were thinking that the 'New World' was Mars or Jupiter or Belgium or something.

By and large, the battle system remains just as strong and compelling as it was in Covenant - which is just as well, really, because you'll be seeing a lot of it. The encounter rate in From The New World is very high in some places, which can feel somewhat frustrating - but at least the battle system is pretty consistently entertaining, and the load delays are extremely short.

New World Order

The Shadow Hearts series, originally a gothic departure from the normal trappings of the RPG genre, has settled into a well-defined niche of its own; aside from the judgement ring, it's the weird, eclectic cast of characters which really make this game, just as they were such an important part of Covenant. It's certainly not all things to all men, and many people will find the light hearted, camp approach to storytelling to be a real turn-off - but for fans of Covenant, this is a second serving of broadly the same thing. Given how enjoyable the last game was, that's a pretty high recommendation.

However, like many second servings, we can't help but feel that this has gone a little bit cold since we last enjoyed it. A newcomer to the series would be strongly advised to play Covenant in preference to this game; From The New World, although it delivers some innovation in its combat, is definitely a weaker game in story and characterisation terms. It's not exactly a harsh criticism - but it's not exactly the gushing commendation we give to our friends regarding Covenant, either. It would be unfair to call this game a stumble for the series; but equally, we find ourselves secretly hoping that XSEED can pick things up a bit for their next outing.

7 / 10

Read the Eurogamer.net scoring policy

Comments (20) Latest comment 5 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • Meho #1 5 years ago

    No comments??? Then this is my first 'first', I guess... Wonder why no one seems to be interested, though, SH games for me are underappreciated gems of JRPG genre. They feature engaging stories, likeable characters, good humour, great set design, excellent combat system and, perhaps, the most refreshing thing of all, they are not set in traditional (J)RPG worlds. I have pretty high hopes for this one.
  • macksed #2 5 years ago

  • Dizzy #3 5 years ago

    >No comments???

    OK... what about MEH?
  • mkreku #4 5 years ago

    I've only played one Shadow Hearts, but that game started off in some village where I met a demon in a church after only a few minutes. That was ok. Then it went downhill as I entered a forest (that's what THEY called it) that consisted of weird linear tunnels with a chest at the end of each branch. Not exactly an explorer's dream.
  • HiddenAway #5 5 years ago

    Wasn't hoping for much but that judgement ring sounds just like the roulette wheel from Unlimited Saga which I loathed (as much as the board game style :p).

    What were the graphics like in Covenant?
  • Aretak #6 5 years ago

    This comments thread is lacking its RDA of Blerk.
  • Schiraman #7 5 years ago

    Shadow Hearts was an ace RPG, I'll happily agree that it was an under appreciated gem. The same does not apply to Covenant however, which had a good battle system and great characters but was crippled by a truly awful plot. If the story for From the New World is actually worse I see little hope for the game.
  • dolphan #8 5 years ago

    I'm about half way through the first one, though I haven't played it in a good while thanks to university/ff12/my wii, but I will go back, it was excellent. I also have Covenant sitting in a cupboard waiting for its chance. May pick this up eventually.
  • dudefella #9 5 years ago

    Man screw you all. Covenant is one of the most enjoyable JRPGs I've ever played. Favorite until FFXII came around. I will buy this.
  • oneshotgame #10 5 years ago

    if we assume:

    1) the story and the battle ring is the meat of the SH series

    2) FTNW does not offer the mature storyline, the creepy "horror" and the unique combination of seriousness and ridiculousness (as it focuses on ridiculous) that other episodes did.

    then we deduce:

    3) FTNW is storywise not a good SH game at all.

    even if you take koudelka into account. it may share some things - as the weird cast (only seen in covenant), the battle system (what is a characteristic but not the only definiens - as showed 1) - and the alternate history. but it lacks other things that made SH so unique.

    so, 4) how can anybody recommend THIS to the TRUE fans of the series?

    i won't buy this. i really really loved part 1 and 2. i really cared for yuri's quest and i enjoyed the kinda fresh battle system. but the - even compared to covenant - weirder cast and the shallow story make me safe money.

    am i wrong?
  • blindlemonjefferson #11 5 years ago

    This sounds like the birthday present I was looking for for my little brother.


    Also, I often have conversations with people that go like:
    Ugly Boy: 'I thought you were a girl'
    Me: 'No'
    Ugly Boy: /punches

    But I think I have had just as many that go like:
    Beautiful Girl: 'I thought you were a girl'
    Me: 'No'
    Beautiful Girl: 'OMG, fit'
    /gives number
    /pulls
    /takes home
    /takes off clothes

    So, what I mean to say is that it's not just Jap developers who think it is hot.
    /defensive
  • DarkChronicle #12 5 years ago

    I absolutely loved the first 2 games in the series, so this was an easy purchase for me back when it was released in the US.

    However I have never managed to persuade myself to go back and finish it, as IMO it is nowhere near as good as the first 2 games in the series. The characters are still great and all have their little quirks, and the battle system is as strong as it always was, but it is let down by a really poor storyline that failed to keep my attention. It's a shame really, as it did initially show some promise.

    I'm waiting for the inevitable next gen sequel(fingers crossed)
  • VMerken #13 5 years ago

    I've followed this team since Koudelka on the PS1. Disgusted by the battle sequences there, I passed SH1, but then got a recommendation to get SH2 by a friend who is pretty much home in RPG-world. I'm glad I followed his advice - SH2 was a great experience (hmm, I suddenly have the urge to stare into nothingness and say "Yeahhh...' in a zombie-like manner for a while). After reading this review, a automatic purchase of SH3 has transformed into awaiting further judgment from said friend.

    By the way, Belgium is the new world - didn't you know? :)
  • Dizzy #14 5 years ago

    "But I think I have had just as many that go like:
    Fat otaku Girl: 'I thought you were a girl'
    Me: 'No' "

    Fixed.
  • Blerk #15 5 years ago

    Y'know, I could've sworn you'd reviewed this already. :-)
  • Blerk #16 5 years ago

    XSEED aren't the developers, btw. They're the US publishers.
  • blindlemonjefferson #17 5 years ago

    @ Dizzy: 'Fat otaku Girl: 'I thought you were a girl' '
    lol @ fat. You'd be closer with anorexic.

    I don't know what otaku means. But what I'm talking about is like aged 21 Bowie/TRex/New Wave fangirls, artschool-bleachblonde-furcoat-highheels-leopardprint-pointy hips-bigeyed-mannequin girls.

    /lives in Brighton
    /still defensive


    It's so much fun having a pointless intrenet argument :(
  • otto #18 5 years ago

    "Here's your lovely assistant. Helpfully, the game gets her to take her clothes off repeatedly in cut-scenes, which is a thoughtful touch."

    Thread, useless, etc
    Edited by 1 at 08/05/07 @ 20:44
  • hybridial #19 5 years ago

    Okay, I bought this game on import, and to give you context...

    I think SHadow Hearts was a great RPG, I thought Covenant was the best goddamn RPG I've ever played and strongly, strongly, disagree with whoever said the story was awful.

    Taking that into account... From the New World is not as good. It is good, I find if anything to be the enemy AI as the game's weakest point because it's quite cheap in using the combo system. The game is funny, but it does suck that it sacrifices almost all the gothic trappings for that. On the whole, I'd call it a decent entry in a series who's finest hours are hopefully still ahead of it. Hell, FF made it to XII on deeply inferior games >_>
    Edited by 1 at 09/05/07 @ 12:29
  • kissthestick #20 5 years ago

    only 17.99 on play.com think i'll pick this up, sounds like a zany fun game:)