Jump to navigation
Advertisement

World Rally Championship 4 Review

PlayStation 2 Review by Kristan Reed

20 October, 2004

We wish they wouldn't do it, but do it they must. This annual ritual of churning out sporting sequels, we feel, utterly diminishes any sense of excitement to the point that trying to glean any sense of novelty from the game is rendered null and void. It wouldn't be a big issue were it not for the fact that everyone else has steadfastly adopted the same tactic so we're left trying to play spot the difference between four or more different Rally brands on an annual basis. Pardon us if we're starting the review off on a negative note, but it's a disclaimer worth mentioning from the off.

What's worse for these evidently hard working teams is that the punters out there have become less and less interested, despite the gradual improvement in quality. So, it's hardly surprising to see the law of diminishing returns kick in and watch as the sales of these niche titles drops year on year despite the ever rising installed base. If the excitement's not there for guys like us playing them year after year, the chances are all but the hardcore stalwarts will be clamouring for yet another rally title, not matter how good it is.

Don't let them go soggy

'World Rally Championship 4' Screenshot 1

And you know what sucks even more? Despite the frustration of watching publishers shoot themselves in the foot by sticking to this dogged policy of development-by-numbers, the results, taken in isolation are often very respectable indeed. All we need now is that X factor. A sense of anticipation. That excitement of getting something new, something you've really had to look forward to. Gaming should never be something you merely take for granted, like the morning bowl of cereal. It may well be the greatest bowl of cereal you've had in your life, but you'd hardly be singing about it in the shower after. "Oh my my. These Kellog's Crunchy Nut Cornflakes. They are so yummy". Actually that's quite catchy. I'll have another bowl just to make sure...

Before this article descends into utter madness, let's address the task at hand. WRC 4. A Rally game so crammed full of features it's like the development team at Evolution has been determined to make sure no-one wants another Rally game as long as they live. But that wouldn't work would it? Who would buy next year's? The last thing we want to do, either, is turn the review into some kind of cheap fact sheet to pad out the word count, but even if you're vaguely into Rally games, this lot should at least pique your interest a little: online play for up to 16 players, 16 WRC locations across five continents, 100 stages with 'photo realistic' textures, all the cars and all the drivers of the 2004 season (something no other Rally game can offer), as well as the usual Point to Point, Super Special, Shakedown and Sprint stages to endure. And it is endurance, of the most brutal kind, but more of that later.

As a package it's almost too overwhelming to come to terms with. Where to even start? Of course, the usual Quick Race and Time Trial offer a hint of what's to come, but it's a mere sniff compared to some of the other modes on offer. The real meat comes from the Championship and Events modes, which will test the mettle of any remotely serious simulation driver. Playable for one to four players and via four different classes, you get to take on either the Super 1600 (a cut down entry level mode with Super 1600 cars), WRC Professional (the full championship with WRC cars), then the daunting WRC Expert (same again, but even harder), then the mighty Extreme mode which, as the name suggests, provides the chance to take on a cut down championship but with the Extreme series of cars. We're shaking our head just typing the words.

Months of struggle ahead

'World Rally Championship 4' Screenshot 2

And as if that alone wasn't enough to keep you going, then there's always the Events mode to fall back on, featuring another four individually involving and taxing modes to plough through, making this another long-lasting Rally epic. Essentially breaking down the Championship into their constituent parts and throwing in more besides, Single Rally does exactly what you'd expect, allowing you to choose a specific set of races under the same four skill levels of the full Championship, Super Special lets you play the various enjoyable one on one races, Test Track lets you race on a variety of surfaces as well as general control exercises, while the superbly constructed Pro Driver Challenge acts as a kind of arcade mode, giving the player 11 distinct challenges, from Newbie, right through the ranks of becoming a pro, up to the Future of Rallying, which gives you the chance to try out super-charged Extreme cars - which in the past would've made an entire game on its own.

So, having dispensed all that information, and filled ourselves with so much expectation, how isn't this the essential rally package? Well, in truth, it's simply going to be out of reach for most gamers unless they're prepared to invest a serious amount of time into it. Last year's version we found similar issues, although at least the entry level was distinctly accommodating. This time around, it seems as if the game is expecting you to be exceptionally proficient from the word go, which to us is a dangerous tactic commercially. Sure, the hardcore racers will lap it up and no doubt get a huge amount out of the game, but for those used to the kind of challenges presented in Colin McRae, Rallisport Challenge, or even TOCA Race Driver 2, it's way off the scale in terms of difficulty. The Burnout and Need For Speed crowd won't know what's hit them.

What's odd, is that if you didn't know better, you'd assume you were doing well. A full race taking a good racing line, with maybe the odd slip up here and there, can put you so far down the pecking order it's tough to imagine what kind of superhuman racing droids Evolution employed to do the pre-release testing. Evidently, if you're a mere mortal, you need not apply here unless you particularly enjoy learning every course inside out before you can even compete. Surely the idea of differing skill levels is to deliver the kind of challenge required? Beating the gamer around the head the second they saddle up is just dispiriting, no matter how many features the game provides. Tragically, from our experience, making games too daunting is the quickest way to move players onto something else. Of course, if you're a very experienced driver, you can discount all of these observations because you're going to have a ball; in every other aspect the game hits the spot bang on.

Too hot to handle?

'World Rally Championship 4' Screenshot 3

In terms of the handling, it's a very different system to the McRaes and the RSCs of the world and might take a bit of getting used to. If anything it's the toughest of the bunch, often feeling deceptively assured, and yet it can also feel like even the slightest miscalculation on your part will have you careering off the track. There still remain the old complaints that it feels like the whole car is being steered on central pivot, and that getting away from a standing start takes too long. Still, many fans of WRC are exceptionally vocal on the merits of this handling model. It's not our preferred system, but some of you still insist it's the best. We'll agree to disagree. Still, we have to express how absolutely spot on the force feedback feels, and really delivers one of the most perfect sensations of rattling over cattle grids ever! Kudos, also, goes to Evolution for pinching Codies' excellent between-race repairs idea, with time allocated to each bit of the car you've trashed. If it's a good idea, you may as well pinch it.

Visually it's hard to find too many faults, and although it's slightly ambitious marketing fluff to describe the tracks as having "photo realistic textures" (maybe on a 14" Aiwa portable blurro-vision TV through squinting eyes), it's still a huge advancement on any other Rally game on the PS2. The tracks really are wonderfully constructed achievements (cardboard cut out trees aside), and deliver a palpable sense of being in the middle of bloody nowhere in inclement conditions on the side of a mountain and seconds away from certain death. Gone are the draw distance issues of old, and the whole spectacle is often breathtaking with stunning vistas viewable from various camera angles, including surely the best in-car view ever, that on certain tracks seems to make it easier, as opposed to the disorientating mess of other games.

In fact, on a presentation level in general, Evolution gets top marks, with brilliant replays (which we'd really rather you could just click X to exit from, please guys) and some excellent musical accompaniments to spice things up. In terms of the engine audio, though, we're still convinced a swarm of bees were descending on us during some races. If that's what these cars really sound like, then fair enough, but just be prepared to endure the bewildered giggles of anyone within earshot wondering why you're engaged in a Hive flying simulator.

Until we get a retail copy that allows us to go online with the general public, we're not really in a position to accurate assess the relative merits of this mode, but once Sony gives us the nod we'll be keen to update this review with some of our musings on this most anticipated of modes. For the record, expect 16 player support and an online time trial mode that lets players race any stage at any time either just against the clock or against other racers. If you make the Top 100 you can also upload the times, which, while welcome seems an alarmingly small leaderboard.

You know the score

Having overcome our initial reservations about wading knee deep in Rally mud yet again, it's evidently a top-notch package for those with the necessary skills to really make the most of it, and a pleasing improvement over the last version. If you don't consider yourself a very skilled racing gamer, then be aware of the pitfalls ahead. This is not for the faint-hearted, and although it leads the field in arguably every area in terms of PS2 Rally games, there are minimum entry requirements that even regular gamers will have issues coming to terms with. Danger! Hardcore racing ahead...

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about World Rally Championship 4 on PlayStation 2?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-40 of 40 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
ssuellid
20/10/04 @ 15:24
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I like the 'you know the score' bit. Made me grin.

Thats 2 games reviewed today that I will be buying. Don't think thats ever happened before.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 20/10/04 @ 16:27
lost_soul
20/10/04 @ 15:34
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Think I'll pick up a cheap copy of the previous version when I get my PS2.
Stevas mkII
20/10/04 @ 15:41
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So no raped wookies this time, huh?

As someone who pretty much sailed through the last game on every difficulty level, would you say I'd still struggle with this? Is it that much of a quantum leap in 'hard'?
krudster [mod]
20/10/04 @ 15:45
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Well, probably not for you, mr uber racer. You'll be back on the comment thread later dissing my racing skills!
Stevas mkII
20/10/04 @ 15:48
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
And don't you forget it.
Grrr.
Freylis
20/10/04 @ 15:53
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nice review Kristan, all is forgiven... :)

By the way, the online mode really is something special. No doubt some of the team will be popping on and off to see what the world has to offer.
krudster [mod]
20/10/04 @ 16:04
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Truth is no one even told us there was online reviewing sessions.
IronGiant
20/10/04 @ 16:13
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Freylis, will people have good things to say about Sony's online service after playing this? So far it ain't a patch on LIVE.
Freylis
20/10/04 @ 16:15
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
IronGiant: Read some of the quotes I posted on our website from the Beta testers. It's a shame we couldn't make the entire forum public, there was some great stuff on there.
rocketScience
20/10/04 @ 16:35
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"feels like the whole car is being steered on central pivot"

Well it isn't. Sorry it was too tough for the reviewer, perhaps he should stick with it some more.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 20/10/04 @ 17:37
krudster [mod]
20/10/04 @ 16:36
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ooh, touched a nerve?
krudster [mod]
20/10/04 @ 16:41
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I didn't say it *was* on a central pivot, it just feels like it is. That's not a bad thing, it's just more evident in this game than other games that get acccused of the same thing (but don't feel like that at all).
Corben Dallas
20/10/04 @ 17:11
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
OOHHhhhh handbags handbags rocketscience dont have a hissy fit now :p

Goin to give this a blast, (always get Colin and this) the WRC games have got steadily better, where colin has always had the edge in handling last years wasnt too bad.

Got CMR2005 PS2 and found it majorily dumbed down (too easy) so i this is tougher then good! THink codies tried to simplfy everything on CMr2005 this year and this is not a good direction to take the series.

CMR05 online isnt bad at all running real quick against 8 others. Want to see how WRC4 runs online. ?:|
William
20/10/04 @ 17:39
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Rhythm: "The superwide tracks always put me off of the WRC games."

You must be confusing CMR and WRC. IMO, CMR always provides super wide tracks (apparently so you can drift), whereas WRC features more realistic and narrow tracks and junctions.
Tippytappy
20/10/04 @ 18:55
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Getting this on friday :D some of the devs post on the www.wrc.com forums, and the online mode is fantastic according to the beta testers.

Who else is going online with it?
bluebird
20/10/04 @ 19:56
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I hated the strange steering that seemed to make your car pivot around a central point in the first WRC on the PS2, it just felt all wrong. And from this review it sounds it STILL hasn't changed! Isn't a decent, 4 wheel independant racing model the basis for a rally game? Very disappointing.
tiddles
20/10/04 @ 20:49
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Where's Peej when you need him, eh? (Don't answer that.)

You need to distinguish between the four wheels being independent (ie. if a single wheel strays onto a different surface, you'll see the car react accordingly), and the way the camera lag in chase mode works. I'm no camera expert, but as I understand it, depending on where the developers lock the camera pivot on the car, you'll get different effects (it was fully explained by somebody on a thread round here recently). If it's in the middle of the car, you'll see the effect of the car pivoting around a central point, even though the physics are all being calculated properly. Or something like that :)
tiddles
20/10/04 @ 21:26
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's amazing how much the way the camera is set up affects our view of a game's driving experience... Outrun 2, for example, largely feels so weird and old-school to play because they've locked the camera down very tightly - there's very little lag when turning, which mimics the way the original game only had a limited number of sprites for the car's movement (ie. turning slightly left/turning slightly right/going straight). But to us, it seems very stiff and (initially) unsubtle, because we're used to having more "give" in the camera as the car turns.
skalmanxl
21/10/04 @ 07:41
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Think I'll pick up a cheap copy of the previous version when I get my PS2.

Make sure to get WRC 2 then, as it's far better then WRC 3.
krudster [mod]
21/10/04 @ 07:59
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So....judging by some of the comments here, if the press materials state that it has a four point steering model, I'm supposed to just take that as gospel? If it still feels like you're steering on a single pivot, then I've got every right to say that, end of chat.
Grom
21/10/04 @ 09:12
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
hehe it's like 'spot the dev team' in these comments!
Virvel
21/10/04 @ 09:17
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Lets hope WRC4 runs at a full frame-rate when playing online. I recently picked up Toca2 for PS2, and it has no slowdowns when playing online. Full 60FPS all the time. Nice. If WRC4 has this, it is a must-buy for me.
sam_spade
21/10/04 @ 09:20
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
They are the ones dressed in black. Oh and Freylis
Freylis
21/10/04 @ 09:57
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hi.
infoxicated
21/10/04 @ 10:17
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Make sure to get WRC 2 then, as it's far better then WRC 3.

Weird... other than the juddery replay camera, I thought WRC3 was head and shoulders above WRC2.
nasanu
21/10/04 @ 11:17
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Q: Does WRC4 use a single pivot point, or is it true four point physics?

A: WRC4 uses true four-point physics. "

You know Codemasters claim the same thing (I will never buy another codies racer :( ), but their model is quite clearly center pivot. You have have a 4 point model, but if you are basically saying rear wheels turn -1, front turn +1 then 4 point really is just center pivot...

The above does not in any way relate to WRC4 though, I am yet to play it. Just saying that developers will tell you anything if they think you will believe it.
krudster [mod]
21/10/04 @ 11:23
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I must admit, the whole pivot argument does entirely depend on which camera view you use, and yes, in chase cam it does look and feel like it's on a pivot. Not so in the excellent dash view, which I mentioned.
infoxicated
21/10/04 @ 11:59
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
You know how last year, when you gave the game a 6/10 because it was too difficult.

Well... why is it an 8/10 this year, despite being too difficult again, in your opinion?

Is Eurogamer helping with the online set-up this time around?
krudster [mod]
21/10/04 @ 12:15
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think technically it's a lot stronger, it's got online, the repairs feature is a decent inclusion, there are many more modes than before, it reeks of quality. But it's as hard as hell, but evidently some people think that's a strong point. I could've marked it down for that. I probably was too harsh on last year's, a 7 would probably be fairer with hindsight.
infoxicated
21/10/04 @ 13:12
#30
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wow... that's big of you to say that Kristian.

Best. Reviewer. Ever.

;o)
Feanor
21/10/04 @ 13:27
#31
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's funny, just yesterday I was reading Eurogamer's controversial review of WRC 3 after finding it thru gamerankings. I'm sure the comments thread will be less a touch less fiery this time.

Anyone heard if this game might be coming to the U.S.?
Feanor
21/10/04 @ 13:32
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Of course, if you right a review based entirely on playing in chase-cam then the review is flawed to some extent."

Umm, right. :)
David W
21/10/04 @ 21:12
#33
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Think I'll pick up a cheap copy of the previous version when I get my PS2.

Make sure to get WRC 2 then, as it's far better then WRC 3. "

Whoa, stay well clear of wrc2! It's sticky barriers WILL drive you crazy.
Corben Dallas
22/10/04 @ 11:09
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
So ref the repair deal do they actually have 'Real' damage in it? Ie when you clatter the car into a wall it dents teh preformance as well as the bodypanels?

In WRC3 unless u where a total spanner (constantly whackin the walls/barriers) it had no real/ effect payback it looked as if u were really hurting the car but often it had no effect on performance and was purely cosmtic (Like PRG2's damage)

CMR2003/04 had the best damage system ever, u could even loose yur wheels if u drove like a looney. In CMR05 they have toned this down as well (part of the whole dumbing down of the series IMO) which caters for the whining skilless wonders ie> "Crap I hit a metal signpost at 110mph and it teh game totally destoryed my car , no fair"
No shit sherlock, this shows the game is REALISTIC :(
Edited 1 times, most recently on 22/10/04 @ 12:13
greatest_fish30
25/10/04 @ 07:17
#35
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
u must have sore hands from typing so much
greatest_fish30
25/10/04 @ 07:37
#36
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Is this so. Well then what do you prefer penguins cats or dogs
Kengro
25/10/04 @ 14:03
#37
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wrc has gotten better, but still not good. I'll stay with richard burns rally. Colin was not so good this year, but it will come back. Codemasters will not give up
tiddles
28/10/04 @ 21:57
#38
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Question - when you buy an Evolution upgrade, and you are part-way through a Championship, does the upgrade get applied to your car? Is there any way to do this?

Fantastic looking game, but very exacting... don't know if I'm enjoying it quite as much as its more forgiving predecessor (at least, it was on the default difficulty level). Getting stuck in the scenery can often be very frustrating - shades of WRCII with "sticky trees", and for some reason, Cyprus appears to have some super deadly barriers - a light brush with one particular crash barrier left me with practically everything damaged and a burst rear tyre!
Homer Simpson
20/11/04 @ 23:56
#39
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
If the first three are out there then I don't see why the fourth one shouldn't be.
UncleLou
24/03/05 @ 09:42
#40
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hehe, why do I have the feeling you just got 11?

Comments: 1-40 of 40 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery