Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War Review
Considerable improvements over last year's Warhammer 39,999.
Version tested: PC

Both for newcomers and the initiated, I think it's worth taking a few moments to reiterate what the Warhammer 40,000 universe is all about. Bear with me. If we're exceedingly lucky, we'll chance upon a point.
It's the 40th millennia. This Dark Age, after the fall of Man. Humanity's domain is a million worlds, governed by a fascistic theocracy with a God-Emperor worshipped as a bona-fide deity. This man would be dead - in fact, it's entirely possible that he is dead - were not for the fact that an enormous baroque machine siphons the souls of thousands of psychics every day. A vast Inquisition gathers these frightening minds, between performing purges across human space, persecuting and executing untold billions, with rebel planets following rival creeds regularly suffering sterilisation bombardments from space. There is no hope, no truth, no peace, no love: only War.
And these are the good guys.
The 40K universe was invented in the eighties as Games Workshop took their pre-existing fantasy - also determinedly grim - franchise into a far gothic future. The reason why the Imperium, as man's domain is known, are the good guys is the alternatives are even worse (i.e. even more apocalyptic). A jackboot stomping on a human face forever is preferable to being rendered immortal by one of the Chaos powers then having your organs re-arranged as a fashionable hat. In short, 40K has everything required to power a brilliant videogame.
And it really does have everything - it's very much a maximalist creation, baroquely taking from every science-fiction convention and forming it into a glistening fleshy sticky whole. Brilliant character design - in fact, so brilliant that their influence is seen in more than half the science-fiction videogames in existence. A scenario where improbably violent conflict naturally emerges from its licence rather than feeling crammed in. And ludicrously sized guns.

Dawn of War just nails it.
Now, 40K hasn't been as badly treated in games as legend would have it - the pair of EA Space Hulk games can justify the lineage by themselves - but nothing has been even a fraction as successful as exploiting the possibilities of the licence as this has. It's a perfect gaming world, being exploited perfectly, for the first time. That alone deserves some kind of applause, and that alone is going to gather some serious sales for Games Workshop's army of fans - and those who would be fans if they could spare the time and money to create a huge army. And, since the universe really is ideal fodder for a videogame, the point of this extended rambling intro, pretty much anyone else who likes their RTS to be lively and bloody too.
In terms of the pure RTS, it's the most attractive yet seen. It's all in the details and the illusion of life, and the animation. The characters bubble with personality and - in many cases - barely restrained violence. Seeing the Avatar of Khaine tear its way through a rank of hapless yelping-goblinoid Gretchin is a thrilling sight.
This season there are, essentially, three contenders for your strategy money. Kohan 2, Rome: Total War and this. Out of the three, it's Dawn of War which is closest to the entral mainstream - for that read "Whatever Blizzard are doing". Kohan 2 interests in how it elegantly and intelligently deviates from the formula. Total War, in the best tradition of British developers, doesn't give a damn what the colonials are up to, and carries on building its Roman Road to the future in a manner unlike anyone else. While there are moments Dawn of War does something unexpected, it's instantly familiar and recognisable to anyone who's dabbled in Starcraft. The population of Korea will feel very much at home.

But that undersells Dawn of War. Its animation, while glorious, isn't just for vicious kicks. For example, touches like a squad being sent flying by a grenade or lobbed over the horizon by a Dreadnought, the Marine's hulking mechanical walkers, create a direct impact in what weapons are used where, as well as looking spectacular.
Since so much is familiar, you may... well, think it a little shallow. While we'll only be able to tell for certain the truth of the matter a year of multi-playing down the line, there's actually considerable subtlety available to a player. Take, for example, the standard Space Marine (the Imperium's super-human armoured warriors) squad. Once created, you're given options of either keeping with the basic squad size, or pushing it up to a cap. Equally, as the research tree opens up, you get the option of paying for up to four heavy weapons (from four separate sorts) for the squad. Each of the four heavy weapons have their own uses and disadvantages, and there's even an argument not to take them, since you have to stay stationary for a period prior to firing. Expanding out to the entire army, there's certainly a lot to think about and options to process, and while its classical nature means it's going to descend into a giant scrum upon occasion, it's underestimating its potential to think that's all it is.
The multiplayer is very much the centre of the game. The eleven-mission campaign , while put together competently, will be marched through swiftly by vaguely competent players. In terms of narrative, it's tied together by a story which leans on the major themes of the 40K universe: corruption of the Imperium by Chaos. It aspires to competency and almost reaches the mark, mainly stumbling by failing to introduce the principle sides in any real way. If, for example, you don't know who the Eldar are or what they're doing on the planet, you'll be none the wiser for playing. And if you want to actually play the Eldar single-player... Well, it's off to the fairly standard skirmish mode for you. Only one campaign, with you stuck as the Marines, is available, which seems more than a little on the mean side.

Which is a backhanded compliment towards the quality of the four sides: due to the unique flavour, you do want to play them all. The Orks (Space Orks!) favour mobs - in fact, have their build options limited until they reach a certain critical mass of bodies. The Eldar (Space Elves!) are delicate and evasive, with each unit type having a clear role in which it excels. The Marines (Er... Space Marines?) are a resilient all-round army, which can be customised considerably on the fly. And the Chaos side mixes their elite Chaos Marines with cannon-fodder mobs and frankly terrifying summoned Daemons. And for a non-backhanded compliment to their quality, I honestly don't have a favourite. They all charm.
And it's charm which cements Dawn of War in the affections. In fact, it charms so casually that the contrary parts of the gaming world will just lazily dismiss it as a bimbo. It really isn't. Charm lures us in, but there's enough happening upstairs to keep it firmly in our affections.
Though whether "charm" really is the right word where by "charm" you mean "the visceral thrill when you see an Ork advance rent asunder by giant pincers" is a matter I leave to you.
You may also like...
-
Happy Action Theater Review
-
Motorola Xoom 2 Tablet Reviews
-
ModNation Racers: Road Trip Review
-
Sony confirms PS Vita 1st Party digital only game prices
-
Call of Duty: Black Ops has best game ending ever, says Guinness World Records
-
Sony explains PlayStation Vita game price strategy
-
Why Devs Owe You Nothing
-
Mass Effect 3 Demo: The First 20 Minutes
-
3DS Ambassador Super Mario Bros. game updated
-
Rockstar mulling LA Noire 2 development
-
DICE working on multiple Battlefield 3 fixes
-
Mojang: no plans for Minecraft on Vita
-
EGTV: Eurogamer playtests PlayStation Vita
-
The Witcher 2: Enhanced Edition Xbox 360 trailer
-
Halo 4 Master Chief action figure flaunts new suit design
-
Tim Schafer: publishers aren't evil
-
Apple begins Foxconn factories inspections
-
Face-Off: Final Fantasy 13-2
-
Digital Foundry: PS3 Skyrim Lag Fixed?
-
Who Killed Rare?
-
App of the Day: Monkey Bump
-
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning Review
-
Retrospective: Star Wars Episode I Racer
-
Fallout: New Vegas dev asks fans what game they would like it to Kickstart
-
UK Top 40: Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning beats Darkness 2









Comments (39) Latest comment 7 years ago
Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
...
Ah, it's KG, will I be seeing this in PC Gamer as well?
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
great game. single poor, multi great.
thou shalt kill
Comment below viewing threshold Show
?
Anyway, great review though! May get this.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Still it will be nice to see some more reviews from Mr Gillen. I've missed PCGamer since I had to stop buying, it became too much of a depressing read when I knew my PC couldn't play a single game reviewed. Half-life 2 previews still make me cry :'-(
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Unless it's me playing, in which case they usually are, in favour of some half cyborg american teen who has interfaced with his shortcuts...
Nice review!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Maybe there's potential for an expansion pack...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
That aside, this is a tasty review and makes me want to buy this game ASAP.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
WC3 is the only RTS I've ever really got into online and I wonder if this is as fun or as deep.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I hope this one's good fun, but I doubt that relic will support it with the endless patches that Blizzard seem to do for Warcraft 3. They are adding new heroes 2 years on which is fantastic!
Battles in Warhammer 40k's demo are very good, and surprisingly violent too.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Haven't played for about a year in all honesty, but will deffo be giving it a go now
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Excellent.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
So if I want to play Eldar I can only play online or vs AI? Why? Why? Why? I love single player RTS games! Online there usually is way to much cheating in these kind of games.
/removes W40K from wish list
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
You couldn't be MORE wrong on all accounts.
a) There is NO 'tank rushing'. Naturally, there is an element of rushing, a quickly produced squad of seer council WILL wreck havoc. But, that's it. A tank-tech-rush is simply impossible, because it implies that you get at least 50% of the tactical points on the map. Problem is, unless the opponent isn't interesting in taking yours (which he will be), the majority of the early- and midgame money will be spent on reinforcing your squads with new men and weaponry. However, if he doesn't, you should be able to have ONE (yes, one) dreadnought after six minutes (this is based directly off the beta, where such tests were conducted). alternatively, your opponent will probably have 2 squads, a force commander, several scout squads. In short, you'll be a goner.
b) massive lack of innovation? Tactical points? Morale (which is far from a gimmick. Any experienced player will tell you this)? the fact that both closecombat and ranged combat plays a role, not seen in any other game before? Sorry, but I completely disagree with this.
c) same structure as starcraft? What, because it's based around getting ressources? Or because it's a fast RTS? Or that you build buildings? Sure, there are similarities, but this is more a troll than anything else.
As for your final R:TW comnent. Well, QUAKE II IS THE BESTEST GAME EVER SINCE NFS:UNDERGROUND. Apples and oranges doesn't compare well.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I didn't shed a tear though.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
They used to do some pretty funky live-action WH40k short films at the annual convention thingy in Birmingham when I were a lad, very nice props and that, seemed quite professional.
Played the demo, not sure if it's for me, don't think the game would fit my style of play.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
It's a nice review but doesn't go into enough technical depth about the game and it's pro's and con's of gameplay.
I've learnt more about whether i'd like the game from the comments section tbh.
Like someone else said its more of a preview type sum-up of the game than an indepth review. Please don't skip on the gameplay details ie: holding points, upgrade paths, computer ai etc...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Played game for a couple of days now. It's ok, but I think it stops short of being brilliant.
Also it can still get occasionally choppy on my 3.6gz, 1gb ram, P4 with a Radeon 9800 ( Reading the dawn of war forums leads me to believe theres an issue with the AI, as it's not choppy without computer opponents ).
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Try the reader reviews on Amazon then, they may be more suitable for one of your reading age.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Discovering the fully 3D camera option helped.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I played the demo to death, played a friend's copy after that then went and bought my own.
Too bad the online game is being swamped by those who believe to be 'leet'.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I left it on the shelf for a few months, picked it up again now, and I can hardly stop playing it.