Jump to navigation
Advertisement

Star Wars Galaxies: Trials of Obi-Wan Review

PC MMO Review by George Kotsiofides

1 November, 2005

Like many of you we've been waiting to see the molten planet that would explain Darth Vader's need for a bondage suit since we first saw Star Wars back in 1977.

Lucas and co. did a great job bringing it to life on the silver screen with Episode III. But would it work as a setting within an MMORPG? Why not introduce Hoth as a new planet? Or Dagobah?

When this third expansion was announced for Star Wars Galaxies we had mixed feelings. Did we really want to go to Mustafar?

"We're doomed"

Well, for starters, it certainly looks the part, boasting some of the best visuals to grace Star Wars Galaxies. For example, the environmental lighting is excellent - both inside and out - with some nice bump mapping, blackened skies, a lovely looking heat haze effect and some dangerous-looking lava flows that erupt so often they seem to be alive. It all adds up to creating a hugely atmospheric environment, with a real sense of darkness, foreboding and doom captured magnificently. A better rendition of the hateful planet within a game you simply couldn't wish for.

It's not all just for show either. The molten magma is actually harmful to your character, as you'd expect. Just a few steps into lava and you burst into flames. Then die. You can get around pretty easily using standard transports but at some point you'll have to ride on your newly supplied Lava Flea. It's a bit slow - and has a face only a mother could love - but it gets the job done safely.

Not only is the environment extremely hazardous, the new creatures indigenous to the planet are pretty damn lethal - especially if you're a low level combat character. Attacks seem to be constant from the likes of Xandacs and Blistmoks. Wandering around the place without a high level combat chaperone will see you cloning faster than Anakin turned to the dark side.

"Adventure. Hrrrmph. Excitement..."

'Star Wars Galaxies: Trials of Obi-Wan' Screenshot tow1

Where'd you dig up that old fossil?

The quests themselves are good. Really good. They're varied, many are split into multiple sub-missions and some have a few nasty surprises in store. They also give more background to Mustafar, and tie-in the old planet with the game's current timeline far better than the Rage of the Wookiees expansion did. You can choose different paths for some, with different rewards as a consequence. Most importantly, they make sense and they're fun.

Some dungeons are instanced, or require an amount of time to pass before being entered again, which is good news as it gives everyone a fair crack at completing quests. Criminally, however, some quest-specific NPCs are not instanced and spawn on a timer. There's nothing... NOTHING, more infuriating than sitting around for two hours waiting for a character to kill, only to have another group turn up late and claim the kill, and then proceed to camp the site waiting for the next spawn in order to farm loot (while throwing out weak insults about our mothers, inevitably). Hopefully, this will be less of an issue as the weeks go on and people aren't so desperate and/or greedy to get the loot as they are in the first few days of play.

The mission rewards are unique within the game and add something new, even if it's not always useful to your particular character. A weapon that only a Master Bounty Hunter can use is certainly nice to look at but useless to a dancer, for example. Some items are non-trade, and others need to be bio-linked to you so that only you can use them. There are new buff crystals, new decorative items and shiny new weapons. Jedi get new robes and a 'lava crystal' for their light sabers. Crafters get some new schematics. Entertainers... well, they get a new dance, a couple of props and a new song.

That's the Spirit!

'Star Wars Galaxies: Trials of Obi-Wan' Screenshot tow2

The crash site of an Old Republic cruiser starts off a series of quests.

Of course it wouldn't be called 'Trials of Obi-Wan' if it didn't include the eponymous Jedi, now would it? Obi does make an appearance of course - at the spot where he cuts off Anakin's arm and legs - as the blue-glowy ghost of his Alec Guinness self. While you don't have to be a Jedi character to get a visit from the old guy, you can only take on his quests after a set number of quite challenging missions have already been completed.

Galaxies has, of late, made it harder to play solo, and many of these missions require even hardened players to group up with others in order to succeed. This is now essential with some of the quests and the general difficulty of enemies in the expansion requiring a full group, although Obi-Wan's last mission does separate you from your friends to face the challenge alone.

"I can feel your anger..."

'Star Wars Galaxies: Trials of Obi-Wan' Screenshot tow3

The natives are restless.

While Kashyyk really felt like it was more of a giant 'theme park' within the game, Mustafar feels a lot more like the original planets, although there are, annoyingly, still some invisible walls present for seemingly no other reason than to make your questing take just that little bit longer.

While unfortunately there is no space zone around Mustafar, and ergo no new space content, you can still get hold of a version of Dash Rendar's YT-2400 ship from the N64's 'Shadows of the Empire' to fly. And in a rather more convoluted move, the 4,000 year-old droid from Knights of the Old Republic HK-47 makes an appearance, too. But that's not all. Other goodies are also included. Those that pre-ordered the expansion [waves!] have been playing it for a week already and got an exclusive transport in the form of the Skiff, which is the only vehicle that can hold eight people.

The add-on also increases the number of starships and vehicles you can store in your datapad and a beautiful bunker house is also given as a bonus.

But is it enough? As a low combat-level character, you simply can't do enough on the planet to justify spending $35. Extra storage, a flea and a house hardly makes up for the content you'll be missing out on. Knock three points off the score if you're in an entertainer profession, if your combat level is below 65 or, indeed, if you have no friends.

So it boils down to this: the expansion is aimed squarely at the high-level ground-based combat players, and is a solid addition of content for them. That only this one group of players is catered to fully though only serves to alienate those left behind and devalues the offering overall.

7/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Star Wars Galaxies: Trials of Obi-Wan on PC?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-14 of 14 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Fixxxer
01/11/05 @ 07:02
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wow that's up early.

Maybe I'm not the only person who's been up all night working.

Although I probably am the only person typing in gloves in a style not unlike Edward Scissorhands.
Hench
01/11/05 @ 07:10
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Cool, early review.

I wonder if they just set a timer for these things to pop up early on the site.
krudster [mod]
01/11/05 @ 07:52
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
No, I was just up early!
Bill Door
01/11/05 @ 08:40
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Should that really read $ in the penultimate paragraph or is it a typo? Or, a syndicated review from an American? ;)
w00t
01/11/05 @ 08:47
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nice one qs!
krudster [mod]
01/11/05 @ 08:50
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm guessing that's the currency he paid for it to get the early version.
Psi
01/11/05 @ 09:43
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
its like a million voices cried out 'meh' and suddenly lost interest
superdelphinus
01/11/05 @ 09:51
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Does anyone from the U.K still play this? Its a game ive always been fascinated in but never played due to the seemingly massive amount of time you have to play it
Psi
01/11/05 @ 11:01
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
superdelphinus i played since the yank launch years back, with a lot of ppl i saw starwars mmo and had to play as soon as it was out, over the years they have ruined the game, I left after arguing with the CSR's about game bugs etc.

first mistake was holocubes then the jedi whiners took over, game fell to bits as everyone started grinding and not many played the game as it should have been. then all the classes got overpowered so much solo'ing in the game became the norm, the combat balance screwed everyone over after that and i hear it's been downhill ever since really.

The game could have been great, best thig it did for me was keep me at the keyboard for a few months and net me few thousand in saved cash from not going out and getting lashed all the time.
AOFanboi
01/11/05 @ 16:57
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think people who aren't already addicted to WoW will get more out of the recently released City of Villains anyway. SW:G isn't very Star Wars.
Tyronne
01/11/05 @ 17:15
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I gave up playing galaxies about 3 months into a 1 year sub for it,I put hours into it trying to get to a decent level but no sooner did I get anywhere that there were levels that would of taken weeks if not months to even achieve above the level I was at and I just thought sod it I cannot be bothered anymore and uninstalled it.
Adelpha
03/11/05 @ 21:51
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Supposedly on the 15th of this month, the game is getting a complete overhaul including the combat system.

Taken from swgunderground.net

"Ok, so I'm here at SOE's Austin studio and I've played the new build of SWG which is going to be pushed onto test on Friday...with no real press. Basically they went through, ripped out 80% of the classes, left in the following: Force Sensitive, Bounty Hunter, Officer, Smuggler, Commando, Spy, Trader (all the tradeskills - 4 base sets now - Domestics, Structures, Munitions, Engineering), Medic and Entertainer. Here's the deal. Left click shoots - you have to aim. Right click fires off a special ability.

No more auto attack.
No more hotkey combat.

Once collision detection goes in, this will probably be the game I play. There's actual skill involved now. You can run from people and they can't just autohit you.

I don't know how else to explain it other than SOE has done the right thing. They've revitalized combat in an MMOG. It's a huge step in the right direction. Do I think they'll perfect it here? No. But it's by far the most interesting thing a studio has done. They've taken a gamble, and from what I've seen it's paid off. In other words, they've added the "Wars" back to Star Wars. It's been in the works for over a year now. In fact, the expansions could probably be called smokescreens for the launch of the real game. It'll shake things up.

Cons? 90 levels. The exp curve isn't bad though.
Good? Lots of neat skills such as Orbital Strike, theft from NPCs, working stealth for spies, fencing goods in the field for smugglers, and above all - combat based at least 75% on skill. It isn't quite Unreal Tournament, but it's nowhere near the crap combat we've dealt with for 10 years.

When it rolls out in a few weeks I'm hoping some of you will actually take the dive again with me and see where it goes, if for no other reason than to support innovation. In all seriousness, almost all the changes are for the better. Before anyone else says it - yes, it was shocking to me that SOE took this angle on restructuring an MMOG first. Even moreso that Lucasarts supported it. Ding. Grats."
quantumsheep
03/11/05 @ 23:48
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm looking forward to seeing how the new combat system works.

I'm NOT looking forward to being reduced to one of 9 classes and being stuck as that class forever without being able to try anything new. Being able to mix and match from various professions was a big plus point of galaxies.

We'll find out what it's like soon enough I guess...
vane101
10/11/05 @ 13:05
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
All reviews of SWG and its expansions are no longer relevant because SOE is essentially bringing out SWG 2, which will change nearly everything about the way the game is played.

We'll have to wait for the new game to assess things properly.

Comments: 1-14 of 14 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery