Jump to navigation
Sponsored by Alienware tracer
Advertisement

Rome: Total War - Alexander Review

PC Review by Kieron Gillen

26 June, 2006

Downloadable extras. For cash. There's a lot of that this year, isn't there? While most of the attention has circled around Valve (positively, for its excellent Episode 1) and Bethesda (less positively, for its less excellent give-horsey-some-armour), it's not just the first-person developers who are getting involved. Creative Assembly's Alexander is the most notable example of a strategy developer trying this, and while not up to Episode 1, it's in a position to snort at horsey-armour. That it's about our favourite always-entertaining top-ancient greek bisexual conqueror's another bonus.

Alexander presents a trident of gaming additions - the extended campaign mode, historical battles and the extended multiplayer. While it's arguable that, like its mother game, the map-based campaign-mode is the true heart of the game, the historical matches are of more import than we've seen typically.

In fact, it's a little more like a traditional RTS-campaign. The six of Alexander's great victories (oh - all right, five of Alexander's and one of his old man Phillip when Alexander was just there) are played in sequence, requiring you to beat each one before progressing to the next. Between each you get an extended piece of narrative, with Brian Blessed on voice-overs. One of the few golden rules of videogames is that it's always better to have Brian Blessed doing a voice-over than not. You think we love Shadow of the Colossus? We'd have to make an extension off the top of the mark scheme to contain our ardour if they'd had our Brian's voice booming some gobligook from the heavens. No, really.

While the opening mission is relatively simple, with you merely in charge of few units in a larger mass-melee, it's clear that in terms of difficulty these are aimed at the Total War veteran. Even the initial one took me a few plays to manage to work out how to beat the dastardly Theban phalanx, effectively acting as a chance to remind myself how to best manipulate the more-realistic tactical approaches which are the mainstay of the Total War world. And you need to remind yourself, as well as being hard, the AI appears to have been particularly tweaked on each of these. It's a challenge, and not a bad one at all.

'Rome: Total War - Alexander' Screenshot alex1

When in Rome, be an expansion pack for Rome.

Creative Assembly must be pleased with these six missions, as they're also the heart of the multiplayer game additions. Each of them has been balanced to be playable for online play with teams or individuals taking each side. Also, as well as individual bouts, you can string five of the six into a tournament, with a winner being declared at the end of the struggles. It's clearly one for the more dedicated RTS fan, but a serious challenge to get involved in. As well as this, there's the standard custom-game mode where you can set up dream bouts between the game's four new factions.

The true campaign mode, while the meatiest part of the expansion, is a little more streamlined than you may have come to expect. As opposed to the Barbarian Invasion add-on, which introduced new mechanics for tribes forming hordes and marching wherever they choose, this works with the Rome rules you'll be familiar with before trying to create a unique experience by the situation it presents and unusual victory conditions.

The most obviously pressing one is a pressing turn time limit. You're charged with conquering thirty regions (which is the vast majority of the map) in a scant 100 turns. This is to simulate the huge achievements Alexander managed in his short life (he was dead by thirty), and requires more daring play than you may be used to than in stately Rome. It's also a more direct game, basically forming a battle between the united Greek City states beneath Macedonia and the huge expanse of the Persian Empire. To simulate this, the diplomacy options have been removed, with only spies and assassins for more subtle hands.

'Rome: Total War - Alexander' Screenshot alex2

Due to overwhelming demand, the offer to exchange a kingdom for a horse has been closed.

There's a couple of problems - or rather quibbles. The first is its difficulty. You start the game in a relatively precarious position, with Persia owning the seas, Greece not completely pacified and an economy which really needs to be a hell of a lot more economical. A great standing army, yes, but it's one which really needs to go out and conquer the world as soon as possible. The problem is that, especially if your skills are rusty, a couple of early mistakes on the battlefield will basically render your position unsalvageable. 100 turns is barely a few pages in the history book, and you don't have time to rebuild an army. It's not a major problem, as it's clear that the pack's aimed at the more experienced Rome-veteran. Perhaps understandably: it's the second Rome expansion, and mainly available via download (It's also in the gorgeous Total War: Eras pack). This isn't a casual thing.

The second niggle is one which will grate with the hardcore: the matter of historical accuracy. While the Total War games are more faithful than any other period mainstream strategy game, its mechanics don't particularly simulate Alexander's method of conquering too well. For example, since your expansion is so rapid, you have to do everything to prevent revolts springing up. You don't have time to bring people into your civilization properly. You're also phenomenally poor. Since you're marching eastward fast you're increasingly reliant on hiring mercenaries as you get further and further from your unit-producing home-cities. The best tactic for dealing with this is a scorched-earth policy. Kill everyone, take all their gold and head on. Problem being, that's really not what Alexander did. Also, Its modeling of Greece - perhaps understandable with the scale of the map - is a little simple, with no real inter-greek politicing... but I suppose that could have easily been an expansion pack by itself. Perhaps its biggest problem is the campaign only lets you play Alexander's position, limiting its replayability.

'Rome: Total War - Alexander' Screenshot alex3

Where do you keep your armies? Near the Pyrenees. (Are you sure? - Ed)

A shame, as the four factions in the game are interesting. The Macedonians rely on their heavy cavalry and ultra-heavy phallanxs. Since their main rivals are the light cavalry and archer heavy Persians, it's an interesting interplay between one side trying to close as quickly as possible to leverage their higher-quality infantry against theirs, and the other trying to stay the hell away from that wall of spears. The assorted Barbarians are an infantry-centered war-cry group, with some particularly mean sicklemen and the Indians marry extremely light infantry with extremely heavy elephants.

So Alexander is limited, but compelling. For a full-price add-on, you'd judge it more harshly, but for £8.50 (Plus an extra couple of quid if you want the "Download Insurance", which frankly sounds a little sinister), for some strategic challenges while we all wait for Medieval 2 it's entirely acceptable. As far as great human achievements go, it's not up with conquering pretty much the entire known world in ten years, but as videogame tributes go, far from embarrassing.

7/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Rome: Total War - Alexander on PC?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-16 of 16 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
York
26/06/06 @ 13:44
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Reviews of games about Rome are like buses.
thegamesthething
26/06/06 @ 13:48
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Smelly? Chewing gum stuck to them?
ecureuil
26/06/06 @ 13:53
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
There seems to be a lot of reviews of very similar games recently..
Gremmi
26/06/06 @ 13:55
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I clearly don't know enough about history. I read the tagline thinking "Why are they making references to an all-in-one DivX encoder?"
UncleLou
26/06/06 @ 14:06
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
As much as I love Rome, I am already in a "waiting for Medieval 2" state of mind.
Darkedge
26/06/06 @ 14:38
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
download insurance?? so if your download fails you can get it again - something everybody else gives for free.
dodgy as hell that
ruttyboy
26/06/06 @ 14:38
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
That 'Download Insurance' is a feckin' disgrace! Two quid for them to 'store a copy of your game for 18 months'! Surely they only hve to host the file in one place and everyone can download it when needed?
Bumbuliuz
26/06/06 @ 15:39
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This is a decent expansion for little money. Well worh what I paid for it ;)
Mr_Brown
26/06/06 @ 16:20
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sounds fair to me. One for the fans, for £8.50 for loads more hours of gameplay you can't go wrong.
Ryuken
26/06/06 @ 17:47
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Time limit? Seems like a no-go.
BremXJones
26/06/06 @ 18:27
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Works for Outrun 2, you wimp!

KG
Kostabi
27/06/06 @ 00:27
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Due to overwhelming demand, the offer to exchange a kingdom for a horse has been closed."

Haha, best caption in a while.
a8a
27/06/06 @ 05:02
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I was about to comment on that caption :)

Whoever thought that one up wins one internet (non-exchangable).
Ryuken
27/06/06 @ 07:24
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hehe, Outrun 2 gets away with that of course, everything needs to be fast there. I can't see the thrill of racing at 5 km/h either, you know. For a strategy game though, I like to take it easy and would want to have things like a timer be more of an option rather than it being forced on you. That's what strategy is all about, do I want to rush in or steadily build up forces? The reason why it is forced is odd too; oh, so Alexander dies young? I think he would have become a bit more careful if he knew that before he started his worldconquest. :)

I don't think, especially with the whole digital download 'is it worth its value'-debate going on (I still prefer one big package or a well worked out addon above anything else), that it's a smart move to limit actions of the player in such a product, despite the low price (which is 10 quid anyway, those damn taxes and all). And then removing diplomacy... that's the kind of thing that made the campaign game of Total War (and just the whole adopted 'turnbased campaign, real-time battles'-concept of Birthright) have that little edge over the standard RTS-campaign fare à la Dune II, as you described. The only way it might still be interesting is to provide more variation in the real-time section, but I don't think you need to attack convoys, suddenly get help from an unknown local faction or need to protect important people here (just imagining that that could be interesting). It's just more of the usual battle or siege it thing, isn't it?

Ah well, the credit card requirement won't even let me try it. Total War Eras it'll probably be then.
BremXJones
27/06/06 @ 14:13
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ryuken: I don't actually disagree with much of what you say - but the "That's what strategy is all about" sends alarm bells ringing. I don't like arguments based around what games (or anything) "should" be, as they inevitably lead to stagnation.

Don't like like time-limits in strategy games then clearly, don't buy this. But for a second add-on pack, at a reasonable price, I'm willing to give them a little more leeway. "Can you match Alexander's achievements" is their idea for the game. A time limit's how they've achieved it.

(I mean, effectively, Civ has a time-limit...)

Of course, it's also noteworthy I gave it a 7/10 and all the Rome stuff has scored considerably more than that previously. It's a minor "thing".

KG
Ryuken
27/06/06 @ 15:11
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sure, you can view it in that way too. An addon always needs a new hook of sorts, making it too long-stretched won't be satisfactory either. Will try it anyway prolly.

Comments: 1-16 of 16 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Metaboli

X View gallery