Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness Review

Gotta Ignore This One.

Version tested: GameCube

As you sit there with your shiny new Xbox 360 suspended in its aeratory harness, pity the poor GameCube: its games, cast off the shelves of all but the most dedicated shops, now languish in Woolworths bargain bins and eBay fire-sales.

You would think, or at least hope, that Nintendo would still care about its beloved diminutive purple frinkahedron, even if nobody else does. Alas, it seems not - not in this case.

Last year's much delayed Pokémon Colosseum was not nearly good enough for many Pokémon fans. It did the bare minimum to qualify as an RPG, threw in some cute critters and some other spin-off frippery, and that was about the size of it. Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness seems to be much the same.

Actually, scratch that. It seems to be almost identical. It's still fun, it's still easy. It's barely changed at all.

It's all set five years after Pokémon Colosseum took place, and concerns the plight of powerfully dangerous Shadow Pokémon - regular Pokémon that have gone evil and become Republicans, and now demonstrate a distinct dislike towards being kidnapped and enslaved by humans.

It emerges that a shadowy Cabal, Cipher, is on a mission to collect all the Shadowmon to form a super-evil army of darkness. It falls to you, a young boy and wannabe Pokémon trainer, to save the world from these dastardly villains, by purifying all the escaped Shadow Pokémon.

'Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness' Screenshot fnord

This Pokémon's called "Fnord"

As with the previous game, XD starts out with a long and impressive cinematic introduction, and this is quite unusual for the modern gaming canon, it adds something and manages to set the scene well and prefigures what is about to unfold.

Alas, the startling pace of the introduction doesn't really survive beyond the initial burst of excitement, leading into possibly the most tedious, most drawn-out, most lumpen, lumbering and unbearably slooooow introductory RPG chapter ever committed to bits. And I use the word 'committed' advisedly. It's painful, and so awe-inspiringly wasteful of the player's quality time it's easy to imagine a significant proportion of the audience will never quite get past it.

By the time the game has extensively belaboured the lead character, his talents, and how the Pokémon Universe revolves around him in its gut-scorchingly dull fashion, it's already become difficult to care, let alone find the energy to persist with it beyond the point at which it finally picks up and you get to learning the art of sponging up Shadowmon and cleansing them for your own depraved, illicit purposes.

'Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness' Screenshot steroid

This one's called "Steroidanger"

Assuming you do, your starter Pokémon is Evee, and with her you'll instigate or get caught up in various creature confrontations - with pedestrians, in Colosseums and other places like hideouts. As you progress, you'll be awarded a device that makes Shadowmon visible, and allows you to steal them from other trainers. Kidnap, Slavery, Theft. So far, so wholesome.

Once caught, a Shadow Pokémon needs to be purified, to make it "open its heart". This can be done by taking them into battle with you, or by popping it in the enormously sinister "purification chamber". This Pokémon Inquisition takes place at Research HQ. Within, you place one of your bad boys in a ring, and then purify it by surrounding it with a selection of your faithful slaves. You can leave up to nine sets of Pokémon purifying as a background task, while you get on with the game. All a bit peculiar, and the only really new thing in Gale of Darkness.

Other than purification, you now don't cruelly abduct and cleanse the 'Mon in the wild like a lunatic Pokémon Bader Meinhof gang member, but rather "snag" them away from trainers during a fight. It's not much, but it's something that the handheld outings don't have, for what it's worth.

'Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness' Screenshot fuss

This one's called "Fussfussfussfussfuss"

There isn't much beyond that though, apart from the ability to catch wild Pokémon as well as ones in battle. Again though, it's nothing to get excited about, because it isn't anything like as flexible or powerful as the games of yore, allowing you to capture any wild Pokémon you found. This time around, you have to trap the wild Pokémon and lure them to their doom with Pokémon Goodies, and when you are alerted via your PDA that a wild Pokémon is in the area, you can go to that area and battle the Pokémon with the hopes of capturing it. It's a kerfuffle, so you won't want to spend much time looking for rare wild creatures.

There are basically only three spots to capture wild Pokémon, which further demonstrates how lacking this game is compared to the GBA games in that regard, in which one can snap up the creatures all over the extensive world maps on the Earth's favourite handheld. At least with XD it is now somewhat possible now to amass a Pokémon army outside of battle, but it doesn't count for much.

Disappointing, then. Indeed, XD is largely the same experience as Colosseum, a multiplayer Pokémon Stadium game with a bit of a single-player train-steal-purify adventure, which is somewhat dull. The average Pokémon Game Boy RPG is far more detailed and expansive in every sense.

'Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness' Screenshot inflatabreast

This one's called "Inflatabreast"

On the visual side, the game has notched up the detail of the graphics a bit, but otherwise the graphics in Gale of Darkness look much the same as Colosseum's. The characters are, in true Nintendo style, cheerful and colourful, and there's oodles of blue sky all round. The critters look fab in full 3D, but they don't really move or do much, unless they attack, in which case they look unerringly smooth and stylish.

So, is any of this enough to justify a new purchase if you've already bought and played through the first? Not by any stretch of anybody's Pokémon-addled imagination.

As far as Nintendo seems to be concerned, at least until the first DS outing, Pokémon begins and ends with the Game Boy. Pokémon XD is tedious and restrictive. The message is clear: if you want Pokémon, crack open a GBA.

4 / 10

Read the Eurogamer.net scoring policy

Comments (22) Latest comment 2 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • Kain_Cross #1 6 years ago

  • Talha #2 6 years ago

    Oh Lordy, EG now have an anti-Nintendo bias to add to their woes!
    Edited by 1 at 05/12/05 @ 11:15
  • Psi #3 6 years ago

    aw.. was gonna get this, never played a pokemon game before..
  • Stickman #4 6 years ago

    Are these little buggers still running around then? Surely people must have 'caught them all' by now.

    "pity the poor GameCube: its games, cast off the shelves of all but the most dedicated shops, now languish in Woolworths bargain bins and eBay fire-sales."

    /looks at large banner and side advert

    /sniggers
  • Zuiyo #5 6 years ago

    Kids should be out there playing basketball and looking for mating partners instead of getting jiggy with this crap.
  • Pirotic #6 6 years ago

    I had caught them all, until the new DS game on japanese import decided to wipe the data from my GBA carts (you can transfere pokemon around by having a GBA cart in the GBA slot while playing it you see, alas - it doesn't bloody work!).
  • marilena #7 6 years ago

    Wow, what a string of bad games. The last few days have broken all the records in terms of bad ratings give by EG.
  • Kami #8 6 years ago

    I notice that they haven't reviewed PoP: The Two Thrones, a game which I've knocked soundly into shape over the weekend. It's bloody fantastic - ignore this poke-crap and go out and get The Two Thrones - or wait a couple weeks for the 'Cube/X-Box versions. Easily in my opinion THE game to own this Xmas.

    Prince of Persia: The Two Thrones is nothing short of perfect. Aside from some choppy graphics, which you CAN get past. I predict a 9/10 easily... personally, I think it's easily much better than Sands of Time so I'd have to give the game a 10. Or I'd need a new ratings system. Either way, The Two Thrones is ACE!

    Sorry. Needed to vent that.
  • Kami #9 6 years ago

    The Two Thrones was released Friday for the PS2, and THIS Friday 9th for the PC, 'Cube and X-Box versions.

    Either way, I highly recommend the game. OK, yes, I beat it in a weekend where I had little else to do. But the game kept me hooked, I would turn it off only to go back about half an hour later for more.

    Best way to describe it is this; Take the platforming bits of Sands of Time. Add the combat system from Warrior Within. Then add a dash of genius, a pinch of stealth and a couple teaspoons of cliche. Mix, pour into some great game design, and bake well inside a really interesting storyline, then take out and sprinkle with a sparkling narrative. Delicious!

    It really is a hell of a way to go... after all, this is supposed to be the last one in the Sands Trilogy...
  • GuiltySpark #10 6 years ago

    "if you want Pokémon, crack open a GBA."

    i wonder how many little kids are gonna smash up thier gbas thinking there is pokemon inside....

    sorry.......
  • Kami #11 6 years ago

    Idiot prince - less idiot, more naive this time.
    The terrible music - long gone.
    The attitude - replaced with witty and informative narrative. The prnce has grown up - only one time did I hear the beginnings of a swear word. But it was done in good context.
    The dark theme - also gone for the most part, although there is one part of the game that IS pitch-black almost. But that's near the end of the game and it's not that tricky.
    The useless map - buh-bye!
    The endless backtracking - thankfully, gone. Good riddance. It makes the game a LITTLE shorter, but infinitely more rewarding. It progresses much like Sands of Time did...

    It's also got an awesome CG bit. I won't spoil it, but it was ace.
  • Kami #12 6 years ago

    The Two Thrones is superb. I can't recommend it enough. This and Mario Kart DS will keep me happy and content through the long Xmas period...
  • Zuiyo #13 6 years ago

    My flatmate just got a DS and Mario Kart and he's been playing Wi-Fi like crazy for days. We have a wireless modem which we use for the computers and laptops.
  • Kami #14 6 years ago

    Azmol, most places sold out! I don't even get mine for a few more days!

    But when I've got it, I'm more than game for a few EG races...
  • Kami #15 6 years ago

    Aww, bless, let's see if you're that confident after a few sound thrashings... ^^ lol

    This is what I love about games like this though. The pre-match idle taunts and empty threats. You can't beat it, really...
  • Kami #16 6 years ago

    Nope. Considering I've been Mario Karting for years now... I kinda have a bit of experience under my belt (shame about the lack of N64 Wario Stadium though. I always loved hitting the lightning bolt just as my opponent was trying to jump the gap in that one... *evil laugh*)...

    Sounds like fun though. Can't wait.

    Edit: As for Resi DS, allegedly. We'll have to wait and see...
    Edited by 1 at 05/12/05 @ 16:15
  • Carrybagma #17 6 years ago

    Not as funny as the Awesome!/10! review.
  • Talha #18 6 years ago

    @SuperGamerMatt: You forgot one game: NFS Most Wanted. Good or bad, it would make for a good review. Unless EG are actually bored with it (no blaming them after NFSU and U2), in which case it would be 3-4/10, but with a bland review.

    The Two Thrones is amazing. It is so good, I like it even before playing it(!). Especially since these days I am re-playing SoT (PC) with a PS2 controller plugged into the USB. Funnily enough, Windows recognizes every function on DualShock - someone at MS was surely sleeping.

    As for Thrones, I like it based on the features mentioned in other reviews (less darkness, more platforming, more story, better combat, no Godsmack.)

  • gypsumfantastic #19 6 years ago

    Interestingly irrelevant set of comments.

    Two points: Two Thrones, yes it's very good. No, it's not 9/10 because it falls short of Sands of Time in a couple of key areas.

    1) Pointless chariot race minigames.
    2) Overly hard boss (the ring of fire - Gah!)
    3) Not quite as magical as PoPSoT.
    4) Overuse of the Sonic the Hedgehog wall-springs and dagger-holds
    5) Atrocious voice acting.

    It's buoyed up by being a much needed return to form, the speed-kills, the playfulness and the thankfully brief dark prince segments. I predict a Kristan 8/10.

    Secondly, Mario Kart. Somebody please start a forum thread so we can exchange friend codes. Thanks.

    Martin
  • 3william56 #20 6 years ago

    If you don't see the Fnord, it can't eat you.
    Edited by 1 at 06/12/05 @ 13:43
  • gypsumfantastic #21 6 years ago

    I have seen the Fnords. They're *rubbish*.
  • Wolverfrog #22 2 years ago

    I remember loving this game. I haven't played it since the age of nine though. It looks terrible now. Damn you, rose tinted glasses!