Jump to navigation
Advertisement

Makai Kingdom: Chronicles of the Sacred Tome Review

PlayStation 2 Review by Simon Parkin

1 December, 2005

The strategy RPG genre is often thought of as one of videogaming's dark and dusty side streets, where people lurk for a reason that nobody on the cobbles of action and driving beyond truly understands any more.

Videogaming's closest equivalent to chess, strategy RPGs look simple on the surface but have vast, complex, number-crunching underbellies. They addict players into agonising and obsessing for hours over the hit-points and manoeuvres of tiny sprites: weighing each of the precious character's moves with a care and precision scarcely seen elsewhere.

But not really on our TVs. But for a few fringe titles like Future Tactics, and Nintendo's burgeoning interest in transferring its successes to the Cube, it's rare that we get them on things like the PS2. Where once our TVs were abuzz with the likes of Shining Force (SEGA), Ogre Battle (Atlus) and their ilk, modern gamers have been enticed away by the promise of bigger, bolder and better graphics, wooed by the FMV sequences of 32-bit RPGs and then caught up in the relentless, vacuous quest for realism. As have the devs, who left the visually ageing simplicity of these wide, expansive math puzzles to embrace polygons and third-person cameras. Where SRPGs used to thrive on 8- and 16-bit home formats (and 32- if you count Square's efforts, which we'd be foolish not to), they now seem to enjoy the best of us on Nintendo's handhelds.

But not in every case. Back in 2003, a tiny start-up Japanese codeshop, previously known for a niche musical RPG (Rhapsody), released an odd-looking strategy RPG that somehow managed to make it from Japan to America. Nippon Ichi's Disgaea packed so much charm, humour, flair and wonder that the western videogame world slowly turned its fickle head back to strategy RPGs, took a long hard look and realised the mistake it had made. Eventually, it even came out over here - as part of a distribution relationship between Nippon Ichi and KOEI, which has now brought us Makai Kingdom.

MK is Disgaea's grandson, and bears all the family likenesses: deep, complicated but accessible strategy, infinitely customisable characters and a laugh-out-loud funny script all mixed in with a few of its own inventions. Indeed, the game combines some of the best elements of its forebears in an attempt to produce the definitive remix of the Nippon Ichi core strategy engine.

'Makai Kingdom: Chronicles of the Sacred Tome' Screenshot 3

Graphically the game is charming if slightly retro.

But the best engine in the world is no fun unless the bodywork is up to scratch. As with all Nippon Ichi's crazed-eyed scenarios, the back-story casing to Makai Kingdom is as outlandish as it is bombastic and ensures that you keep playing where other plot lines might leave you bored. True to form, the game is set in and around the 'Netherworld'. In a horribly failed metaphysical experiment to destroy a sacred tome that prophesies his annihilation, Lord Zetta, the ruler of hell, inadvertently destroys himself and, in doing so, fulfils the prophecy. Before he expires he just manages to put his soul into the self-same book ensuring he can continue to exist, if only as a sacred manuscript.

Bear with it.

Lord Zetta isn't the only Netherworld overlord. In fact, there are numerous universes each with their own hellish master and, throughout the game, a whole host of them enter the fray to either offer their support to Lord Zetta in his efforts to restore his power over his netherworld or attempt to move in on his territory.

You are cast as Lord Zetta himself and, through the help of some of these colourful overlords, have to build an army of followers to help you reclaim the netherworld as your own. When we say build an army of followers that is exactly what we mean because, unlike in your standard RPG setting, you are not gifted with a team of pre-packaged characters. Rather, you have to create the soldiers, thieves, healers and magicians that will comprise your crack squad of fighters by creating them from objects you find in each Netherworld.

'Makai Kingdom: Chronicles of the Sacred Tome' Screenshot 2

Every level can be returned to for leveling your characters.

Each of the objects has its own bonuses (e.g. making a soldier from a rock will grant him high defence) and so there is a certain amount of strategy in choosing which class of fighter you create for each object. As you level up the characters you begin to unlock more classes. Eventually you can even reincarnate your favourite characters into a new class altogether, where they start again from level one but with all the abilities they obtained in their earlier form. So as you progress deep into the game your characters become Swiss-army knives of skills and abilities and their make-up is uniquely yours.

For anyone yet to play a strategy RPG, the flow of play is fairly straightforward. You're treated to a cut-scene followed by a battle on a static, usually small, map. Traditionally these maps are divided up into squares like a chessboard, onto which you deploy and move your troops move by move as you attack the enemy units with a mixture of brute force and magic.

However, in Nippon Ichi's last game, Phantom Brave, they did away with the grid system instead allowing you to position units anywhere you wanted on the map within their movement allowance. This added a gameplay element of weapon and spell distance and made the whole thing a little less like a board game. Makai Kingdom continues this development but traditionalists will probably favour the old grid based system as this, ironically, allowed for far more precision in targeting attacks. Now you can have a huddle of fighters all within a virtual metre-square of each other often resulting in you attacking the wrong person.

'Makai Kingdom: Chronicles of the Sacred Tome' Screenshot 1

Each stage has a series of prizes that can be earned by the number of points earned during battle.

There is a wonderful line up of inventive weaponry at your disposal as you work through the game mixing up the ancient (broadswords and axes) with the modern (rocket launchers and tanks) in a delightfully anachronistic tussle. The more your characters use these weapons, the higher their skill becomes in turn unlocking bigger and better attacks.

Another new addition is the ability to create vehicles and facilities to take out into battle. Facilities can be used to store units to have them deployed onto the field and even have their own effects on the battlefield, like HP regeneration, defence or attack bonuses or even experience bonuses.

The system is a lot freer than Disgaea, which, although allowed a lot of customisation, still guided you down a set path. Makai Kingdom by contrast give you full responsibility of every facet of your team and, for many gamers not used to strategy RPGs, it will seem extremely confusing and frightening. It's too open, requires too much understanding and knowledge of Nippon Ichi's previous games to welcome new players in, and is another example of why the strategy RPG genre will likely remain a niche area.

However, for genre fans, the educated, the talented or the time-rich, Makai Kingdom represents a rich and deep pasture with almost limitless ways to play. It's clever, expansive, funny, well made and beautifully translated and, if you are committed enough, could be one of the best videogame investments you'll ever make.

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Makai Kingdom: Chronicles of the Sacred Tome on PlayStation 2?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-29 of 29 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
SIDEARM
01/12/05 @ 08:37
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Uh too many games to get!
itamae
01/12/05 @ 08:41
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
*sigh* I guess I'll have to buy it now...

/glances at (small yet nevertheless intimidating) pile of unplayed games
hula hoops
01/12/05 @ 08:44
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Why do people like the word 'chronicles' so much ??
... of Riddick
... of Narnia
... of the Sacred Tome
... of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
... of Valhalla
Crystal ...

tengu
01/12/05 @ 08:47
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Don't forget Dark Chronicle too :)

But yeah, looks very nice, I'll get it as soon as I get done with the fifty or so other games I've yet to play through, including all the other N1 titles.

Sigh, it's either a very good, or a very bad time to be a gamer, depending on your outlook.
Firewine
01/12/05 @ 09:01
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
+1 to the owns it but hasn't played it yet camp... I haven't even finished Disgaea yet :(
joey
01/12/05 @ 09:02
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
....arrrgh, another one to get.

I have a nasty feeling that this is one of those games that if you don't get it quite soon after release it will be hard to get and you will be reduced to paying daft money on ebay to get it.

..and I agree it's an expensive time to be a gamer, usually this season brings out a lot of games, many are 'Christmas Crud', but this year we do seem to have a run of actually quite good stuff for all the consoles.

I have made a desicion not to get a 360 for the simple fact that there is too much to get for my exisiting stock of consoles, which I think in the long run will work out fine as I really want a HD TV to make the most of it (and I want Morrow Wind!!) which means a lot of saving up in the new year!
SonicBoom
01/12/05 @ 09:12
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I have Disgaea, Phantom Brave and La Pucelle - do I really need this too...

Likewise, I can see this turning into another PD Saga or Valkyrie Profile if left too long.
Blerk
01/12/05 @ 09:17
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've had a copy of this since release day, but it got confiscated to be used as a birthday present. I get it back on Sunday! :-)

Not that I'll be finished with Phantom Brave before then, but... there you go.

Anyway - Nippon Ichi. I would quite happily cook them dinner. For a week. Actually that might be more of a punishment than an offer of gratitude.... perhaps I ought to wash their cars instead? And I'd better do Koei's too. Bless 'em all.

/hugs
Hog-lumps
01/12/05 @ 09:36
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The system is a lot freer than Disgaea

Yikes!


DodgyPast
01/12/05 @ 09:53
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I already have this, Pucelle and Disgaea all unplayed

still at least i won't be wanting an xbox 360 for a while.
karlidog
01/12/05 @ 10:13
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've had this for a bit, and had great fun with the few hours I've put in so far, but I'm really looking forward to Disgaea 2 and the return of the grid system - no more scrums? Yes please, Nippon Ichi!
gamesb*tch
01/12/05 @ 10:35
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
yip!
Decoded
01/12/05 @ 11:04
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
*sigh* I guess I'll have to buy it now...

You mean my recommendations in the forum were not convincing enough? Tut.

Good review. This is the most accessible of the Nippon Ichi titles I've played and consequently the most fun. And it features oppressed cockney corn - seriously, what more could one ask for?
thegamesthething
01/12/05 @ 11:10
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"Why do people like the word 'chronicles' so much ??
... of Riddick
... of Narnia
... of the Sacred Tome
... of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
... of Valhalla
Crystal ... "

... of Thomas Covnenant the Unbeliever - 3000 pages of abject depression and 1 of redemption


Sko
01/12/05 @ 11:33
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Christ, thegamesthething! Spoiler!
toy_brain
01/12/05 @ 11:42
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
" I already have this, Pucelle and Disgaea all unplayed"

Ahh, nice to know I'm not the only person out there who has bought all these games only to barely touch them.
Well, I'm about halfway through Disgaea - its been 'on the go' for ages now. Gets pulled out every few months or so for a spot of grinding. I usually do a couple chapters at a time before putting it away again for another stupidly long period of time.
doctor_nick
01/12/05 @ 12:05
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"for genre fans, the educated, the talented or the time-rich"

About 2.5 out of four? Matt?
PinkSpider
01/12/05 @ 12:20
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I have this; It is good. It feels abit like what Phantom Brave should have been more like (dont get me wrong I liked the game it just didnt hook me). La Pucelle to play after this also... sigh. Pile of RPGs also to big :(
Singularity
01/12/05 @ 12:40
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ngg. Must. Finish. Disgaea. First.

/doesn't order
Blerk
01/12/05 @ 12:46
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Slackers! I finished Disgaea and La Pucelle and I'm two thirds of the way through Phantom Brave.

Get to it! :-)

/cracks whip
MJ
01/12/05 @ 13:21
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"for genre fans, the educated, the talented or the time-rich"

"About 2.5 out of four? Matt?"

More like 3.5; you pick where the 0.5 is lost.

Shouldn't it read:

"for genre fans, the educated, the talented and the time-rich."

i.e. for people who don't work for IT companies!

BAM!

PS. this game is ace!
Edited 1 times, most recently on 01/12/05 @ 13:22
Bertie [staff]
01/12/05 @ 16:17
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hrrrrrm. This game sounds really damn good. I'd like an RPG on the PC that went in to such depth. PS2's crap and all that /runs
Blerk
01/12/05 @ 16:25
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
*gasp*

Eurogamer bias proven!

/calls Rupert
SuperGamerMatt
01/12/05 @ 16:36
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
It's a good time to be a PS2 gamer

First this and then Soul Calibur III in a week or so. Plus all the new £15 Platinum games, Battlefront I and Lego Star Wars etc
Bertie [staff]
01/12/05 @ 18:08
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Seriously though, I've been umming and arrring over the possibilities of getting alittle slimline ps2 to play the classics on. Looking back through the catalog, there are swathes of great games there. Xbox has a lot too, but I do quite a bit of PC gaming and the titles seem fairly similar. GC is nice, too - I'm not sure if it's possible for me to get any better at Mario Kart though.

/blows own trumpet
tengu
01/12/05 @ 19:52
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Matt, Soul Calibur III was out a couple of weeks ago :)
Blerk
02/12/05 @ 10:04
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Everyone needs a PS2, Bertie! ^_^
azmol01
02/12/05 @ 17:10
#28
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm not all that great with RPG's I recently finished Fire Emblem on the cube and absouletly loved the game and its accesibility. I'm really curious about theses Nippon Ichi games though can anyone please explain to me what these games are all about and if its easy for a RPG newbie like myself to get to grips with, is it like Fire Emblem?
fantabulo
21/12/05 @ 09:54
#29
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I bought it recently, and I am finding the "laugh-out-loud funny" script extremley grating. The first time the hero said "badass freaking overlord" I cringed; when he went on to repeat it over and over again felt annoyed at the lazy writers. All in all, cheap gags that consistently fall flat. Ridiculous in the worst possible way.

Comments: 1-29 of 29 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery