Jump to navigation
Advertisement

Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes Review

Xbox Review by Jim Rossignol

27 October, 2005

Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes is part of that series of games, cousin to Dynasty Warriors, in which you command units of troops in something akin to a close-camera RTS, before diving into fantasy melee and finding yourself cast as the lead pugilist in a 100-man beat ‘em up. Needless to say, such a game concept is hugely entertaining: hence the ongoing series.

But before you get to the brutality, you must parse the names. The Kingdom of Arenia, the east Bersian continent of Vellond; the annexation of Hexter by Valdemar the Half Vampire; the elves in the Hironeidian territory; the Encalblossa War, ogre tribes in the marches...

All this on the loading screen alone.

I’ve been told off by editors before for fantasy bashing on a number of occasions. But in all honesty I have no prejudice; I simply want to convey the awfulness that many games, films or books wish to pass off as some kind of story-like substance. More often than not, the cocaine of a good yarn is cut with 90 per cent powdered gibberish, and that’s going to get up anyone’s nose. (In a bad, Daniella Westbrook-type way.)

But I can’t help myself: I have perverse love for the sheer audacity of the epic-fantasy insanity that games like this attempt to deliver. The dialogue is a voluminous exercise in disjointed absurdity. I baulk at imagining what the voice actors made of the script, and I’m always end thinking of what it must have been like just getting this garbage over with in their $5-per-hour studios. Perhaps they’ll give some false-gusto, clutching a cup of lukewarm Starbucks bean-mud as they recite the nonsense. This acting career was meant to be Hollywood and Shakespeare, wasn’t it? Wasn’t it?

Will they later buy the game and proudly demonstrate their performance to their agents and/or mother? (The lonely voice actor steps out into the rain for a good cry...)

'Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes' Screenshot hammer

The guy with the big hammer is splendid for killing orcs and demolishing garden sheds.

There’s even a guy who occasionally says "..." apropos of nothing at all. And then there are the implied events in the dialogue which, because they are taking place off-camera (while you stare a pixelly 3D world map screen), are unseen and completely obscure.

What the hell is going on?

Fortunately, I swallowed the blue pill, and instead of seeing the truth of this fantasy lard-slab, I have plunged into the fantastical battles beyond. Scene-skipping is your friend: make up your own story, put your fingers in your ears and go "la-la-la!" when the cut-scenes occur. Just think about the slaying, and give yourself over to the moment. Those giant scorpions must pay: they’re on the wrong team.

Still with me, eh? Okay, so the truth of it is that no one is going to care about the rubbish story, because there’s something delicious under the wrinkly skin of a long-dead Tolkien. It’s this: incredible fighting.

When I say 'incredible', I don’t mean as in 'leaving you incredulous', or as in some kind of fighting activity you won’t be familiar with. I mean spectacular, showy, and high-fivingly entertaining. Dragons strafe the field of battle, hordes of snarling orcs come barrelling in, axes in hand; heroes spin, kick and scythe their way through a soup of enemies, blades whirling. It’s thrilling stuff. I found myself punching the air after the defeat of one particularly hairy band of orcs; much to the bemusement of my girlfriend, who was sat behind me on the sofa, practicing her frowning.

Anyway, the tactical sections of Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes actually constitute a relatively sophisticated RTS. You take to the field with a certain set of objectives, which must be accomplished by not getting slaughtered. When the action kicks off you’ll need to position ranged troops correctly and deploy units in the manner in which they’ll be most effective. Bowmen will suffer if they’re firing into the sun, or if they’re firing up hill. Likewise infantry will move faster if they’re spread out, but will be more vulnerable to attack; bunch them up into that tight phalanx and you’ll hit harder as you plunge into enemy ranks.

'Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes' Screenshot mounted

Mounted troops cause lots of damage on the charge, while flying beasts must be tackled by archers.

Occasionally (annoyingly) it’s possible to break the sequence of events. I failed to retreat from one fight, for example, killing everyone even though they pleaded mercy, and so failed to open up the latter part of the mission where I’d save their Elf princess. A restart was necessary. Likewise, there a few missions where - without any obvious waypoints - you’ll end up wandering about aimlessly. While the over-laid map is useful for moving units and for positioning yourself with regards to enemies, it is entirely featureless and devoid of navigational use. Don’t expect clues about where to go (although it’s generally linear enough not to matter).

Although each of your units have all have defined roles, each one can be upgraded and re-classed in substantial action-interlude map-screen menu sections. As they level up their role can change, with infantry becoming cavalry, or heavy infantry, depending on your tactical whims. War begets experience and gold, and that must be spent on new swords and shinier shields for both men and leaders. While you won’t necessarily notice the effect of this in-game, you’ll need to keep on top of their upgrade curve so that units won’t get a bloody nose in later melees.

When that close-range combat occurs, your lead unit switches from indirect RTS controls to the melee itself. This is where the titular heroes get to flex their powers, in a beat-‘em-up style fight against potentially hundreds of enemies. Charging headlong into a churning wall of orcs is hugely satisfying, especially when your suitably supercharged weapons send them flying in a shower of blood and sparks. As with other fighting games, the right sequence of button bashing lets you pull off a sequence of moves, including the odd power-up hyperblast that you’ll impress yourself with in times of need. A smattering of special characters join you on the field, too, and the tough fights can be turned with deft use of their special moves. Discovering new ways to lay the smack down brings a smile to even the stiffest upper lip. It’s stupid pixel-opera of this kind that games excel at, and the sheer simplicity of stabbing the dark legion do-badders in the face gives way to constant delight.

The melee combat is too easy and too chaotic to really be regarded as any kind of skill-based challenge, though, but it's nevertheless just relentlessly amusing, and help augment the fiddly strategic sections with gratuitous, open carnage (Whack! Stab-biff!). Nevertheless, as the game progresses it becomes tougher for you to win these skirmishes single-handedly, although the hero characters always define the course of any fight.

'Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes' Screenshot kebab

Stab! How will ever know that you don’t like orc-flesh kebab if you won’t try one?

And there’s a lot of this incredible fighting to get through, too. There are multiple story-campaigns to enjoy, as well as a skirmish mode. You have a choice of characters to begin with, although only the default one actually leads you into the story properly. Further heroes are unlocked as you complete the early campaigns, each one representing another tier of trickiness. The war can also be played from the point of view of the evil-folk, who really do excel in the silly voice department.

Needless to say, there’s Live support too, so you can set up some grand epic-scale custom games to play online, pushing the game to its over-wrought limits. The truly top-end battles that can be produced in this way really do impress even the terminally cynical.

That said, it seems that Heroes could be a whole lot prettier. There’s a hell of a lot of washed-out colour and bad camera wobbles in there. But when it gets it right, when the field of battle is writhing with combatants, when the archers are setting enemies on fire with flaming arrows, when meteors plunge to Earth and when dragons dive from the sky to strafe the melee with jets of green fire, then you really begin to believe. Imperfections be damned. There’s enough energy here to make up for a hundred made-up elf names.

Actually, the finest thing about the Kingdom games (and I know I’m not the first person to point this out) is the music. Rather than default to the 'Oooo-laaa' of contemporary fantasy soundtracks, KUFH employs dense speed-metal loops for the melee, framed by incidental post-rock in the movement and map screen phases. It’s glorious, and slightly incongruous.

The orcs and the elves: they listen to Motorhead.

8/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about Kingdom Under Fire: Heroes on Xbox?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-27 of 27 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Scimarad
27/10/05 @ 07:02
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I’ve been told off by editors before for fantasy bashing on a number of occasions. But in all honesty I have no prejudice; I simply want to convey the awfulness that many games, films or books wish to pass off as some kind of story-like substance. More often than not, the cocaine of a good yarn is cut with 90 per cent powdered gibberish, and that’s going to get up anyone’s nose."

See I don't get this - The only things that were 'gibberish' in that paragraph were the made up names. It's a fantasy world FFS, what sort of names would you expect to have? Real world names? If it's a made up world it will have made up place names and I really don't see what is wrong with that. Take a look at some place names in the real world...

On the subject of the game - So it's a decent fantasy Dynasty Warriors type game, then?

/orders
Edited 1 times, most recently on 27/10/05 @ 08:00
Psi
27/10/05 @ 07:03
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Are motorhead a playable race?
krudster [mod]
27/10/05 @ 07:06
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hehe, with Lemmy as lead?
Talha
27/10/05 @ 07:11
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Valdemar=Voldemort?

There are shades of Tolkien AND, er, Rowling in here!!!

And here is the Standard EA-Bash for this forum, proudly presented by me: "I think this game is better than any LOTR stuff EA will ever come up with or for that matter, ANY stuff they will ever come up with and they are just evil like the orcs and LOTR should better lie with this dev rather than those morons at EA..."

Got there first!!!!

/in case you missed it, there is sarcasm in here somewhere!!
bootsy_NL_30
27/10/05 @ 07:28
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
scimrad I agree totally

I can picture it now

Ron the Destroyer attacks Bob the Orc with his sword from Liverpool Army surplus dump....

give me Gorank the mighty or Bromp the orc or whatever any day of the week
Roamer
27/10/05 @ 07:28
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
At which point did EA overtake Microsoft as the most evil game publisher?
Talha
27/10/05 @ 07:39
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Roamer: Actually, MS are the most evil SOFTWARE publisher. EA have the distinction of being the most evil GAME publishers. Geddit?

Incidentally they are also the biggest in their sectors, which just implies that you can sell pure bull to people who are stupid and scale new heights of success. See, the most competent and profitable company in its sector will always be evil no matter what it does. On the other hand, an underdog trying to sell you a machine with a tiny screen capable of playing videos bought by you, otherwise available for free on television, will always be a master of innovation etc etc etc.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 27/10/05 @ 08:37
old_boy
27/10/05 @ 07:47
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Scimarad,

I agree, let's defend fanatasy names to the hilt!

BTW forgive my ignorance if yr name has another origin.

. -)
Xerx3s
27/10/05 @ 08:03
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I think this game is better than any LOTR stuff EA will ever come up with or for that matter, ANY stuff they will ever come up with and they are just evil like the orcs and LOTR should better lie with this dev rather than those morons at EA..."

Well duh, this games scores higher than a 2.0, so its automatically better than anything ea made in the past 8 to 9 years.

"At which point did EA overtake Microsoft as the most evil game publisher? "

ms may be evil in software stuff, but on the games front they are kinda oke. They seem to turn out so pretty good games (AoK i.e.). ea on the other hand is just the root of all evil in this world. ^_^
blizeH
27/10/05 @ 08:19
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Is this an Xbox exclusive?
octo
27/10/05 @ 08:54
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I bought the original on the back of some excellent reviews. And the core gameplay was very good - a little repetitive perhaps. But the glitches in the game utterly ruined it for me. When something is so story driven, having cutscenes where dialogue drops out, characters pop in and out and music screeches (although the music is terribly mismatched anyhow) utterly takes you out of any kind of engagement.

What is the presentation like this time? Equally as buggy a second time around?
Edited 2 times, most recently on 27/10/05 @ 09:56
Teeth
27/10/05 @ 09:04
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
" Scimarad,

I agree, let's defend fanatasy names to the hilt!

BTW forgive my ignorance if yr name has another origin. "


LOL
Dr.Haggard
27/10/05 @ 09:17
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Shame they haven't sorted out the dreadful story and dialogue. I never finished KUF:The Crusaders, partly because no matter how much fun the strategy and fighting bits could be I just couldn't get immersed in the game because the rest of it was so utterly awful.

Every bit of dialogue made me cringe and curse the idiots who wrote it, not to mention the bloody awful voice acting. It's so bad that I was too embarrassed to play the game when anyone else was in the room, despite how impressive the core game can actually be when it's at its best.

My hand still hovers over the box on the shelf occasionally, but rarely do I pick it up. There are always more intelligent and immersive games to play instead, and when I do occasionally pop it in and have a go at playing it again it's not long before I'm poking the 'Off' switch in despair.

You might argue I'm cutting my nose off to spite my face, but personally I like to lose myself in a game, and if I have to stick my fingers in my ears during the godawful dialogue and skip all the cut scenes just to get a bit of visceral fun out of the battles themselves then I might as well play something else.

Anyway, good read Jim, and at least now I know nothing's really changed so I won't be picking this one up.
Firewine
27/10/05 @ 09:37
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Dr.Haggard: Bear in mind that the Korean dialogue has been included this time around, it should make things more tolerable ;)
Dr.Haggard
27/10/05 @ 10:04
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Bear in mind that the Korean dialogue has been included this time around, it should make things more tolerable ;)

Ah, that's interesting. I was hoping they'd do that with Crusaders, shame they didn't as it probably would have helped reduce the cheese factor. I might at least check out the demo for Heroes.
Mirkan
27/10/05 @ 10:14
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Being able to put up with the music must be a huge plus, indeed. This game, like any strategy game, is sloooooooooooow, and that means you'll spend loads of time in each session. After about 10 minutes of relentless korean metal my brain is all mushy and I just want to scream and jump through a window.
bink
27/10/05 @ 10:45
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Off topic: I know grammar-bashing's something of a favoured pastime on EG, but that review really was pretty awful (grammatically, not factually). Okay, I'm an editor so I'm possibly slightly biased, but there's no excuse for some of those mistakes getting through to publication. EG consistently hosts some of the most intelligent and entertaining reviews and articles out there (especially since Edge went to pot), and it'd be a shame to see it fall into the all-too-usual Internet publishing trap of slightly rushed and slapdash copy.

NB: This isn't a comment on the usual standard of EG reviews; it's me paranoidally jumping the gun on a one-off (hopefully) slipping through the net.
Stickman
27/10/05 @ 11:03
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Actually it was pretty slip-shod to be honest.

Game sounds good though, might pick this up in a bargain bin in a few months time. Can you pause the RTS bits to issue orders?
thegamesthething
27/10/05 @ 11:14
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ bink

EG sometimes publish, then edit, as with Civ4 yesterday - the grammar of the review will no doubt organically improve during the day :)
Edited 1 times, most recently on 27/10/05 @ 12:10
krudster [mod]
27/10/05 @ 11:49
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
We appreciate that not all mistakes are spotted. Often, multiple checks miss the most obvious typos, but we're only human, and extremely busy at this particular point of the year (63 reviews in the past month alone).

Rather than bleat that we've failed to spot an error, you'd be doing us a favour by either saying what the error is, or emailing the 'contact@eurogamer.net' address. We'd appreciate it. We hate slip-shod grammar as much as some of you lot evidently do.
Stickman
27/10/05 @ 12:37
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Aye, sorry, I felt a bit of a tart for saying that to be honest. You're doing a bang up job, keep up the good work!
kangarootoo
27/10/05 @ 12:52
#22
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
For the record, I don't personally mind if the proof reading takes second bat to a higher volume of informative articles. With only 24 hours in the day I think you are all doing a fine old job. Just my 2p.
bink
27/10/05 @ 13:25
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm only concerned 'cos I loves ya.

EG is the best review site by a long way, and a spelling mistake here and there isn't going to stop me reading it.... That piece just set alarm bells ringing.
Scimarad
27/10/05 @ 19:04
#24
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"I agree, let's defend fanatasy names to the hilt!

BTW forgive my ignorance if yr name has another origin. "

:-)

Yep, it's a planet name from a P&P RPG I was running. Buggered if I know why I keep using it...
Edited 1 times, most recently on 27/10/05 @ 20:00
Teeth
28/10/05 @ 09:14
#25
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"For the record, I don't personally mind if the proof reading takes second bat to a higher volume of informative articles. With only 24 hours in the day I think you are all doing a fine old job. Just my 2p."

This is not the training I remember dragging your sorry ass through, soldier! STAND TO ATTENTION WHEN I'M TALKING TO YOU! What the hell do you think you're playing at, eh? Trying to undermine this great country's noble and refined mode of communication? Eh? EH?
Xerx3s
28/10/05 @ 09:44
#26
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
*barf*
Krun
30/10/05 @ 05:09
#27
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I have the first xbox one.
Never finished it. the acting in it just put me off so much I just want to kill my own war leaders and join the other side
"Lets kill them goddamn russki...eh I mean Orcs, USA rocks Sir!!!"

A Fantasy game where the "heroes" have broad American GI Heroes accents just don't sit well with me. The Heavy metal sound track just echos this travesty of clashing style throughout the battles.

The battles didn't seem to make up for this as the reward for completing them was more of this bilge.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 30/10/05 @ 05:05

Comments: 1-27 of 27 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery