Original Beatles advising on Rock Band Comments by Ellie Gibson
McCartney's been heckling the designers.
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total
Poster
|
4thVariety
25/06/09 @ 08:40
0
They were involved. I'm not going to put words in their mouth, but seeing all four of them at the Microsoft press event
All four of them?? Is there something fishy going on at Harmonix involving some sort of necromancy? Or do we list Yoko Ono as a Beatle now? |
|
-6
The living Beatles, and the wives of the dead ones
Do you think you could write about these people with just a little more respect? Not just for the fact that they're part of one of the indisputably greatest musical groups of all time, but just the fact that they're fellow human beings? "The living Beatles, and the wives of those no longer with us.." or "The living Beatles, and the wives of Lennon and Harrison.." Either of those would have been nicer. |
|
+3
"They were involved. I'm not going to put words in their mouth, but seeing all four of them at the Microsoft press event is about as validating as everything."
Validating? What I saw of that press event actually seemed to show that they had about as much interest and involvement in the project as Tom Clancy did in HAWX. |
|
Triggerhappytel
25/06/09 @ 09:16
+1
Bloody hell schnide, calm down; it's only a throwaway news story! Besides, it's written by Ellie who doesn't do sensitivity.
EDIT - also, I agree with Skillian. I doubt they really give a shit, so long as (potentially) their album sales increase as a result and their royalty cheques come through in a timely fashion.
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 25/06/09 @ 10:17
|
|
jack_klugman
25/06/09 @ 09:18
+8
"They don't get together for almost anything... It has to be something important, something they believe in."
Money. |
|
0
"They don't get together for almost anything... It has to be something important, something they believe in."
Right, something they believe in. In all likelihood, the only thing all of them believe in is a biiiig pile of cash. Basically, the guy says they glanced over it, and one of them even told them he played the bass with a plectron instead of finger-picking. Still, I'm a big Beatles fan and I guess this could be a very nice game. I'm also a big Ellie fan, but just quoting some carefully worded PR bits tells me nothing of much value. |
|
0
@Triggerhappytel
I'm perfectly calm. Just because this article was written by someone with breasts, doesn't mean I lose my objectivity. I've been raised to believe it's nice not to talk ill of the dead, and especially the dead who had more talent in their right hand than you or I have in our entire bodies. |
|
+2
And her fucking their granddaughters would be bad because..?
It read to me like it was deliberately harsh-worded to get a small laugh out of it or to setup a tone for the rest of the article. If I'm right about that, it's disrespectful and it's cheap journalism. If I'm wrong about that, I apologise. |
|
Triggerhappytel
25/06/09 @ 12:03
0
@schnide
"I'm perfectly calm. Just because this article was written by someone with breasts, doesn't mean I lose my objectivity." And I made no mention of the fact she's female, so I'm not sure why you've focused on that. I try not to speak ill of the dead either, but like Liam said, I think Ellie's comment was a little informal but hardly offensive or in need of editing. Anyway, I don't want to be confrontational over this and I appreciate everyone has a different opinion (particularly over a topic which can be so sensitive) so I can see how you might find this a little more jarring than I. Fair enough. |
|
-1
"The greatest enemy to human souls is the self-righteous spirit which makes men look to themselves for salvation."
I disagree with that. My greatest hope for salvation lies in me, not anyone else. But then I am the nuts. I wouldn't, for instance, feed my baby a huge Greggs sausage roll and watch him get fat at the age of 2 like the women I saw on the bus just now. Or allow my kids to get some shit tattoo halfway down their arm. But that's just me. *rant over* |
Comments: 1-23 of 23 in total
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Advertisement
