Jump to navigation
Advertisement

NHL 2K7 Review

Xbox 360 Review by Matt Martin

22 December, 2006

All those guns and muscles and pumped-up shouting and macho tactics - honestly, sometimes games are embarrassing. The more mature they try to be, the more they look like kids' fantasies. It's tiring. Give me a tough and exhilarating sports game any day. Hockey, that's where it's at. Checking opponents, slamming the puck, weaving in and out, landing flat on your arse and grinding you teeth in last minute tension. Man's stuff.

After last year's hanging port of the Xbox version of NHL 2K6 to 360, this year we've got the real deal - the best ice hockey game on console, complete with all the beauty we expect from this new-fangled next-gen.

What we don't get is a leap in innovation, like we've experienced with the right stick control in EA's NHL 07. We can't have it all. Playing 2K's effort after getting used to EA's Skill Stick (where the analogue stick is used as the hockey stick, in a similar way to Fight Night's sticks-as-arms control method) is actually a bit of a shock at first, but give it an hour and you'll forget you've experienced a glimpse of the future.

Back to the game on hand. NHL 2K7's big change for this season is a curiosity, which actually begins to endear itself quite quickly. The Cinemotion presentation drops TV commentary and features in favour of upping the drama to sports movie levels. With an orchestral score, poor play is accompanied by sombre composition, while any comeback or white-hot skills are rewarded with a rousing soundtrack.

'NHL 2K7' Screenshot 1

It's a trick that was first pumped out in SSX, with a customised soundtrack that reacts to play. Although it sounds off-putting, it actually grows on you. Not innovation then, but nice to see some developers are willing to approach presentation a little differently. Especially in a sports game. It's like when the BBC Orchestra scores highlights of a football match and completely goes off on one with noodling guitars and dramatic strings. Or at least they used to in the '80s, back when I were a lad. Nowadays it's all Hot Chip, RjD2 and Mark Ronson soundtracks on yer sports TV.

Control-wise it's as responsive and slick as we've come to expect. There are a few new moves, the most useful of which are the drop pass (back through the player's legs) and a pressure control where tapping the left bumper instructs team-mates to apply a little pressure to troublesome opponents. Tap it once and it's just a case of bothering your opponent, like a fly at a picnic. Tap it three times and your boys will check him hard, like a damn rhino just sprinted across your sandwiches.

'NHL 2K7' Screenshot 2

During Franchise mode there's a little more emphasis on rivalry between players, with bonuses added to player stats for competing successfully against a rival team. It's nothing major, but it's a smart addition. As is the phone calls from your team owner. In a similar method, players can utilise bonuses depending on recent news, so sponsorship will boost a player's performance for a couple of games. You don't have to take the calls either, so bad news won't affect your team if you ignore it. Of course, you have no idea whether you're going to receive good or bad news, so there's a few nice little gambling opportunities to consider during a season.

Online mode is what many will be picking the game up for. Compared to its rival EA effort, it's a monster. Tournament and season for between four and 30 different teams is the big draw, with stat tracking via the 2K Sports site. There are mini-games and single matches for between two and eight different players too, and with little or no lag, you can expect to put a serious amount of time into online games.

'NHL 2K7' Screenshot 3

As I said at the beginning, NHL 2K7 is a beauty to look at, which helps bring the matches to life on the ice. Animation is realistic and smooth, with character models and their clothing flowing as they glide, check, deke and slam the puck into the back of the net. Motion and inertia feels much more relevant this year, so there's no chance of changing direction radically, which actually makes the player consider space and positioning on the ice much more tactically. With players shouting while in the match, and the coach hollering throughout a game, there's a real vibrancy in the stadiums. Switch that commentary off though, it's just background chatter. Oh, and there's a mad Sub Pop soundtrack, which might not be to many people's tastes, but is actually pretty appropriate to the rowdy atmosphere.

So NHL 2K7 hasn't leapt forward this year, but it has smartened up its act. It looks top-bollocks, and plays as good as it always has done. The way I see it is that for 50 quid I want the best experience from my game, whatever the genre. I don't want novelty or an eight-hour campaign that I won't play again. Nor do I want just above average or something to pass the time. Like Eric Roberts, I want the best of the best. NHL 2K7 represents the best value for money out there, and it plays like a dream. Seriously, you're doing yourselves a disservice by buying all those guns-and-tits games that get hyped. That's nonsense. Get yourself a proper man's game, and grow a pair of balls while you're at it.

9/10

Read our Scoring Policy

Advertisement

Are you excited about NHL 2K7 on Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-21 of 21 in total

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
FabricatedLunatic
23/12/06 @ 14:53
#1
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
There goes the first £30 or so of my Christmas money. I loved 2K5 and reckon that it's time to get a new version.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 23/12/06 @ 14:54
Dermoth
23/12/06 @ 14:58
#2
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Blah blah Gears blah blah.

I love me some hockey videogame. I'd rather watch highly toxic paint dry on the inside of my eyelids than sit through an actual ice hockey match, but it's probably the best sport for gaming there is.

Blah rhubarb Gears etc.
Yossarian
23/12/06 @ 15:31
#3
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
tempted to buy this or the basketball one, either thought I have a limited knowledge of both sports

just seems like a good game to have around for friends over the Christmas period
AgentFosterGrant
23/12/06 @ 15:49
#4
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
What frod said. So good they used it twice.
udat
23/12/06 @ 15:57
#5
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
is it even remotely accessible to someone only passingly familar with hockey who last played a hockey game on the megadrive?

I tried 2K4 (i think) on the xbox but the controls and game in general were just horrifically complicated.

-Udat
captainrentboy
23/12/06 @ 16:16
#6
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I saw a dig at G.O.W in that review there,DAMMMMMMIT!
:)
Xerx3s
23/12/06 @ 17:06
#7
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
A few more page hit's before Christmas never hurts, right?
petebritish
23/12/06 @ 17:17
#8
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Have not played hockey since the megadrive nhlpa93 that was class.Hope its as good. Notice Gamestation have it in stores at £29.99 as part of buy one get one free. So not bad could get this plus NBA2k7 for £30 not bad. Too many games not enough time.
Darren
23/12/06 @ 18:46
#9
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This score really shows how different people's opinions of games can be, particularly as most of the Xbox 360 magazines weren't bowled over by this game and most gave it 6 or 7/10 at most.

To be honest, I can see where they're coming from as I own the game but it's not that different from the nine month old NHL 2K6 really; slightly improved graphics (that still don't use anti-aliasing), a few tweaks here and there and some awful menus (to match NBA 2K7's awful menus). At times it's hard to spot the differences over the version to be honest.

Good game but it's an 8/10 at most. 9/10 is far too generous for a game that isn't really that different from it's less-than-one-year-old predecessor. I think EG are being a little over generous myself, a touch too much Christmas sherry perhaps? ;)
BBIAJ
23/12/06 @ 19:01
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Ah, but for those yet to go next gen hockey, can they not be allowed to bump it back up to EG's score of a 9?

;o)
PhakeDC
23/12/06 @ 19:11
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
NHL2K1 on the Dreamcast was ace. I bought NHL2004 two years later and wasn't really impressed. Is there a PC version?
KiLlerKnight
23/12/06 @ 19:43
#12
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
What about the bugs? On the 2k forum they talk about the game being unplayable because it freezes all the time. Every version has that freeze bug, including the new ps3 one. And according to those people Take 2 are blaming the 360 harddisk or something and refuse to make a patch. If that is true, and why not those people don't have a reason to make things up, EA's effort seems the better one.
Clive Dunn
23/12/06 @ 22:53
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I pray at the altar of the 2k series of US sports games, they are head and shoulders above EA.

Bring back the NFL !
mkreku
24/12/06 @ 04:32
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I am so getting this!

And I am beginning to suspect that Eurogamer, too, are sick and tired of the over-hype the rather mediocre Gears of War has been getting. It's less than ten hours long, all you do is shoot and hide, shoot and hide and the multiplayer (even with its chainsaw glory) is for four people! FOUR PEOPLE! I just can't get myself excited about that.
ruckus
24/12/06 @ 06:32
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I agree with you KiLlerKnight, I've heard the same things.
I've always been pissed at the nhl 2Kx sports stuff because they've always had the better game of hockey but screw it all up due to bugs. I'm not going to bother with it until they release something that plays well in 2 player season/franchise mode.
I just wish I could play ALL sports games in franchise mode with the option of both players being on the same team without it srewing up some time along the way.

So looks like it's either inferior 360 EA hockey* or none at all...

*I'm guessing that 2k plays a better game of hockey but fecks it all up in the long term. I don't play online, so it's the 2 player season/franchise mode that I'm interested in.
mattigan
24/12/06 @ 07:18
#16
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
But can you make Wayne Gretsky's head bleed? The real mark of a great Hockey game!
Der_tolle_Emil
24/12/06 @ 08:12
#17
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
But can you make Wayne Gretsky's head bleed? The real mark of a great Hockey game!

Now that you mention Wayne Gretzky; I want Wayne Gretzky 3D Hockey (N64) on virtual console. That was a damn fun game.
morriss
24/12/06 @ 09:10
#18
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Wow! 9/10 for a game I have absolutely no interest in whatsoever. Ice-Hockey's a girls game.
KiLlerKnight
24/12/06 @ 09:45
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Just saw some NHL match on CNN. So this defender was fighting for the puck in front of his goal. He pushed the attacker against the goal quite hard, but in icehockey terms quite 'normal'. So the referee stopped the game, and this defender was just standing not looking at the same attacker. The moron attacker stands up and gave the poor guy a one hit KO in the neck, ouch! He is suspended for 10 games or so, LOL. 10 games, c'mon at least half a season is what he deserves.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 24/12/06 @ 09:46
phl0w
25/12/06 @ 14:16
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I doubt you put enough time into the game to justify a 9/10 review. Having played every predecessor from 2K1 to 2K6, I'm now in the second season of my Franchise and quit because of all the flaws and bugs. It's actually a major step back from 2K6, let alone 2K5.
Goaltenders are one of the worst in the series (kicking and diving in the most unrealistic of ways), CPU Offense is messed up (One-Timer, anyone?), checking is too effective (especially open-ice hits) and kills the flow of the game as skaters loose momentum when they are touched even slightly, commentary hasn't changed, and puts you to sleep, shot power is unrealistically low resulting in the dreaded "floating" shots, D-men still can't hold the blue line effectively, and the list goes on and those are only gameplay flaws when you're actually on the ice. Don't even get me started on the flaws in game modes like Franchise, which is the heart of any hockey game (Dynasty in EA's game). Gameplay wise 2K5 was the peak of the series so far. Goaltending-wise it's 2K6 on the cg XBox.
Oh, but the new camera view (parametric) is very good, could have created the most immersive hockey game, if it wasn't for all the other flaws in presentation (commentary, cut-scenes, fog, face-off, ...)

Sorry, but I don't think one should base his purchase decision on this review.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 25/12/06 @ 14:18
BBIAJ
26/12/06 @ 04:52
#21
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ phl0w:

Fog? EH!?

Comments: 1-21 of 21 in total

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

X View gallery