Molyneux would give Fable 2 9/10 Comments by Tom Bramwell
Bias claim probably for once justified.
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Poster
|
Sir_TimAlot
02/09/08 @ 08:11
0
i would give the crap i took this morning a 9/10 to.
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 02/09/08 @ 09:12
|
|
the_dudefather
02/09/08 @ 08:25
0
"When I think back to Dungeon Keeper, and even the original Fable, they were incredibly guilty of having those mechanics in them where at the end of the day you think, 'So what?'"
Don't you talk smack about Dungeon Keeper! Thats probably the best game you will ever make! Anyway, to be fair, if asked, what would be an acceptable score to give your own game when asked, 10 is too high, 8 and under could be seen as 'oh he must think his game is rubbish if he give it that'
Edited 1 times,
most recently on 02/09/08 @ 09:27
|
|
GamesProgrammer
02/09/08 @ 08:28
0
Hmm if the ultimateley over hyping biased maker only gives it a 9 that doesnt bode well
|
|
andywilkie35
02/09/08 @ 08:33
0
He's said its the most complete game ever but says its only a 9/10, which I think is fair enough in a way, he clearly means that no game can justify a 10 out of 10 because nothing that has been made yet is absolute perfection
I personally thought "Shaq Fu" was perfection however |
|
0
DOG POLISH OTHERWISE KNOWN AS NO CONTROL - YES YOU CAN NOW NOT FOR A LIMITED TIME NOT CONTROL THE DOG IN FABLE 2. THIS REVOLUTIONARY FEATURE COMES FROM LOTS OF COMPLAINTS WE RECEIVED ABOUT THEME PARK BECAUSE THERE WASN'T ENOUGH NOT-CONTROLLING OF DOGS.
OH GO ON THEN, CONTROL THE DOG.... PSYCH! YOU CAN'T! I WAS BEING COY EARLIER THIS IS NOT A 9/10 IT'S A 10/DOG I MEAN 10 |
|
0
The 9/10 he was referring to wasn't what review score he thought it was worth, but rather how it compared to "his original vision". Which, given how outlandish they usually are, means that it must be a damn good achievement.
All the sites that are running this story today of course prefer the more controversial version of the story it seems. |
|
captainrentboy
02/09/08 @ 09:01
0
I can't fooking wait for this game, this, Dead Space, GOW2 and Banjo 3 will hopefully provide a great gaming end to the year.
To be fair, I haven't seen anything on this game where I've thought ''Uh-oh, that's looking kind of shitty'', the only downer is the already reported fairly average game length. |
|
WinterSnowblind
02/09/08 @ 09:02
0
What's with the hate on the first Fable? Although ultimately disappointing because of the hype, it was still a solid game, infact it was easily one of the best games on the Xbox, very original and a lot of fun to play. If you've been paying any attention to the sequel, it HASN'T been being overhyped, he's takled about it very little and whenever he's talked about the new amazing features, it's only been when they're complete and actually in the game, and are usually accompanied by a video demonstartion, unlike with the original were it seemed he was making up new features that may eventually be added.
|
|
MightyMouse
02/09/08 @ 09:02
0
@Lutz
Bashing Fable by far, there's the whole extra dimension provided by PM. |
|
Triggerhappytel
02/09/08 @ 09:15
0
And likewise I expect Dennis Dyack would have given Too Human 9/10.
This means absolutely nothing; is PM just upset that he hadn't been in an EG news story for a week or two? |
|
0
I must admit I'm a bit sceptical about Fable 2 but still looking forward to it nevertheless (it's pre-ordered!). I've been a big fan of Peter Molyneux's work since playing Populous on the Amiga years and years ago and Dungeon Keeper 2 and Magic Carpet are two of my faves. Sadly I thought the original Fable was a tad underwhelming, having undelivered on its promises, but it wasn't a bad game par se, just a terribly ordinary one albeit one with a delightfully English feel to it (like Rare's games too). I really do hope that this game turns out to be everything the first one should have been... it certainly looks a lot of fun in the (few) videos I've seen. And I can't wait to have my own dog! :)
|
|
0
"Hmm if the ultimateley over hyping biased maker only gives it a 9 that doesnt bode well "
There was an article about this a while back, turns out that all the 'hype' is largely the media's fault by twisting his words. I.e. When he said that they where exploring the concept of open world it would then be printed as 'it will have an open world!'. "I wonder what he gave the first (and incredible bad) Fable game? " Just because you thought fable was bad, doesn't mean that it is. If it was, the fable 2 thread wouldn't be filled with tons of people who are very much looking out to the refreshing style. |
|
Britesparc
02/09/08 @ 09:41
0
I really liked the first Fable but I still wouldn't give it 29/10. That's just silly.
|
|
0
Molyneux ALWAYS does this. He's been doing it since the days of the Amiga.
You'll first hear about the new game he's working on, and he'll say it's the most revolutionary game since his last one, except this one has all the features he promised last time but this time it will REALLY have them! Then the game is near completion, and he'll still say it's the best game he's ever worked on (who would ever say that their new title isn't as good as their last?) and that hey, even though a few things he wanted to do didn't quite work out, he really really likes this one. Cue reviews that say it's fun, cute but essentially average and forgettable - repeat to line 2. |
|
0
"I really liked the first Fable but I still wouldn't give it 29/10. That's just silly. "
Spot the person who didn't read it. ;) "I wish people would read the actual interview before flying off the handle: "I'd rate it a 9 out of 10," Molyneux added, when asked if he'd fulfilled his original vision with Fable II." This is exactly what I mean. Here is an idea, why don't people try to best him in accomplishments instead of being so grumpy. In the mean time, try to avoid this as much as possible if you will. |
|
General_Zod
02/09/08 @ 10:51
0
@septimus
Aye forget Dungeon Keeper, give me a new Syndicate. I had so much fun burning people with the flamethrower. |
|
0
Maybe he meant best game I've ever done for Microsoft - Populous 2 was a 10/10 without question. :P
I found the original ACE manazine review online (you can too) of Populous 2, it scored a 985/1000, one of the highest rankings in that excellent magazine ever. It was in the period that the magazine was at its very peak too, with wonderful 6 page reviews and a review system that many could learn from in this day and age. God that magazine was awesome. |
|
JediMasterMalik
02/09/08 @ 10:57
0
This is useless without him rating his other game, or at least with a decent comparison.
|
|
0
"So he's a gobshite because he thinks his game is good?,
go fuck yourself gobshite" awesome! no hes a gobshite because he thinks everything he does is 'gold' and for some reason manages to get quoted as such in any publication/website that'll give him airspace. i'd rather see him have a little humility / modesty rather than being the biggest gob on legs because hes proven himself wrong on several occasions. chew on that after you've finished chewing your dads dick. |
|
0
A new Syndicate or Dungeon Keeper... they'd be fantastic. However, no matter how much you and I want them, Molyneux can't deliver them to you. EA owns the intellectual rights to those and all the other Bullfrog franchises when they bought the company from Molyneux and Edgar (Populous, Powermonger, Magic Carpet, Theme Park, Gene Wars... etc).
|
Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!
Advertisement
