Neverwinter Nights 2 toolset
Bad workmen blame their tools. And not reading the manual.
The map won't scroll.
Normally admissions of complete incompetence are something to be avoided when writing about games, in favour of cultivating an aura of general infallibility. Obviously I completed the game on Expert, blindfolded, while having Rossignol flick my earlobe in an attempt to distract me from the task at hand. Do you think I'd dare write a review of Totally Average Ultra-Hyped Big Franchise Game Which Has All The Fanboys In The World without having done that? This is a little different. We're having a look at the toolset that comes with Neverwinter Nights 2, which we deliberately didn't consider. Here incompetence is absolutely key to my qualifications in writing this.
You see, the Neverwinter 2 toolset is enormously powerful. Clearly, as Obsidian actually made the game with it. However, almost all major PC games come with some manner of editing tools that they used to make the game with. It's not actually just the top-end of the power that's relevant. The promise with Neverwinter Nights is towards the bottom end, the level of power it puts in the hands of those of us whose native language isn't assembly.
To see how good NWN is at that I did the following. Firstly, work my way through the basic tutorials including, skipping anything which looks like a bit like hard-work. Secondly, start a clock and see what manner of adventure I can construct in two hours precisely. And thirdly, write about it.
Admissions about my prior skill in these: I once programmed a game in Easy Amos back when I was teenage and had more brain cells. I was kind of Project Lead on a moderately successful Deus Ex mod, but didn't actually do any of the map editing or similar (just did all the conversations). And I know the Dungeons and Dragons rules with a splash more than a layman's familiarity, so I won't be wasting time wondering what's the difference between Constitution and Strength. Finally, I have a splash of experience with the Neverwinter 1's Aurora construction kit, where I spent about an hour and a half fiddling with it when it came out. Clearly, I remember nothing of that, and certainly not how to scroll the map.
Anyway - onwards.
Existential horror, the RPG construction kit way.
The top of the actual tutorial document helps by providing a big list of what's new to the toolkit, handily divided into World Creation and Usability sections. In the first, elements like Terrain Painting, uniquely generated trees, weather control, dynamic day cycles, increased armour customisations (but they spell it "Armor", because they're uppity colonials), an editor for the special effects, the ability to scale objects (which I kind of fall in love with later), Global Scripting (which I read and know in my heart of hearts I'll never get) and better camera controls for cinematics. In terms of usability, there's a lot of streamlining going on. For example, the customisable workspace element allows you to place tools better, and a better conversation editor allows you to "pass parameters to scripts and assign multiple conditional and action scripts", which sounds terribly exciting. Yes. Also, you're able to have multiple working areas open at once - for example, typing a conversation while having a couple of maps available, which even for a newbie like me is an obvious boon. Also, there's the ability to create plugins a la Photoshop, which has the aura of something considerably beyond the boundaries of this little piece.
Skimming down past the "What is a Module" sections - it's a module, of course! - I hit the important issue of making a first area. Create an outdoors area, eventually locate the "Start Position" function and save. Load up the game and... OMFG!!! I'm in a game within five minutes. Marvellous.
The tutorials progress through the basics of placing objects, scenery, putting things in containers, putting down monsters, setting up basic conversations, creating custom objects and... well, seriously. You'll have noticed by now that we've actually got the absolute basics of getting an adventure working. Which is what I was hoping for. When I was conceiving this exercise, I knew that we'd be able to make something in two hours. If this was Valve's Source Engine, I'm sure I'd have worked out how to put down some corridors, some guns and a few people to shoot - the perennial joy of constructing a first-person shooting game is how relatively easy it is to create something which, at some ridiculously reduced level, resembles the game proper. Conversely, the problem with - say - editing Deus Ex is that just lobbing some things down in a mass doesn't actually create something that works in any noticeable way like the main game, since it's so much more reliant on exploration, plot and so on.
A role-playing game like Neverwinter Nights is in a similar situation. Sure, a dungeon could be easy to do, if the underground levels work in the way that NWN does (insides are made from having large squares which click together, in some manner of subterranean-despot interior-decorator Lego-esque manner), but a dungeon isn't an adventure. An adventure needs a situation, a plot, a twist, a reason for doing things. And already, in the hour or so I've been working through the tutorial, I have the skill to do something at a basic level.
Well, at a very basic level anyway. There's a section on scripting, which looks a little too much like programming to me, and I just page-downed past that. And despite all this information I've been given efficiently, I still don't know how to scroll the map. The only guidance in how to do it is a note near the top saying that you can rotate the map with by holding down the third-mouse button, and zoom in and out with the mouse-wheel, but that can't be the only way of moving around the view, surely? I'm tempted to go hit a NWN forum to see if I can get more help, but that'll be breaking my self-imposed rules. Instead, I work from one side of the keyboard to the other, desperately pressing each key. None of them seem to do anything which I'd like to. Man!
Still, it doesn't matter. I can actually get it to do what I want to via this bizarre rotate and zoom approach, so I set a time. 8th November, 10pm. Finish time, 12 midnight. Let's go!
I've already got a vague conception of what I want to do. Basic "find object for reason" sort of set-up. To do that, I'll need two zones, one external and one internal. By 10:35, both are constructed to my vague satisfaction. Despite the instructions saying that making a decent outside zone is much more work than an internal, my outside - er - turns out far better. Experienced with the bio-lab floor in Startopia, the raising and reducing of ground, then retexturing it is very familiar. A small lake. Some trees. A tiny village - in fact, a hamlet. A cave. What a veritable world of fantasy clichés I've created!
Underground is more problematic, which makes me feel dumb when it's clearly far easier. My problem is that I basically skimmed over the section on clicking together tiles, and my resultant dungeon has some visible holes in it where I've put the wrong pieces in place. Still, aesthetics are secondary here, and I haven't time to be perfectionist. I connect the two with area transition bits, as I haven't time to work out how doors work, and boot up to test. It works, but I discover that the doors work just the same way as area transitions. No time to fix.
The third option in any RPG must always be 'YOU MUST DIE!!!'
Next sweep adds the NPCs to the world. I've got two major speaking characters, one which involves creating my own villager template and the other involving gleeful experimentation with the object-scaling. Both are set up so they'll wander up to the player when they reach a certain area. Since I haven't read the section on scripting, I end up having all the adventurers' weapons in a closet in the village. Why a closet? Chests just seemed a bit played out. Assorted unimportant villages are lobbed down for colour. I wonder how I could make them wander around? Probably something with waypoints, but... well, minor details. Heading underground, I select the lizardmen and lob down half a dozen or so to guard the treasure, which I make (a unique plot item "thing") them store in a chest. Yeah, chests are back in. Deal with it.
This has actually taken longer than you'd think. The thing with the toolset is creating big-scale content is easy. Zones can come together, in a remedial, undecorated sense, enormously quickly. But having someone chat to you, that's content that requires an actual degree of work. Still, I've got enough time to made some secondary conversations for the main NPCs - including some branching and moderately clever stuff - and playtest it a couple of times. I discover I've been a bit too optimistic in how hard a level 1 NPC is, so remove some of the lizardpeople and add some healing potions to the closet in the village. Also, there's a major graphical problem in the dungeon which I haven't the time to read the documentation to work out how to fix, so instead I do something I do know, and set a third conversation to a Lizardman NPC.
Try and ignore the holes in the walls. I was (er) in a rush.
The two hours click around and... well, I'm finished, and a quest - of sorts - remains. The basic fantasy story arc's there - villagers in trouble, you going to solve the problem, end up having to retrieve an object from a place of peril. If I had another hour, I'd have actually read the scripting and got it to do the very basic thing I needed it to - that is, recognise when you were holding the object you had to rescue, and only run the victory conversation then. Oh yeah - and actually entered a Quest dialogue in the player's journal. They'd have probably been time to elaborate in a few other areas. The dungeon's incredibly bare, but stocking it with interesting objects - pots, perhaps. Or maybe pans - would have been as easy as clicking. Traps would be another simple thing, a case of marking the area and selecting what's hurting. More jokey NPCs...
And that hour would have been eaten up. Role-playing games devour content, which is where the strength of a toolset like NWN is. Rather than wrestling with the toolset, you're wrestling with the enormity of the task you've set yourself.
Anyway - my adventure. Two hours. Forgive me. It's not exactly Planescape Torment.
And the toolset generally? It does exactly what it promises. It won't make it easy to make your own adventures. Nothing will, as it's always going to be a lot of work. But even for the total layperson, there's the ability to incarnate your fantasy into some manner of digital flesh. Just wasting a Sunday afternoon in a pleasurable way, never bothering to learn how to make the map scroll because that'll involve reading the documentation. And for someone who's more serious - well, it's probably your first step to being the next Chris Avellone.
You may also like...
-
Gravity Rush Review 54
-
Sony patents method to interrupt your gaming with an ad 127
-
Wii U Aliens: Colonial Marines is best-looking version because of console's "more modern tech" 92
-
XCOM: Enemy Unknown Preview: First Contact 11
-
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning needed to sell 3 million to break even 75
-
Activision vs. Vince Zampella and Jason West: Inside the game industry trial of the decade 73
-
Arma 3 in-engine footage shows off lighting tech 24
-
Skyrim gets mounted combat in new update 60
-
Jet Set Radio announced for PlayStation Vita 31
-
App of the Day: Go Robo! 3
-
Ghost Recon: Future Soldier Review 132
-
Dirt Showdown Review 90
-
Minecraft overtakes Black Ops on XBL activity chart 26
-
Minecraft total sales hit 9.2 million 9
-
Anarchy Reigns delayed in the West, Platinum says 13
Comments (30) Latest comment 4 years ago
Comments for this article are now closed, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
(Actually, considering it was literally done as I describe, it's pretty impressive. But it's pretty rubbish).
KG
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Aye aye sailor!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
or am I misremembering...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Of course, the one thing that isn't mentioned in this article is that Module Creation Time eats into your actual Game Playing Time like nothing else...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Very.
"Indeed, the writing is top class. But you don't really see it in the first hour of gameplay."
The first hour? I played for the first 4 hours then sold the game on.
TBH, If you're used to far superior console RPGs then look elsewhere, if you like the sound of faffing around in map editors and stuff, without caring for the main game, try this instead. I tried this editing lark, and really couldn't be bothered with it all.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
If you enjoyed Baldur's Gate 2, you'll enjoy this.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Ah, of course. Ok.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Thinking about it, I suspect the Dwarf Fighter may be my favourite RPG NPC of the year so far. I was giggling like an idiot.
KG
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I guess you'll have to just take my word that I play alot of RPGs (not just FF) across alot of platforms, and the story in NWN2 (which was the main reason i bought it) didn't strike a chord with me. I so wanted to like it, but the characters were not likable (even my own attempt to make my character look good, failed misrably) the story wasn't engaging and the amount of bugs throwing me around the place was just dismal.
Oh and ironically, i hated the story in FF8 (even though i finished it which is more than i can say for NWN2) so go figure on that one.
EDIT: I should still be entitled to an opinion if not for just being an ardent RPG player and fan of the genre - BUT as someone who has bought and played this, regardless of my poor choice in names...
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Danbojones: So you like Hack-and-slash roleplaying, yeah?
KG
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Oblivion is a cliché + boredom, Gothic 3 is too bug filled and performance issued to play and that leaves what?
Console RPGs ... oh well, lets ALL import FF XII, play Enchanted Arms and KH2 because that is about it.
I play a lot of RPGs too and at it stands we cannot aford to be too much picky, the days of Troika are gone and you are not going to get FO(s) or BG(s) any time soon, let alone PS:T(s).
NwN2 is kinda within BG1 and BG2, a bit better that BG1 but not reaching BG2.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Sorry Keiron, but I really don't care about you. I want to know what this game is like. Please cut the waffle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Anyway: I also bought NWN1 because I devoted a scary amount of time to the infinity engine over the course of it's lifespan and hoped for a game that would let me enjoy some more hours of funny and quirky characters, dialog and inspired quests. But no. Go here. Go to these four areas, collect 4 items and return to the main area to progress. Ad infinitum. And it looked like shit. So yes, I personally felt shafted by NWN, but if I had been inclined to get back into modding again i'm sure the toolkit would have kept me busy for a long time.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Have you even read the article? It's not a review of the game, it's about his personal experiences with the toolkit.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
>>never bothering to learn how to make the map scroll because that'll involve reading the documentation
rofl. Never read the documentation!
Comment below viewing threshold Show
And no i dont have cd emulators etc running....
Strange how some companies think screwing normal customers helps sales
Comment below viewing threshold Show
I remember my writing the exact same thing a couple years ago on planetneverwinter about NWN. Did you copy my post from there?
You can argue all you want about it, NWN IS all about the toolset, the campaign only shows you what the toolset is capable of. In fact it's an application you pay for, that comes with one big- free- exemplary piece of work done with it. simple as that.
Comment below viewing threshold Show
Says who? I bet there are more people who buy NWN for the single-player campaign than people who want to use the toolset and/or download modules.
Comment below viewing threshold Show