Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 3 Next

Advertisement

DJ Hero Review

Xbox 360 PlayStation 2 PlayStation 3 Wii
Review by Johnny Minkley

30 October, 2009

Page 1 of 3. Page 2 ->

The turnaround has been astonishing. Guitar Hero launched in 2005, its first set-list composed extensively of cover versions, with the music industry's nostrils too busy sweeping lustily over cisterns to pay it much heed. Developer Harmonix was virtually required to shuffle up to record label doors, cap in hand, begging for whatever scraps of licensed music were lying around.

$2 billion and 25 million sales later, someone else is now wearing the trousers in this increasingly noisy relationship, and so DJ Hero arrives this week with an emperor's fanfare and a marketing budget beyond the wildest fantasies of the original Guitar Hero team. Indeed, as I type this, fizzing flutes are clinking at the DJ Hero London launch bash where, the game's official Twitter feed hics, "DJ Shadow two hour set rocked the house!" Not this one, buddy.

But the point is that DJ Shadow features heavily in the game, both as content and semi-shrouded avatar. And he's hardly alone. Jay-Z, Eminem, Daft Punk, Grandmaster Flash, Scratch Perverts, Z-Trip and DJ Yoda are just some of the Who's Who of stars actively involved in the project, from inception through to release.

Somewhere beneath this megabucks power-mongering is FreeStyleGames, and a tale of two studios: one in glamorous Leamington Spa, handling the game development; the other in trendier east London, devoted exclusively to mix-creation. It's this that starts to mark DJ Hero out as something different from other music games.

The 93 mixes on the game disc, blended from a pool of some 100 tracks, have been created exclusively and specifically for the title. At best, a Guitar Hero or Rock Band product is a game and a greatest hits compilation. DJ Hero's vital, varied, surprising and vast musical content is as fresh to a music gamer's ears as the gameplay is to their fingers.

'DJ Hero' Screenshot 1

As a first-timer, DJ Hero boasts a phenomenal cast of superstar DJ talent, like sci-fi weirdos Daft Punk.

It's brilliant. Different strokes for different folks and all that, but it's hard to imagine any interested gamer not finding something to inspire them here, whether it's the cocksure Euro-sleaze of Queen crowned by Daft Punk, the prankish eargasm of Vanilla Ice melted into MC Hammer, or the synapse-frying relentlessness of Scratch Perverts' Noisia.

The music is divided into 24 distinct sets, some artist-specific - "Jay-Z Mixtape", "DJ Shadow presents", and so on - others compiled thematically by FreeStyle. This provides a compelling structure that accentuates the game's unexpected diversity, with some sets leaning heavily on frenzied scratching, while others fly more familiar button combos down the vinyl track at the player.

Let's talk turntable. While DJ Hero's peripheral carries the unmistakable, Fisher Price 'my first instrument' look pioneered by Guitar Hero, it feels pleasingly sturdy and, in the main, performs its tasks admirably - with one notable exception, which I'll come to.

'DJ Hero' Screenshot 2

It can be frustratingly hard to cross-fade precisely in the heat of the action.

First, to recap how it all works: to simulate real-world dual turntables without requiring the player always to look down at the controller, blue and green buttons on the single platter represent left and right. The platter rotates freely in both directions through 360 degrees, though the only time you're required to give it a full spin is when activating 'Rewind' - a skill reward allowing you partially to roll back and replay to boost your score. Otherwise, short, sharp scratching is in order to match the on-screen patterns.

Mixes are performed by button-matching and scratching in time, switching left and right with the crossfader, then layering samples - either scripted, via the platter's central red button, or freeform via the 'euphoria' button at relevant points - and bending audio in real-time by twiddling an effects knob.

I've no doubt there will be many self-regarding 'real' DJs queuing up to call out Hero's inaccuracies and inconsistencies as a DJ experience. I can't comment directly since I don't DJ; what I can say, as a Guitar Hero-worshipping guitar player, is that I see such opinions as I do those of the binary-minded bores who scorn Guitar Hero because you can't suddenly break out into a minor mixolydian flourish mid-song. To do so is to miss the point spectacularly; the failure is one of imagination. What should be focused on ought to be obvious: how engaging it is as a game, and whether the simulated experience is actually fun.

Advertisement

Are you excited about DJ Hero on PlayStation 2?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 99 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
Santino
30/10/09 @ 10:12
#1
+21
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
i cant believe the guitar hero was only started 4 years ago, feels like much longer than that because of how fast it was milked to death. Now i just cant be bothered with music games at all.
aidey6
30/10/09 @ 10:13
#2
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I look forward to seeing the sales figures for this title £90 for a game coming up to christmas... Is the Renegade Edition features going to be available as DLC for those who buy the standard edition?
Moz
30/10/09 @ 10:14
#3
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I have a stack of trade ins (way too many in fact, buy too many games!!) Off to shops, who knows maybe a couple will be worth £20 and i'll have enough for tekken as well :D
Beano
30/10/09 @ 10:14
#4
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Got DJ Hero yesterday and agree with the review - a fun game :)

The cross-fader is a issue and hard to master - but seems to be a matter of getting used to.
Adam_T
30/10/09 @ 10:17
#5
+11
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Can we have any real shots of the controller instead of lame cgi images all the time?
VicViper
30/10/09 @ 10:17
#6
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Can't wait for this, off to the shop later to get my pre-order.
Normski
30/10/09 @ 10:21
#7
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sainsburys are doing it for 79.99 in store apparently (I don't know if anyone still price matches, but it's worth looking out for). Thanks Metro!
BlackSentoki
30/10/09 @ 10:21
#8
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
As regards the crossfader issue - a lot of crossfaders on proper DJ mixing consoles don't have much resistance for the mid-point, which is why you find DJs using the individual channel faders instead or as well. It's just something you'd have to get used to in the game.

Wonder if there's any chance of a release of the actual soundtrack (not the Eminem/Jay-Z best of in the Renegade edition)?
andywilkie35
30/10/09 @ 10:24
#9
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Sold! Can't wait
magicpocket
30/10/09 @ 10:25
#10
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I guess if they upgrade the mixer they might add fader depth like on scratch mixers, whereby if you so much as touch the fader towards the middle it cuts in the other track. Without that function a lot of scratch patterns wouldn't be possible.

Edit: I should add, I've been caining the hell out of this and had so much fun. I can't wait to get home and jump online to challenge people :)
Edited 1 times, most recently on 30/10/09 @ 10:26
simiankid
30/10/09 @ 10:29
#11
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
the music industry's nostrils too busy sweeping lustily over cisterns to pay it much heed...

Genius, pure unadulterated genius.
mingster
30/10/09 @ 10:33
#13
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hmmm ..
Is it better than Frequency or Amplitude though?
djronz
30/10/09 @ 10:34
#14
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"As regards the crossfader issue - a lot of crossfaders on proper DJ mixing consoles don't have much resistance for the mid-point, which is why you find DJs using the individual channel faders instead or as well. It's just something you'd have to get used to in the game. "

indeed, my cross fader had a tiny indent but thats all, i really want this but the price tag is a little steep, i guess what id really like to buy it for is the awsome track list!
andijames
30/10/09 @ 10:36
#15
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@MagicPocket

Do you mean xfade contours? They could add them i guess. That way i suppose it tailors each mixer / deck to a user's liking.

As a DJ myself i'm really not sure about this. Intrigued to have a go thou so might be one of those impulse buys when the price comes down a bit.
Beano
30/10/09 @ 10:37
#16
+7
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"As regards the crossfader issue - a lot of crossfaders on proper DJ mixing consoles don't have much resistance for the mid-point..."

But real DJ doesn't have to match on-screen notes - this is a controller and not proper DJ equipment :)
djronz
30/10/09 @ 10:37
#17
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
rhubarbandcustard
30/10/09 @ 10:33
ignore poster | #13 -1 You buried this comment Comment below viewing threshold Show
The sweat stained, grease monkey rocker in me hopes this game fails miserably.

Hip, cool music is just an epic fail all round.

And no, spinning the decks does not make you a musician.

DJ Hero, my arse.


No spinning decks does nt make you a musician, but "proper dj's" dont just play records, "turntablism" is an artform in its own right and just as hard to master properly as any guitar or drum kit, you ever tried scratching with out it sounding like wood cutting?
Mkwone
30/10/09 @ 10:42
#19
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Why is there a picture of future Stig on the front page?
LHH
30/10/09 @ 10:42
#20
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I think I'll wait to see what the DLC offers as all I can see in the tracklist is hip hop and some daftpunk. Where's my banging techno, old skool hardcore, drum and bass (etc) ? Although if the DLC offers what I want, i bet your arse it'll be cheaper than buying vinyl!
Also, how long will it be before someone does a novelty club night soley using this game?

@rhubarbandcustard

DJ Hype wants a word
Edited 2 times, most recently on 30/10/09 @ 10:44
chudders
30/10/09 @ 10:46
#21
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ Rhubarb.

Last night a DJ saved my life. When was the last time a grease monkey rocker did that?
BlackSentoki
30/10/09 @ 10:46
#22
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
""As regards the crossfader issue - a lot of crossfaders on proper DJ mixing consoles don't have much resistance for the mid-point..."

But real DJ doesn't have to match on-screen notes - this is a controller and not proper DJ equipment :)"

Oh, I know! I've been DJing (in clubs and at festivals) since 1997 (I am old)! Of course this game is nothing like real DJing (you're just pressing buttons to pre-mixed music, and indeed the music is closer to mashups than anything else), but Guitar Hero was not like playing a guitar.

I still want it and think it looks very fun indeed. But I want the soundtrack even more. :)
Toothball
30/10/09 @ 10:47
#23
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'd be more interested in this if it weren't for the presence of Black Eyed Peas on the track list. That and I should probably spend more time with all the fake instruments I already have. Rhythm action and expensive peripherals is a big weakness of mine.
djronz
30/10/09 @ 10:53
#24
-3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
rhubarbandcustard :
"No spinning decks does nt make you a musician, but "proper dj's" dont just play records, "turntablism" is an artform in its own right and just as hard to master properly as any guitar or drum kit"

Bollocks.

lol your either just trying to wind people up or your just ignorant to a different style of musical art. Go strum your guitar string.
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 10:55
#25
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Good turntablism is as much about musicianship as anything else.

I suspect this thread is now going to get bogged down in semantic nonsense, with those that don't like DJing referring to celebrity iPod shufflers pressing the play button in an attempt to discredit all DJs.

There are plenty of shit DJs out there, but there are also some incredible ones. The shit DJs make DJing look easy, because what they are doing is basic. The good DJs have technical mastery and compositional ability. Just like a good beatboxer.

Truth is, someone who is good at something pushes the boundaries of what they do, so using a crap Dj as an example of what DJing is and isn't is a basic mistake.
djronz
30/10/09 @ 10:57
#26
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
svd_grasshopper
30/10/09 @ 10:46

proficient scratching takes YEARS to master... and a LOT less people can do it than master the guitar... fact. you need really fast and strong fingers.

i have mixed for years, can beatmatch and mix records perfectly. can hardly scratch my arse.

+1 to that, you could teach any ont to beatmatch and mix, its more of a knack than a talent, but what some of these guys can do with 2,3 or even more decks and a few samplers is simply awsome!
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 10:57
#27
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@svd_grasshopper

I agree. I know a few people than can DJ (mix) really well, but when talking to one of them about scratching he just said he tried for months and gave up as it was just seemingly impossible to get anything good sounding to happen, despite him normally being in perfect control of his decks.
Hog-lumps
30/10/09 @ 10:58
#28
+15
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The review recomends standing up with the turntable sat on a high flat surface.

The only surface I can think of high enough for this at home is my ironing board - wouldn't really fit with the uber-cool DJ aesthetic! :)
djronz
30/10/09 @ 11:00
#29
-4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ kangarootoo

yes indeed, i can play the guitar, you just twang the strings and noise comes out dont it? of course im joking but i dont see why rhubarb had to come on here and spout his ignorant bile ??
skillian
30/10/09 @ 11:07
#31
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I don't know why I'm responding as you're clearly posting just to get a reaction from people, but just in case you're not, you should consider the possibility that rock music has just as many, if not more, hipsters as any other kind of music.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 30/10/09 @ 11:07
djronz
30/10/09 @ 11:09
#32
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"rap music" lol i hate that term, indeed modern "rap" is a long way from its hip hop culture origins, id tend to agree with some of whats said there, but hip hop was never about gansters and all that bull shit.

depends what you mean by "rock music" i guess, it tends to conjure images of leather clad bikers , and that is scary!!
andywilkie35
30/10/09 @ 11:15
#33
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ Hog-lumps

I've been trying to think of something in my flat I could use that was high, hadn't thought of the ironing board! Think I'm actually gonna use it

/scratches decks whilst ironing shirts
/burns self
cianchristopher
30/10/09 @ 11:17
#34
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
One thing's for sure.... Activision don't "do" DLC for their rhythm-action games (certainly nothing like Harmonix)!

Expect to see 12 (full-priced, boxed) sequels and spin-offs to this game on the shelves by this time next year!
creepylizard
30/10/09 @ 11:17
#35
-4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
What a waste of time load of old shite that looks like
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 11:18
#36
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Hog-lumps

There is nothing cooler than having the balls to do something that is deemed uncool. I say take your ironing board to the local clubs and start a new trend.
Widge
30/10/09 @ 11:19
#37
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I WANT to buy this. I really do. But considering all the games I could buy at the asking price, I just can't. Also there is that sneaking suspicion that it will devalue in a similar fashion to the Guitar Hero packages.

As such, I reckon I can engage will power and make do with my unfinished games pile.
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 11:20
#38
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@rhubarbandcustard

What in the name of God's slippers are you on about?


P.s. "Rock music on the other hand is raw, real and scary as all hell."

That is cheesy as hell, and one step away from saying "have you played with firte and burned your fingers?". Scary as hell indeed - the gentleman doth protest too much.

Seems to me that by your own admission you dismiss turntablism as challenging and musicical because you don't like the associated lifestyle. Hey man, I understand. I was a metaller as a kid, and I know its easier to rebel and say you "don't like it and don't want it" than be mocked for not having the coolest trainers. You aren't the first, you won't be the last.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 30/10/09 @ 11:24
djronz
30/10/09 @ 11:20
#39
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
svd_grasshopper
30/10/09 @ 11:16

a good electronic artist will write their own music, produce it and master it, and even distribute themselves. too many rockers are puppets with limited talent. they dont produce their own stuff.

there's plenty of good and bad in every musical genre
Ace_McCloud
30/10/09 @ 11:21
#40
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
What has the type of people who follow the music got to do with the talent it takes to master the instruments?

Watching talented people on the decks is an eye opener...

Watching something like 2ManyDjs at a big show where they mix video and music in unison can really help you understand just what these guys are doing and how talented they are. At Bestival when 2manyDjs dropped MGMT Kids, it was 1000 times better than when MGMT actually played the track themselves!
PlugMonkey
30/10/09 @ 11:24
#41
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The sweat stained, grease monkey rocker in me hopes this game fails miserably.

I want to like it. I like the concept. I love rhythm action games, and the 'DJing' songs were the best ones in Amplitude...

but

I just absolutely hate every single piece of music that I've heard from this. Despite being a sweat stained, grease monkey rocker myself, I really like 2 Many DJs and Felix Da Housecat and The Avalanches and the like so I was quite looking forward to this, but everything I've heard from DJ Hero sounds like something from the Need For Speed: Underground soundtrack.

I don't want to be the perpetrator behind a 50 Cent/David Bowie 'mash-up'. That's not a fantasy I want to live out.
Buztafen
30/10/09 @ 11:26
#42
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hey, where have Daft Punk gone?
Boomerang
30/10/09 @ 11:27
#43
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@rhubarbandcustard

Copying and pasting from Wikipedia does not a good argument make.

And while you're banging on about it not being realistic, since when was flapping on a plastic guitar in any way like playing a real guitar? Your -1 marks are all justified.
Drpwnage
30/10/09 @ 11:30
#44
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
"At Bestival when 2manyDjs dropped MGMT Kids, it was 1000 times better than when MGMT actually played the track themselves!"

That's a matter of personal taste, sounded like a bag of fail to me.
jonbwfc
30/10/09 @ 11:33
#45
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Am I think only one thinking a game that costs the best part of One Hundred British Pounds should really be more than an 8/10?

Jon
Hog-lumps
30/10/09 @ 11:37
#46
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@ Kangarootoo

I would have to come up with an appropriate DJ stage name ;)

DJ Steam?
DJ Laundretto?
DJ Crisp Sheets?

Hmmm, these names need a bit of work ......

Edited 1 times, most recently on 30/10/09 @ 11:39
Shane86
30/10/09 @ 11:42
#47
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Buztafen
30/10/09 @ 11:26

"Hey, where have Daft Punk gone? "


They're playing at my house....my house.
kinky_mong
30/10/09 @ 11:44
#48
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
but how many rock artists master their own work and mixing their albums down? none. every EDM artist does this.

Pretty sure a lot of EDM artists will have their music mastered and albums mixed down by a professional if they want it to be taken seriously. I know my old housemate does.

Back to the real topic, The review for DJ Hero was very positive but I'm going to have to give it a try myself before I blow so much money on it.
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 11:49
#49
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Hog-lumps

I like Crisp Sheets.

DJ Crease (with an option plural for Creases) would be my suggestion. You can have that one royalty free ;)
kangarootoo
30/10/09 @ 11:51
#50
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@donnie080208

I think the game being fun to play is more important than all of that. If Guitar Hero makes you feel like a rock god, that is a happy extra layer of icing. It isn't what sells the game in the first place, and if the gameplay sucked the rock god icing would taste bitter.

Comments: 1-50 of 99 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Get Games.  Download Great PC Games!

X View gallery