Jump to navigation

Table of contents

Page Previous 1 2 3 Next

Advertisement

Brütal Legend Review

Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Review by Christian Donlan

12 October, 2009

Page 2 of 3. <- Page 1Page 3 ->

Simple to get to grips with, the combat's rather satisfying, your growing arsenal of attacks split between a range of melee axe smashes and a suite of guitar-triggered magic assaults, all of which resemble comically lame stage pyros. The two elements dovetail hilariously at times, as you learn to blast people into the air with a polite burst of flame before "knocking them into the bleachers of pure pain". Every ally you meet as you gather your band together will have their own double-team attack, too, allowing you to launch goth minx Ophelia into a wave of satanic nuns where she deals death like a make-up-encrusted ninja, or to blow away the enemy with murderous seagull-popping sound-waves while riding on teetering stacks of a roadie's amps.

Despite such pleasures, Brutal Legend never quite feels like its full attention is on the quest: beyond a smattering of spiders' nests and mines there are no real dungeons to hack through and surprisingly few bosses to dismember, and almost every mission is over in a brisk 15 or 20 minutes. It's tempting to say that the game's heart is not in the adventure because its mind is out roaming the battlefield - and this is where Brutal Legend starts to get wilful and a little divisive.

Threaded inside the main narrative - and becoming an increasingly regular occurrence as the game continues - is a surprisingly elaborate RTS: the characters you meet en route double as traditional unit types, and the open world you explore on foot or behind the wheel of the Deuce is built to pull back into a smart arena of capture spots and choke-points. It's all rather elegant; as the game's dual nature starts to take shape, it's fascinating to watch how Double Fine gets the videogame equivalent of overtime out of the same small handful of elements. That said, it may come as something of an annoyance if you were expecting a few hours of soothingly simple hacking and slashing only to find yourself leading troops into pitched combat instead.

'Brütal Legend' Screenshot 3

Rolling eyes and arched brows, it can be hard to tell where Black ends and Riggs begins.

Still, even RTS newcomers shouldn't have trouble handling Brutal Legend's battles. Early on, Riggs gains the ability - this is a spoiler of sorts, but a small one - to sprout wings on cue and move about the field of conflict from above, and the d-pad is home to a handful of basic commands - attack, defend, follow, and move-over-there - that cover almost every eventuality. The massive rumbles are fairly streamlined - each fight is framed as a battle of opposing bands, with trashy stages providing the HQs to over-run, while "fan-geysers" can be captured to increase the flow of resources you'll need to build new units.

What Double Fine doesn't necessarily bring with it is the constant drip-feed of new objectives that keeps the best RTS games from feeling like slogs. Although Brutal Legend does occasionally throw in mid-mission challenges, they're uninspired affairs based on taking down various defences to get closer to the enemy base. Even on easy mode, the game's rather basic arenas make for some drawn-out encounters, and the whole thing never quite shakes the feeling that this half of the adventure is something of a cover version: a commendable attempt at a strategy game made by a team more at home with the one-on-one slugging.

Advertisement

Are you excited about Brutal Legend on PlayStation 3/Xbox 360?
View Eurogamer readers most anticipated games

Thanks!

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Comments: 1-50 of 154 in total | next 50 »

Poster
Comment Low-scoring comments hidden. Log in to see them!
PrivateFloyd
12/10/09 @ 23:09
#2
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
on the xmas list for me as uncharted 2 and left 4 dead 2 are set to take up alllllllllll my time!!!!
Metalfish
12/10/09 @ 23:15
#4
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I could complain about the score, but that is the preserve of those who haven't read the text (even if this may be a "high 8" or at least "reads like one").
JavierˇdeˇAss
12/10/09 @ 23:26
#5
+17
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
pretty much the only console game I'm interested in for the rest of the year. too bad there isn't a pc version really, hehe. will probably pick up the ps3 version in a few weeks.
Alkeno
12/10/09 @ 23:37
#6
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I quite understand the score. After reading this review and IGN's it seems quite clear that the game is both unique and not for everybody to enjoy; cool and bold yet a little rough.

The demo also didn't help to make my mind. I found it brutal (easy pun) but still too short, as if I had been given the intro and some very cool cinematics but very little gameplay to try. I dreared the RTS element of the multiplayer and wanted to try it, but luck was tough and the demo was over before I even began playing.

And then I see the reviews and I find that the RTS is not only the multiplayer, but it is a huge part of the one player campaign! I have been following the game for some time, but didn't know that (maybe my fault, but I don't think so). We should have been given a taster of RTS on the demo, didn't we deserve it? It's quite bad thinking from my part, but it seems as if the demo was deliberately too short, I can even hear the marketing guys "give them the laughs, give them coool intro, let them summon The Deuce... just don't let them play in case they find they might not be into the sandbox/RTS mix".

Don't get me wrong, I loved every minute of the demo (and so did my girlfriend, we laughed and enjoyed most jokes even when we are not into heavy and know very little of the inside jokes) but still after some reviews and a demo I can't make my mind over if I should get this game. I want to like it, but somehow these last few days have put me a little off...

So guys, please go buy it and fill the comments section with spoiler-free feedback!!!
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 00:52
StooMonster
12/10/09 @ 23:47
#7
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Looking forward to this, enjoyed the demo and Jack Black is okay in small doses.
BabyJesus
13/10/09 @ 00:01
#8
+32
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Schafer deserves a hit.
cristoflanga
13/10/09 @ 00:17
#9
+41
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hmmm... I kind of expected a reassuring 9. I loved every last one of Schafer games, but the presence of Uncharted 2 retailing the same day as this game here at Chile really filled me with doubts. Nevertheless, there's something inside me that leans towards originality and character even if the core product is not that good. I'm going to the store tomorrow, and I'm pretty sure I'll leave with a copy of Brutal Legend and not Uncharted Poo, as Black calls it. Will post some feed back when I've played the game.

On a different note, I have no idea if someone at Eurogamer actually reads this comments, but I have to take some time and say that you guys really have THE gaming site right here. I roam around like 20 or so other gaming sites and I just love this one (and Giant Bomb). There's something about your gaming that feels real, and your commentaries on games are intelligent and satisfying. Congratulations.

Excuse my English if I made mistakes, I am still learning.
figaro7
13/10/09 @ 00:20
#10
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Well written review, i had my hopes up on the first page and then the 2nd page came along and dipped my hopes a bit. Pre order stands, only just. How does the RTS elements compare to say, battalion wars?
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 01:22
Sunyavadin
13/10/09 @ 00:52
#11
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Looking forward to my copy arriving.
beastmaster
13/10/09 @ 00:55
#12
+12
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Excellent review for an excellent game. Excellent!

/plays air guitar
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 01:56
smelly
13/10/09 @ 01:39
#13
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Im drawn..

I *WANTED* this.. but was put off by the demo.. and i usually avoid ANYTHING remotely related to jack black.. however it HAS gotten good reviews...

hmmm....
copper08
13/10/09 @ 01:44
#14
-5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I thought the demo was a bit shite, goes to show don't judge a book....game.....by it's......... Demo cover? I'm losing it.
Genji
13/10/09 @ 02:39
#16
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Hrm. I was half interested in this before, but the review is turning me off a bit. It doesn't seem like my cup of tea, now. Maybe I'll borrow it off a friend for a day, and buy it if I like it.
Slipstream
13/10/09 @ 03:23
#18
+12
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Loved the demo!
Hahaha I knew as soon as that little emo band got torn to shreds I would love this game!
3william56
13/10/09 @ 05:08
#20
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Maybe should have a word with Tim Schafer and organise a second demo (as per Ratchet and Clank, supposedly). The current demo also left me cold; thought the jokes were weak, and the game it showed was (apart from the wonderful art design) badly formulaic sub God of War. And don't get me started on the lame bit at the end where only a certain special move will progress the game, with no real clue (it's a real immersion breaker to realise the monster will keep it's head in just the right stupid position indefinitelty, with the Rock Minx spouting the same line over and over, until you hit that special move). But if it improves I might be sold, and the RTS bits sound really interesting.

And of course we gotta see Our Lord Lemmy!
Emilia'sHorse
13/10/09 @ 05:40
#21
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I am very pleased to see the game turned out well. Will be buying this, I still feel bad that it took me almost a year to get around to buying Psychonauts.
Emilia'sHorse
13/10/09 @ 05:49
#22
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@Cristoflanga

I agree, EG is the best game site on the web. It is clean, clear and the writing of a very high standard. But the reason I visit is for the comments, love to read what the gaming public think even if it turns out to be a big fanboy fight.

Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 06:50
Antaios
13/10/09 @ 05:59
#24
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm pleased this is getting decent scores in most places and I'll certainly be picking this up as soon as it's out.
seasidebaz
13/10/09 @ 06:06
#25
+27
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This is not... The greatest game in the world, no, this is just a tribute...
Scimarad
13/10/09 @ 06:12
#26
+4
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Nice review. I was kind of hoping for more dungeony bits but it still sounds pretty fantastic.
Miths
13/10/09 @ 06:37
#30
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
The demo completely failed to convince me this would be a game I would enjoy - even though the subject matter should provide a good nostalgia flashback to my teen years around the early 90s, and I'm sure I would like the humour as well.
I just didn't care at all for the hack and slash gameplay - something I used to enjoy a fair bit, but which I've gotten rather sick and tired of the last couple of years (I really hope God of War 3 can help me get over that problem :)). And I was never much of an RTS fan either.

Still, it looks like a game I could potentially feel inclined to pick up somewhere down the line during a release slump.
ProtoformX
13/10/09 @ 06:38
#31
+24
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I've just finshed the first Uncharted and was defintely interested in picking up the second but can Nathan Drake summon a CAR with the power of METAL? NO. Epic fail Mr. Drake, epic fail.
Dezm0nd
13/10/09 @ 06:47
#32
+5
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Awesome score but I was sold with the demo! Bring on Rocktober 16th!!
mkreku
13/10/09 @ 07:01
#33
+16
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This reviews sounds like "Yeah, the game is short, shallow and repetitive, but it's TIM SCHAFER!! 8/10!". Very odd.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 08:02
Darren
13/10/09 @ 07:02
#34
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm not liking the sound of these RTS sections too much myself after playing and enjoying the demo which gave no indication that those even existed. I was kind of hoping it would just be an open-world hack 'n' slash game, kind of Viking meets Zelda sort of thing. I have no love of heavy metal music either, although the score didn't annoy me in the demo. Nevertheless I'm still looking forward to playing this but have a feeling it will be totally swamped by Uncharted 2, another game that I've been itching to play all year.
tossetaz
13/10/09 @ 07:03
#35
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Preordered this months ago as I was sure the Schafer will once again show what an awesome game imaginear he is - and this review confirms it!
sickpuppysoftware
13/10/09 @ 07:14
#36
+2
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Shame the demo didn't include an RTS section. I hate RTS games and this could be a deal breaker for me.

Might be a rental for me.
muscleblade
13/10/09 @ 07:15
#37
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Not sure about this. The RTS sections worry me. I loved the demo though.
roz123
13/10/09 @ 07:17
#38
+3
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Was surprised with the 8 after reading the review, gameplay itself sounds like a 6 or 7. But i guess the metal and the comedy elements make it very worth playing. I think i am going to wait for a pc release or for the price to drop.
RobotRocker
13/10/09 @ 07:36
#40
+20
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Brutal Legend seems like a game that will grow on you rather than immediatey blow you away like Psychonauts did (And god help us if you hold Psychonauts to long term scrutiny. Amazing characters and atmosphere but if you strip all it away, its a Rare platformer Circa Donkey Kong 64 era that controls like a tank. And this is from someone who loves Psychonauts). So its still probably worth a look see despite Mr. Donlan being decidedly un-metal. Gonna grab it anyway because Double Fine deserves your money and FUCK YOU BOBBY KOTTICK (Hate buying is the best buying).

/Activision tried to kill the metal, THEY FAILED as they were thrown to the ground.

S8AN
13/10/09 @ 07:36
#41
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Can't wait till Friday, as I'm getting this and Uncharted 2. Which to put in first? Mmmmm...
speedjack
13/10/09 @ 07:42
#42
+12
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Its probably a stupid thing to say, but I'd buy Tim Schafer games on principle if it wasn't for the fact that they're normally so darn good anyway.

Loved the demo so this is another definite purchase for me.
JahB
13/10/09 @ 07:42
#43
+26
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This looks like a good game but to pick this up over Uncharted 2??????? People should have their heads checked

yeah, where do these idiots get off, having a different opinion than you? obviously they must all be mentally ill
muscleblade
13/10/09 @ 07:43
#44
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
@S8AN

Why wait until Friday. Release date is on Thursday.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 08:43
Quint2020
13/10/09 @ 07:53
#45
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Haven't got time for this at the moment with Forza 3 and Dragon Age but I'll be picking it up along with Assassin's Creed II early December-ish me thinks.
jimboton
13/10/09 @ 08:00
#46
-1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This game needed deeper adventure elements, some puzzles like Schafer's true classics used to have (only to be presented in zelda style rather than point'n click style), instead of so much repetitive, unchallenging rts/brawling and filler cookie cutter missions. Shame. it still sounds a lot more interesting than Uncharted 2.
Edited 1 times, most recently on 13/10/09 @ 09:00
spekkeh
13/10/09 @ 08:00
#47
0
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
This reviews sounds like "Yeah, the game is short, shallow and repetitive, but it's TIM SCHAFER!! 8/10!". Very odd.

Odd? Seems perfectly logical to me.
Shinetop
13/10/09 @ 08:03
#48
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
Reads more like a 9, actually.
menage
13/10/09 @ 08:10
#49
+6
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
I'm still sold. Schafer still needs to get my 50 bucks for Psychonauts:D
actionfitz
13/10/09 @ 08:11
#50
+1
You buried this comment
Comment below viewing threshold
Show
chorus:
Activision Tried to kill the metal!
but failed! as it was stuck to the ground!
etc.

:P
looking forward to this, but like others have said, it'll have to wait till around xmass time for me.
L4D2 and Uncharted 2 are all I can budget for in both time and money.
(i still havent gone back to finish Arkham asylum yet - /shame - got distracted by Aion heh).

Comments: 1-50 of 154 in total | next 50 »

Want to comment on this article? Log in, or register!

Get Games.  Download Great PC Games!

X View gallery